Pivot Podcast Summary: DeepSeek Shockwaves, Nvidia's Plunge, and Target's DEI Rollback
Release Date: January 28, 2025
Hosts: Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway
Published by: New York Magazine and Vox Media Podcast Network
1. Navigating Elder Care Challenges
Timestamp: [01:12] - [07:07]
Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway open the episode by sharing personal experiences and challenges related to elderly care. Kara discusses the consideration of moving her mother to a newly converted senior facility, highlighting the complexities and emotional strain involved in such decisions. Scott echoes these sentiments, emphasizing the high costs and the often uncooperative nature of elderly parents when it comes to accepting care.
Notable Quotes:
- Scott Galloway: "It's a ton of time. I mean, you have one, the costs are incredible." [02:36]
- Kara Swisher: "It's really something. It’s, it’s. Takes a lot out of your system." [02:36]
2. DeepSeek's Disruption in the AI Landscape
Timestamp: [07:16] - [15:56]
The conversation shifts to the emergence of DeepSeek, a new AI model developed in China. DeepSeek is noted for outperforming established models from OpenAI, Meta, and Anthropic in third-party tests while operating at a fraction of the cost. This development has led to significant stock market reactions, with companies like Nvidia, Oracle, and Microsoft experiencing substantial declines.
Scott provides an in-depth analysis of the situation, suggesting that DeepSeek's efficiency challenges the previously held belief that high-end GPUs and significant energy consumption are indispensable for advanced AI models. He also touches upon the second-order effects on energy companies, noting the impact on nuclear stocks due to DeepSeek's optimized energy usage.
Notable Quotes:
- Scott Galloway: "Nvidia will have a pretty interesting argument on Capitol Hill saying when you refuse to let us sell into these countries, they come up with workarounds and in this case this workaround might tank the U.S. economy." [08:53]
- Kara Swisher: "Jan LeCun from Meta was making an argument that it isn't as what they're doing kind of a cheap and dirty version." [12:15]
3. Trade War Tensions: US vs. Colombia
Timestamp: [15:56] - [19:34]
Kara brings up a recent standoff between the US and Colombia, sparked by President Trump's threat to impose a 25% tariff on Colombian goods following Colombia's denial of entry to US military planes carrying migrants. The situation escalated quickly but was resolved within the day as Colombia agreed to facilitate the planes, effectively nullifying Trump's tariff threat.
Scott criticizes the move, describing it as unnecessary and symbolic cruelty. He highlights the potential long-term repercussions of such aggressive rhetoric, suggesting it could foster tensions that benefit rival powers like China.
Notable Quotes:
- Scott Galloway: "You make unnecessary enemies where they don't need to have them." [16:53]
- Kara Swisher: "Trump response by saying he'd impose a 25% tariff on Colombian goods coffee, which was met with retaliatory tariffs from Colombia." [15:56]
4. Oracle and Microsoft's Pursuit to Acquire TikTok
Timestamp: [23:17] - [27:35]
The hosts delve into the ongoing negotiations involving Oracle and Microsoft aiming to take over TikTok's global operations. This potential acquisition is reminiscent of the early days of Trump's presidency, with implications for data security and US-China technological competition. Scott raises concerns about the lack of communication from the Chinese government regarding the deal and warns of possible economic repercussions if the deal falls through.
Kara adds context by referencing OpenAI's open-source model, Llama, and its impact on the AI industry, further emphasizing the competitive race in AI advancements between the US and China.
Notable Quotes:
- Scott Galloway: "If this is the beginning of a massive correction that will infect the entire Nasdaq, the entire S and P." [14:22]
- Kara Swisher: "Deep Seek has profited from open research and open source. For example, PyTorch and Llama from Meta." [12:15]
5. Target's DEI Rollback and Corporate Responses
Timestamp: [31:13] - [35:20]
Kara discusses Target's decision to eliminate Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) goals and programs aimed at supporting black and minority-owned businesses. This move comes amidst increasing legal challenges and shareholder resistance from companies like Costco and Apple, who are choosing to uphold their DEI initiatives despite external pressures.
Scott shares his perspective on the necessity and implementation of DEI, advocating for nuanced approaches where DEI is essential but cautioning against overextension, especially within educational institutions.
Notable Quotes:
- Kara Swisher: "Target is one of the latest companies to hop on the anti DEI train." [31:13]
- Scott Galloway: "I think companies or private companies should do what they want. I think there are laws to protect." [32:08]
6. Character AI Lawsuit and the Future of Section 230
Timestamp: [37:28] - [39:30]
The discussion turns to a lawsuit filed against Character AI by a mother whose son committed suicide after interacting with a chatbot. Kara and Scott debate the implications of the lawsuit, particularly focusing on the protections provided by Section 230 and the First Amendment. Scott argues for the reevaluation of Section 230 in the context of algorithmically generated content, emphasizing the need for accountability, especially concerning content that can lead to self-harm.
Notable Quotes:
- Scott Galloway: "All algorithmically elevated content should, should lose or be absolved of 230 protection." [38:45]
- Kara Swisher: "These bots can say anything they want, but of course we prosecuted a young woman for convincing a young man to commit suicide." [37:28]
7. Wins and Fails: Reflecting on Society and Leadership
Timestamp: [40:16] - [54:28]
Wins:
- Kara Swisher: Praises the TV show "Severance" for its compelling storytelling and exceptional performances. [40:38]
- Scott Galloway: Highlights the 80th anniversary of Auschwitz liberation, emphasizing the importance of remembrance to prevent history from repeating itself. [43:44]
Fails:
- Kara Swisher: Expresses concern over ongoing legal challenges to same-sex marriage and the potential rollback of Obergefell v. Hodges. [40:22]
- Scott Galloway: Criticizes the Democratic leadership for being unprepared for Trump's presidency and calls for more proactive and forceful responses to current political challenges. [51:00]
Notable Quotes:
- Scott Galloway: "This is the most horrific case of a group of people perceiving enemies where they didn't have them and then combining it with industrial production." [47:13]
- Kara Swisher: "It's theater. It's theater. But they're trying to get a case up there that will make it happen the same way they're trying to get a libel case." [40:22]
8. Emerging Trends: The Rise of the Manosphere
Timestamp: [55:16] - [58:35]
Scott discusses the increasing popularity of manosphere podcasts, noting their relatability among young men who feel disconnected from mainstream media narratives. Kara reflects on how these podcasts resonate with their audience while also acknowledging the diverse reactions they elicit.
Notable Quotes:
- Scott Galloway: "There are tens of millions of mostly young men who are like, I don't need some over educated liberal in New York telling me the day's news." [57:00]
- Kara Swisher: "My son is fully in the Scott Galloway maniverse." [57:35]
9. Closing Remarks and Future Directions
Kara and Scott conclude the episode by encouraging listeners to engage with the show's content and participate in ongoing discussions about technology, business, and societal issues. They reiterate the importance of addressing the challenges highlighted throughout the episode and emphasize their commitment to fostering informed and critical conversations.
Notable Quotes:
- Kara Swisher: "We do not choose violence." [54:24]
- Scott Galloway: "We choose angry." [54:24]
Conclusion
In this episode of "Pivot," Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway navigate a diverse array of topics, from the disruptive advancements in AI and their economic implications to the intricate dynamics of trade relations and corporate DEI initiatives. Their candid discussions offer listeners a comprehensive understanding of the current technological and political landscapes, enriched with personal anecdotes and critical insights.
Remember to subscribe to "Pivot" on your preferred podcast platform and follow New York Magazine for more in-depth analyses and discussions on the latest in tech, business, and politics.