← Piers Morgan Uncensored
Piers Morgan Uncensored
'Leave Lebanon ALONE!' Civilians Killed As Israel Targets Hezbollah | With Naftali Bennett
01:17:06
Loading summary
Transcript178 lines
- [00:00]
Naftali Bennett
Quick pause.
- [00:01]
Cenk Uygur
Something useful for you.
- [00:02]
Naftali Bennett
Love fishing. TikTok isn't just for young people. It's full of real tips, better knots,
- [00:08]
Cenk Uygur
better baits, better catches.
- [00:09]
Naftali Bennett
Quick videos from people who actually fish. Download TikTok now.
- [00:16]
Piers Morgan
Is the fact that America want to get out an indication that Israel want to get out?
- [00:22]
Naftali Bennett
Let there be no mistake, there will be inevitably a lot of civilian casualties when those horrible people in Hezbollah, Iran, Hamas place those weapons within homes, within hospitals, within kindergartens.
- [00:36]
Dr. Salah Maknuk
We are officially and irrevocably done as Lebanese people of our land being used for proxy wars. Some of your viewers might not know that from simply navigating X the entire day and listening to ideologue.
- [00:50]
Rania Khalek
You mentioned over a million displaced. That's 25% of Lebanon and. And Israel is responsible for doing this. But if you look at Hezbollah's statement, it was a response to Israeli ceasefire
- [01:01]
Piers Morgan
violations Even I was worried about. You looked like every blood vessel was about to erupt and your spleen was going to collapse in front of me live on uncensored.
- [01:11]
Cenk Uygur
I love that I yelled at Ben Ferguson. He had it coming. Your viewers loved it. Everybody in America loved it. And I'll do it again. I think everybody should be as angry as me.
- [01:23]
Piers Morgan
Much of the debate about the Iran war is centered on whether Israel is responsible for President Trump starting it. It may very soon become a question of whether Israel is the barrier to ending it. The US President is talking up the prospects of a peace deal at the same time as deploying 3,000 paratroopers in readiness for a ground operation.
- [01:42]
Naftali Bennett
They're going to make a deal.
- [01:43]
Piers Morgan
They're going to make a deal. They did something yesterday that was amazing, actually. They gave us a presentation and the president arrived today, and it was a very big present worth a tremendous amount of money.
- [01:56]
Naftali Bennett
And I'm not going to tell you
- [01:58]
Piers Morgan
what that president is, but it was a very significant prize and they gave it to us and they said they were going to give it. So that meant one thing to me. We're dealing with the right people. No, it wasn't nuclear related. It was oil and gas related. And it was a very nice thing they did. But what it showed me is that we're dealing with the right people. Well, for its part, Iranian officials are still denying that any talks have taken place and that any big presents have changed hands. An Iranian military spokesman said that Trump is negotiating with himself. And amid the confusion, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin NETanyahu made clear Ms. Week that Israel will decide when Israeli forces are done. There is no indication that they are anywhere close to being done. Most of the world's eyes are on Iran, but Israel is waging a major second front of its war against Hezbollah. In Lebanon, more than 1,000 Lebanese have been killed. More than 1 million, almost a quarter of the entire population, have been displaced from their homes. Defense Minister Israel Katz said Israel intends to occupy southern Lebanon. The BBC reports that Israeli forces have been ordered to destroy homes if necessary, using Gaza as a blueprint. Mr. Katz himself said yesterday, Israel's policy in Lebanon is clear. If there is terrorism and missiles, there are no homes and no residents. Add all of this to the US President's anger over unsanctioned Israeli strikes on Iran's biggest gas field, as well as the U.S. condemnation of settler violence in the west bank, and the differences in their national interests become very clear. President Trump ended the 12 day war between Israel and Iran last summer after sending US Forces to bomb its nuclear sites. Netanyahu told his people that two existential threats have been eliminated, both the nuclear and ballistic missile programs. He said, and I quote directly, this victory will stand for decades. But as the two sides traded bombs just hours after the ceasefire, Trump said this.
- [03:55]
Cenk Uygur
We basically have two countries that have been fighting so long and so hard
- [04:01]
Piers Morgan
that they don't know what the fuck they're doing. Do you understand that? Well, it might not be long before we hear the same profanities again. Returning to uncensored now is the former Israeli Prime Minister, Naftali Bennett. Mr. Bennett, thank you very much indeed for rejoining me.
- [04:15]
Naftali Bennett
Yeah, great to be here.
- [04:16]
Piers Morgan
So here's the big question. Donald Trump clearly is trying to get out of this war. All his talk is of, it's over, we've won, we've destroyed their military, they want to do a deal, they're giving us presents, et cetera, et cetera. All of which remains unconfirmed by anyone in the Iranian regime. But putting that to one side, is the fact that America want to get out an indication that Israel want to get out, or would Israel potentially just continue?
- [04:47]
Naftali Bennett
Well, we have to achieve our objectives. And we set one major objective, which is to dismantle the nuclear program, the ballistic program, and the regional terror. We've had the neglect for decades now, allowed this huge monster to envelope us and surround us with proxies. And it's very painful to dismantle this, but we have to do it if we want to survive.
- [05:17]
Piers Morgan
Okay, that's not an answer to my question, though.
- [05:21]
Naftali Bennett
Yeah, I like doing that, Piers, from
- [05:23]
Piers Morgan
time to time I've noticed.
- [05:25]
Naftali Bennett
Look, we're going to have to continue until we reach our objectives. I'm not privy. I'm not the prime minister today. I can say from our perspective, if we finish the war without dismantling the nuclear program and the ballistic missile program, then we've not met our objectives, as Prime Minister Netanyahu defined it, and we failed. So we'll see.
- [05:53]
Piers Morgan
So Prime Minister Netanyahu, he said on the record a few days ago it's impossible to win this war purely from the air, indicating that at some stage ground troops have to be deployed. And many people believe that. The reason he said that is because Iran has a lot of enriched uranium enriching to the point where it's getting close to building a nuclear weapon, but that it's buried away and that the only way to actually get at that enriched uranium, which would be through ground forces. A, do you agree with that assessment? And B, if there are ground forces committed, that is clearly a major escalation in a war that Donald Trump wants apparently to be de escalating.
- [06:37]
Naftali Bennett
Well, there's a few ways you can get the uranium out. One is that Iran understands that it has to remove the uranium, hand it over to, say, America or some international organization if they want the war to end. So you can do it in a mix of action and kinetic action and diplomacy. That's also another option. And as you suggested, there always is the land forces option and I guess a few others.
- [07:08]
Piers Morgan
Would Israel commit its own ground forces?
- [07:14]
Naftali Bennett
We have to do everything to remove this threat. We have a very unique and strange situation that I think no other country in the world has. You've got a country that explicitly says it wants to annihilate my country. I don't think there's another case right now in the world, at least I can't recall, that one country says we are going to destroy, totally destroy another, and the act towards building it. And now we saw that they actually mean it because they've shot at our country hundreds and hundreds of ballistic missiles. And we know they have a very advanced or had a very advanced nuclear program. So from our perspective, we have to remove it. We have to put in place a permanent structure that will prevent them from rebuilding it. Now, how we get there, there's many options, but ultimately we have to do it. We have no choice. Wouldn't you do that?
- [08:11]
Piers Morgan
Well, I think my confusion is that Netanyahu, the Israeli prime minister, said after the 12 day war, you'd already done it. You had removed the nuclear and ballistic missile capacity and threat. And so the world breathed Again, it was all over in 12 days. It seemed very quick, very successful, everyone patting each other on the back. And yet here we are less than a year later and we're being told the mission of this entire war is to do exactly what we've been told had been done last summer. So hence the confusion.
- [08:45]
Naftali Bennett
No, that I have to agree with you. I think when Netanyahu declared victory in all kinds of places, sometimes it's premature. You have to get the job done, really get the job done. And I would have less major declarations and more results. So I definitely agree with you. The result has to be that Iran cannot nuclearize itself again.
