It’s my tree. Why can’t I cut it down?

Summary

Planet Money, NPR

Episode: "It’s my tree. Why can’t I cut it down?"
Date: June 12, 2026
Hosts: Jeff Guo & Amanda Aronczyk

---

Overview

This episode explores the increasingly contentious battle between individual property rights and collective community interests, centered around the simple—but consequential—question: If you own a tree on your property, can you cut it down? Through the story of Sarah Bond, a Portland homeowner, and a pivotal legal case from Canton, Michigan, the hosts dive into the clash between tree protection laws, personal liberty, and urban environmental responsibilities.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Sarah Bond’s Homeownership Story and Her Tree Dilemma

• [00:22] Sarah Bond and her husband, eager to settle down in Southwest Portland, finally buy their dream house in 2021.
• [01:41] After moving in, Sarah notices a giant, leaning Douglas fir in her backyard—stretching 100 feet tall, ominously tilting towards her house.
• Sarah’s reaction:
  "My immediate feeling was like, oh my gosh, this should have been taken out like yesterday. Like, this is really scary." [02:01]
• [02:28] The Bonds apply for a city permit to remove the tree—only to be denied. The city decides the tree is both healthy and important to neighborhood character.
• Sarah laments:
  "I don't understand how we are the owners of the tree if we have no power over making a decision about it. It makes no sense." [03:34]

---

2. The Purpose and Spread of Tree Laws

• [03:43] Many American cities have adopted laws to protect trees, preserving urban canopies for public benefits: shade, air purification, flood prevention, and climate resilience.
• [06:02] Canton, Michigan is spotlighted as a prototypical suburb deeply invested in its community greenery.
• Ann Marie Graham Hudak (Canton’s Supervisor):
  "We did not want a town that turned into all concrete." [07:01]
• [07:41] Canton passes an ordinance requiring permits to remove large trees—mainly targeting developers, but emblematic of broader trends.

---

3. Developers vs. City: The Canton, Michigan Case

• [09:08] The permitting process appears to work—until 2018, when local businessmen illegally clearcut 16 acres (~1,500 trees).
• [09:51] The city calculates a remediation fee: about $500,000.
• [10:06] The owners object, lawyer up, and lawsuits ensue, attracting free-market legal advocates.

---

4. Property Rights, Constitutional Law, and The “Takings Clause”

• [10:39] Enter Chance Weldon, litigation director at the Texas Public Policy Foundation, who sees such laws as governmental overreach.
• Chance Weldon:
  "Anytime I see the city come in and act in ways that remind me of a landlord, it just sets off my alarm bells of somebody's property rights are being violated." [11:06]
• [12:33] Weldon invokes the Fifth Amendment’s “takings clause"—government cannot take private property for public use without just compensation.
• [14:05] He draws on a 1980s Supreme Court precedent: the government cannot unreasonably occupy a property (e.g., with a cable box) or require keeping a tree against the owner’s wishes.
• Jeff Guo’s summary:
  "It's like the government should pay you tree rent." [14:47]

---

5. Court Ruling & Implications

• [16:21] In 2021, the 6th Circuit Court sides with Weldon—ruling that Canton’s method of calculating tree removal fees is unconstitutional. The fee must be tailored to the actual ecological benefit provided by each tree, not a blanket sum.
• Ann Marie Graham Hudak (Canton’s Supervisor):
  "Yeah. I didn't understand it." [17:22]
• [17:39] Canton rewrites its law: fees are now based on an arborist’s valuation.

---

6. Back to Portland: The Tree Falls

• [19:39] Three years later, Sarah Bond’s anxieties are realized—the giant Douglas fir crashes through their house during a storm.
• Sarah relates the experience:
  "I do remember the sound of wood splitting, like, of it cracking as it was falling. Yeah, it's like so loud." [21:02]
• [22:21] Panic ensues as family searches for daughter JoJo, but everyone (and eventually their cat) is found safe.
• Sarah’s relief:
  "We all lived and we never have to worry about that frickin tree again." [23:02]
• [23:27] Ironically, the city requires the Bonds to pay for a retroactive permit for the "removed" tree, with a fee or tree replacement requirement.

