Are We Being Unfair to Cam Smith? Are Expectations Just Too High?

Summary

---

Podcast Summary: Payne & Pendergast

Episode: Are We Being Unfair to Cam Smith? Are Expectations Just Too High?
Date: July 7, 2026
Hosts: Seth Payne (Sports Analyst), Luke Morrow (Sports Analyst, filling in for Sean Pendergast)
Topic: Critical examination of the expectations placed upon Astros outfielder Cam Smith and discussion of whether the Houston fanbase is being fair in their assessment.

---

Episode Overview

This episode centers on Cam Smith, the Astros' promising young outfielder. Seth Payne and guest host Luke Morrow debate whether Smith is being judged too harshly or if the high expectations accompanying his prospect status are warranted. The conversation explores both statistical analysis and fan sentiment, drawing comparisons to historical metrics and broader trends in Major League Baseball.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Cam Smith’s Current Value and Performance

• Statistical Snapshot:

  • Smith is on pace to hit 20 home runs for the season.
  • He's recognized as a "Gold Glove outfielder" and is near the top of MLB for Defensive Runs Saved.
  • His batting average sits around .229 to .230, which, though below average historically, is “almost like a .260 hitter 25 years ago.” (02:56 – Luke Morrow)
  • Smith’s WAR (Wins Above Replacement) is currently a tenth higher than star outfielder Kyle Tucker, per Baseball Reference. (04:26 – Seth Payne)

• Quote:

  • “He’s on pace to hit 20 homers... Gold Glove 20 Homer guy, wouldn’t you sign up for that each year to have a very good right fielder who's going to have some pop in the lineup?” — Luke Morrow (02:56)

2. Are Expectations Too High?

• Prospect Pressure:

  • Morrow notes that Smith may be “hurt by the expectations that have been bestowed upon him” since he was fast-tracked to the majors as a highly touted prospect. (03:41)
  • Payne points out that people overlook how young Smith is and that his development trajectory shouldn’t be set in stone after just two MLB seasons (04:00).

• Quote:

  • “There’s just no reason for me, at least that I can think of, that, oh yeah, this is what he's going to be for the rest of his career. And like, he’s already sealed his fate.” — Seth Payne (05:26)

3. The Historical Precedent (Or Lack Thereof)

• Can Players 'Turn It Around'?

  • Morrow shares a data deep dive into players who hit .230 or worse in their first 1,000 plate appearances—Mike Schmidt was the only notable example who became a star after such a slow start at the plate. (06:05–06:39)
  • The conversation highlights that low early averages rarely translate into All-Star careers, though batting average is less significant in today’s power-focused game.

• Quote:

  • “The only guy there was one, I think it was Mike Schmidt was the only guy that turned into like a great baseball player after struggling that mightily early on.” — Luke Morrow (05:26)

4. Context Matters: The Astros’ Outfield

• The current Astros outfield is described as “the worst outfield in the MLB right now and one of the worst in Astros history.” (07:00–07:15)

• Smith’s reputation suffers by association, as he’s lumped in with struggling outfielders like Jake Myers and Joey Loperfido.

• Quote:

  • “When the people next to him look so bad, we can be guilty of associating Cam Smith with Jake Myers and Joey Loperfido.” — Luke Morrow (07:13)

5. The Shift in Prospect Anticipation

• Payne laments that the fan experience has moved from eager anticipation about prospects (e.g., George Springer, Carlos Correa) to young players being rushed up and subsequently underwhelming. (09:24)

• Quote:

  • "We've gone from back in the day waiting for, 'Oh boy, when’s Springer gonna come up?' ... to like, 'Oh no, you don't have to wait for those guys to come up. We're just gonna throw them out there and they're going to disappoint you.'" — Seth Payne (09:24)

6. Whose Fault Are Expectations?

• Morrow suggests Smith “didn’t assign himself” the top prospect label; outsider evaluations set those expectations. If his performance is reframed—20 HR, Gold Glove defense for 10 years—as a generic right fielder, “a lot of teams would sign up for that.” (10:05)

• Quote:

  • “Maybe it was the evaluators who were wrong, put these lofty expectations on him. But if you were to remove those expectations...I think a lot of teams would sign up for that.” — Luke Morrow (10:34)

7. Fan Frustration and Sentiment

• Payne doesn't sense significant frustration from the fanbase towards Smith, at least recently (11:00). Other players are drawing more ire, with Smith escaping harsher criticism due to being "not the worst guy on the team right now." (11:34)

• Quote:

  • “I don't feel like the fan base is done with Cam Smith or something, but maybe I don't spend enough time on social media.” — Seth Payne (11:13)
  • “I think there's other guys that are doing worse ... you let Cam Smith slide because he’s not the worst guy on the team right now.” — Luke Morrow (11:34)

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On statistics and modern baseball:

  • “Batting average is such a...an afterthought now in terms of what guys are even worried about or concerned about. The power is what intrigues people.” — Seth Payne (06:46)

• On prospect disappointment:

  • “It’s a double whammy that we don’t even get anticipation for their arrivals. And then it’s been a very underwhelming appearance when they do show up.” — Seth Payne (09:24)

• Playful exchange on tone:

  • “Let’s do the maybe I’m being too positive.” — Luke Morrow (12:17)
  • “Pause in early July here and figure out who we're being too tough on.” — Seth Payne (12:21)
  • “Yeah, I guess I've been too positive here this past hour. So when we come back, let's flip the bill here and get to the petty cast—who’s being petty in the sports world?” — Luke Morrow (12:32)

---

Timestamps for Key Segments

• 01:30: Episode starts, topic introduced
• 02:19–03:48: Cam Smith’s defensive value and home run pace
• 04:00–05:26: Discussion on Smith’s developmental timeline and potential
• 05:26–06:46: Historical player comps for low-average hitters; Mike Schmidt precedent
• 06:59–08:00: WAR, power metrics, and context of Astros outfield struggles
• 09:24: Changing relationship between fans and prospects
• 10:05–11:00: The ethics of expectations and prospect labels
• 11:00–12:00: Fan sentiment towards Smith and shift to broader team issues

---

Summary & Takeaways

• Cam Smith is a genuinely plus defender with solid power, contributing in ways often overlooked by batting average-focused analysis.
• The expectations placed on him—stemming from top prospect status and a weak Astros outfield—have colored perceptions of his performance.
• Statistically and contextually, Smith's output is valuable, but past trends indicate he's unlikely to blossom into an All-Star unless he bucks established MLB norms.
• Ultimately, the episode argues that Smith is unfairly burdened by expectations of stardom, noting most teams would accept his current production from a right fielder, especially over a decade.
• The tone is self-aware, with hosts recognizing the tendency of media and fans to overhype or underappreciate young players based on early labels and team context.

---

For listeners seeking sharp Astros analysis and a candid take on prospect evaluation, this episode offers a nuanced, statistically grounded discussion—with plenty of good-natured banter and honest self-reflection.

Transcript

[Oregon Lottery Announcer]

Oregon parks make an Oregon summer, but what makes an Oregon park well, Oregon Lottery gameplay helps no matter the game Megabucks, video lottery or keno funds from lottery games help support parks projects across the state, ensuring they stay safe, accessible, and open for all. In fact, Discover State Park Scratches are in stores now. It's the perfect way to put a little bit of Oregon's parks in your pocket. The Oregon Lottery Together we do good things. Must be 18 or older to play. Lottery games are based on chance and should be played for entertainment only.

[Boar's Head Spokesperson]

Dedication isn't born in the light of day. It's carved in the quiet hours before the world blinks awake. At Boar's Head, we rise with a mission to deliver craftsmanship worthy of your table. A slice of something special folded into every moment worth savoring. Because dedication means delivering only the very best.

[Mistplay Advertiser]

Thank you.

[Sports Analyst Seth Payne]

You're welcome.

[Boar's Head Spokesperson]

Boar's Head Committed to craft since 1905

[Mistplay Advertiser]

at Amica Insurance, we know it's not just about where you're going, but who you go with. That's why we work even harder to protect what matters most. And as a mutual insurance company, we're built for our customers and prioritize your needs. Amica empathy is our best policy. Visit amica.com and get a quote today.

[Sports Analyst Luke Morrow]

Are you being unfair to Cam Smith? It's Payne and Pendergast. I'm Luke Morrow in for Sean alongside Seth Payne. You can always text the show 713-572-4610 to join the conversation on the text line. Where we did hear from somebody who tailors suits for professional athletes here in Houston. So oh yeah, we got everybody out there listening. Join the conversation on YouTube and Twitch as well. Are you being unfair to Cam Smith?

[Sports Analyst Seth Payne]

Wait, you said somebody texted in who does Taylor professional tailor for professional athletes? What's he say? He's probably one of the good ones.