- [09:13]
Piers Morgan
If the Iranian regime remains intact at the end of all this, wouldn't that be a failure? Given all the rhetoric at the start of this war about removing the regime, if they remain intact and the IRGC remains in control, doesn't the threat that you were trying to eliminate remain?
- [09:34]
Naftali Bennett
In a sense it does. But that depends really on what parameters we have on the nuclear program. Because if, for instance, there's an agreement where 460kg of highly enriched uranium are taken out of Iran and there's verifiable verification that they dismantled all of the system and the inspections under international systems and we can verify that that's a reasonable way to know that they're not progressing on the nuclear program.
- [10:11]
Piers Morgan
Let's turn to the Lebanon, because several days after the attacks on Iran, Israel attacked the Lebanon, Lebanese authorities say over a thousand people have said to them,
- [10:21]
Naftali Bennett
no, Piers, I have to correct you just so you get your facts right. That's not what happened.
- [10:27]
Piers Morgan
Sorry, let me rephrase my. No, you're right. I know what you're going to say. I know what you're going to say and let me rephrase that. Hezbollah launched strikes.
- [10:35]
Naftali Bennett
No, it's not what I'm going to say. It's just a fact.
- [10:38]
Piers Morgan
It's just a fact. I am uniquely self correcting myself before I even let you answer, to correct me, which is probably the first time I've done it, just to rephrase my inaccurately phrased question.
- [10:49]
Naftali Bennett
That's because you're a decent guy. Even if we disagree, at least you listen and you look at the facts as they.
- [10:56]
Piers Morgan
You know what? I like to be fair and I like to be accurate. And if I get accused of being inaccurate and unfair, it doesn't matter. It doesn't work. Exactly. So several days after the attacks on Iran, Hezbollah launched strikes against Israel and Israel then responded. And as with Gaza and the attacks on Hamas, I don't think people have a problem with Israel defending itself. They simply have a problem with the scale of the defense and how it is executed. And the Lebanese authorities say at least 1,000 people have been killed and nearly 3,000 injured in Israeli attacks since March 2, more than a million people dispersed. And the major charity Oxfam has now said that Israel is deploying the Gaza genocide playbook in Lebanon and says its analysis shows that Israeli forces are also destroying water and sanitation infrastructure, has damaged at least seven critical water sources, including reservoirs, pipe networks and pumping station, and destroyed electricity networks and bridges, cut off vital supplies and services for entire towns and villages, which in many people's eyes would cross a lot of red lines. When you are engaged in military action, what is your response specifically to what Oxfam say about you deploying the genocide playbook that was done in Gaza? As they see it,
- [12:29]
Naftali Bennett
they're full of, you know what, look, here's the deal. Here's where we stand. We have a major and big terror organization that says we want to destroy Israel. They attack Israel. They build many, many rocket launchers and disperse them across Lebanon, including in houses. Let me tell you a personal story. In my previous life before entering politics, I was a reservist, a commander in a special unit and I commanded operations search and destroy missions on rocket launchers in Lebanon of Hezbollah. I was an expert. If you ever need that service, give me a call. And one day I came into town in southern Lebanon into a house. There's a living room, a parent's room, kids room and a frickin rocket room. There was a rocket launcher in the house with a movable ceiling. So when we attack that rocket launcher, obviously that house will be destroyed. But who's responsible? Of course it's Hezbollah responsible and the stupid family who places a rocket in their home. Would you place a rocket in your children's room?
- [13:47]
Piers Morgan
Well, no, I wouldn't. But I think the issue becomes, well, they do.
- [13:51]
Naftali Bennett
And if you do, if you place a rocket launcher in your home, your home will be destroyed. That's sort of one of the things.
- [13:59]
Piers Morgan
But what about all the homes? I don't recommend anyone, but here's my point though. Natalie Bennett I understand that, but here's the problem. In big built up residential areas, if you target one home for that purpose and it has got a rocket in it, therefore you have justification because they're clearly planning to use that we would assume to attack you, then you have a lot of other residential homes around there that won't have rockets that have completely innocent civilians in it. So Israel can say, we never deliberately target civilians, but what you are doing is deliberately targeting residential areas where you believe, often with good reason, that there are terrorists or people supporting terrorists with arms. And in the process of taking them out, you're killing a lot of civilians as well. And that is the problem that you've had, I would say, in the PR that surrounded the war against Hamas is that so many civilians were killed in the process. And it seems to me you're going to face the same problem in the Lebanon here, where it's not. When you say, look, if we target this house and blow it up because it has rockets aiming at us, people say, fair enough. But when you take out 20 homes around it and none of those have rockets in them and they're just innocent civilians, and that adds up and adds up and adds up. Eventually you get to a position rather like with Gaza where you're leveling vast swathes of the Lebanon, displacing a million people, maybe more, attacking water supplies, sanitation supplies, all the rest of it. And just in the end, the totality of what you do is deemed to be disproportionate.
- [15:41]
Rania Khalek
There's nothing like your first Mac. Here's what people online are sharing. Rhain says, everything is just so smooth and fast. I still can't get over it. Syncing stuff between my phone and this is just chef's kiss. Rincredible488 says Apple Silicon basically cures low battery trauma. That's how they felt with their first Mac. How will you Introducing the all new MacBook Neo, an amazing Mac at a surprising price. Find out more on apple.comMac.
- [16:14]
Naftali Bennett
Well, war is a bad thing. War is a bad thing. And when we havewe target threats, we don't target civilians, we target threats. The responsibility lies only and exclusively at the hands of those who place those threats and embed them within neighborhoods. We send text messages, we evacuate people. What you've suggested, we sometimes even send pamphlets. We bend over backward to reduce those casualties. But let me be clear. In war against terror, there will be casualties. Now here are the we basically have three options. One is say, look, you know, Piers Morgan says this is really complicated and it's improper, so let's just let it be. And they'll shoot rockets and kill my family. Option A, bad option. Option B, let's bomb the heck out of everywhere and you know, just put huge bombs and incinerate the whole area, kill hundreds of thousands of people. We don't want to do that. That would be easy, by the way, and it would be less costly from our perspective. And then we have option C, which is the only one possible to do our best to remove the threat while minimizing as best as we can, civilian casualties. But let there be no mistake, there will be inevitably a lot of civilian casualties when those horrible people in Hezbollah, Iran, Hamas, place those weapons within homes, within hospitals, within kindergartens. Option D. If anyone in the world has some beautiful new idea of how to solve this problem in a different way, let me know. I'll be the first to adopt it.
- [18:14]
Piers Morgan
But I would say, I would argue that option B is pretty much what you operated in Gaza. I mean, you've leveled 75.
- [18:20]
Naftali Bennett
Come on,
- [18:22]
Piers Morgan
let me explain why.
- [18:23]
Naftali Bennett
You know. No, hold on.
- [18:26]
Piers Morgan
You haven't let me explain why.
- [18:27]
Naftali Bennett
Hold on. If that.
- [18:28]
Piers Morgan
Well, at least let me explain why.
- [18:29]
Naftali Bennett
But look at the numbers, my friend.
- [18:31]
Piers Morgan
I'm about to tell you the numbers.
- [18:32]
Naftali Bennett
Look at the numbers. There would have been a million dead civilians.
- [18:35]
Piers Morgan
You haven't let me explain why.
- [18:37]
Naftali Bennett
10 or 15,000.
- [18:38]
Piers Morgan
Afford me the respect to explain why, which is you have leveled about 75% of Gaza. Leveled it. You agree?
- [18:49]
Naftali Bennett
We have leveled the infrastructure because they placed tunnels.
- [18:56]
Piers Morgan
Okay, but you don't dispute. You've leveled 75% of Gaza.
- [18:59]
Naftali Bennett
Warehouses in almost every house in.
- [19:01]
Piers Morgan
But you don't. You're not.
- [19:03]
Naftali Bennett
When you decide to turn, I'm not
- [19:04]
Piers Morgan
asking you to explain.
- [19:05]
Naftali Bennett
Into a huge terror base, then it's no longer a city, it is a terror base and a terror bit.