---

7. Aftermath and Broader Implications

• [24:15] The Bonds sue the city for lack of compensation and for the trauma they endured—another chapter in the property rights vs. community welfare debate.
• Sarah’s reflection:
  "I felt very angry and annoyed, like we were sold this idea of homeownership, and we actually, like, didn't have control over it as much as I assumed we would... It was a safety reason. And so that was, like, the part that was extra demoralizing." [24:39]
• [25:10] The episode closes by framing these stories as the latest round in a tug-of-war. In recent years, courts may be swinging the pendulum back toward property rights, forcing cities to be more precise—and fair—in their environmental regulations.

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• Sarah Bond (fear of the tree, being denied):
  "I don't understand how we are the owners of the tree if we have no power over making a decision about it. It makes no sense." [03:34]

• Ann Marie Graham Hudak (communitarian perspective):
  "Everything we do affects everybody. And unfortunately... too many people think of only, what do I want? What's me, me, me, me. But you don't live isolated in a bubble." [08:05]

• Chance Weldon (property rights alarm):
  "Anytime I see the city come in and act in ways that remind me of a landlord, it just sets off my alarm bells of somebody's property rights are being violated." [11:06]

• Court’s practical effect:
  "The court says that the way Canton is doing its tree permits is unconstitutional..." [16:21]

• Sarah’s relief after the tree falls:
  "We all lived and we never have to worry about that frickin tree again." [23:02]

---

Timeline of Key Segments

• 00:22 – Sarah Bond’s dream house & the discovery of the dangerous tree
• 02:28 – Denied permit & awakening to legal limits
• 06:02 – Canton, Michigan: the urban tree protection model
• 09:51 – The “missing forest” and legal showdown
• 10:39 – 16:21 – Chance Weldon and the takings clause argument; federal court decision
• 19:39 – The Portland tree falls: the family’s ordeal
• 23:27 – Retroactive regulation & family’s lawsuit
• 24:39 – Sarah’s reflection on homeownership and agency

---

Tone and Delivery

Fluid storytelling; a blend of personal anecdote (Sarah’s family), legal explanation (Chance Weldon), and civic perspective (Ann Marie Graham Hudak). Approachable, sometimes wry; maintains focus on the human stakes beneath the policy debates.

---

Conclusion

The episode masterfully ties a singular homeownership experience to a national legal and economic conflict, illustrating how the boundaries between personal autonomy and communal responsibility are constantly redrawn—one tree, one law, one court case at a time. Whether tree laws will continue to chip away at homeowners’ control, or if the courts will pull back in favor of property rights, remains an open question—one with real consequences for families, neighborhoods, and cities everywhere.

Transcript

[Commercial Announcer]

This message comes from U.S. bank. Simplify how you do business with business Essentials. A powerful combination of no monthly maintenance fee, checking and card payment processing. Deposit products are offered by U.S. bank National association member FDIC.

[Sarah Bond]

This is Planet Money from NPR.

[Jeff Guo]

The day that Sarah Bond finally became a homeowner, she'd almost given up. It was 2021. The housing market was red hot. She and her husband Joel kept getting outbid. They were starting to think maybe their family would never have a place they could make their own. Place where she and Joel could plant blueberry bushes. Place where their daughter Jojo could raise baby ducks and chickens. Then she got a call from her realtor.

[Sarah Bond]

She left a voicemail. And she said, congratulations. And I was like, what? And I just started like. I was like, no way. And I told my husband, he was like, are you serious? Are you kidding?

[Amanda Aronczyk]

The house that was now their house was white with black trim, two stories tall. It was nicer than she ever thought she could afford. And it was located in their dream neighborhood on a tree lined street in southwest Portland. She remembers when they first went to visit the area.

[Sarah Bond]

And as soon as we open the doors of the car, we just hear like an eruption of children laughing and screaming. And there was all these kids like rolling down the hill and they're just like tumbling all over each other and it's just like magic.

[Jeff Guo]

Sarah's favorite part about their new home was the huge yard. She used to work at a garden center and she loved how many plants and trees were grown around their home.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

About a week or two after they move in, Sarah's in the backyard when she realizes that one of the trees is growing at a kind of weird angle. It's this huge Douglas fir. It's like 100ft tall. And it is so big that standing in the backyard, she couldn't even see the top of it. And it is leaning towards the house.

