Tony Romo was arrested in Wisconsin

Summary

---

Payne & Pendergast – Episode Summary

Episode Title: Tony Romo was arrested in Wisconsin
Date: July 27, 2026
Hosts: Seth Payne & Sean Pendergast
Podcast by: Audacy

---

Overview

This episode of Payne & Pendergast centers on the breaking news that former Dallas Cowboys quarterback and CBS lead football analyst Tony Romo was arrested in Wisconsin for Operating While Intoxicated (OWI). The hosts weigh in with their trademark mix of serious sports analysis, irreverent humor, and local Houston angles. They also riff on a viral moment involving Mike Vrabel bringing a puppy to a press conference and debate the state of NFL broadcasting teams—particularly the futures of Romo and J.J. Watt as lead network analysts.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Press Conference Gimmicks: Kids vs. Puppies

[01:25 – 04:00]

• The episode kicks off with banter between Seth and Sean (Scott filling in for Sean) about what’s more inappropriate at a sports press conference: Joel Embiid bringing his kid or Mike Vrabel bringing a puppy.
  • Seth: “Much worse to me because [the puppy] is more deliberate. ... The child thing, it could be on purpose. It could also just be how Joel Embiid gets there.” [01:58]
  • Seth: “I don't think it's appropriate either way. Whether it's a win, a loss, you're going to get scrutinized or not, but it's up to that parent to do whatever they want.”
  • They joke about Vrabel needing an emotional support dog and the awkwardness that would ensue at practice.
  • Jim (Scott): “Can you imagine Vrabel at training camp, having to carry a support dog under his arm?” [03:00]
  • Seth: “The most trauma you’ve had is the summer where you get revealed as a philanderer.” [04:00]
  • Visual gags imagining DeAndre Hopkins holding a puppy for Vrabel during linebacker drills.

---

2. Tony Romo's Arrest & Broadcasting Future

[04:18 – 13:59]

The News Breaks

• Jim brings up the major headline: “Tony Romo busted for OWI in Milwaukee. Operating while intoxicated.” [04:18]
  • They lampoon how strange it would be to see Romo’s mugshot before surgery (“the last face you see as the ether kicks in” [04:31]).
  • Seth questions “what does that version of Tony Romo look and sound like when confronted with the possibility of going to jail?” [05:52]

The Tony Romo “Body Cam” Wait

• Jim says, “This is the first one I can think of in my life where I am going to be hitting refresh on TMZ to see when this thing drops. Tony Romo is so off kilter on these broadcasts. I can only imagine what failed sobriety tests look like for him.” [05:05]
  • They riff about Romo asking for NFL rules clarification from officiating analyst Gene Steratore during a field sobriety test.
  • Seth: “Gene, are they allowed to ask me to stand on one leg and recite the alphabet backwards?” [06:11]
  • Jim: “How many times did Tony Romo's voice crack in this encounter with the police?” [06:20]

Reviewing Romo’s Broadcasting Decline

• Both hosts agree Romo’s performance as a color commentator has dipped since his high-earning start.
  • Jim: “His performance as a broadcaster has not been to the level it was that earned him $18 million a year.” [06:33]
  • Raises the potential impact on Romo’s contract and CBS’s options.

Comparing Romo and J.J. Watt

• Seth and Jim tout J.J. Watt as a superior broadcaster who could replace Romo.
  • Jim: “I would also say J.J. Watt would never.” [08:58]
  • Seth agrees, especially noting the Wisconsin context—both Romo and Watt are state natives, but “J.J. Watt would never. ... Of all places [for Romo to get busted].” [09:07]
  • Allude to Brett Favre’s legendary but troubled tenure in Wisconsin (“How many did Brett Favre get away with back in the day?” [09:28])

Could JJ Take the Lead Job?