- [19:12]
Piers Morgan
I'm only asking what you would do. Hang on, you talked earlier about facts being important. They are. You seem to have just confirmed that 75% of Gaza has been leveled. Right? We can agree that.
- [19:24]
Naftali Bennett
No, I don't know the numbers. That's a number. You said. I have no idea. But I do know what we're doing. And we're leveling places that are used against us as terror base.
- [19:34]
Piers Morgan
I understand, but my point being, you said that option B. You said option B was indiscriminate bombing, right? Razing place to the ground. And many people believe that in Gaza. If you level 75% of the entire Gaza, having displaced millions of people, then you are. That's option B right there. That's what you're doing.
- [19:56]
Naftali Bennett
No, option B is bombing them. Like. Like Britain bombed Dresden. Is bombing it with the people inside. We did something that I think very few armies do. We tell them we're about to bomb the terror base in that building. Get out of the building. Who does that. We do that.
- [20:16]
Piers Morgan
If you're. I do keep hearing.
- [20:18]
Naftali Bennett
Up to it.
- [20:19]
Piers Morgan
Okay, but Naftali, I do. I do keep hearing.
- [20:22]
Naftali Bennett
I mean, that's a big difference.
- [20:23]
Piers Morgan
Listen, for what it's worth, I have condemned what happened in Dresden. I thought it was outrageous and it's one of the reasons.
- [20:30]
Naftali Bennett
I don't.
- [20:30]
Piers Morgan
It's one of the reasons after World War II, whole new rules of engagement were implemented through the Geneva Convention. Right. So that's the whole point of what happened post The World War II was. A lot of stuff happened people felt was beyond the pale and shouldn't happen again. Mosul, let's say I would categorize the leveling of Dresden as one of those things, but I just want to talk about the targeting, as the Lebanese see it, of their medical facilities. They say that you've hit 128 medical facilities and ambulances across South Lebanon, killing 40 health care workers and wounding 107. Is that accurate?
- [21:13]
Naftali Bennett
I have no idea. I don't know every fact that you're reciting. I can tell you how we operate because I'm a major in reserve. I was a defense minister of Israel and I was prime Minister of Israel, so I know how we operate. We never deliberately target civilians, Period. Full stop. Never. We never deliberately target hospitals. We do destroy terror bases that are embedded anywhere, and I don't care where they're embedded. If you Hamas or you Hezbollah decide to convert a hospital into a terror base, we will destroy it. And you are responsible, not us.
- [21:54]
Piers Morgan
If everything you're doing lives up to your self styled claim that many Israelis have said on this show that you're the most moral army in the world, then why don't you lift your ban on international journalists going in to Gaza say so that they can see for themselves that ban is still in place.
- [22:14]
Naftali Bennett
No, I don't know. That's a fair question. And I'm not running Israel now. From my perspective, we have nothing to hide. And I'm proud of being Israel. And you know, the most moral, the second most moral. All I know is that we are in the toughest circumstances on earth. No other nation, no other democracy with decent people. The people out here are just good people. If you meet Israelis, by and large, most of them are good, decent people that just want to live our lives. We didn't choose to be surrounded by radical Islamists that want to kill me, my kids. And they say it and they do it. So we're doing our best to defend ourselves the most moral way possible. But it's not gonna be sterile. It's not gonna be beautiful. It's war. War is a horrible thing.
- [23:02]
Piers Morgan
I think the question I would ask
- [23:03]
Naftali Bennett
is whether it's their decision.
- [23:05]
Piers Morgan
Yeah. And listen, I agree with you. If there's nothing to hide, why not let the journalists in?
- [23:10]
Naftali Bennett
No, I don't disagree with you. You know, maybe there's some consideration I'm not aware of, but by and large, I'm not ashamed of it.
- [23:18]
Piers Morgan
You can understand why, given there's supposed to be a ceasefire there, you can understand why the continued ban on journalists going into Gaza is making people deeply suspicious about what has been done there.
- [23:32]
Naftali Bennett
Well, people. Those same people are very adept at being suspicious and anti Israel with or without this decision. But granted, I. I don't disagree.
- [23:43]
Piers Morgan
Final question. I'm not sure I've asked you this before, but there's been a growing sense that if you criticize the Israeli government and its actions or decision making, automatically you're anti Semitic. What do you feel about that? Because I feel it's ridiculous. In the same way that when I opposed the Iraq war in 2003 as editor of a big newspaper in the UK it didn't mean I was anti the British people or my country. Why should it follow that? If you criticize Israeli actions, military actions, which everyone should be entitled to do, de facto you're an anti Semite.
- [24:20]
Naftali Bennett
No, I agree with you, Piers. It's totally fair and legitimate to criticize the Israeli government. I criticize the Israeli government. Heck, I'm trying to replace the Israeli government. I intend to be the next prime minister of Israel. I'm full of criticism. That's what a democracy is about. So that's totally legit. I'll tell you what's not legit. It's to have double standards towards Israel and to not look at the big picture and just claim that Israel wants to swallow all the territory around and not look at the basic fact, which is we're a democracy. We're not looking to have. We're not looking to conquer Jordan or Lebanon or anywhere.
- [25:02]
Rania Khalek
We.
- [25:03]
Naftali Bennett
We're happy. We're content with Israel, but we're being threatened by these crazy nuts that want to kill us.
- [25:13]
Piers Morgan
We're talking of crazy. Talking of crazy, homicidal nuts who want to do bad things to people. Let's just end with what is happening on the west bank with some appalling incidents involving extremist settlers there receiving global condemnation. Another former prime minister of your country, Ehud Olmert, said this week there should be an ICC intervention. There's been a new report come out that no prosecutions have happened in Israel for settler killings in the past decade. There have been some appalling scenes in the last week. Can you condemn those?
- [25:50]
Naftali Bennett
Of course. I didn't wait for you. I condemn it in Israel. So did the prime minister. But I'll tell you, look, we are a country with rule of law in Judea and Samaria, there's half a million 550,000 Israelis and roughly two, two and a half million Palestinians. And there must only be rule of law wherever there's crime and any sort of violence. I have zero tolerance for that. Many Jews have been murdered by Palestinians. And if there's violence from Jews towards Palestinians, that's totally unacceptable. And we have to use all our tools to take care of that. No question.
- [26:35]
Piers Morgan
Natalie Bennett, I always appreciate you coming on. We always have a robust conversation, which is important. And I thank you.
- [26:41]
Naftali Bennett
Robust is the good word. Thanks, Piers. I appreciate it. And it's always a pleasure being here.
- [26:47]
Piers Morgan
Thank you very much. A little earlier, I got a passionate view from inside Lebanon from Dr. Salah Maknuk, professor at University of St. Joseph in Beirut. Welcome to Uncensored.
- [26:59]
Dr. Salah Maknuk
Thank you for having me.
- [27:00]
Piers Morgan
Chris, I think what's getting lost in the last three weeks or so is what has been happening in Lebanon. That's why I wanted you on. A mutual friend sent me a clip of you talking very passionately about what has been going on in the Lebanon. Now, for those who've not been following it as closely as they're following what's happening in Iran, just summarize what is going on.
