Is NICK CASERIO the best in the NFL at finding one position?

Summary

---

Podcast Summary: Payne & Pendergast

Episode: Is NICK CASERIO the best in the NFL at finding one position?
Date: July 22, 2026
Hosts: Seth Payne & Sean Pendergast (SportsRadio 610, Houston)

Episode Overview

This episode tackles a compelling question: Is Texans GM Nick Caserio the best in the NFL at identifying and acquiring defensive backs? Seth and Sean break down Caserio’s impressive track record with defensive backs, explore the synergy between the front office and coaching staff, and explain why Houston has become a surprisingly reliable pipeline for productive DBs—even without high draft picks. The hosts provide insight on player development, the importance of coaching, and notable trends in the Texans' draft strategy, especially with late-round talent from programs like USC.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

Caserio’s Defensive Back Success Story

Timestamp: 04:32 - 07:11

• The perception around Houston is that Nick Caserio is exceptional at finding quality defensive backs.

• Remarkably, most of Houston’s current defensive backs were not high draft picks; Derek Stingley Jr. is the only first-rounder.

• Seth highlights that Texan’s DB success is a combination of:

  • Caserio identifying the right players.
  • Dynamic coaching—a particular nod to Dino Vasso, D’Ameco Ryans, and Matt Burke—who maximize players’ skills.
  • The match between player, system, and coaching.

    “It's a combination of identifying the right kinds of guys that fit D'Ameco's system, but then also Dino Vasso coaching those guys up and getting the most out of them. It's a group effort.” – Seth Payne [06:26]

• The physical profile of these DBs isn’t always elite, but their attitude, toughness, and fit with Houston’s physical defensive philosophy are what set them apart.

List of Caserio’s Drafted Defensive Backs

Timestamp: 07:11; 09:01 - 10:24

• Eight DBs drafted since Caserio’s arrival; only Stingley and Petrie (second-round) were high picks.
• Notable names:
  • Jalen Petrie: Second rounder, standout rookie year but still developing.
  • Kamari Lassiter, Kalen Bullock: Both became Pro Bowlers; initially not high-profile picks.
  • Jalen Smith: Third round last year, considered a reach at the time but drawing rave reviews.
  • Other names: Brandon Hill (7th rd), Jalen Reed (6th rd), Kamari Ramsey (day 3), and more.
• Many have overperformed relative to their draft position.

  “Kamari Lassiter, likewise. There's really, really good coaching... It does annoy me when I hear from people outside of Houston say, well, they just line up and play because they've got such good players.” – Seth Payne [05:48]

The Houston Advantage: Scouting, Coaching, & Culture

Timestamp: 05:47 - 07:11

• Sean and Seth emphasize it’s not just scouting; coaching and team culture are crucial.
• Many DBs Houston finds may have failed elsewhere or been overlooked because other teams didn't realize their fit in the right scheme.
• D’Ameco Ryans and Dino Vasso’s coaching “get the most out of” the DBs’ talent.

The Value of Late-Round & “Distressed” Assets

Timestamp: 10:07 - 13:32

• A noticeable trend: Houston frequently drafts players from USC in later rounds—especially defenders—because the hosts believe those players are physically talented but underdeveloped in college.

  “They get guys cheap because USC hasn't developed them as well as they should... They’re buying low on those guys.” – Seth Payne [10:26]

• Seth and Sean joke that while the Texans brass will praise coaching at Iowa State or Minnesota, they’re silent about USC—indicating it’s a market inefficiency Caserio exploits.
• Examples (drafted since 2024): Kaylin Bullock, Solomon Byrd, Woody Marks, Jalen Smith, Kamari Ramsey.

  “Five guys from USC in the last three years and not a word about how great the USC program. No, they're all day three guys too. They're all day three and like three of them probably should have been day two at least.” – Sean Pendergast [13:12]

Have Any Caserio Picks Flopped and Thrived Elsewhere?

Timestamp: 11:04 - 12:48

• Seth: Few players drafted by Caserio have left Houston and excelled as starters with other teams.
  • Example: Roy Lopez, late-round pick, had some success elsewhere (DT for the Texans, started with the Raiders after leaving Houston).
• Most picks washed out or remained backups in the NFL if they did not stick in Houston.
• Christian Harris (LB): Once considered a major part of the defense, injuries derailed his career; now in Atlanta.