[Sports Analyst Luke Morrow]

He said we do all the suits for Houston pro athletes, including many of the Astros tapered and somewhat form fitting retailer suits. Yada yada yada. Anyways, they said sneakers can work as long as they are clean and fit with the event.

[Sports Analyst Seth Payne]

Yeah.

[Sports Analyst Luke Morrow]

Oh, and then they also said we'd love to have you stop by. All right. I got a wedding going to a wedding later this month, so hey, hook me up. I'll be there. Adam Ross custom. Appreciate you listening. I won't be wearing sneakers, but I'll take the suit. Are we being unfair to Cam Smith? I had this realization the other day and he had a good night last night. Like the whole back Half of the lineup did for the Astros. But I had this realization of, you know, like, he's going to be a. He's like a Gold Glove outfielder. Last I checked, which might have been maybe two weeks ago. He was towards the top of the league and like defensive run saved for outfielders.

[Sports Analyst Seth Payne]

Yeah.

[Sports Analyst Luke Morrow]

And he's on pace to hit 20 homers. And his batting average obviously is not there. You know, he's a career.230 hitter, which is not good. But we're grading on a curve when it comes to batting average these days. That's almost like a.260 hitter 25 years ago, you know, not terrible, which sounds crazy to say, but my point being, Gold Glove 20 Homer guy, wouldn't you sign that for up for that each year to have a very good right fielder who's going to have some pop in the lineup. That's almost like an. You know, Andrew Jones had a Hall of Fame career by just playing good outfield hitting homers. I think he had a career like.250 average. Never a great hitter, but he's a Hall of Famer because he played good defense and had some pop. Cam Smith can do that for you. I think Cam Smith is almost a. What's the word I'm looking for? I think he's been hurt by the expectations that have been bestowed upon him.

[Sports Analyst Seth Payne]

Well, I think, I guess the only issue I have with that is that you're also like, if you're going to say, okay, this is what he's going to be. I'd be kind of alarmed if a guy who probably came up into the majors too early and he was fast tracked as this shiny new toy that you need to get him into the majors. He can learn on the fly as much as possible that in his second year, this is going to be what he is for the rest of his career. Like, he's still very, very young and he has been like in a. I did an extreme cherry pick where I went down. I went back 43 games to May 9, but like, okay, let's cherry pick a little bit it. Since May 9, he's got a.756 OPS. So he's an above average or just right around average. A little bit above average as at the plate, while also being really, really good in the outfield. He's got it. For whatever it's worth, his war is 1/10 above Kyle Tucker's overall war right now. Yeah, if you want to go for B ref's war, that's where he is, you know, and it's this is all anchored by defense. It never feels. I hate, I hate taking somebody's overall war and acting like that tells the whole picture because, like, having a guy who's a drain in your lineup doesn't. It isn't offset by his defensive contributions. But I think that, I think for where he is right now and what your expectations should be, reasonably, there's just no reason to. There's no reason for me, at least that I can think of, that, oh, yeah, this is what he's going to be for the rest of his career. And like, he's already sealed his fate. In terms of not being a plus player at the plate.

[Sports Analyst Luke Morrow]

I would normally agree with you, but I did this exercise a few weeks back when I was on a different show and I looked into it and I asked again, going back to AI, I didn't do the legwork, but I asked AI, I said, give me players that hit 230 or worse through the first 1,000 plate appearances. And I wanted to see if they ever did turn it around. And the only guy there was one, I think it was Mike Schmidt was the only guy that turned into like a great baseball player. After struggling that mightily early on, Cam Smith is now over 800 plate appearances. So he's not at 1000 yet, but I think he's a career like 229 hitter. Historically. And again, batting average, we have to look at it on a curve now, but historically, guys that don't hit well or at least hit for average through their first a thousand plate appearances.

[Sports Analyst Seth Payne]

Yeah.

[Sports Analyst Luke Morrow]

They don't turn it around enough to at least become like a perennial All Star or Hall of Famer.

[Sports Analyst Seth Payne]

Yeah, I guess. Yeah, I guess. Wait, did you say Mike Schmidt?

[Sports Analyst Luke Morrow]

I think Mike Schmidt was the one.

[Sports Analyst Seth Payne]

I guess that's like a pretty high bar. It's weird that Mike Schmidt would be the only. So that's a. If you're, if you're saying, okay, he's not going to be Mike Schmidt, I'm not going to cry into my pillow at night over that necessarily was that. But that was that the only notably good, like, guy that became an All Star, etc. Etc. Right. any point.

[Sports Analyst Luke Morrow]

Yeah, the only notable guy that was batting 230 or worse through their first 1000 career plate appearances and then really turned it on.