- [27:24]
Dr. Salah Maknuk
First, I'm incredibly grateful to be here and I'm thankful for you for allowing a voice of the Lebanese people who for 57 straight years have been reduced to footnotes in a variety of regional conflict, ideological conflict, more recently Gaza and Iran, where we are treated all 5 million of us, either as data or by people counting the number of casualties or simply as a natural consequence or extension of some ideological war. First it was the Palestinians in the 60s and then it was the Egyptians, and then it was the Syrians, and then it was Hezbollah, and Now it's the IRGC and its proxy. You know, Pierce, since 1969, since 1969, one delusional militia after the other has drawn Lebanon to war against the will of its own people. I am 42 now. This is the sixth war in my lifetime. So what I want to say using your platform, is that we are officially and irrevocably done as Lebanese people of our land being used for proxy wars. And when I say we, I speak not only in my name, but in the name of millions of Lebanese, an absolutely astounding majority of which refuse to be part of this conflict. Now, some of, some of your viewers might not know that from simply navigating X the entire day and listening to ideologue, but I brought with you, I brought to you today a poll conducted by Gallup, one of the most respectable US Institutions conducting polls in Lebanon. And what does the poll say? The polls say when they ask, do you believe that the Lebanese army should be the only group, only group that bears weapons and not the militias. 79% of Lebanese said yes. Only 19% of Lebanese said no. The poll asks again, in your opinion, do you favor Lebanon supporting Palestine in each of the following ways or not? When asked about engaging in military conflict with Israel in the service of other causes, 86% of Lebanon said no. Only 10% said yes. So our message today is very clear to the world. This is not our war. This is not a war of the Lebanese people against Israel. This is not a war between Lebanon and Israel, between the government of Lebanon and Israel. This is a proxy war fought by the IRGC and its proxy Hezbollah and Lebanon and the Israeli government. And we are simply all 5 million of us, just pawns and hostages in for the millionth time in this regional equation. And we hear constantly and constantly peers from people in the west living comfortably in their living rooms, lectures in morality about resistance and about aggression. You know when Hezbollah launched these rockets against Israel on March 2, you know what they got from the Iranians? They got a thank you from Mushtava Khamenei himself. He thanked them in a letter for entering a war and I quote, in defense of Iran, despite local obstacles. Local obstacles being the Lebanese people, you know what we Lebanese people got? Not just bombs. A million displaced, over a thousand dead, mayhem all over the country, billions of dollars in losses. No, we got lectures, lectures in morality from pundits and intellectuals and academics living comfortably in the west who want to use our suffering as Lebanese people for their ideological fantasies. And I want to say today that I want these people to leave us alone, to find other venues where they can express their ideological fantasy. Because this conflict is not about their problem in America with Donald Trump. It's not about their views in Gaza, some of which might be right. It's not about the reductive worldview of good and bad. And it's not about some idea that they want to change the world through using Lebanese lives. These ideologues woke leftists want to use our suffering for their ideological fantasies because these people, Pierce, are the objective and reasonable allies of the worst elements of Israeli society. The worst elements of the Israeli right. You remember very well since 1993 when Hamas was bombing the buses and an extreme lunatic fanatic from the Israeli society killed Ishaq Rabin. Since then, these two powers of ideological woke left, Hezbollah and the extreme right wing elements in Israel have been fighting it out at the expense of people in this region and especially in Lebanon, where it is the will of the Lebanese people and the Lebanese government to put an end to this war. We want these people, as well as the militias, as well as the IRGC, to all leave us alone, to let us live in peace and prosperity.
- [32:20]
Piers Morgan
I mean, incredibly powerful and eloquent statement there. In the context of what you said, do you think there is a justification for what Israel and the United States are now doing in Iran? Do you believe that Iran has basically been propping up Hezbollah, the Houthis, Hamas for decades and that until that gets dealt with, there can never be proper peace in the region?
- [32:48]
Dr. Salah Maknuk
Part of what we stand for as Lebanese peers today is to make sure that these regional conflicts, no matter their righteousness or lack thereof, are not extended into Lebanon at the expense of the Lebanese people. Now, if you ask me as an analyst and as a Lebanese, we've seen nothing from the IRGC except assassinations, bombings, radicalization of society, increasing sectarianism and never ending wars. So yes, if you ask me, would I like to see the Iranian regime fall down, would this solve the problems of Lebanon? I would say absolutely yes. But my main concern is not supporting or not supporting the war of Israel, United States against Iran. My main concern is Lebanon. And what is said in particular appears, if you allow me, by Western pundits about Lebanon. I've seen a lot of pundits, some of which were guests on your show all the way from the conference of America, 7,000 miles away from here. The likes of Mr. Ugur, I've seen him, and the likes of Mr. Hassan, I've seen them speak about Lebanon. And I would like to ask them a question right here from Beirut, if you allow me. How many Lebanese need to die so you can satisfy your ideological cravings? How many? We keep being pontificated at as if we are children who are unable to decide their own fate and their own national interest. Khalas, as we say in Lebanon, Khalas, we want them to leave us alone. I've heard the argument that you know Israel is attacking Lebanon and the Lebanese army need to stand by with Hezbollah to fight Israel as if this is the national interest of the Lebanese. This is not only idiotic beers and shameful, it's counterproductive. And you know how I know that it's counterproductive? Because unlike them, I rely on facts, research and history to prove my point. We know from history when Lebanon was attacked and when Lebanon was not attacked. If you allow me to show you this study I did, if we can take it on camera for just two seconds, I will tell you about these numbers. We know in Lebanon very well, 80% of us, that for 20 years between the Armistice Agreement of 1949 and the beginning of PLO attacks against Israel in 1969, for these 20 years we know what happened between Lebanon and Israel. We know that in this 20 year period. Do you know how many times Israel violated Lebanese sovereignty in a 20 year period?
- [35:31]
Piers Morgan
Tell me.
- [35:31]
Dr. Salah Maknuk
82 times. Fierce 82 times in 20 years. Do you know how many Lebanese people died in 20 years as a result of skirmishes between Lebanon and Israel on the Israeli Lebanese border? In 20 years 15 people died. Do you know how many people were injured in 20 years? In a whole 20 years 16 people were injured. That's in a whole 20 years. Why? Because there were no militias in South Lebanon and the state owned the monopoly of arms. Now if you compare that very quickly to the era that is often praised by some of these pundits, the era where the resistance was fighting against Israel and protecting Lebanon in this period between 2006 and 2026, a perfectly comparable period in terms of time frame. The number of Lebanese deaths, 6,152 people. The number of Lebanese injured, 23,056 people. The number of Israeli violations to Lebanese sovereignty that the resistance was protecting 62,150 violations. That's a 410 times fold in dead people and 756 times fold in violations. So the math is clear, Piers. We knew when we were a jewel of the Mediterranean and the Middle east and why that is. We know these facts. We need them to stop lying because of their ideology at our expense. We also know, by the way peers speaking of occupation and aggression, by certificate of UN Secretary General in April 2000 that Israel had exited left its occupation of every single inch of Lebanese territory. Today, because of the wars of liberation for Gaza and For Iran, about 25% of our territory is now occupied. We also know as a matter of historical fact that for 78 years of existence of Lebanon and Israel, despite 20 years of military occupation in the south, not one Jewish settlement, not one Jewish settlement was put in south Lebanon. So save us your buzzwords about expansionism and colonialism and settlements, et cetera. We know our history and we don't need people blinded by ideology to tell us that we need to stand with an illegal sectarian fundamentalist militia and fight Israel. We don't need to do that. We need to stand with our army to establish Lebanese sovereignty, after which Israel would not be able or willing to attack Lebanon and thousands of people would not die.
- [38:15]
Piers Morgan
Salah El Maknuk I really appreciate coming on uncensored. We've run out of time. I could have talked to you for a lot longer. Please come back again because I think
- [38:23]
Dr. Salah Maknuk
thank you for giving me the opportunity.
- [38:25]
Piers Morgan
I think you're a very speaker Lebanese. I appreciate, very powerful and very eloquent and I can feel your passion and I can tell you you've gone back in history and you've thought about this very carefully and I appreciate you coming on. Thank you very much.
- [38:38]
Dr. Salah Maknuk
Thank you, Piers.
- [38:40]
Piers Morgan
Well, joining me now is the Lebanese American journalist Rania Khalek. Rania, welcome to Uncensored. Rania, what is your response to what we just heard from Dr. Saleh?