[Sarah Bond]

When I first noticed the lean, my immediate feeling was like, oh my gosh, this should have been taken out like yesterday. Like, this is really scary.

[Jeff Guo]

It was like this tree of Damocles just looming over them. Sarah kept picturing it falling.

[Sarah Bond]

This tree wasn't going to like fall and you know, put a hole in our roof. It was going to fall and we would be lucky to walk away.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

Sarah and Joel start looking into how to remove a hundred foot tall tree from your backyard. They find out that they need to get approval from the city because in Portland, like in many places, anytime you want to remove a large tree, you have to apply for a permit.

[Jeff Guo]

And Sarah's like, well, clearly this tree is dangerous, so let's just get this permit. They go online, fill out the forms. Pretty soon a city inspector comes to look at the trees. And a couple weeks later, Sarah and Joel get the letter.

[Sarah Bond]

I have a memory of my husband, like, walking into the living room and saying, oh, they denied our permit. I was like, what?

[Amanda Aronczyk]

The city had determined that the leaning tree looked healthy and normal and that removing this tree would significantly affect neighborhood character, so the city would not let the bonds cut down their tree.

[Sarah Bond]

It was so surreal and like, I couldn't. I was in a state of disbelief for a long time.

[Jeff Guo]

Sarah's like, wait, this is not a city tree. This is our tree in our own backyard.

[Sarah Bond]

I don't understand how we are the owners of the tree if we have no power over making a decision about it. It makes no sense.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

In recent years, hundreds of towns and cities in America have passed laws to protect trees, to preserve the urban canopy for the good of the neighborhood.

[Jeff Guo]

And these laws are redrawing the line between what belongs to the property owner and what belongs to the community. Hello and welcome to Planet Money. I'm Jeff Guo.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

And I'm Amanda Aronczyk. Here in the United States, the general rule is that towns and cities have a lot of power when it comes to land and how people use it. Towns and cities can pass zoning laws. They can ban certain types of buildings. They can even require houses to look a certain way.

[Jeff Guo]

But can a city actually stop you from cutting down a tree in your own backyard? Today on the show, when does a zoning law go too far? And how the fight over tree laws is changing? The answer to that question.

[Commercial Announcer]

This message comes from Schwab. With the new Schwab teen investor account, teens can gain hands on investing experience. It's co owned by you and your teen so you can monitor the account while you your teen learns how to invest and manage money.

[Commercial Announcer 2]

Learn [e-mail] this message comes from Whole Foods Market. Save on seasonal favorites at Whole Foods Market. Start in the vibrant produce department stocked with organic fruits and veggies. Then head to prepared foods for easy grab and go lunches and dinners. There are so many ways to save. Those yellow sale signs are just about everywhere. Plus prime members can find extra in store deals every Tuesday and Friday. And the low priced $3.65 by Whole Foods Market brand never sacrifices on qu quality. Save today and every day at Whole Foods Market. This message comes from Dell. Dell PCs with Intel inside are built for the moments that Matter like a big project that can't be interrupted by an update with long lasting battery life. You can stay focused on what matters built for you. Dell.com DellPCS

[Jeff Guo]

Sarah Bond didn't know it at the time, but when she bought her house with this tree of Damocles looming over it, she was stepping into a larger battle over what ownership and property rights even mean. A battle that has been escalating over the last few decades. And the front line of this battle involves a tree law over a thousand miles away in the township of Canton, Michigan.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

Canton is about 40 minutes west of Detroit. Picture your classic American suburb. Lawns are neat and tidy. Streets have names like Cherrywood Lane and Beechwood Drive.

[Ann Marie Graham Hudak]

Canton is, it's basically the ninth largest community in Michigan. It's got about over 100,000 people.

[Jeff Guo]

Ann Marie Graham Hudak is the township supervisor. She's like the mayor. She is Canton's number one fan. She's got this real earnest energy.

[Ann Marie Graham Hudak]

We have about 414 miles of roads. We have 1100 acres of parks, and we have, yeah, lots of trees.

[Jeff Guo]

And how important are trees to the people of Canton?

[Ann Marie Graham Hudak]

Oh, they're very important. Are you kidding?