• The duo speculate on CBS possibly using this incident as a contractual out for Romo and promoting J.J. Watt.
  • Seth: “Could this be a reason with that on top of this? ... We’re gonna make JJ our top guy.” [10:59]
  • Jim: “J.J. has gotten really good at this really fast.” [11:33]
  • They express fondness for the J.J. Watt-Ian Eagle broadcasting team and argue they’d rather watch them than the current Jim Nantz-Tony Romo pairing.
  • Seth references the baseball concept of “Wally Pipping” (losing a job to a replacement): “An Iron Eagle, J.J. Watt, Wally Pipping of the Jim Nantz-Tony Romo combination… I would be absolutely fine with.” [12:28]
  • Jim notes: “Nance already feels like he’s a little annoyed by Tony Romo during broadcast.” [12:49]

Texans and JJ Watt Anecdote

• Jim shares a personal run-in with Watt at a Texans game, underscoring Watt’s preparedness as a broadcaster and adaptability on air. [13:16 – 13:59]

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On Vrabel’s Puppy:

  • Seth: “The most trauma you’ve had in this game is the summer where you get revealed as a philanderer.” [04:00]

• On Tony Romo’s OWI:

  • Jim: “Tony Romo seems like a super nice guy. His performance as a broadcaster has not been to the level it was that earned him $18 million a year.” [06:33]
  • Jim: “This is the first one I can think of in my life where I am going to be hitting refresh on TMZ to see when this thing drops.” [05:05]

• Gene Steratore Riff:

  • Seth: “Gene, are they allowed to ask me to stand on one leg and recite the alphabet backwards?” [06:11]

• On Broadcasting Future:

  • Seth: “I would prefer both of them [J.J. Watt and Ian Eagle] over the A team that they have now.” [12:28]

---

Key Timestamps

• 01:25–04:00 – Press Conference children/puppy debate; Vrabel's support dog jokes
• 04:18 – Breaking news: Tony Romo's mugshot & OWI arrest
• 05:05 – Hosts’ eagerness to see Romo’s “body cam” footage
• 06:11–06:20 – Gene Steratore field sobriety test bit
• 06:33–07:00 – Romo’s broadcasting performance decline discussion
• 08:57–09:41 – Would J.J. Watt ever be arrested like Romo? Wisconsin heroes
• 09:41–10:34 – If Romo had to answer NFL questions for his sobriety test
• 10:56–12:28 – Speculation on CBS swapping Romo for J.J. Watt
• 13:16–13:59 – Personal story about J.J. Watt’s on-camera skills

---

Tone & Style

• The conversation is irreverent, fast-moving, and packed with in-jokes familiar to Houston sports fans.
• Hosts balance pointed criticism (“Tony Romo’s decline is real”) with humor (broadcasting riffing, visual gags).
• Frequent references to NFL culture, CBS contracts, and Houston sports icons (notably J.J. Watt).

---

Summary

This episode blends real-time reaction to a significant sports-media controversy (Tony Romo’s arrest) with broader conversations about sports broadcasting and locker-room culture. Seth and Jim (filling in for Sean) dissect Romo’s future, poke fun at offbeat press conference optics, and highlight the ascent of J.J. Watt as a media personality. Their verdict: J.J. is poised to take over, and with incidents like Romo’s, that might happen sooner rather than later.

Quote to sum it up:
Jim: “Stop driving drunk, that’s what I would say. And then we won’t talk about it.” [11:51]

---

End of summary

Transcript

[Ad Voice]

Latte for Keenan.

[Keenan Thompson]

That's me.

[Ad Voice]

Hey, you're.

[Ad Voice 2]

Yeah.

[Ad Voice]

Buying a car online on autotrader.

[Keenan Thompson]

Really? But unlike other sites, you can start online, test drive with a local dealer, then finish online or at the dealership.

[Jim Pendergast]

Really?

[Ad Voice]

Wait, are you.

[Keenan Thompson]

Yep. It's Keaton.

[Ad Voice]

Able to finish in person without starting the process over.

[Keenan Thompson]

Really? Your info stays with you every step of the way.

[Ad Voice]

Cool. Enjoy.

[Keenan Thompson]

It's Keenan Thompson. Buy your car online on autotrader.

[Jim Pendergast]

Really avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start. Thumbtack knows homes, so you don't have to. Don't know the difference between matte paint, finish and satin or what that clunking sound from your dryer is. With thumbtack, you don't have to be a home pro. You just have to hire one. You can hire top rated pros, see price estimates and read reviews all on the app. Download today.

[Ad Voice]

Every week on the Moth podcast, you'll hear true stories that will intrigue you, inspire you and make you laugh.

[Seth Payne]

He said, is there anything in your

[Jim Pendergast]

diet that might be spiking your blood sugar?