- [38:51]
Rania Khalek
Well, I got a chance to view some of his interview and I mean, he definitely represents certainly a segment of Lebanese, a tiny segment, I would say, who seek to normalize with Israel and who see Hezbollah as the bigger threat. You know, Lebanese have different opinions about this. It's a very polarized society. But one thing I will say is there is this sentiment among people who have his views that maybe this is an opportunity for the Israelis to take out their political opponent being Hezbollah in Lebanon, which I would kind of equate to if the democrats were kind of cheering on China to invade the US and remove the Republicans from power or something. But beyond that, Piers, I just want to add some context that I think was missing from what he said because, yes, there's a horrific war on Lebanon. I saw you in your earlier segment mentioning some of the toll of that war, which I appreciate. Over a thousand have been killed. We're in week four. 118 of those killed have been children, 40 medical workers, some of them killed in double tax strikes. You've got 128 health facilities targeted. And on and on and on. You mentioned over a million displaced. That's 25% of Lebanon and Israel is responsible for doing this. I want to add some context, though, to how this happened because, yes, on March 2nd, Hezbollah escalated against Israel by firing rockets that none of which did any damage but did fire rockets after the war with Iran started. But if you look at Hezbollah's statement for why they did that, in their statement they say it was a response to Israeli ceasefire violations. There has been a ceasefire in place for 15 months since the war in November that ended in November 2024 between Israel and Hezbollah. In those 15 months, Israel violated the ceasefire over 15,000 times. That's according to numbers collected by the Lebanese. And those ceasefire violations included nearly daily bombings. You know, I live in Lebanon, I've seen it happening. It included the killing of 370 people in Lebanon in those 15 months. And the Israelis never withdrew from the eight to nine points that they had occupied, strategic points in the border areas of southern Lebanon. Meanwhile, Hezbollah held its fire for those 15 months and abided by the ceasefire. The Americans were supposed to oversee that ceasefire, but of course did nothing to make Israel abide by it. All that's to say Hezbollah was responding to that and I guess found the time with the war and Iran appropriate to do it because the Israelis would have to fight on two fronts. But I think that context is really important because it goes back to I would love to have a national army that can protect this country from aggression from outside. The unfortunate fact of Lebanon is that the Lebanese army is not capable of doing that because it's dependent on hand me down weapons from the Americans. The Americans give the Lebanese army weapons that could never be used to challenge the Israelis. And most of them are broken and they're dependent on donations from the Gulf monarchies. So because of their donors, they are actually not able to even respond to Israeli aggression. In fact, in this war, Pierce, the Israelis have killed several Lebanese army soldiers and there has been no retaliation from the Lebanese army because they literally cannot retaliate. So all that's to say we don't have a national defense strategy in Lebanon. The government has done nothing to protect the people of the south who had been being bombed and having their land occupied for the last 15 months. So as a result, it's that vacuum with which you have a non state actor like Hezbollah coming in, stepping in. And they're a part of the south, they're of the south and protecting their villages and people from Israeli aggression, which I would also add has taken on, I wouldn't even call it a new element because Israel has always had an ambition to occupy southern Lebanon since even before Israel was created. You heard Israeli leaders like Ben Gurion stating that the Latani river is the natural border of Lebanon. The only reason they haven't been able to take Lebanon is because of fierce armed resistance in the south that even preceded Hezbollah. But that's what Hezbollah grew out of, is Israel's many invasions.
- [42:53]
Piers Morgan
Okay, but let me ask you, how would you categorize Israel Hezbollah? Because many people categorize them as terrorists in the same way that they view Hamas as terrorists, they view the Houthis as terrorists.
- [43:05]
Naftali Bennett
All.
- [43:05]
Piers Morgan
And the common theme, the link, is they've all been funded and armed by Iran. And that is, of course, the main reason why Israel in particular wants to go after Iran. Because they say it's been a constant war of attrition through proxies, including Hezbollah. You've described Hezbollah as strategic deterrence. That's a long way from calling them terrorists. What do you feel about Hezbollah themselves? They may have come out of, as you say, a vacuum. And, you know, your argument about the army and so on is a legitimate thing to raise. But, you know, the way that Hezbollah goes about his business is that of a terrorist organization.
- [43:49]
Rania Khalek
Well, I mean, Piers, that's according to the view of Western states, which don't make up the whole world. I mean, Hezbollah political wing in this country, and they're actually like, you know, Israel likes to call itself the only democracy in the Middle East. And in those elections, Hezbollah is elected to power by their base. They actually are a part of the biggest parliamentary bloc in Lebanon. So they're not some fringe organization. Right. And they have that support from their base, mostly in the south, because, again, people see them as a protector that they don't get from the Lebanese government. But I want to just add something here. This is Israel's seventh invasion of Lebanon since 1978. Seven invasions. Right. Some of those invasions preceded Hezbollah's existence. Hezbollah grew out of Israel's 1982 invasion and occupation of Lebanon. Because if you occupy peers, if you occupy, or if you invade and occupy any country, there's going to be local resistance to that occupation, and people are gonna take arms from whoever they can. In the case of Hezbollah, they took arms and funding from Iran. That's absolutely true. And they did that to fight off an Israeli occupation that they eventually pushed out in 2000 and again in 2006, and there was invasion in 2024, and there's an invasion again. So I just also want to say something else here is, you know, I'm speaking to you from Lebanon. Right. I'm a Lebanese woman.
- [45:05]
Piers Morgan
Yeah.
- [45:06]
Rania Khalek
I'm in Beirut right now, and I am well aware that a few weeks ago the Israelis acquitted five of their soldiers who were caught on camera gang raping a Palestinian prisoner. Okay. On camera, on CCTV footage, you probably know this story. They were acquitted and then embraced afterwards by several Israeli government officials and the media and the public as heroes. There was even protests and rallies in Israel against their prosecution. And that is not an isolated incident. Human rights organizations, including Israeli human rights organizations, have documented systematic sexual violence against Palestinians by the Israeli military. And I raise that just to say this military, some might call it an army of rapists, in this case, is currently invading my country. And the only thing standing in the way of me and this army of rapists is this group fighting in the south of Lebanon. So it's hard for me to sit here and abide by categorizations that people in Washington are making when I know, again, that is the only obstacle between me and Beirut. And this army that has raped, has killed tens of thousands of children recently. Recently tortured a child in Gaza. A child.
- [46:20]
Piers Morgan
All right, so would you smoke cigarettes? Okay, listen, I hear you. So would you therefore also condemn what Hamas did on October 7th?
- [46:29]
Rania Khalek
Well, Piers, we've had this conversation before. This is so last season, the condemnation game. I'm gonna stick by the same answer.
- [46:34]
Piers Morgan
I really are still dead, sadly. So let me just ask you.
- [46:36]
Rania Khalek
I'm going to stick by the answer I already gave you. I don't. I'm not going to condemn people who are living under annihilation and genocide for resisting their genocide.
- [46:43]
Piers Morgan
No, it's fine. You're condemning the actions of the idf. And yet, as you know, as you know and I know and the world knows, on October 7, 3,000 Hamas terrorists poured over the border in three different waves. They attacked innocent people at a music festival. They attacked innocent people in kibbutzes. They murdered indiscriminately people. They killed 1200. They kidnapped over 250, including a baby. And Holocaust survivors. They did despicable things all day that day. And yet you are very, very quick to condemn the idf. And trust me, no one's been more condemnary of IDF actions when I think they're wrong than I have. But you won't condemn Hamas. And that's been my problem. And why? I've always asked that question of people who come on like yourself. Because the reluctance to condemn terrorism when it's clearly terrorism and it's the indiscriminate, brutal killing and murder of innocent people. You can smile. I don't find it funny.
- [47:44]
Rania Khalek
I'm not. I'M so Piers. I'm sm. I don't find anything funny. I'm in a war zone right now.
- [47:51]
Piers Morgan
Explain why. Explain why you find why you. Here's my question, right, Ronnie? Here's my question. Here's my question, Ronnie. Ronnie, my question is why are you so quick to condemn the IDF for their atrocities, as you see it, but so reluctant to condemn the same kind of atrocities from Hamas or Hezbollah or the Houthis? What's the difference? Atrocities are atrocities. They should all be condemned, shouldn't they?
- [48:20]
Naftali Bennett
This episode is brought to you by White Claw Surge. Nice choice hitting up this podcast. No surprises. You're all about diving into tastes everyone
- [48:28]
Cenk Uygur
in the room can enjoy.
