Pardon My Take Episode Summary: Steve Young, ASU’s Kenny Dillingham, Bengals Revival, and More

Release Date: December 11, 2024

Overview

In this action-packed episode of Pardon My Take, hosts Big Cat and PFT Commenter delve into a myriad of sports topics, ranging from the resurgence of the Cincinnati Bengals and the dynamics between Jalen Hurts and AJ Brown to insightful interviews with NFL legend Steve Young and Arizona State Sun Devils head coach Kenny Dillingham. The episode also tackles controversies in the NFL coaching scene, the intricacies of the College Football Playoff system, and highlights among Heisman Trophy finalists.

1. NFL Segment

A. Cincinnati Bengals: Are They Back?

Timestamp: [03:15]

Big Cat initiates the discussion by expressing cautious optimism about the Bengals' prospects, especially highlighting Jamar Chase's exceptional performance. He remarks, “Jamar Chase is so goddamn good, it's actually insane to watch” ([03:16]). Despite acknowledging the team's struggles in previous seasons, he emphasizes the offensive strengths that keep Bengals fans hopeful, albeit recognizing the defense’s persistent issues.

B. Critique of Mike McCarthy’s Coaching

Timestamp: [03:56]

PFT Commenter critiques Cowboys head coach Mike McCarthy, particularly spotlighting McCarthy's tendency to ruminate over poor plays. He humorously suggests, “You got to stop subjecting yourself to just trauma repeatedly over and over again” ([04:24]). The hosts discuss McCarthy's infamous moments, including an incident where he allegedly assaulted a cameraman, further questioning whether this season marks McCarthy’s best coaching stint.

C. Jalen Hurts and AJ Brown: From Friends to Teammates?

Timestamp: [12:50]

The conversation shifts to the Philadelphia Eagles, focusing on the reported friction between quarterback Jalen Hurts and wide receiver AJ Brown. After Brandon Graham's comments suggesting that Hurts and Brown "don't fuck with each other" ([13:08]), the hosts dissect the validity of these claims. Big Cat clarifies, “They used to be friends before being teammates” ([13:14]), highlighting how professional environments can strain personal relationships.

D. NFL Playoff Predictor and Bengals’ Chances

Timestamp: [06:03]

Discussing the playoff landscape, Big Cat assesses the Bengals' slim chances of making it to the postseason, estimating a roughly 3-10% probability ([06:05]). He underscores the difficulty of their path, which would require the team to win all remaining games while other key teams falter.

2. College Football Playoffs and Conference System

A. Heisman Trophy Finalists

Timestamp: [26:29]

The hosts review the Heisman Trophy finalists: Ashton Gentee (Boise State), Cam Ward (Miami), Dylan Gabriel (Oregon), and Travis Hunter (Colorado). They humorously debate omissions and the accuracy of stat presentations, such as Cam Ward’s exaggerated yardage ([26:52]). The discussion underscores the competitiveness and talent present among the finalists, with both hosts expressing a desire to see them share the award.

B. Critique of the College Football Playoff (CFP) System

Timestamp: [28:14]

Big Cat and PFT Commenter critique the CFP’s conference buy-in system, arguing that it inherently favors traditional powerhouses and undervalues exceptionally strong teams from non-elite conferences. They discuss the potential benefits and drawbacks of allowing teams like Boise State or Oregon more direct paths to the playoffs, suggesting that the current system is more lucrative than merit-based ([29:06]).

They propose alternatives such as expanding the playoff slots or eliminating conference championships to prioritize on-field performance over conference affiliations. The hosts express concern over the SEC’s influence and the potential marginalization of other conferences, emphasizing the need for a more equitable system that recognizes talent irrespective of conference prestige.

3. Heisman Trophy Finalists

Timestamp: [26:29] – [27:56]

Big Cat and PFT Commenter delve into the performances of the Heisman finalists, debating their merits and potential impact in the award race. They express admiration for the finalists’ abilities and discuss the organizational aspects of the award process, noting how the voting has likely concluded without their input.

PFT Commenter suggests, “I would split it. I think it would be a four-way tie if it were up to me” ([27:25]), highlighting the competitiveness among the finalists. Both hosts agree that while they have personal favorites, the candidates’ performances make it a close race deserving of recognition.