[Seth Payne]

I said, sometimes I eat pizza until I'm unconscious.

[Jim Pendergast]

He said, I think that might be it for real.

[Ad Voice]

Stories live on stage from comedians, astronauts, accountants, farmers and people just like you follow and listen to the Moth wherever you get your podcasts.

[Jim Pendergast]

Sports Radio 610 presents live from the West Point Lincoln and West Point Lincoln of Sugarland Studios. Here's Pain and Pendergast. Scott and I during the break just came to the conclusion that there's no choice. We have to pender pole this. This Tate Tet that you and I got into in the previous segment. B. Scott thinks that Vrabel bringing a puppy dog to a press conference is worse than Joel Embiid bringing his kid to a press conference.

[Seth Payne]

Much worse.

[Jim Pendergast]

Much worse.

[Seth Payne]

Much worse to me because to me it's more deliberate. I think that the child thing, it could be on purpose. It could also just be how Joel Embiid gets there. Some people get down. I've seen children at press conferences before. Now I want to be clear. I think it's inappropriate either way. It ain't really for me to decide it's not my kid, but I just. I don't think it's appropriate either way. Whether it's a positive a win, a loss, you're going to get scrutinized or not, I just don't think it's great. But it's up to that parent to do whatever they want. I don't think it's that big of a deal. What is the dog thing to me is a clear and obvious deliberate attempt to PR the dog.

[Jim Pendergast]

Mike Rabel has been through a lot. What if it's a support dog? What if it's an emotional support dog and he has to carry that out over the course of the rest of his life?

[Seth Payne]

I'd like to be the journalist that goes, hey, Mike, what's the. What? Ptsd. What are you suffering from?

[Jim Pendergast]

Have you looked at the. Was it the tabloids the last five months?

[Seth Payne]

What's the trauma?

[Keenan Thompson]

Look at the.

[Jim Pendergast]

Have you looked at the tabloids? Dude, Rabel having to carry a support dog around under his arm at training camp would be hilarious because there's no more hands on. There's no more hands on head coach than Mike Vrabel.

[Seth Payne]

Right.

[Jim Pendergast]

He puts on that linebacker vest.

[Seth Payne]

Yeah.

[Jim Pendergast]

And he gets in there and does the drills with guys.

[Ad Voice]

Yeah.

[Seth Payne]

He'll go out there and bleed with you.

[Jim Pendergast]

Can you imagine it?

[Seth Payne]

It comes down to it.

[Jim Pendergast]

Having to do that with, you know, with. With the dog underneath his arm or

[Seth Payne]

Rabel going over to DeAndre Hopkins, like, hey, DeAndre, can you hold my dog?

[Jim Pendergast]

Yeah.

[Seth Payne]

Can you hold my dog while I battle with the offensive lineman?

[Jim Pendergast]

Yeah, that's. That'll be the job DeAndre has. You know, I don't really want to coach, but if you need someone to hold your dog when you do linebacker drills, I'm your guy.

[Seth Payne]

Just the visual. The video of Vrabel handing over the little pup to DeAndre Hopkins.

[Jim Pendergast]

Chat GPT project.

[Seth Payne]

These two guys with these massive hands, just palming. Palming the little pup. Palming the little pup.

[Jim Pendergast]

Dismissing the possibility that it's an emotional support dog for a guy who's been through a lot.

[Seth Payne]

No, it's inflicted.

[Jim Pendergast]

That's the part. Yeah.

[Seth Payne]

It's like, why, though? Why is it that you are a former linebacker? Slash. Like, just badass defensive player who used to do car crashes. Human car crashes. And the. The most trauma you've had in this game is the summer where you get revealed as a philanderer.

[Jim Pendergast]

Right, right, right. Okay, so I've got the Tony Romo mug shot in front of me right now. Headline, Tony Romo busted for OWI in Milwaukee. Operating while intoxicated.

[Guest or Additional Ad Voice]

Yes.

[Jim Pendergast]

Not operating on a person. I think Tony Romo would be the last person I'd like to see as the. As the ether kicks in. Here we go, Jim. Yeah. You're getting ready for an important surgery.

[Seth Payne]

It's a triple bypass.