  “Christian Harris. That'll be the one I'll be. Well, he's in Atlanta now, if I'm not mistaken... it may just very well be Christian Harris isn't going to be a good NFL football [player].” – Sean Pendergast [12:29]

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On the keys to the Texans’ DB success:
  “It's a combination of identifying the right kinds of guys that fit D'Ameco's system, but then also Dino Vasso coaching those guys up and getting the most out of them. It's a group effort.”
  – Seth Payne [06:26]

• On Houston’s “market inefficiency” with USC prospects:
  “Five guys from USC in the last three years and not a word about how great the USC program. No, they're all day three guys too. They're all day three and like three of them probably should have been day two at least.”
  – Sean Pendergast [13:12]

• On outside critics undervaluing coaching:
  “It does annoy me when I hear from people outside of Houston say, well, they just line up and play because they've got such good players... Where were you guys pre draft talking about these guys?”
  – Seth Payne [05:48]

• On the collaborative front office–coaching relationship:
  “It's always about the mix of your GM and your head coach and how well they work together. And I think that D’Ameco and Nick work really well together.”
  – Seth Payne [05:02]

---

Segment Timestamps

• [04:32] – Introduction of main topic: Is Houston best at finding DBs?
• [05:47] – Coaching’s role and “pre-draft” hypocrisy
• [07:11] – Breakdown of Caserio’s draft history with DBs
• [09:01] – Evaluating “over-drafted” players and development stories
• [10:07] – How Houston targets underdeveloped college talent, especially from USC
• [11:04] – Discussion of former picks’ success/failure outside Houston
• [12:29] – Christian Harris as a case study for non-success stories
• [13:32] – Recap on Texans’ “distressed asset” strategy with USC players

---

Takeaways

• Nick Caserio’s reputation for drafting and developing defensive backs is well-deserved, but the real success is a synergy between scouting, coaching, and team culture.
• The Texans make a habit of exploiting “market inefficiencies” by targeting physically talented but underdeveloped late-round players from certain colleges, especially USC.
• Coaching, especially under D’Ameco Ryans and staff, elevates overlooked or undervalued prospects into NFL contributors and sometimes Pro Bowlers.
• Most of Caserio’s picks who don’t stick in Houston don’t tend to become breakout NFL stars elsewhere, suggesting it’s not just about raw talent, but about Houston’s unique developmental environment.

---

This summary captures all essential analysis and banter from Payne & Pendergast’s July 22, 2026 episode, giving you an in-depth understanding of Houston’s defensive back success story without sitting through the ad reads or unrelated segments.

Transcript

[Facebook Advertiser]

You know, that thing that you love? You'll find others geeking out about it on Facebook. Whether you're looking for community or inspiration, Facebook helps turn passion into action. Obsessed with running a marathon? Discover a neighborhood run club group, Start training and meet your new neighbor. Thinking about cooking more at home? Connect with meal prep groups to discover recipes in a new community. And as you're scrolling the feed, you may even find reels showing you top running shoes or the best tools for your culinary journey this summer. Find more on Facebook.

[Progressive Insurance Representative]

Ever notice how life's best stories don't happen in your living room? They happen on the open road, out on the water, or parked under the stars. At Progressive, they get that you want to focus on the experience, not worry about the what ifs. That's why they offer quality insurance designed for your ride, whether That's a boat, RV, or motorcycle adventure with confidence. Visit progressive.com and see how easy it is to protect your favorite way to get away. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates not available in D.C. prices vary based on

[Fast Food Advertiser]

how you buy on the under $3 menu. At McDonald's, a McChicken is $2, because when you're craving a McChicken, you deserve a McChicken. And now that McChicken is just $2,

[Sports Analyst 1]

limited time only, prices and participation may vary.

[Sports Analyst 2]

Prices may be higher for delivery things. Big announcement 10am today. Be here for that. 9am will circle back to one of the big stories today. The Miami Heat accidentally air quotes leaking a link to a YouTube. A YouTube link for a press conference to introduce LeBron James on Monday. Posted it last night, took it down quickly, downplayed it, said we were just doing it just in case. We'll talk about that.