- [48:30]
Naftali Bennett
Just like White CL Claw Surge.
- [48:31]
Cenk Uygur
It's for celebrating those moments when connections have been made and the night's just begun. With bold flavors and 8% alcohol by volume. Unleash the night. Unleash White Claw Surge. Please drink responsibly.
- [48:44]
Naftali Bennett
Hard seltzer with flavors, 8% alcohol by volume. White cloth seltzer works Chicago, Illinois,
- [48:54]
Rania Khalek
Lebanon As a Lebanese person, under the situation I'm in, to condemn resistance to a brutal supremacist settler colony is like asking an Austrian Jew in the 1940s to condemn resistance to Nazi Germany. Because atrocities. That's all I'm hearing from you. Because my entire life my family has been subjected to constant aggression and war crimes by Israel. Because since its existence and founding in this region as a settler colony, a Jewish settler colony implanted in this region and in a region that's not majority Jewish. So it has to commit constant ethnic cleansing and demographic engineering to exist as a ethno state, not a normal country, a settler colony, ethnostate. Just constant aggression and torture and rape and land theft against my people. They've currently displaced over a million in Lebanon and they're saying they can't return. You have Israeli Finance Minister Bazalo Smotrich saying they're going to annex southern Lebanon, depopulate it of Lebanese and replace it with Jewish settlers, just like they've done in the West Bank. You're asking me?
- [49:58]
Piers Morgan
Well, here's okay, but here's the difference between me and you is I am very happy to publicly condemn Smodrich and Ben gvir. I think they're a pair of right wing headbangers who are doing Israel a massive disservice every time they open their mouths. And I do think they are pursuing a policy of ethnic cleansing and the nearest I've seen to genocidal language has come out of their mouths. So you're not going to get any truck with me. I'm happy to condemn them. You know, I just wish that you would be intellectually honest and say I find all this kind of behavior disgusting. From the IDF or from Smodrich and Ben Gavir or whoever it may be, or the settlers on the West Bank. I would agree with you. By the way, I don't condone slaves. But your abject refusal to condemn atrocities from anyone on your side does you a disservice. On my side? Well, it's true.
- [50:50]
Rania Khalek
Years. Wow. Listen, you have a very intelligent woman coming to you.
- [50:56]
Piers Morgan
Intelligent.
- [50:56]
Rania Khalek
Wolfman, Lebanon. I have such good knowledge of this region. No? And instead of sitting here, you can actually learn some things from me, Piers. And instead of sitting here asking me about what's happening on the ground, talking to you about the situation in Lebanon, which I can give you a lot of nuance about, you're playing a condemnation game with me that I just don't want to play. And I've given you the reason why.
- [51:19]
Piers Morgan
I'm playing a hypocrisy game, that's all. A double standard game. That's all I'm playing. I'm asking you to be intellectually consistent and you're not. You condemn atrocities on one side, but not the other side, and that is intellectually dishonest. I can condemn both happily and loudly. That's intellectually honest. And I don't think there's going to be any resolution to any of these big issues in the Middle east until people are genuinely intellectually honest and condemn all atrocities wherever they occur, perpetrated by whomever. It shouldn't be difficult, but it's all got too. Unfortunately, people are too entrenched and they can't be intellectually honest. But look, I like having you on the program. Thank you very much indeed for coming. I appreciate it.
- [52:08]
Rania Khalek
Thanks.
- [52:10]
Piers Morgan
Well, joining me now is the founder and CEO of the Young Turks, Cenk Yuga. Cenk, how are you
- [52:16]
Cenk Uygur
hanging in there, brother?
- [52:18]
Piers Morgan
I'm worried about you because last week, whenever the last time you were on, we had a very pretty civilized debate. And then the last five minutes, you completely exploded in a way that even by your standards. Let's just remind viewers of what happened because I was taken aback by it. Hence why I wanted to get you on one on one to discuss things in a slightly calmer manner. Let's take a look.
- [52:41]
Cenk Uygur
The Israeli Adelsons gave Jonathan Pollard a trip on their private jet back to Israel and celebrated him like a hero because they love people, betraying America for Israel. I can prove it. I can prove it. So tell me if we should put American troops or Israeli troops in. Okay. Why are we putting our guys in? Ben Ferguson, that traitor, said that it was no big deal that 13Americans died. It's a huge deal. Never said that 13Americans died. Why don't you send your goddamn Israeli friends into a war? Take the heads, bro. They started it.
- [53:23]
Piers Morgan
Now, Cheng, I. As you know, I like you. When I come to la, we meet up, we have great bagels together, we chew the fat, we. I'm a big admirer of you, what you do, the Young Turks, all of it. I love you. Probably one of my biggest repeat guests I ever have on Uncensored. But even I was worried about you. Look like every blood vessel was about to erupt and your spleen was gonna collapse in front of me. Live on Uncensored. I don't want your body uncensored on my screen. Why were you so angry? And do you think it actually is constructive to get that angry when we're trying to debate these things?
- [54:03]
Cenk Uygur
Yes, I do. I don't apologize for it at all. I love that I yelled at Ben Ferguson. He had it coming. Your viewers loved it. Everybody in America loved it. And I'll do it again. No, my health is perfectly fine. So if I die for any reason, you should ask around. It is not my heart. My heart's perfectly healthy. And in my real life, I'm very optimistic, very hopeful guy. We literally have a segment called Operation Hope on the Young Turks.
- [54:30]
Piers Morgan
You're very calm.
- [54:31]
Cenk Uygur
You're a calm guy.
- [54:32]
Piers Morgan
Exercised about this when I meet you. You're a calm guy. Yeah, you're just a chilled out dude.
- [54:38]
Cenk Uygur
That's right.
- [54:38]
Piers Morgan
But you seem to work yourself into this rage, and I have to say, it is always. It is always so waking you up. Well, I would say. Look, I would say this. You said to me, you would like to come on and have a one on one, a proper discussion between us about all this. I would say, as a dispassionate observer, that the rage is invariably fueled by Israel. So what is it about Israel in particular that makes you so enraged? Be honest.
- [55:09]
Cenk Uygur
Yeah, 100%. Believe me, I'm going to be honest. I don't have a problem with that. So first of all, just real quick, on your program and on any program, the only time that I raise my volume is when people interrupt me. And Israel first has a strategy of interrupting everyone else who talks because they want to monopolize the time. They want to monopolize the propaganda so I don't let them talk over me, and I never will. So they'll always fail at that. And I don't care how loud I have to get, and I'm being loud on behalf of the American people. All right, now to the core of the issue. Why does Israel enrage me so much? So there's several issues. First of all, I remember growing up thinking, I wonder what I would do if I was growing up in the 1930s and 40s, would I have tried as hard as I possibly can to fight the Holocaust? And I always thought, I wish I knew. And I would hope that I did. Right. Well, unfortunately, we got an opportunity here because there was a genocide in our lifetime. And so I'm fighting as hard as I possibly can to save as many lives as I can. And Israel's not finished. Israel's still bombing Gaza. They're still trying to annex West Bank. There is out of control terrorism in the west bank by the settlers. And they just invaded Lebanon and they just caused a war with Iran. I mean, if you can't get upset about that, you're not upset about fascism. You're not upset about over the top terrorism. I think everybody should be as angry as me. But those are part of the issue. The other part, Piers, that is so important is that Israel is obviously controlling our politicians and our media here. And the media's gaslighting is unbearable propaganda after propaganda for Israel, and always on behalf of Israel. Like, for example, they asked this silly question, does Israel have a right to exist? It's not asked of any other country. Does Turkey have a right to exist? Does Greece have a right to exist? Well, of course they do. They already exist. But they never asked the question of the country that actually doesn't exist, which is Palestine. Does Palestine have a right to exist? That is the pertinent question. It is asked by approximately 0 times by cable news anchors in America. None. Never. And that is a super weird phenomenon where you keep asking if a country should exist that already does and has Iron Dome and nuclear weapons and the biggest military in the Middle East. But you won't ask the obvious question of shouldn't the Palestinians be allowed to exist? And it's obvious that Israel is not allowing them. Why do we have this overwhelming propaganda? Those are very legitimate questions and those are things that are enraging a lot of Americans, and I'm just speaking on their behalf.