[Amanda Aronczyk]

Yeah. The town flag, which was flying outside Ann Marie's office, has a big green tree on it. But as Canton, Michigan grew over the decades, as developers put in more strip malls and suburban subdivisions, the town was losing more and more of its trees.

[Jeff Guo]

It got to a Point in 2006 when the town's leaders decided to do something.

[Ann Marie Graham Hudak]

You know, if people can come in and just start raising fields of trees, and we had no say in it, that that was scary to us because we have so many wetlands, we have so many natural areas, and we did not want a town that turned into all concrete.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

Annemarie says there are a lot of reasons why trees are better than concrete. Trees filter the air and provide shade. Their roots help absorb stormwater and prevent floods. Studies have shown that trees can even save lives by keeping neighborhoods cool on hot days.

[Ann Marie Graham Hudak]

And so in Canton, we want to keep that balance. We're very, very cognizant of the health of the community and we're responsible for keeping that healthy community.

[Jeff Guo]

So the township board passed an ordinance to protect the community by protecting the trees. Anyone who wanted to cut down a large tree now needed to get the town's approval. They had to get a permit.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

Emory says it's just like how you might need an electrical permit to rewire your garage. Like, the township wants to review your plants because if your shoddy wiring sets Your garage on fire, that affects your neighbors.

[Ann Marie Graham Hudak]

Everything we do affects everybody. And unfortunately, you know, too many people think of only, what do I want? What's me, me, me, me. But you don't live isolated in a bubble.

[Jeff Guo]

Anne Marie says these tree permits were all about protecting the neighbors, too. The town wanted to hold people accountable for how removing a tree would hurt the community by taking away shade, increasing the risk of floods.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

Now, in Canton, this tree permit ordinance mostly applied to developers, not homeowners. And the township would usually grant developers the permit as long as they agreed to either plant a replacement tree on the property or pay a remediation fee. That fee, usually a couple hundred dollars per tree, would go into the township's tree fund.

[Jeff Guo]

And this is a pretty common system in a lot of towns and cities these days, from Dallas to Denver to Mobile, Alabama. A lot of these places have similar laws requiring people to compensate the community when they cut down a tree.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

And in Canton, Anne Marie says that the system worked pretty smoothly. The township issued thousands of tree permits, and along with developers, they replanted thousands

[Jeff Guo]

of trees until, that is, the spring of 2018. That is when the township discovers that on the edge of town, an entire forest has secretly gone missing.

[Ann Marie Graham Hudak]

The only reason we found out is because a neighbor told on them someone

[Amanda Aronczyk]

had cut down all of these trees. So the town sends an official to investigate, and what they find is just mud and tree stumps. Property owners out there have clear cut about 16 acres of woods just like that. No permits, no notice, nothing. The town leaders are shocked.

[Jeff Guo]

Anne Marie knows these property owners. A lot of people do. They're local businessmen. One of them owns a sign company. The other two run a trucking company.

[Ann Marie Graham Hudak]

Companies that had been here for a long time. Then they knew the rules.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

The town calculates that more than 1500 trees had been cut down. They tell the property owners, okay, what is done is done. Now you're gonna have to replace all these trees or pay the fee for 1500 trees. The fee would come out to around half a million dollars.

[Ann Marie Graham Hudak]

And they threw a fit. And instead of saying, oh, well, we'll pay this much, or how about we plant these trees, whatever, they hung up and they called the lawyer. And then all the lawsuits started.

[Jeff Guo]

This is how Canton, Michigan, ends up at the center of a major legal battle. A battle over not just the tree protection law, but about the limits of what cities can even do when it comes to permitting and zoning.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

This dispute makes the local news, and from there, it quickly attracts the attention of a lawyer named Chance. Weldon Chance had been looking for a case just like this.

[Chance Weldon]

I'm the director of litigation at the Texas Public Policy foundation, and that means that I sue the government for a living, which is an absolutely sweet gig.

[Jeff Guo]

The Texas Public Policy foundation is this free market think tank, and Chance is a constitutional lawyer. He's one of those constitutional lawyers who cares a lot about property rights. He says as a kid growing up in Houston, he learned a lot about what it means not to have property rights. His parents were renters. They didn't own their own home.