[Sports Analyst 1]

Yeah. What are they having a fire drill or something? Like, hey, just gonna go through this. This is what we'll do.

[Sports Analyst 2]

This is what it's like to put a YouTube link up.

[Sports Analyst 1]

Yeah. Yeah.

[Sports Analyst 2]

It takes so long.

[Sports Analyst 1]

Oh, God. What if it was that? What if it's just like somebody onboarding a new social media person, just having fun? Like, okay, so this is what you do. Let's say we're gonna. We're gonna introduce LeBron James. And then they went through it and the. Into the eager young intern. Hit, hit enter and then you hit post like this. Yeah.

[Fast Food Advertiser]

All right.

[Sports Analyst 2]

By the way, Patrick Creighton, colleague and friend here AT Sports Radio 6 10, said his rule would be the Baytown

[Sports Analyst 1]

rule of you can't make it to Baytown without getting annoyed with a guy that you're interviewing.

[Sports Analyst 2]

Boot him Out. He said, if you get to that BUC EE's right there at exit what, 7, 91 or something like that. Out. And for those wondering what we're talking about, I told a story about how if you're looking to hire people and you're not sure if you should hire them, then we call it the. We'll call it here. We'll call, you know, Patrick, we'll call it the Baytown rule. Pretend that you're driving to New Orleans from Houston. And if you want to beat the snot out of the person by the time you get to Baytown, do not hire that person.

[Sports Analyst 1]

Yeah.

[Sports Analyst 2]

Do not surround yourself with. With people that fail the Baytown rule.

[Sports Analyst 1]

Hey, Speaking of BUC EE's, by the way.

[Tire Rack Advertiser]

Yeah.

[Sports Analyst 1]

So I was driving. I was driving towards Texarkana on Interstate 30, you know, from up northeast, and I saw Buc EE's sign and I got excited and then It's. It's like Buc ee's 137 miles.

[Sports Analyst 2]

Oh, they do that all the time.

[Sports Analyst 1]

I know, but I don't. I don't like it. No, I don't either. I hate it. I was all I was looking at, you know, I. I like going to truck stops more so than they tend to be cleaner, have more options, usually better rest or like better fast food and everything.

[Sports Analyst 2]

One impulse buys.

[Sports Analyst 1]

Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Like, oh, yeah, I totally need this Dickies jacket and. Or a fluorescent vest. Yeah, I need this fluorescent vest. And I need one of those trucker. Trucker headsets. Yes. They only cover one ear. No, I didn't like it. But right around the same time, one of the most impressively, impressively jerk drivers I've ever seen. Guy driving aggressively while pulling a travel trailer with a big jacked up Ram pickup truck. That was all it was. And it was, it was. It was adjusted to be able to roll coal. So like, no, it was. This guy must have. I wanted to go. I wanted to pull this guy over and interview him because he's. He's willing a pretty big travel trailer and like dodging in and out of traffic. And every time he's jamming on the gas, it's blowing black smoke up. It was the most dangerous thing I've ever seen in my entire life. And yet I have like a grudging respect for just the. The amount of testosterone and idiocy coursing through this guy.

[Sports Analyst 2]

That's hilarious.

[Sports Analyst 1]

This guy has definitely been married six times. Yeah.

[Sports Analyst 2]

Yes. And smoke seven packs a day. Okay, question. Are the Texans the best in the NFL at finding defensive backs, at staffing a defensive backs room. This front looks.

[Sports Analyst 1]

This coach kind of been the. The word or the narrative or the belief around Casario since he's been here is like, man, he's really hit it out of the park with defensive backs.

[Sports Analyst 2]

And the only high pick in that room is Derek Stingley.

[Sports Analyst 1]

Right, right, right. I think that's where it's a combo deal. And, you know, I always like to look at, like, I think there's so many times. And I go back to, you know, Charlie Casserly and Don Dom Capers with our first team here. I think both of those guys were awesome at their jobs. I don't know if they were the right fit for each other. And it's not because, if anything, it was because, like, neither one of them was an a hole. Like, which that's. It doesn't have to be that way. But I think that it's always about the mix of your GM and your head coach and how well they work together. And I think that d' Ameco and Nick work really well together. So, like, I don't know. I don't know how good Kaylin Bullock would have been if he'd gone to other teams. I don't know how good Jaylen Petrie would be if he'd gone to other teams and had different coaches. You know, he had a very promising rookie year, but there was a lot of stuff that he had to work on.

