Pardon My Take Episode Summary – April 28, 2025

In this high-energy episode of Barstool Sports' "Pardon My Take," hosts Big Cat and PFT Commenter delve into a whirlwind of sports topics, including the NFL Draft, NBA and NHL Playoffs, and a candid discussion with special guest Peter Schrager. The episode is packed with insightful analysis, memorable quotes, and engaging banter that caters to both avid sports fans and casual listeners.

NFL Draft Recap and Shador Sanders’ Surprise Selection

The episode kicks off with an in-depth recap of the NFL Draft, highlighting the surprising selection of quarterback Shador Sanders by the Cleveland Browns in the fifth round. Previously projected as a potential first-round pick by pundits like Mel Kiper, Sanders' slide has left many scratching their heads.

Big Cat discusses the unexpected move:

“[04:14] PFT Commenter: Fourth round.”

PFT Commenter adds perspective on the Browns' strategy:

“[05:00] Big Cat: That was from 2018. So bias is out in the open with Dion. Spin zone for Dion and the Sanders family.”

The hosts commend Deion Sanders for defending his son despite the draft outcome:

“[05:50] Big Cat: But credit to Dion. Oh, fifth round. Sorry, fifth round. Why? I.”

Mel Kiper’s Meltdown: A Media Frenzy

A significant portion of the discussion centers around Mel Kiper’s highly emotional reaction to Sanders not being drafted in the first round. Kiper's passionate defenses and subsequent meltdown became viral, sparking widespread debate.

PFT Commenter mocks the situation with humor:

“[08:36] PFT Commenter: I think he'll be okay.”

Big Cat sympathizes with Kiper’s reaction:

“[14:10] PFT Commenter: I think he'll be okay. He was very passionate about Shador.”

Shador Sanders Prank Call Incident

The episode transitions into the infamous prank call aimed at Shador Sanders, orchestrated by Jeff Ulbrich’s son, Jax. This incident not only embarrassed Sanders but also ignited a storm of online ridicule and debate.

Big Cat recounts the event:

“[09:58] PFT Commenter: I cannot bring myself to watch it because it just seems like the most, like, cringy, awkward video.”

Stavros Halkias, in agreement, expresses his dismay:

“[11:06] Stavros Halkias: He was literally on the video.”

The hosts discuss the broader implications of the prank call, emphasizing the importance of sportsmanship and respect.

NBA Playoffs: Thrilling Series and Iconic Moments

Shifting gears, Big Cat and PFT Commenter provide a vibrant analysis of the ongoing NBA Playoffs. They highlight standout performances, such as Nikola Jokić’s dominance and Steph Curry’s game-winning dunks.

PFT Commenter shares excitement over Curry’s prowess:

“[55:00] PFT Commenter: I agree.”

Big Cat praises Jokić’s stat line:

“[56:39] Big Cat: If you look at the box score like, Jamal Murray was 5 for 17. Christian Brown was 8 for 19.”

The duo also touches on refereeing controversies and the intensity of playoff hockey, comparing the fervor to iconic moments in sports history.

NHL Playoffs: Intense Games and Player Highlights

The conversation seamlessly flows into the NHL Playoffs, where the hosts discuss memorable games, player performances, and unexpected turns. They recount the fierce competitiveness of teams like the Carolina Hurricanes and the electrifying atmosphere in Montreal's Bell Centre.

Stavros Halkias highlights the passion of Montreal fans:

“[78:18] PFT Commenter: That's the loudest stadium I've ever been in my life.”

Big Cat reflects on the intensity of playoff hockey:

“[84:53] Big Cat: What happened. Yeah. So yeah, no, Pistons. Pistons fans have every right to be upset because that was bullshit.”

Interview with Peter Schrager: Inside the Draft and Media Reactions

Special guest Peter Schrager joins the show fresh from Green Bay, offering exclusive insights into the NFL Draft and the media's role in shaping player narratives. Schrager defends the Browns' picks and sheds light on the challenges of covering unorthodox prospects like Shador Sanders.

Peter Schrager explains:

“[116:00] Peter Schrager: So my first week at ESPN was April and I walked into get up. And the topics on get up...”

Big Cat praises Schrager’s coverage:

“[136:51] Big Cat: You could give him a food and he'll tell. He’ll pair it with the soda.”

Schrager also addresses the aftermath of Mel Kiper’s meltdown, emphasizing the importance of passion and dedication in sports journalism.

Conclusion: Navigating the Sports Landscape with Humor and Insight

As the episode wraps up, Big Cat and PFT Commenter reflect on the humorous and sometimes chaotic nature of sports media. They emphasize the value of staying true to one’s perspective amidst widespread opinions and hype.

PFT Commenter concludes with optimism:

“[39:52] Big Cat: That was the worst draft party.”

Big Cat sums up the episode’s themes:

“[99:47] Big Cat: Why can't, like, Bezos or someone do this? ”

Throughout the episode, the hosts maintain their signature blend of humor, critique, and genuine passion for sports, making "Pardon My Take" a must-listen for fans eager to stay informed and entertained.

Notable Quotes:

• Big Cat on Sanders’ draft value:

  “[04:00] PFT Commenter: Only A given out because they got Shador. What a steal.”

• PFT Commenter on Mel Kiper:

  “[14:10] PFT Commenter: I think he'll be okay.”

• Stavros Halkias on the prank call:

  “[11:06] Stavros Halkias: He was literally on the video.”

This comprehensive summary captures the essence of the episode, providing listeners with a clear overview of the discussions, key moments, and insightful commentary delivered by the hosts and their guest.