- [57:42]
Piers Morgan
Okay? So as you know, a lot of people have tried to frame your very regular attacks on Israel as anti Semitic, a Charge that you have always strenuously denied. And for what it's worth, I have never detected when you come on my show that what you're saying is driven by a hatred of Jewish people. I think it's driven by a hatred. I think it is a hatred of the way the Israeli government conducts itself. And we can come to that in more detail in a minute. But I want to play you a clip which is what one anti Semitism campaign group called Canary Mission have highlighted. They say that you flop from calling out anti Semitic tropes to and stereotypes to now perpetuating every one of them against Israel. Let's take a look.
- [58:30]
Cenk Uygur
Oh, who do you think is really the one responsible? They always say the Jews because they think, oh, they're the puppet masters. This anti Semitic tropes, etc.
- [58:38]
Naftali Bennett
Right.
- [58:39]
Cenk Uygur
And it's obvious that they control us. And now Trump is out here like a puppet.
- [58:43]
Piers Morgan
Yes, I said puppet.
- [58:44]
Cenk Uygur
You could suck it. Puppets for Israel, puppet regimes, Israeli puppet. Yo, you guys like your money? Abby, you. You can't get any more anti Semitic than this. Okay, owe me more money. You owe me more money.
- [58:54]
Piers Morgan
Give me money.
- [58:55]
Cenk Uygur
Give me. 310 billion isn't enough. The Jews own the media, right? So that's the anti Semitic trope. This is a control of our media by Israeli forces. The root of all of these theories is always the Jews control the now.
- [59:10]
Piers Morgan
Cheng, when you watch that, there does seem to be shifting sounds between what you're saying originally and what you then say.
- [59:23]
Cenk Uygur
Absolutely not. First of all, of course, Canary Mission, I'm really glad you brought them up. So there are these Israel first thugs in this country and if you've never experienced it actually now you have before when you were for Israel, you never experienced it. Now once you slightly criticize Israel, you begin to experience it. But what you don't know is, is that when I go to Muslim American events, they say, we're so happy you speak out. Cuz if we speak out, we get fired from just regular jobs or our businesses get attacked by things like Canary Missions, StopAntisemitism.com. they're not actually trying to stop anti Semitism, they're trying to stop any criticism of Israel. And so that goes to the heart of that clip as well, which is we're not conflating Israel and Jews. In fact, on the Young Turks, I've literally said hundreds, maybe thousands of times, guys, this is not about religion. Do not attack Jewish Americans or Jews at all. This is about a country, and every country does. And governments do Terrible things. The people who actually conflate Israel and Jews are actually people like Canary Mission and all these Israel first groups. And what they're doing is they're hiding behind Jewish civilians and they're saying, if you criticize Israel at all, that means you hate all Jews. But wait a minute. If we played that game with every country, then we couldn't criticize any country. Oh, if you criticize the Chinese government, you hate all Chinese people. Well, that's absurd. Of course that's not true. If you criticize the Turkish government, you hate all Turkish people, you're anti Turkish. Well, of course that's not true. So it's not that we're anybody's picking on Israel and certainly not on Jewish Americans. It's that we're saying, can we apply the same standard to Israel? And when we say that, they go, oh, no, you're not allowed to apply that same standard to Israel because you're all anti Semites. And as Brad Schneider, a Congressman Democrat, did today to my nephew Hasan Piker, he said, and this is a very common trick that Israel first does, okay? Hasan said things he claims that are anti Semitic. That's not at all true. But he says it. He says that's why Abdul Al said a Democrat running for office in Michigan is not allowed to campaign with him, is not allowed to support him. Why do they do that? Isolate Israel's critics and try to pretend that they're toxic and eliminate them from the national conversation so that no one can criticize Israel. This is a game that they've done to average Americans, to people in the media even more vehemently, and to people in politics, so that you eliminate all of Israel's enemies and critics and opponents. And then where is the moral outrage? The moral outrage should be towards this genocide in Gaza where 72,000 kill people, at a bare minimum have been killed. Over 20,000 children, at a bare minimum, have been killed. But we're not talking about the slaughter of 20,000 children. Instead, we're talking about, should we condemn the people criticizing the genocide? Should we condemn the people criticizing Israel, starting seven wars, dragging us into a war. No, all of this is a defense of not Jewish people, but of Israel. And the reality is both me and, by the way, wonderful Jewish Americans like Dave Smith, Glenn Greenwald, Ben Cohen, Jeff Cohen, Robert Greenwald, you can go on and on for hours. So many young Jewish Americans are actually doing something wonderful, which is they're fighting for peace, they're being principled, and they're on the right side. And they're standing up for America and they're us. They're us. So I say that all the time. But they actually think that the bigger problem is people like us who are not anti Semitic. Cuz it's easy to say, oh, Nick Fuentes, no one should talk to him because he's clearly anti Semitic and all the other charges, right? The problem for them is when they can't show that we're anti Semitic. So then they take our criticism of Israel and they set up all these landmines propaganda landmines with tropes. So here, I'll give you an example. So blood libel. Now blood libel is a terrible anti Semitic trope from the 18th and 19th century made up about Jewish people drinking the blood of babies. That's crazy talk, right? But when we criticize Israel actually killing 20,000 children, they say, oh, that's blood libel. But wait a minute, that doesn't have anything to do with blood libel. Nobody's talking about drinking the blood of babies or anything like that. Oh, you're using it in a very callous and disgusting and immoral way to shield the government of Israel from criticism and thereby endangering Jewish people. Because when you actually go to criticize Israel, they go, no, all Jews stand for genocide. That's not true. That's actually a more anti Semitic statement. So all of this is propaganda in order to protect Israel.
- [64:06]
Piers Morgan
Okay, let me play. This is a clip from what Douglas Murray, he's been one of your biggest critics. What he said on this show actually back in December 2023, about you. You only really get animated if the Jews are involved.
- [64:18]
Cenk Uygur
And I can tell that for the following reason. I mean, your surname's Uyghur, isn't it?
- [64:22]
Naftali Bennett
One million Uyghur Muslims in China have
- [64:24]
Cenk Uygur
been put in concentration camps in the last decade.
- [64:27]
Piers Morgan
And you know, people of your ilk
- [64:29]
Cenk Uygur
never really care about that, do you? Because it's not the Jews doing it,
- [64:32]
Piers Morgan
it's a Chinese Communist party at the moment. One million people who are in Pakistan at the moment, who are your fellow
- [64:40]
Cenk Uygur
Muslims and who happen to be Afghan. And I don't think you care about them, do you? One million Afghans are currently being forcibly
- [64:47]
Piers Morgan
deported from Pakistan to Afghanistan. You don't care about that.
- [64:50]
Cenk Uygur
You're not riled up about that. You're not riled up about what the
- [64:53]
Piers Morgan
Jangaweed are currently doing in Sudan where
- [64:56]
Cenk Uygur
thousands and thousands of people are being
- [64:58]
Piers Morgan
attacked by the Islamist militia there.
- [65:01]
Cenk Uygur
You don't care about any of that. You get exercised and you rile up what little base you have of malcontents because you're riled up when the Jews do anything.
- [65:11]
Piers Morgan
So that is what people think. They think we watch chank a lot. But the thing that really gets him raging is always Israel. Ultimately, it always comes back to one thing. And the point they make about the anti Semitic tropes is simply that, as that mashup showed earlier, you used to be one of the people who would be very quick to point out the problem of people falling into the trap of reciting anti Semitic tropes, blaming the Jews for controlling the media, controlling politicians, and so on and so on. And now you seem to have moved to a place where you're openly doing that yourself with conviction, because you presumably believe it to be true. But I'm not saying I think that. I'm just saying that's what your critics think. But in relation to what Douglas said, there, there is a clear pattern. You blow up about Israel. You don't seem to have the same angry fury and rage about much else other than Israel. Why is it such a particular thing for you?