[Sports Analyst 2]

What about Lassiter?

[Sports Analyst 1]

Lassiter, likewise. I think that Lassiter. There's a. There's really, really good coaching. Like, Dino Vasso does an incredible job coaching those guys. D' Amico and Matt Burke have done a great job putting together that defense. And one thing that it does annoy me when I hear from people outside of Houston say, well, well, they just line up and play because they've got such good players. And like, all right, look, they've got. And they'll. They'll start reeling off Kalin Bullock, Kamari Lassiter, Jalen Petrie. Well, where were you guys pre draft talking about these guys?

[Sports Analyst 2]

Exactly.

[Sports Analyst 1]

You know, like, wait a second. Aren't you the guy that said that Kamari Lassiter was too slow to go in the first round?

[Sports Analyst 2]

Yeah.

[Sports Analyst 1]

So it's a combination of identifying the right kinds of guys that fit d' Amico's system, but then also Dino Vasso coaching those guys up and getting the most out of them. It's a group effort. Yeah. Yeah. Like, it's like, to have. To have. This is plenty. Like, you don't want to get too married to draft status or anything, but to have that many guys who aren't first round picks so don't have those, those high level physical traits coming out of college to be performing as they are as well as they are individually. Yeah, that's a lot of it's on. It's Kasario finding the right guys for the system. It's. It's the coaching that goes on and then it's the players themselves just kind of they're like having the right attitude and mindset to play this defense which involves a whole lot more physicality than than what they want out of defensive backs elsewhere.

[Sports Analyst 2]

Yeah, Casario has drafted eight defensive backs since he got here as the GM. Most of them have been while D' Amico Ryan has been here. The two that were not were Derek Stingley Jr. Who's the third overall pick in the draft and then Jalen Petrie was a second round pick. The others are Brandon Hill was a seventh round pick.

[Squarespace Advertiser]

He's Squarespace is not only the best place to build your website, but to discover new domains too. Something like topfootballcamp.com for your top football camp. Whisperingbloom.com for your silent retreat. Or whisperingboom.com for your shouting retreat. Maybe velvetcords.com for your music studio or existentialglitter.com for your artist studio. With a website from Squarespace, you can build your brand and your business [e-mail] get your domain before they're gone with offer code. Make it real for 10% off your domain or website.

[Facebook Advertiser]

You know that thing that you love? You'll find others geeking out about it on Facebook. Whether you're looking for community or inspiration, Facebook helps turn passion into action. Obsessed with running a marathon? Discover a neighborhood run club group. Start training and meet your new neighbor. Thinking about cooking more at home? Connect with meal prep groups to discover recipes in a new community. And as you're scrolling the feed, you may even find reels showing you top running shoes or the best tools for your culinary journey this summer. Find more on Facebook Lemonade Fresh squeezed Lemonade Lemonade. Oh no.

[Digital Marketing Representative]

Is your business struggling to be seen not reaching the right customer?

[Insurance Advertiser]

Yeah.

[Digital Marketing Representative]

Odyssey's here to help your one stop shop for digital marketing. Wait, really? With targeted digital media plus SEO, SEM, Social, OTT and more, we help your business reach the right audience and drive results.

[Fast Food Advertiser]

Whoa.

[Tire Rack Advertiser]

Hey.

[Insurance Advertiser]

One at a time.

[Digital Marketing Representative]

Stop missing out on valuable customers. Visit digitallocalads.com to learn more about our local advertising solutions that's digitallocalads.com okay, people, line starts here.

[Sports Analyst 2]

You know he seventh round pick, Kamari Lassiter, Pro Bowler, Kalen Bullock, Pro Bowler. And I know they're alternates and they may, but they're good players. Yeah, Jalen Smith is a really interesting one to me. Drafted in the third round last year by the consensus boards, maybe overdrafted a little bit. He was seen more as a day three guy than a third round pick. Their guys, his teammates this off season have been gushing about him. Yeah, he's had a good off season.