[Jim Pendergast]

The last face you see is this one right Here. Yeah. So, no, he was operating a motor vehicle. He failed a bunch of sobriety tests. Apparently, Tony Romo did.

[Seth Payne]

With that face? No way.

[Jim Pendergast]

We. I asked you this question earlier. I cannot remember. I. I'll be honest with you. When I see these celebrities get DWIs and things like that, I'm not somebody whose mind goes, oh, like rubbing my hands. I can't wait to see the body kit now when the body cam comes out. I do enjoy watching it from time to time. You know, some are more entertaining than others. This is the first one I can think of in my life where I am going to be hitting refresh on TMZ to see when this thing drops. Tony Romo is. He's. He's so off kilter on these broadcasts. I can only imagine what failed sobriety tests look like for him.

[Seth Payne]

Yeah. So just assuming that Tony Romo is on the air when he's doing these CBS broadcasts, that he's sober when we're listening to him on the regular. What does. To your question, what does he sound like when he's unable to properly operate a vehicle?

[Ad Voice]

Yeah.

[Seth Payne]

When it's bad enough for him to be failing sobriety tests, to taking mug shots where he's looking like that.

[Guest or Additional Ad Voice]

Yeah.

[Seth Payne]

Getting charged and arrested and all of that. Like what? What does that version of Tony Romo look and sound like? And then what does that version of Tony Romo look and sound like when confronted with the possibility of going to jail? That.

[Jim Pendergast]

Do you think that as he was doing the test, that he was looking around for Gene Steritor, trying to find out what the rules are?

[Seth Payne]

Gene?

[Keenan Thompson]

I don't know.

[Seth Payne]

Gene. Gene, what do you think?

[Jim Pendergast]

Gene, Are they allowed to ask me to stand on one leg and recite the Alphabet backwards?

[Seth Payne]

Gene, there's only one. All right, Jim, there's only one way to find out. How many times did Tony Romo's voice crack in this encounter with the police in Wisconsin?

[Jim Pendergast]

Tony Romo seems like a super nice guy. His performance as a broadcaster has not been to the level it was that earned him 18 million a year. And he earned that. He was really good his first couple years, and it feels like his performance.

[Ad Voice]

Latte for Keenan.

[Keenan Thompson]

That's me.

[Ad Voice]

Hey, you're.

[Ad Voice 2]

Yeah.

[Ad Voice]

Buying a car online on Autotrader.

[Keenan Thompson]

Really? But unlike other sites, you can start online, test drive with a local dealer, then finish online or at the dealership.

[Jim Pendergast]

Really?

[Ad Voice]

Wait, are you.

[Keenan Thompson]

Yep. It's. Keenan.

[Ad Voice]

Able to finish in person without starting the process over?

[Keenan Thompson]

Really? Your info stays with you every step of the Way cool.

[Ad Voice]

Enjoy.

[Keenan Thompson]

It's Keenan Thompson. Buy your car online on Autotrader. Really?

[Ad Voice 2]

You ever heard the story of Harry? He was a legend around here. Until one afternoon he left, never came back. Turns out Harry went and made himself a website using Squarespace. Used Squarespace domains to buy artisanseatcushions.com and he built a beautiful site with an online store to sell his artisan seat cushions. Now Harry's sitting on a fortune. And if our Harry can do it, anyone can. Build your [e-mail] use offer code everything for 10% off your website or domain.

[Ad Voice]

Lemonade. Fresh squeezed Lemonade.

[Guest or Additional Ad Voice]

Lemonade.

[Ad Voice]

Oh nuts.

[Seth Payne]

Is your business struggling to be seen not reaching the right customers?

[Ad Voice]

Yeah.

[Jim Pendergast]

Odysee's here to help your one stop

[Seth Payne]

shop for digital marketing.

[Ad Voice]

Wait, really?

[Seth Payne]

With targeted digital media plus SEO, SEM, social OTT and more, we help your

[Ad Voice 2]

business reach the right audience and drive results.

[Guest or Additional Ad Voice]

Whoa.

[Ad Voice]

Hey. One at a time.

[Seth Payne]

Stop missing out on valuable customers. Visit digitallocalads.com to learn more about our local advertising solutions.