4. Interviews

A. Steve Young: Reflections and Insights

Timestamp: [57:51] – [85:55]

The first major interview features Steve Young, the Pro Football Hall of Famer, who shares his journey from being a struggling quarterback to achieving superstardom with the San Francisco 49ers. Young recounts pivotal moments, such as his mentorship under Bill Walsh and the resilience required to overcome setbacks.

Key Highlights:

• Transition to the 49ers: Young discusses his move from the struggling Cowboys to the 49ers, highlighting how Bill Walsh’s philosophy emphasized teamwork and mutual respect. He recounts Walsh’s inspiring advice: “We’re going to win because we have shared common experiences amongst each other and an element of love for each other” ([58:30]).

• Overcoming Adversity: Young shares personal anecdotes about facing criticism and injuries, emphasizing the importance of mindset and support systems in achieving success.

• Advice for Aspiring Coaches and Players: He underscores the significance of being open to learning, adapting strategies, and fostering a positive team culture to thrive in high-pressure environments.

Young also reflects on his legendary career moments, including the iconic "monkey off my back" touchdown celebration, and discusses the evolution of quarterback play, addressing modern techniques like the slide and how they impact the game’s dynamics.

Notable Quote:

“What Steve Young did with the 49ers really set the foundation for the modern game, emphasizing intelligence and adaptability over sheer physicality.” ([75:00])

B. Kenny Dillingham: Building a Champion at Arizona State

Timestamp: [115:33] – [143:57]

In the second interview, Kenny Dillingham, head coach of the Arizona State Sun Devils, discusses his remarkable season leading ASU to the Big 12 Championship despite being tipped to finish last. Dillingham attributes the team’s success to resilience, strategic play-calling, and fostering a supportive environment.

Key Highlights:

• Unexpected Success: Dillingham shares how ASU defied expectations by winning the Big 12, emphasizing the team's collective determination and adaptability. He states, “We have a lot of people who were at these blue blood programs that chose to come out here... compete for championships at the same time” ([116:33]).

• Innovative Coaching Strategies: He discusses the utilization of versatile play designs and the importance of empowering quarterbacks to make decisive plays under pressure. Highlighting Cam Scatterboats’ smart decision-making during critical moments, Dillingham praises his intelligence and competitiveness ([117:21]).

• Transfer Portal and Recruiting Philosophy: Dillingham articulates his positive approach to the transfer portal, supporting players’ career aspirations and maintaining a reputation that attracts quality recruits. He emphasizes, “College sports is supposed to be to help the kids... I root for them. I try to help them” ([125:59]).

• Team Culture and Leadership: Emphasizing the importance of character, Dillingham highlights unsung heroes like safety Xavian Alford, who contribute significantly behind the scenes, reinforcing the team’s values of hard work and integrity ([126:04]).

Notable Quote:

“Be a good person. Make good decisions. And have more fun working harder than anyone in the country. You want to have a lot of fun working your ass off. This is spot for you.” ([127:24])

5. Light-Hearted and Interactive Segments

Throughout the episode, Big Cat and PFT Commenter engage in humorous banter, addressing listener interactions from segments like “Hot Seat” and “Cool Throne.” They discuss various offbeat topics, share personal anecdotes, and react to listener reviews, adding a relatable and entertaining layer to the sports discourse.

Examples:

• Discussing listener reviews about relationships and personal habits humorously, such as dealing with questions about personal activities when away from partners ([147:57] – [153:49]).
• Engaging in playful debates about fictional scenarios and humorous public figures, maintaining an engaging and light-hearted tone.

Conclusion

This episode of Pardon My Take offers a comprehensive blend of in-depth sports analysis, candid interviews with prominent figures like Steve Young and Kenny Dillingham, and the hosts’ trademark humor and relatability. Whether dissecting the Bengals' potential resurgence, critiquing coaching strategies, or exploring the nuances of the College Football Playoff system, Big Cat and PFT Commenter provide listeners with insightful perspectives and entertaining commentary. Their interviews add valuable firsthand insights from both an NFL legend and a rising college football coach, making this episode a must-listen for sports enthusiasts seeking both knowledge and entertainment.