[Sports Analyst 1]

No, and he, you know, he had a hamstring injury last year that basically just wiped out anything that, that you might have seen out of him. But yeah, they seem, they seem to like him a lot. And I think he's another one that when you watch him in college, okay. There's a lot of elements to where you see, okay, he's not afraid of contact whatsoever. Makes a lot of plays behind the line of scrimmage. The, the high level physical traits aren't there. But we've seen, we've seen the Texans get the absolute most out of guys physical ability by, by coaching him up real well. And then Jalen Reed and Kamari Rams Jalen Reed last year and Kamari Ramsey.

[Sports Analyst 2]

Jalen Reed got on the field last year, six round pick, but he, and

[Sports Analyst 1]

he had injuries that he was dealing with too as a rookie. Yep. Kamari Ramsey is another interesting one. Kamari Ramsey, the latest of the Texans liking some college programs because they seem to be coached really well, but then liking USC because I think they don't get enough out of, get this guy

[Sports Analyst 2]

three rounds later in his talent.

[Sports Analyst 1]

They get guys cheap because USC hasn't developed them as well as they should

[Sports Analyst 2]

pay attention to defense there.

[Sports Analyst 1]

I think if they drafted more USC players than any other college in the last couple of years, there's at least

[Sports Analyst 2]

four or five USC guys on the team.

[Fast Food Advertiser]

Yeah.

[Sports Analyst 1]

So the, because you know, Nick and d' Ameco both said like, okay, well we know they love Matt Campbell and he does such a great job with the Iowa State guys. Yeah, they like what's his name up there in Minnesota. They'll talk PJ Flag. They'll, they'll draft some of these guys and they'll gush about the program that they come up, come out of. And yet they draft all these USC guys and they never brag about the program. Yeah, they're buying low on those guys.

[Sports Analyst 2]

Who's the best player that Nick has drafted that didn't work out Here. You know what I mean? And I'm not saying defensive backs. I'm saying just in general, the best

[Sports Analyst 1]

player that they haven't. That Nick has drafted. Honestly, I was hosting this. I think it's Roy Lopez probably. So Roy Lopez, the defensive tackle who is his Knicks last pick in his first draft.

[Sports Analyst 2]

First draft, yeah.

[Sports Analyst 1]

Sixth or seventh round pick. He's gone on to do some good things. I was going through, and I didn't find a lot of other guys who were drafted here, left and then became consistent starters elsewhere. Thomas Booker did start 13 games for the Raiders last year.

[Sports Analyst 2]

Okay.

[Sports Analyst 1]

Like, Garrett Wallow and Austin Deculas have had a few starts here and there, but they're just largely backups.

[Sports Analyst 2]

Yep.

[Sports Analyst 1]

And, yeah, it's. It's been like they're. They're. Yeah, a lot of those. It's not like, okay, the Texans didn't get the most out of these guys, and then they go somewhere else and they're. They look awesome.

[Sports Analyst 2]

The two. The two that I'll keep an eye on this year, the big one I'll keep an eye on is Christian Harris.

[Fast Food Advertiser]

Yeah.

[Sports Analyst 2]

Because two years ago it was.

[Squarespace Advertiser]

Chris.

[Sports Analyst 2]

After the 2023 postseason, Christian Harris was viewed like a guy who could be in line to get a second contract from the Texans. He was arguably the best player on the field defensively for them in those playoff games that year, d' Ameco's first year here. And then the calf injury hit, and then the calf injury healed, but he just never got back on the field again. Christian Harris. That'll be the one I'll be. Well, he's in Atlanta now, if I'm not mistaken.

[Sports Analyst 1]

Yeah.

[Sports Analyst 2]

And look, it may just very well be. Christian Harris isn't going to be a good NFL football.

[Sports Analyst 1]

Well, I think with him, it would be that that calf injury just ended up being some kind of lingering, weird thing that happens with these lower leg injuries sometimes where just the. The nerves don't come back the right way. I don't know. Like, it just whatever the hell Joe Mixon had last year.

[Sports Analyst 2]

Yeah.

[Fast Food Advertiser]

Yeah.

[Sports Analyst 1]

The USC in the last few years has been really.

