Pardon My Take – Episode Summary Release Date: December 4, 2024

Hosts: Big Cat & PFT Commenter
Guest: Steve Smith Senior
Special Cameo: Liam Blutman – Renowned Ball Watcher

1. Jameis Winston’s Historic Performance in the NFL

Timestamp: [03:05] - [07:36]

Big Cat opens the discussion by praising Jameis Winston, dubbing him his favorite athlete despite not being on his own team. PFT Commenter highlights Winston's extraordinary game where he threw for 668 passing yards, the most by any quarterback in NFL history, surpassing Vinnie Testaverde ([03:45]). Winston's performance included four touchdowns, three interceptions, and two pick-sixes, showcasing both his talent and volatility.

Notable Quotes:

• PFT Commenter: “He is the best athlete to root for of all time on, not your team. What we saw on Monday night, 460 yards. It was historic.” ([03:05]
• Big Cat: “James Winston should play every single primetime game. He should be all-time quarterback.” ([04:19]

The hosts delve into Winston’s impact on the game, his ability to elevate the Broncos’ performance, and the consequential effect on rival teams like the Browns, emphasizing the unpredictability and excitement he brings to the field.

2. College Football Playoff and Rivalry Weekend

Timestamp: [17:00] - [43:38]

Brandon Walker joins as the college football expert to analyze the College Football Playoff (CFP) landscape. The conversation centers on Ohio State's shocking loss to Michigan, deemed one of the worst in history, and Ryan Day’s coaching performance. The hosts critique Ohio State’s strategic decisions, particularly their reliance on quarterback Will Howard, and discuss potential changes in hiring practices for head coaches.

Notable Quotes:

• Hank: “Ryan Day came out the other day... a shocking failure of coaching.” ([18:39]
• Big Cat: “Is going to be a hell of a video.” ([70:21]

The discussion extends to the implications of the CFP structure, highlighting issues like strength of schedule and the challenges posed by super conferences. They debate the fairness of the playoff selections, particularly concerning teams like SMU and Alabama, and explore potential reforms, such as adopting NFL-style divisions to mitigate schedule disparities.

Notable Quotes:

• Big Cat: “They need to do the divisions.” ([40:41]
• Hank: “If you have to go into a playoff game like that, it's fine.” ([37:41]

Brandon and the hosts express frustration with the current playoff system, advocating for a more balanced and fair selection process that better represents team performances throughout the season.

3. Heisman Trophy Predictions and Awards

Timestamp: [51:35] - [67:56]

A lighthearted yet competitive segment unfolds as the hosts and guests discuss their picks for the Heisman Trophy. PFT Commenter bets on Travis Hunter, while Hank and others voice support for Ashton Gentee and Nick Nash. The conversation reveals differing opinions on what constitutes a Heisman-caliber performance, with debates on player usage rates and the impact of injuries.

Notable Quotes:

• Big Cat: “Travis Hunter is going to win the 2024 Heisman Trophy.” ([52:24]
• PFT Commenter: “He should have been.” ([56:00]

Liam Blutman joins the discussion, adding his perspective and favorite candidates, further intensifying the friendly rivalry among the hosts. The segment underscores the subjective nature of awards and the diverse criteria voters consider when selecting finalists.

4. Hot Seat & Cool Throne Segments

Timestamp: [66:00] - [85:57]

The Hot Seat and Cool Throne segments provide an interactive and humorous break from the intense sports analysis. Listeners submit playful questions and challenges, with the hosts engaging in witty banter and lighthearted competitions. Topics range from funny bets to amusing takes on current sports events.

Notable Moments:

• Hot Seat: Discussions about NFL kickers and their performance pressures.
• Cool Throne: Interactive quizzes and playful debates on topics like the Four Aces in golf and NFL players’ management.

These segments add a layer of entertainment, showcasing the hosts' chemistry and ability to balance serious discussions with comedic relief.

5. Interview with Steve Smith Senior

Timestamp: [104:54] - [147:57]

Steve Smith Senior returns as a recurring guest, providing expert insights into both the NFL and College Football. The interview covers a range of topics, including Steve’s perspective on coaching changes, player development, and team dynamics. He emphasizes the importance of accountability and effective coaching strategies in rebuilding team performance.

Notable Quotes:

• Steve Smith: “These are the best professionals in the league.” ([105:45]
• Steve Smith: “He is doing really good. He's throwing the football. He beat the Panthers.” ([117:59]

Steve discusses Bryce Young’s development under Coach Canales, highlighting improvements in offensive strategy and quarterback confidence. He also touches on broader issues like the impact of schedule disparities in the CFP and the challenges faced by teams like the Miami Dolphins in cold weather games.

Key Insights:

• Coaching Accountability: Steve underscores the need for leaders who can hold players accountable and foster a winning mentality.
• Player Development: Highlighting Bryce Young’s growth, Steve credits effective coaching for enhancing player performance.
• Season Challenges: Analyzing teams struggling with injuries and strategy flaws, Steve provides a seasoned perspective on navigating tough seasons.

6. Guest Cameo: Liam Blutman

Timestamp: [147:34] - [150:38]

Liam Blutman makes a cameo appearance, contributing to discussions on Heisman voting and sharing his own picks. His participation adds depth to the Heisman segment, as he advocates for balanced representation and highlights emerging talent in college football.

Notable Quotes:

• Liam Blutman: “If I had to vote for the Heisman, I would vote for Ashton.” ([62:29]
• Liam Blutman: “Nick Nash, triple crown leader, it's kind of a no-brainer.” ([63:30]

Liam’s input enriches the conversation, offering alternative viewpoints and emphasizing the importance of recognizing diverse talent in awards.

7. Final Thoughts and Wrap-Up

Timestamp: [150:35] - [151:26]

As the episode nears its end, the hosts reflect on the day’s discussions, reiterate their sports bets, and tease upcoming segments and continued interactions with guests like Steve Smith. They express anticipation for the next episode, highlighting ongoing competitions and listener engagement activities.

Notable Moments:

• Big Cat: “We need to make sure you get to four before Brandon gets five years.” ([147:34]
• PFT Commenter: “You're the one that I got hang into office.” ([148:37]

The episode concludes with a blend of humor and camaraderie, reinforcing the show's engaging and dynamic format.

Conclusion:

This episode of Pardon My Take delivers a comprehensive and entertaining exploration of both NFL and College Football topics. From celebrating Jameis Winston’s remarkable performance to dissecting the complexities of the College Football Playoff system, the hosts provide insightful commentary enriched by expert guest Steve Smith Senior. Interactive segments like the Hot Seat and Cool Throne, along with guest cameos, ensure a lively and engaging listen for sports enthusiasts.

Key Takeaways:

• Jameis Winston’s Impact: His historic performance adds excitement and unpredictability to the NFL season.
• CFP Challenges: The current playoff system’s flaws highlight the need for structural reforms to ensure fairness.
• Heisman Predictions: Diverse opinions underscore the subjective nature of sports awards.
• Guest Expertise: Steve Smith Senior offers valuable insights into team dynamics and player development.
• Engaging Segments: Interactive elements keep the show lively and entertaining.

For those who haven’t listened to this episode, Pardon My Take continues to deliver a blend of loud, correct takes with humor and expert analysis, making it a must-listen for sports talk enthusiasts.