[Chance Weldon]

And the one thing that always stuck out to me is like, you couldn't have a tree house. You couldn't change things in the yard because you had to ask the landlord first. And the thing that distinguished to me ownership from renting is not having to ask the landlord. And so anytime I see the city come in and act in ways that remind me of a landlord, it just sets off my alarm bells of somebody's property rights are being violated.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

Around 2018, Chance's property rights alarm bells were going off on account of these tree protection ordinances. He had watched them pop up all over the country, including where he lives in Texas. To him, these towns were pretty obviously violating people's property rights.

[Jeff Guo]

And, okay, now the idea of property rights seems simple, right? They're what you get to do when you own property.

[Chance Weldon]

Typically, that means that I can sell it or I can use it, or I can change it, or I can build something on it.

[Jeff Guo]

But there are limits to your property rights. You only get to do what you want up until it affects your neighbors. So cities can tell you, for instance, you can't put a slaughterhouse next to a schoolyard. And before you build anything, they can make you get construction permits and noise permits and environmental permits.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

And Chance agrees that a lot of these local regulations are important. But he and the folks he works with think that modern zoning and permitting laws have gone too far. He thinks a lot of them are unconstitutional, that they violate what is called the takings clause of the Fifth Amendment.

[Chance Weldon]

So the takings clause says that the government cannot take private property except for a public use and with just compensation.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

The basic idea here is the government can't force you to provide your property to the public for free.

[Jeff Guo]

So traditionally, that has meant that the government can't physically take your land without paying you for it. But there's also something called a regulatory taking. The Supreme Court has said that when the government puts too many regulations and restrictions on a piece of property, that's the same as taking it away.

[Chance Weldon]

And so then the question becomes, when has the government gone too far by regulating what you can do on your property that it's effectively taken it away?

[Amanda Aronczyk]

Now, for more than 100 years, some people have been trying to argue that zoning and permitting laws violate the takings clause. They're like, if the city's gonna tell me what I can or can't build on my own property, it's basically acting like the city owns my property. But mostly those arguments have not been that successful.

[Jeff Guo]

Yeah, by and large, the rule is that cities these days mostly get to do whatever they want when it comes to zoning and permits. They can even regulate the look and feel of a neighborhood. They can force you to paint your house a certain color because, you know, a tacky looking house hurts the community. But there are some limits, and Chance, the lawyer, wants to test those limits.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

When he hears about the fight over the tree permits in Canton, Michigan, he reaches out to the attorney for the local property owners and offers to help them out for free. Eventually, in 2021, one of those cases reaches the 6th Circuit Court of Appeals, which is one rung below the Supreme Court.

[Jeff Guo]

One of Chance's main arguments is based on this old case from the 1980s, where the Supreme Court said that the government can't force someone to put an unwanted cable box on their property. That that is an unconstitutional taking because the government is taking away your right to use a part of your property.

[Chance Weldon]

So if you think about if the government just came and stood on your property and occupied it, that part of the property that they occupied, they've really just taken possession of it.

[Jeff Guo]

What you're saying is if you can't cut down the tree, then is it still your tree? Does it just become the government's tree?

[Chance Weldon]

Yeah, that's the theory. And they're just basically forcing you into this mandatory physical occupation of your property.

[Jeff Guo]

It's like the government should pay you tree rent.

[Chance Weldon]

Yes, that was the argument. If they care so much about the tree, then they should have to pay for the use of the property.

[Jeff Guo]

From Chance's perspective, the Township of Canton is taking advantage of property owners by requiring them to keep these trees for the benefit of the community. And that should be unconstitutional.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

The township was like, no, this isn't about trying to force property owners to provide a benefit for free. It's because when you take down a tree, that makes flooding worse. It makes neighborhoods hotter. It harms the community.

[Jeff Guo]

Now, the 6th Circuit did not quite buy Chance's argument that this was an unconstitutional occupation of their property. But Chance also had this clever backup argument. He was like, okay, if the problem here is that when someone cuts down a tree, that hurts the rest of the community, fine. But not all trees are the same. And this tree ordinance in Canton didn't take into account whether it was a big tree that was getting chopped down that provided a lot of shade for people or a tree in the middle of nowhere that didn't benefit that many people in the community.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

And the Supreme Court has said that permit requirements have to be proportional to the harm the permit is trying to prevent. Unreasonable permit fees can be an unconstitutional taking. So Chance was like, whatever fee the township wanted to charge for removing a tree has to be related to that specific tree. And in this case, the township's one size fits all policy valued his client's trees was too much, too high. So basically, the half a million dollars total that the township was asking for, too much.