[Jim Pendergast]

That's digitallocalads.com OK people, line starts here. Dropped off. I, I thought this, you know, I don't. They've got several years still left of Tony Romo on that contract. Multiple years still left and he is making big money. He's the best thing to ever happen to guys like Troy Aikman and Chris Collinsworth and other A list guys who are on A teams for their various NFL media contracts. Yeah, Tony Romo reset the market. So that was really cool for them. But I wonder if there's any sort of clause in his contract like CBS has got to be looking for an opening here with Romo to like not have to pay him $18 million. I feel, I just feel like his performance has gone backwards. And, and I would also say J.J. watt would never.

[Seth Payne]

Yeah, I, I was.

[Jim Pendergast]

J.J. watt would never.

[Seth Payne]

Just gonna say that.

[Jim Pendergast]

Dot dot.

[Seth Payne]

Not only would J.J. watt never. Which I think is the most important

[Jim Pendergast]

part here, especially in Wisconsin.

[Seth Payne]

Yeah. Of all places.

[Jim Pendergast]

J.J. find a way to get out

[Seth Payne]

of that Wisconsin's native son. Like one of their best to one of their best products. Like you figure if there are guys

[Jim Pendergast]

Tony Romo's from Wisconsin, we should point that out.

[Seth Payne]

Right.

[Ad Voice]

But.

[Seth Payne]

But you figured he'd be on this list too. Like J.J. watt, Tony Romo, a current athlete. Tyrese Halliburton. Like there are certain guys that are.

[Jim Pendergast]

How many did Brett Favre get away with back in the day?

[Seth Payne]

Yeah, like Wisconsin heroes should be like how bad must it have been? Did you hit a stop sign, Right. Were, were there pedestrians that barely escaped your wrath?

[Jim Pendergast]

Can you imagine because of this? Can you imagine if they. They're like, okay, we have body cam, so we've got to do something to test you. So this is what we're going to do. We know, Tony, that you're the lead analyst on cbs. We're just going to give you some really easy NFL questions and all you got to do is answer them and, and we'll let you go. And they ask him things like, who's the quarterback for the Buffalo Bills?

[Seth Payne]

Oh, come on. And he's asking for Gene.

[Jim Pendergast]

Can I call Gene?

[Seth Payne]

Tony, Can I call Jim?

[Ad Voice]

Jim.

[Jim Pendergast]

Joe Ferguson,

[Keenan Thompson]

the.

[Seth Payne]

Nathan Peterman.

[Ad Voice 2]

Yeah.

[Jim Pendergast]

Nathan Peter.

[Seth Payne]

Yeah. Is Ryan Fitzpatrick still there, Dude.

[Jim Pendergast]

Yeah. Tony Romo.

[Seth Payne]

Nah, that's. That's not great. Well, I would point out too though, since you mentioned jj, not only would he not do this, but Tony Romo started getting all that money and became their top guy.

[Jim Pendergast]

Yeah.

[Seth Payne]

Before JJ retired. Right. Before JJ became what he is now as a broadcaster. And I think very quickly, very promptly, J.J. watt became very good at this. And I would say, like, objectively, not just because I'm a Texans fan or. Cause we know JJ a little bit and all that and covered him and all of that. I think JJ is just better at it than Tony Romo.

[Guest or Additional Ad Voice]

Yeah.

[Seth Payne]

So could this be a reason with that on top of this?

[Jim Pendergast]

That's my point.

[Seth Payne]

Be a justification for. You know what, Tony, we've appreciated you. I guess you're still going to get your money or whatever it is, however the contract lays out. But we're going to make JJ our top guy.

[Jim Pendergast]

This is the tricky thing about this though. If you're talking about moving a guy from the B team to the A team and B team is not an insult by any means when it comes to this. We're talking about CBS and they've got like seven announce crews. You're number two. And J.J. watts been doing this for like, you know, two years.

[Seth Payne]

Right.

[Jim Pendergast]

Really A year plus a game.

[Seth Payne]

Because he was in studio first.

[Jim Pendergast]

He's in studio first year.

[Seth Payne]

Yeah. Right.

[Jim Pendergast]

And even on that was on a part time basis.

[Seth Payne]

Yeah.

[Jim Pendergast]

J.J. has gotten really good at this really fast. And so the thing I would hate though would be for them to break up J.J. watt and Ian Eagle, you know, like if. Because if you, if you did a move to the A team and we're totally speculating here, like, we're probably way out over our skis.

