Perpetual Traffic Podcast Summary Episode: "Why These 5 Ads Are The Best and Worst Super Bowl LIX Ads (Part Two)" Release Date: February 18, 2025

Introduction

In this engaging episode of Perpetual Traffic, hosts Ralph Burns and Lauren E. Petrullo delve into the standout advertisements from Super Bowl LIX. They dissect the effectiveness, creativity, and emotional impact of various commercials, providing valuable insights for marketers and business owners striving to optimize their advertising strategies.

Least Favorite and Most Ineffective Ads

Coffee Mate's Cringeworthy Commercial

Lauren kicks off the discussion by expressing her disdain for the Coffee Mate ad featuring an "explosive tongue."
Lauren [04:03]: "This ad bothered me to no end. The coffee mate commercial with the tongue... I was so disgusted by this ad."

Ralph echoes her sentiments, highlighting how disturbing yet memorable the ad was:
Ralph [04:17]: "I know. Oh, my God. I hated it. Absolutely hated it. It was like. It was disturbing. It was disturbing but effective."

Despite their negative feelings, both acknowledge the ad's effectiveness in being memorable, a crucial factor in advertising success.

Tubi's Unsettling Ads

The conversation shifts to Tubi's ads, which feature imagery that didn't resonate with the hosts. Lauren points out the discomfort caused by the portrayal of a "skin cowboy hat," tying it to the negative connotations of the term "skinhead."
Lauren [06:12]: "I don't like Skinheads. It was gross. And I don't watch western, so I didn't feel the appeal."

Ralph adds that while the ads were memorable, they failed to connect with their personal interests:
Ralph [07:20]: "It didn't resonate with me because I don't watch westerns either... I remembered it, but I hated it."

Most Emotional and Empowering Ads

Dove's Empowering Campaigns

Lauren highlights Dove's commercials aimed at empowering women, referencing specific campaigns like "Fight Like a Girl."
Lauren [09:23]: "There were two ads made geared towards women... Dove always has really strong empowering campaigns."

She shares a personal connection to the Dove ad depicting a toddler running, reflecting on societal pressures faced by young girls:
Lauren [11:01]: "It tugged on my heartstrings a lot... It resonated with me, specifically the challenges."

Ralph concurs, appreciating the alignment with Dove's brand and its impact on viewers:
Ralph [11:38]: "I thought Dove like was very much on brand, but the ad itself was really smart."

Climate Change Commercials

The hosts discuss commercials addressing climate change, emphasizing the urgency and emotional weight conveyed through storytelling. Lauren points out the difficulty in filming with young children and the powerful message it delivered:
Lauren [10:57]: "I remember... there was like, there's such a short period in which you can address this environment."

Ralph adds that these ads effectively blend emotional appeal with brand messaging, reinforcing the importance of aligning cause-driven content with brand values.

Political Influences in Super Bowl Ads

Trump's Attendance and the Ontario Ad

Lauren brings up the political undertones introduced by President Trump's attendance at the Super Bowl, leading to an Ontario-sponsored ad promoting trade relations amidst tariff tensions.
Lauren [16:47]: "There was an Ontario ad... it felt so politically driven based off the tariffs that Trump is introducing."

Ralph provides additional context, noting Trump's rare presence and its implications:
Ralph [16:37]: "Me too. So factoid is that he is the first sitting president to ever attend a Super Bowl."

Both hosts agree that while the inclusion of political figures can be strategic for reach, it risks alienating segments of the audience who prefer to keep politics separate from entertainment events.

Commercial Intent Behind Empowerment Ads

Ralph emphasizes that even feel-good ads with empowering messages carry commercial intent:
Ralph [16:36]: "All these feel good feelings... They're paying for that. And the military is also trying to recruit people through using the NFL."

This highlights the dual purpose of such ads—to promote positive values while advancing the brand's commercial goals.

