Summary of Philosophize This! Episode #216: "The Self-Overcoming of Nihilism - Kyoto School pt. 1 - Nishitani"
Release Date: November 18, 2024
Host: Stephen West
Podcast: Philosophize This!
In Episode #216 of "Philosophize This!", host Stephen West delves into the profound philosophical explorations of Keiji Nishitani, a pivotal figure in the Kyoto School. This episode marks the beginning of a mini-series dedicated to understanding the intricate interplay between Eastern and Western philosophical traditions, particularly focusing on nihilism and the concept of the self.
1. Introduction to Keiji Nishitani and the Kyoto School
Stephen West opens the episode by situating Keiji Nishitani within the broader context of Western philosophy's engagement with nihilism. Nishitani, a prominent member of the Kyoto School, is introduced as a fervent admirer of Friedrich Nietzsche, even traveling to Germany in the 1930s to study under Martin Heidegger. His dedication is exemplified by his habit of carrying Nietzsche's Thus Spoke Zarathustra wherever he went during his early years.
"The man we're talking about today is a member of what's now become known as the famous Kyoto School out of Kyoto, Japan. The guy we're talking about today went by the name of Keiji Nishitani." [02:15]
2. Understanding the Kyoto School
West anticipates questions about the Kyoto School, addressing common misconceptions. While many perceive the Kyoto School as a blend of Eastern and Western existentialist thought, West clarifies that such broad categorizations can be reductive. He emphasizes that, throughout the series, he plans to explore the limitations of framing these thinkers strictly in East-West dichotomies.
"A lot of people that are fans of the Kyoto School would hate for it to be described in this way." [04:30]
3. Nishitani's Approach to Nihilism
Central to Nishitani's philosophy is his unique approach to nihilism. West contrasts Nishitani's deep, experiential engagement with nihilism against the often superficial Western interpretations. While Western nihilism is frequently seen as a crisis of meaning leading to despair or passive acceptance, Nishitani views it as a profound gateway to understanding the nature of existence.
"Nihilism, when you view it as an experiment that's being run by a particular self, nihilism, when truly experienced, eventually overcomes itself." [20:45]
West discusses how Western responses, influenced by Nietzsche, advocate for overcoming nihilism through the creation of personal values and active affirmation. In contrast, Nishitani encourages a more immersive confrontation with nihilism, viewing it not merely as a problem to be solved but as an inherent aspect of being that can lead to transformative insight.
4. Western vs. Eastern Responses to Nihilism
The episode contrasts Western and Eastern (specifically Mahayana Buddhism and Zen Buddhism) responses to nihilism. West explains that while Western thinkers often attempt to define and rigidly categorize nihilism, Nishitani proposes a more fluid and individualized approach. This Eastern perspective views nihilism not as a static state but as a dynamic process that can lead to a deeper understanding of existence.
"In this perspective, a person feeling horrible because they recognize there isn't a God with a plan for them... is actually evidence of the fact that there's somebody who's questioning their reality beyond the conventions they were born into." [16:20]
5. The Concept of Sunyata and the Self
A significant portion of the episode is dedicated to unpacking Nishitani's concept of sunyata (emptiness) and its implications for understanding the self. West elucidates how Nishitani rejects the notion of a fixed, durable self, advocating instead for a view of the self as interdependent and ever-evolving.
"At the bottom of the self, the self really gains whatever meaning it has to us in terms of how it relates to everything else around it." [32:10]
Using metaphors from structural linguistics, West explains that just as the meaning of a word like "squirrel" is determined by its relations to other words, the self's meaning arises from its interactions and dependencies. This perspective aligns with the Buddhist principle of dependent origination, highlighting the interconnectedness of all phenomena.
6. Methods to Experience Nihilism
Nishitani advocates for experiential engagement with nihilism, urging individuals to undergo a personal "experiment" to truly grasp its essence. West discusses practical approaches inspired by Zen Buddhism, such as koans—paradoxical questions designed to transcend logical reasoning and provoke deeper understanding.
"Meditation definitely can help loosen things up. Apparently, there are things called koans that are commonly used in Zen Buddhism." [38:25]
West emphasizes that these practices aim to dissolve dualistic thinking, allowing individuals to experience reality more directly and authentically, free from the constraints of rigid philosophical constructs.
7. Conclusions and Anticipation for Future Episodes
Stephen West concludes the episode by reflecting on the depth and challenges of Nishitani's philosophy, acknowledging the limitations of language in fully conveying such profound concepts. He teases future discussions, including deeper explorations into the nature of the self, the role of religion, and comparisons between Eastern and Western philosophical traditions.
"You can sit around and think about death from a theoretical perspective, but still not fully understand what it is. Sunyata, nihility. These are things that, to Nishitani, need to be lived and experienced to be fully understood." [50:40]
West encourages listeners to engage with these ideas not just intellectually but experientially, setting the stage for the subsequent episodes in the series.
Notable Quotes:
- "Nihilism is not something to run from. It's not a problem to be solved." [45:10]
- "The metaphysical foundation of being is nothingness." [47:50]
- "Sunyata, or emptiness, is an imminent aspect of our very existence." [49:30]
Looking Ahead:
Episode #216 serves as a foundational exploration into Nishitani's philosophy, setting the stage for deeper analysis in subsequent episodes. Listeners can anticipate discussions on:
- The barriers to experiencing sunyata and how to overcome them.
- The interplay between religion and nihilism in Nishitani's thought.
- Comparative insights into how Western thinkers like Nietzsche might align or diverge from Buddhist concepts.
- A broader understanding of what constitutes "Eastern" philosophy in this context.
Stay tuned for the next installment to continue this enlightening journey into the self-overcoming of nihilism through the lens of the Kyoto School.
For more insights and to support the podcast, visit Patreon.com/philosophizethis.