[Sports Analyst Seth Payne]

It's hard, though, because it is. Batting average is such a. Yeah. An afterthought now in terms of what guys are even worried about or concerned about. The power is what intrigues people. Like with Cam Smith. More than anything.

[Sports Analyst Luke Morrow]

Right. And to your point. And look war like you laid out it's not a perfect stat. Take it with a grain of salt what is it good for? But I had to take the low hanging fruit but, but but it shows that what he does overall all encompassing when you factor in the defense that to this point statistically he's been more valuable than even a Kyle Tucker. Even though he's batting only like 229. He doesn't draw a ton of walks, but he hits homers. He plays really good defense and that adds something to a team. So I think there's two things at play for Cam Smith. Number one, he's part of part of the worst outfield in the MLB right now and one of the worst in Astros history. So I think he gets grouped into that that when the people next to him look so bad we can be guilty of of associating Cam Smith with the Jake Myers and the Joey Loper Feto. Yeah, in the minors I don't think it helps that the outfield just overall we have such negative thoughts about the outfield because it's been so bad and Cam Smith is part of the outfield

[Oregon Lottery Announcer]

Oregon Parks make an Oregon Summer but what makes an Oregon park? Well, Oregon Lottery Gameplay helps no matter the game Megabucks, video lottery or keno funds from lottery games help support parks projects across the state, ensuring they stay safe, accessible and open for all. In fact, Discover State Park Scratches are in stores now. It's the perfect way to put a little bit of Oregon's parks in your pocket. The Oregon Lottery Together we do good things. Must be 18 or older to play Lottery games are based on chance and should be played for entertainment only.

[Sports Analyst Luke Morrow]

Lemonade Fresh squeezed lemonade Lemonade.

[Boar's Head Spokesperson]

Oh nuts.

[Richard Deitch]

Is your business struggling to be seen not reaching the right customers?

[Boar's Head Spokesperson]

Yeah.

[Richard Deitch]

Odysee's here to help your one stop shop for digital marketing.

[Mistplay User/Advertiser]

Wait, really?

[Richard Deitch]

With targeted digital media plus SEO, SEM, social OTT and more, we help your business reach the right audience and drive results.

[Boar's Head Spokesperson]

Whoa. Hey.

[Oregon Lottery Announcer]

One at a time.

[Richard Deitch]

Stop missing out on valuable customers. Visit digitallocalads.com to learn more about our local advertising solutions. That's digitallocalads.com okay people, line starts here.

[Mistplay User/Advertiser]

Paragould has luxury home's largest selection of outdoor furniture, lighting, decor and more. Access more than 2,000 of design's best brands with beautiful all weather pieces in every style from traditional to modern. Plus, enjoy free design services and full service delivery on most items. Shop in store and [e-mail] Paragould Luxury lives here.

[Sports Analyst Seth Payne]

Yeah. And then, I mean, it doesn't help when you've got both of your, you know, the guys that you've put all your faith into, including Bryce Matthews, who's new to the outfield himself and also isn't providing anything either. Like the. We've gone from back in the day waiting for, oh boy, when's Springer gonna come up? When's Carlos Correa gonna come up? When Alex Bregman coming up. We've gone to like, oh no, you don't have to wait for those guys to come up. We're just gonna throw them out there and they're going to disappoint you. I feel like it's a, it's a double whammy that we don't even get the, the anti. We don't get as much of an anticipation for their, for their arrivals. And then it's been a very underwhelming appearance when they do show up.

[Sports Analyst Luke Morrow]

And then the other thing though to me is like I said, the expectations where it's not Cam Smith's fault. They labeled him as like the number one prospect in this camp Miss Guy. It's almost like the preseason rankings in college sports where when a team doesn't live up to that ranking, it's like, oh, what a disappointment. This team stinks. And it's like, well, they didn't put that ranking on themselves. Maybe just all of the college football writers had it wrong and overrated or overvalued this team. Similar at Cam Smith where people are going to say, oh, what a bust, he was the number one prospect. Well, he didn't assign himself as that. Maybe it was the evaluators who were wrong, put these lofty expectations on him. But if you were to remove those expectations and say he was a no name minor leaguer, but just hypothetically speaking, say he's your right fielder for 10 years, winning Gold Gloves and hitting 20 homers a year. I think a lot of teams would sign up for that. Yeah, but because he's supposed to be.