Most Disappointing Ads

Taco Bell's Misstep with LeBron James

Lauren expresses disappointment with Taco Bell's Super Bowl ad featuring LeBron James, criticizing its lack of originality and over-reliance on celebrity endorsement.
Lauren [22:20]: "Taco Bell had LeBron James... it felt repeated and unoriginal."

Ralph agrees, noting the saturation of similar concepts:
Ralph [23:02]: "It just seemed like mustaches. Mustaches."

The hosts argue that the ad failed to stand out in a crowded advertising space, ultimately being forgettable.

Dun Kings' Forced Narrative

The discussion moves to Dun Kings' commercial, which the hosts found forced and unoriginal. Ralph, a Bostonian, criticizes the exaggerated Boston accents and lack of authenticity:
Ralph [25:44]: "He's exaggerating it for effect. And everybody in Boston would really pissed off about that."

Lauren adds that the ad's reliance on insider jokes alienated younger audiences:
Lauren [27:15]: "But unless you have statistics that say Gen Z and Gen Alpha aren't watching the Super Bowl, then I'm wrong."

Marketing Insights and Takeaways

Celebrity Endorsements and Authenticity

Both hosts highlight the importance of authenticity in celebrity endorsements. Overuse or forced narratives can lead to audience disengagement, as seen with Taco Bell and Dun Kings.

Originality and Memorable Content

The effectiveness of an ad often hinges on its originality and ability to create memorable content. While shocking or unusual elements can increase recall, they must align with the brand's core message and audience interests to avoid negative perceptions.

Leveraging Emotional Appeal

Ads that successfully tug at emotions, such as Dove's empowerment campaigns, demonstrate the power of storytelling in creating a lasting impact. Aligning emotional narratives with brand values can enhance authenticity and consumer connection.

Navigating Political Landscapes

Incorporating political elements into advertising can expand reach but carries the risk of polarizing the audience. Brands must carefully balance commercial goals with the potential for audience alienation.

Additional Observations

Impact of Large-Scale Events

Ralph and Lauren compare the Super Bowl to other major events like the World Cup, noting the vast differences in viewership and engagement. They suggest that understanding diverse advertising strategies across various platforms can provide broader marketing insights.

Social Media Amplification

The hosts discuss how ads leverage social media to amplify their reach. Instances like Applebee's unintended publicity showcase the importance of monitoring and engaging with audience conversations to enhance campaign effectiveness.

Conclusion

Ralph and Lauren conclude the episode by encouraging listeners to analyze the discussed ads for valuable marketing lessons. They emphasize the importance of creativity, authenticity, and emotional resonance in crafting effective advertising strategies. By understanding the successes and pitfalls of Super Bowl LIX commercials, marketers can better navigate their campaigns to achieve impactful and memorable results.

Notable Quotes with Timestamps:

• Lauren on Coffee Mate Ad Disgust:
  "This ad bothered me to no end. The coffee mate commercial with the tongue... I was so disgusted by this ad."
  [04:03]

• Ralph on Disturbing Yet Effective Ads:
  "I know. Oh, my God. I hated it. Absolutely hated it. It was like... it was disturbing but effective."
  [04:17]

• Lauren on Tubi’s Skinhead Imagery:
  "I don't like Skinheads. It was gross. And I don't watch western, so I didn't feel the appeal."
  [06:12]

• Ralph on Dove’s Smart Branding:
  "I thought Dove like was very much on brand, but the ad itself was really smart."
  [11:38]

• Lauren on Political Undertones with Trump’s Attendance:
  "I didn't expect a government style ad during a football event."
  [17:35]

• Ralph on Political Commercial Intent:
  "All these feel good feelings... they're paying for that... let's never forget that."
  [16:36]

• Lauren on Taco Bell's Lack of Originality:
  "It felt repeated and unoriginal."
  [22:20]

• Ralph on Dun Kings' Forced Narratives:
  "He's exaggerating it for effect. And everybody in Boston would really pissed off about that."
  [25:44]

For more insights and detailed analysis, visit perpetualtraffic.com and follow the podcast across your preferred platforms. Don’t forget to leave a review and share your thoughts!