[Sports Analyst 2]

Can I. Can I try to name them real quick here?

[Sports Analyst 1]

Yeah, you have to name chronologically.

[Sports Analyst 2]

You got them in front of you here. Okay. Okay. So I'm going to say you're going

[Sports Analyst 1]

to miss the one real obvious one.

[Sports Analyst 2]

Does it start in 2024?

[Sports Analyst 1]

It starts in 2024.

[Sports Analyst 2]

Okay, so that would be Kaylin Bullock and Solomon Byrd.

[Sports Analyst 1]

Okay, you got that? Good.

[Sports Analyst 2]

Okay. And then the next year would be Woody Marks and Jalen Smith.

[Sports Analyst 1]

Yep, you got that.

[Sports Analyst 2]

And then Kamari Ramsey last year.

[Sports Analyst 1]

Five guys from USC in the last three years and not a word about how great the USC program.

[Sports Analyst 2]

No, they're all day three guys too. They're all day three and like three of them probably should have been day two at least.

[Sports Analyst 1]

This is where we go to find.

[Sports Analyst 2]

Bullock was a third rounder, so he was day two.

[Sports Analyst 1]

Right. But this is where we go to find undeveloped talent.

[Progressive Insurance Representative]

Ye.

[Sports Analyst 1]

Yeah.

[Sports Analyst 2]

Treasure trove of distressed assets.

[Sports Analyst 1]

I don't know. Like Woody Mark. Woody Marks wouldn't fit that category because they used them a lot, both at Mississippi State and at us.

[Sports Analyst 2]

And he was on offense. Yeah.

[Fast Food Advertiser]

All right.

[Sports Analyst 1]

Yeah. The defensive guys, into the 9 o'

[Sports Analyst 2]

clock hour we go.

[Sports Analyst 1]

All right.

[Sports Analyst 2]

We mentioned it a little bit earlier. Is there an intern getting fired in Miami today over this mistake? Air quotes that happened with the Miami Heat and LeBron James last night. If you haven't heard the story, we'll give you our take on that.

[Fast Food Advertiser]

The Colonels cooked up a new $10 bucket of the day just for you. Monday 24 nuggets for $10. Tuesday 8 piece fried chicken for $10. Wednesday 10 wings for $10. Thursday 8 tenders for $10. Friday 24 nuggets for. Oh, you guessed it, didn't you? $10. The $10 bucket of the day deal every weekday only at KFC. It's finger licking goo Prices and participation

[Digital Marketing Representative]

Variable supplies last night of available on third party ordering platforms.

[Tire Rack Advertiser]

Tax extra Tires matter. They're the only part of your vehicle that touches the road. Tread confidently with new tires from Tire Rack. Whether you're looking for expert recommendations or know exactly what you want, Tire Rack makes it easy, fast. Free shipping, free road hazard protection and convenient installation options. Go to tirerack.com to see Tire test results, tire ratings and consumer reviews. And be sure to check out all the special offers. Tirerack.com the way Tire buying should be

[Insurance Advertiser]

at Ameca Insurance, we know it's not just about where you're going, but who you go with. That's why we work even harder to protect what matters most. And as a mutual insurance company, we're built for our customers and prioritize your needs. Amica Empathy is our best policy. Visit amica.com and get a quote today. Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard but not the pipeline? That's bullspend and marketers are calling it out in dashboard confessions.

[Sports Analyst 1]

My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had.

[Insurance Advertiser]

Impressions Cut the bull Spend See revenue, not just reach LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad NETWORKS. Advertise on LinkedIn, spend $250 on your first campaign and get a 250 DOL at go to LinkedIn.com Campaign Terms and Conditions apply.

[Oregon Lottery Representative]

Oregon Parks make an Oregon summer but what makes an Oregon park? Well? Oregon Lottery Gameplay helps no matter the game Megabucks, video lottery or keno funds from lottery games help support parks projects across the state, ensuring they stay safe, accessible, and open for all. In fact, Discover State Park Scratches are in stores now. It's the perfect way to put a little bit of Oregon's parks in your pocket. The Oregon Lottery Together we do good things. Must be 18 or older to play Lottery games are based on chance and should be played for entertainment only.