[Sports Analyst Seth Payne]

Well, it's a, I mean, for, for the trade and being able to, you know, you know, claim victory in that trade, which I think they already can just by virtue of the, the number of guys that you brought in that are actual contributors. And we'll see about Wisneski when he comes back. That, that, that part of it, the expectations and him being a five tool player and everything else that goes along with it. Yeah, I don't, but I don't have, you sensed. Have you sensed a whole lot of frustration about Cam Smith specifically? I don't feel like the fan base is done with Cam Smith or something, but maybe I don't spend enough time on social media.

[Sports Analyst Luke Morrow]

Honestly. I think they moved. I think it was a lot of Cam Smith early on, like the second half of last year and early this season and, and then this kind of goes against the point I made a few moments ago. But I think people have moved on to like Joey Loafer, Feto, Jake Meyer, like the other disappointments, even though they don't have as high of a profile as Cam Smith. But I think there's other guys that are doing worse. Mike Burroughs, you know, ima that they're the ones drawing the ire. And you kind of you let Cam Smith slide because he's not the worst guy on the team right now. So we'll see. On the text line, somebody said if Cam Smith was still at second base, he would be considered top 25% of second baseman. Yeah, maybe. And another I like this other text coming up next. Are we being too hard on Reed Shepherd? Yeah, I guess.

[Mistplay User/Advertiser]

Maybe.

[Sports Analyst Seth Payne]

I know.

[Sports Analyst Luke Morrow]

Let's do the maybe I'm being too positive.

[Sports Analyst Seth Payne]

Pause in early July here and figure out who we're being too tough on. Yeah, I was a little mean about that Pulisic character earlier on. I got to give him another decade, see if he can figure it out.

[Sports Analyst Luke Morrow]

Yeah, I guess I've been too positive here this past hour. So when we come back, let's flip the flip the bill here and get to the petty cast who's being petty in the sports world? We'll bring you the audio next. Pain and pen or gas?

[Oregon Lottery Announcer]

Oregon parks make an Oregon summer. But what makes an Oregon Park? Well, Oregon Lottery gameplay helps no matter the game Megabucks, video lottery or keno, funds from lottery games help support parks projects across the state, ensuring they stay safe, accessible and open for all. In fact, Discover State Park Scratches are in stores now. It's the perfect way to put a little bit of Oregon's parks in the Oregon Lottery. Together we do good things. Must be 18 or older to play. Lottery games are based on chance and should be played for entertainment only.

[Richard Deitch]

Hey, this is Richard Deitch, the host

[Sports Analyst Luke Morrow]

of the Sports Media Podcast. If you're interested in what's happening with all the places where you consume sports, the Sports Media Podcast has you covered.

[Richard Deitch]

I've been turning down interviews all week. Hoda Kapi reached out. Oprah, George Stephanopoulos. So I said no. I was booked on the DCH Podcast before the Taylor Swift phenomenon, I must live up to my responsibility.

[Sports Analyst Luke Morrow]

Listen wherever you get your podcasts.

[Oregon Lottery Announcer]

Another game day.

[Mistplay User/Advertiser]

But while he's glued to the tv,

[Mistplay Advertiser]

I'm winning my own way with Mistplay.

[Sports Analyst Seth Payne]

Let's go.

[Mistplay User/Advertiser]

Mistplay rewards me just for playing free mobile games. I earn points and swap them for gift cards to Amazon, Uber Eats, and Sephora.

[Sports Analyst Seth Payne]

Yeah, we won.

[Mistplay User/Advertiser]

And I just redeemed a Target gift card.

[Boar's Head Spokesperson]

Woo.

[Mistplay User/Advertiser]

Download Mistplay today and turn your downtime into rewards.

[Mistplay Advertiser]

Need a boost? Sometimes all it takes is tapping into your inner cool. Icebreaker's gum helps you unleash the confidence within. Each chew releases a rush of icy flavor powered by cooling flavor crystals, sending a wave of refreshment to reinvigorate all your senses. Icebreaker's convenient pack fits everywhere from car cup holders to backpack pockets so you can find your cool wherever you go. Grab Icebreaker's gum online or at a store near you.

[Anna Garcia]

I'm Anna Garcia, host of True Crime News, the podcast. Every week we bring you in depth coverage on cases making headlines as well as those that go under the radar. Tune in for murders that defy explanation, mystery seeking exploration, and shocking secrets that will leave you breathless. Each week we honor the victims by going beyond the salacious in our search for justice. Crime never stops, and neither do we. Listen to True Crime News, available now on the Odyssey app or wherever you get your podcasts.