[Jeff Guo]

In the fall of 2021, the court comes out with their decision, and Chance wins on this narrower argument. The court says that the way Canton is doing its tree permits is unconstitutional, which means that the township needs to fix it. And Chance's clients, in the end, they don't have to pay the township anything.

[Chance Weldon]

It's like, oh, man, you know, not only does this solve the problem for my client, but it's going to open the door to, you know, expand property rights and protect property rights and attack a lot more of these permitting regimes.

[Jeff Guo]

This is one of the most high profile wins in a property rights case in a while. And Chance is excited because permit laws are one of the main ways that towns and cities restrict people's property rights. He thinks that this decision will make it easier to go after cities that charge too much for permits, maybe stop them from making too many unnecessary demands.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

For Anne Marie, the supervisor of Canton, the court's decision was a big blow.

[Jeff Guo]

Did it surprise you that the township lost?

[Sarah Bond]

Yeah.

[Ann Marie Graham Hudak]

Yeah. I didn't understand it.

[Jeff Guo]

Annre says the township board debated whether they should appeal this case all the way to the Supreme Court, but they decided that they had already spent too much money on these lawsuits. So they went back to the drawing board, and last June, they came up with a new tree law.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

Now the developer is allowed to hire an arborist to determine the dollar value of the ecological benefits a tree provides, and that's the fee the developers can pay instead of a fee that's been determined by the city if they want to cut that tree down.

[Jeff Guo]

What happened in Canton, Michigan, has set off some alarm bells among towns and urban planners. Who are especially worried about the bigger picture of environmental rental permits and who should bear the cost of, you know, protecting and preserving the environment. But a case like this doesn't change the world overnight. And in the meantime, there are a lot of cities like Portland, Oregon, where even regular homeowners might not be allowed to cut a tree down.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

After the break, Sarah Bond and her family have to make a decision about what they are going to do about the giant tree looming over their house and what the city of Portland has

[Sarah Bond]

to say about it.

[Commercial Announcer]

This message comes from Schwab with the new Schwab Teen Investor account, teens can gain hands on investing experience. It's co owned by you and your teen, so you can monitor the account while your teen learns how to invest and manage money. Learn [e-mail] this message comes from Whole

[Commercial Announcer 2]

Foods Market Save on seasonal favorites at Whole Foods Market. Start in the vibrant produce department stocked with organic fruits and veggies. Then head to prepared foods for easy grab and go lunches and dinners. There are so many ways to save. Those yellow sale signs are just about everywhere. Plus prime members can find extra in store deals every Tuesday and Friday. And the low priced $3.65 by Whole Foods Market brand never sacrifices on quality. Save today and every day at Whole Foods Market. This message comes from Dell Technologies. Interruptions will always come up at work, but with the Dell Pro laptop powered by Intel Core Ultra with vpro, built with optimized battery and built in intelligence, your tech won't slow you down. Dell.com Dell Pro at first, Sarah Bond

[Jeff Guo]

tries to convince herself that the giant tree leaning over her house is not as scary as it seems. She and her husband Joel would spend hours walking around the backyard, squinting at it, trying to picture what would happen if this tree fell.

[Sarah Bond]

We were like, well, maybe it would just like miss the house. And then we would go to like another angle. Like, no, that's there's no way it's falling like directly on top of the house.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

They think about going rogue and just cutting down the tree anyway. But if the city finds out, they could be fined more than $10,000.

[Jeff Guo]

So for almost three years, Sarah and Joel and their family try their best to settle in. They get a dog and two beautiful Siamese cats, but the tree is always looming. It is keeping them up at night.

[Sarah Bond]

Anytime we had wind, any heavy winds, we were like, we couldn't sleep. You'd hear like branches breaking or sticks cracking or whatever and we'd like shoot up out of bed.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

Winter is the worst season for them, Portland can get these big ice storms. One Saturday morning in January, Sarah's daughter JoJo has a friend over and there is a particularly bad storm. The wind gets up to 40 to 50 miles an hour. The power goes out and the cats go into hiding. Two girls head upstairs to look for the cats.