- [66:14]
Cenk Uygur
Yeah, so I'm glad we're addressing this, because when you say a lot of people think that it's that I'm blowing up about Israel because it's related to Jewish people, that's actually not true at all. Only Israel first thinks that. The rest of the country doesn't think that at all. The rest of the country is perfectly rational and understands that we can criticize the Israeli government like we criticize any other government. So now. But why do I get so mad about Israel as opposed to the other governments? First of all, that's what Douglas Murray said about me not being exercised about those other things are not at all true. He hasn't watched the Young Turks at all. So, for example, my last name is Uyghur. The Uyghur people in China are being terribly abused, and I do talk about it on the show. In fact, I had the representatives of the Uyghur government in exile on the show to talk about it. They've got them in concentration camps, and I can't stand it. But why do I spend more time railing against Israel than the Chinese, for example, against the Uyghurs? Well, there's a very good reason for that, because we're not funding the Chinese, we're funding the Israelis. I could yell at the Chinese, and I have, and it doesn't move them at all. I could yell at Hamas or Hezbollah or Al Qaeda, and they don't care. It doesn't move them at all. And it's not the actions of our government. What I am exercising about, what I'm really mad about is the actions of our government that we can control. So we're not funding any of the other terrorists or bad nations in the world, but we are funding Israel as they committed genocide. In fact, Joe Biden and Donald Trump gave them a thank you note along with $30 billion extra they gave them in the middle of a genocide. So that was saying, hey, genocide, well done. Here's Cenk's money, here's an average American's money, here's a family busting their ass, can't pay the rent or the mortgage in Missouri. You're going to take their money and you could use it for a genocide, you could use it for wars, you could use it for an endless occupation of the Palestinians and brutalizing all your neighbors. Well, if you're not upset about that, honestly, I think you're really immoral. That is an immoral position. Not to be enraged that they're using our government and our money. We have to work harder. We have to go and get a second job, pay more taxes so that Israel can commit more genocides. China's not doing it with our money. In fact, we have to borrow money from China to pay Israel for their genocide and their wars. And then my children and grandchildren have to pay the interest on the money we borrowed from China to give to Israel to commit genocide. That is insanity. In terms of the tropes, what's happening, Piers, is that Israel is hiding behind the tropes. So nobody is saying that Jews control this, that or the other thing. We're saying there's a lobby in America. By the way, there is a lot of lobbies who control our politicians. So when I say on the young turks, as I've said definitely thousands of times, maybe getting into the millions, big pharma, big oil, defense contractors, big banks, et cetera, all completely control our politicians. And I can prove it. And in fact, that's what I was yelling on the last time. I can prove it. So big pharma says that we are not allowed to negotiate drug prices. That's insane. We live in a so called free market in capitalism and we're not allowed to negotiate prices. Why? Because our politicians are deeply corrupt. They're 100% corrupt. So they say, americans, we don't care if it even kills you, you will pay whatever the drug companies demand because they don't work for us, the politicians, they work for the drug companies. The oil companies are the most profitable companies in the world, but we give them $35 billion in subsidies every year. By the way, that's nearly 10 times what Israel gets. So I am very exercised about that and I'm furious about that. And I'm not furious at the oil companies in Israel as much as I am furious at our politicians and our media. So when I question big pharma and how much money they give to the politicians, I get no pushback. Oil companies, no pushback. But when you get to the Israeli lobby, they want special rules and they hide behind the troves. Are you saying that money controls politicians? Yes, I'm definitely saying that. Are you saying Jewish money controls? No, I didn't say Jewish. You said Jewish. No one ever said Jewish. If, by the way, if the Bolivian lobby was as strong as the Israeli lobby and they had given billions of dollars to our politicians, then I would be livid with the Bolivian lobby. But it's not the Bolivian lobby, it's not the Malaysian lobby. It is obviously the Israeli lobby. And Piers, can you not see that they are asking for special rules that you're allowed to criticize every lobby except Israel's?
- [70:56]
Piers Morgan
Well, you know what I would say, what I would say about it, given them. Look, as you know, you know, I, for a long time after the start of the war in Gaza, I supported Israel's right to defend itself. I then became increasingly concerned and critical. The longer it went on, the more disproportionate I felt Israel's response had become. Interestingly, I've said that Ben Shapiro, the moment I began to get more critical, refused to come on the show anymore or have anything to do with me. And the same has happened with Douglas Murray. He hasn't appeared on our census since I became more critical of Israel and I've got a problem with that with both of them. I like them both. I've always enjoyed interviewing them and debating with them. But I don't see how you can be as they both are big supporters and defenders of free speech and sort of self appointed crusaders of free speech, but shut down debate with people who are becoming more critical of something that you have been supportive of. So to your credit, you always come on. And also to your credit, today we've managed to speak for 20 odd minutes and you haven't shouted at me once. So I think we are moving to a good place here. Cheng, your spleen has had a better afternoon. But my point being that you will debate anyone that is to your credit. I think it's I don't know why Douglas won't come back on. I think it's probably for the same reason that Ben Shapiro doesn't. And it's just they, they don't like people who are vocally critical of what Israel's been doing in the last three years. And I don't know anyone who's fair minded about it or clear minded about it, who can't find things to criticize the Israeli government for whilst at the same time in my case supporting Israel's right not just to exist but to defend itself. I know a lot of Israelis like them very much as a people. I know a lot of Jewish people and I have to say all the Israelis and Jews that I know have been saying to me how fair minded they think this show is, how I get everybody on. They appreciate that and they themselves are very critical of what their government's been doing in the main of all the people I met. So I don't know why people who profess to be champions of free speech are not able to take legitimate criticism of a government, whichever government that is. So on that point, you and I are totally in agreement. Look, I'm going to leave it there. I know you'll be back soon.
- [73:15]
Cenk Uygur
Oh, can I just say one last quick thing?
- [73:17]
Piers Morgan
You can, you can, yeah.
- [73:18]
Cenk Uygur
One last quick thing. I just want people to know, look, there's difference between these three different groups, Jews, Zionists and Israel First. Jews are just Americans that live here. I grew up with a kid whose parents were physics professors. Mossad never called them, they never got dialed into any plans of Israel or anything like that. So please do not believe these ludicrous conspiracy theories about all Jews are this way or that way. They're regular human beings who have a variety of opinions, obviously. And a lot of Zionists, yes, they catch flak for some good reason, but a lot of them just want Israel to be safe. They don't want the genocide, they don't want the wars, etc. But Israel first is the group that prioritizes Israel above all. They're the ones who do the propaganda. They're the ones who try to eliminate anyone who's opposed to Israel. So my beef is not with the first two groups. My beef is with Israel First. And we are not going to let them say it's anti Semitic to not give Israel another $300 billion or to start another war with them. We are going to fight for America and we have every right to. So you know, you've seen me ask this question a couple of times. So we have every right to ask, why is it American troops that are being sent into Iran and not Israeli troops?
- [74:32]
Piers Morgan
Do you know what I think people should be entitled to? What? When bombs are flying around, people should ask questions. It's the first prerequisite of anyone in the media to be loudly asking difficult questions. Of course, holding all governments to account. Cheng I've got to leave it there. It's been a civilized conversation. I'm glad we've had it. It's an important conversation. I think people who sometimes think all they see is clips of you shouting probably don't realize there's a non shouting. Cheng I do and I've enjoyed this conversation. So thank you.
- [75:03]
Cenk Uygur
Thank you, Piers.
- [75:06]
Piers Morgan
Piers Morgan Uncensored is proudly independent. The only boss around here is me. You enjoy our show. We ask for only one simple thing. Hit subscribe on YouTube and follow Piers Morgan Uncensored on Spotify and Apple podcasts. And in return, we will continue our mission to inform, irritate and entertain. And we'll do it all for free. Independent, Uncensored media has never been more critical and we couldn't do it without you.