[Seth Payne]

Yeah. But.

[Jim Pendergast]

But I think we both like JJ better as an announcer than Tony Romo. So it's fun to kind of kick around a little bit and stop driving drunk. That's what I would say. And then we won't talk about it. Yeah, but. But Jim Nance probably isn't going anywhere as the A team guy. And I just. I don't know. I like Iron Eagle and J.J. watt have such good chemistry together. And I think Ian Eagle is in the. I think he's the best that CBS has. Him and Kevin Harlan, I think are the best that CBS has. And so I would love to see them as a team collectively bumped up. Yeah, I think Jim Nance is still really good.

[Seth Payne]

I do too.

[Jim Pendergast]

I enjoy Ian Eagle and Kevin Harlan a little bit more. You are.

[Seth Payne]

You are preaching to the choir.

[Guest or Additional Ad Voice]

Yeah.

[Seth Payne]

I think that a. An Iron Eagle, J.J. watt, Wally Pipping of the Gym, Nance, Tony Romo combination, can you imagine? I would be absolutely fine with. Nobody's asking me and I'm not the TV executive expert or anything, but that's just my personal preference. I would prefer both of them over the A team that they have now.

[Jim Pendergast]

Nance already feels like he's a little annoy by Tony Romo during broadcast.

[Keenan Thompson]

Oh, yeah.

[Jim Pendergast]

Can you imagine if Romo became the reason that they, as a parent got bumped down to the B team and they bumped up Iron Eagle and J.J.

[Seth Payne]

watt and he stuck with like Texans, Jags games. Yeah. You know, AFC south games as opposed to whatever the. You know, the three o' clock.

[Jim Pendergast]

JJ's. Is JJ undefeated on Texan games. As a commentator.

[Seth Payne]

I believe he is.

[Jim Pendergast]

The one time I saw JJ at a game this past year was at the. We were coming out of the two different elevators in the lobby after that comeback against the Jags.

[Seth Payne]

Yeah.

[Jim Pendergast]

And it was funny because JJ was saying to me, like. Cause they do. He does interviews like on CBS hq. I think he does like different post game interviews on different CBS platforms to talk about the games.

[Seth Payne]

Yeah, they were motor, man, he was

[Jim Pendergast]

like, man, he's like, I had all my. I had all my material ready to go and then the Texans pull this fourth quarter comeback. Yeah, I'm like, yeah, that's called tearing up the rundown in our business. Yeah, there's a tear up the rundown moment.

[Seth Payne]

Tearing up the rundown for writers having to hit control, alt delete on your whole story that you've had pre written ready to publish when the clock hits zero. He's really. That's the business.

[Jim Pendergast]

He's really good. He's really good at what he does all right. Payne and Pendergast B. Scott in for Seth Payne. Coming up next, let's circle back to the Rockets. All right, so the the NBA off season now is finally settling in a little bit here. We'll probably get a schedule pretty soon. What exactly are the Rockets right now on the board and of the of the future, LeBron James matchups, which are the ones we as just NBA fans in general are most excited to see. That's coming up next. I'll tell you who I'm excited to see every time I get to go see him.

[Ad Voice]

Latte for Keenan.

[Keenan Thompson]

That's me.

[Ad Voice]

Hey, you're yeah. Buying a car online on Auto Trader.

[Keenan Thompson]

Really? But unlike other sites, you can start online, test drive with a local dealer, then finish online or at the dealership.

[Ad Voice]

Cool. Enjoy.

[Keenan Thompson]

Buy your car online on Autotrader. Really?

[Seth Payne]

I want to tell you about a new podcast from Odyssey called Family Lore. It's about interesting family stories and the truth behind them. It's available now on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or wherever you get your shows.

[Guest or Additional Ad Voice]

Since 1927, Mountain Cement has been building careers in literally Wyoming. They're hiring electricians, mechanics, truck drivers, entry level employees and salaried professionals to join their team. Employees enjoy year round work, opportunities to grow and unique perks like private elk hunting, access and permits, a stocked fishing pond, Laramie river access, a shooting range and RV and tent sites. Competitive pay day one benefits and relocation packages are available for qualified candidates. Apply [e-mail] or call 307-745-2620.