[Jeff Guo]

Sarah is looking out the backyard window when all of a sudden what she has been fearing starts to happen.

[Sarah Bond]

I do remember the sound of wood splitting, like, of it cracking as it was falling. Yeah, it's like so loud.

[Jeff Guo]

Sarah's memory of that day is a series of snapshots. One moment the tree is swaying in the wind. The next moment the tree is crashing down onto their house, right on top of where the girls had gone looking for the cats.

[Sarah Bond]

I felt like I was underwater because I was yelling and I was saying, like, where is JoJo? But I don't even remember like having a voice.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

Sarah somehow reaches the top of the stairs. She sees that the roof has caved in. She is desperate to find her daughter. She sees JoJo's friend, who is fine, but JoJo is still nowhere to be found.

[Sarah Bond]

And I was just saying, where is jojo? Where is jojo?

[Amanda Aronczyk]

Jojo's friend is white as a sheet. She looks like she's in shock.

[Sarah Bond]

And she didn't, she didn't even answer me with like words. She just like pointed in the bedroom.

[Jeff Guo]

Sarah turns to the bedroom where she sees that the tree has cut through like an axe. It's landed directly on the closet, the closet where the cats like to hide. It's a pile of splintered wood. Now Sarah is imagining the worst. But then she hears her husband Joel call out from the other side of the room.

[Sarah Bond]

And my husband says, I got her. And his voice is like very like he was in panic.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

JoJo is there in his arms.

[Sarah Bond]

I was like, is she okay? Is she okay?

[Jeff Guo]

Joel is frantically looking her over.

[Sarah Bond]

She was covered in dust and there were like wood chips.

[Jeff Guo]

Sarah says she had never been so scared and so relieved JoJo was okay.

[Sarah Bond]

She was like, I was fine. My hair is my hair okay.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

Everyone rushes out of the house. And as they're getting into the car, Sarah takes one last look at the tree that has collapsed on her house.

[Sarah Bond]

And the first thought that came into my head was, we all lived and we never have to worry about that frickin tree again.

[Jeff Guo]

Okay? Well, not quite. You see, one of the cats, Binks, is missing. Also, when Sarah calls the city to tell them, hey, this tree that I told you was gonna fall on my house, Literally just fell on my house. They respond with something that takes her by surprise.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

The city says, you are going to need to pay for a retroactive permit for the tree that fell, you know, to compensate the community for the loss of the benefits of the tree, the lost shade, the lost canopy. So Sarah and Joel would either have to plant replacement trees or pay into the city's tree fund. For a tree as big as the one that fell on their house, the fee could be at least $700.

[Jeff Guo]

This is the moment that sends Sarah over the edge. She and her family are now suing the city of Portland not to challenge the constitutionality of its tree law, but just to get compensated for everything that they went through. Now, we did reach out to the city, and they declined to comment because the lawsuit is still going on. But the city has recently lowered some of its tree permit fees, and it's now in the process of rewriting its tree protection laws.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

It's been over two years since the tree fell on Sarah and Joel's house. They have now rebuilt it and actually just moved back in in March.

[Jeff Guo]

Sarah still has a hard time getting over what happened. She says it would be one thing if all of this had just been a freak accident, but she had asked the city to remove this tree, and they'd said no. She still can't get over how the city made her feel like she didn't even own the house that she supposedly owned.

[Sarah Bond]

I felt very angry and annoyed, like we were sold this idea of homeownership, and we actually, like, didn't have control over it as much as I assumed we would. Yeah, you know, it's not like I wanted to put a giant pool in our backyard. And, you know, they wouldn't allow it. This. It was a safety reason. And so that was, like, the part that was extra demoralizing.

[Jeff Guo]

The story of Sarah Bond versus the tree and the story of Canton, Michigan. These are two stories about, on one hand, the right to do what you want with your own property, versus, on the other hand, your obligations to your community, to your neighborhood. It's the latest in this tug of war between property rights and zoning laws. For a long time, zoning laws were winning. But with the backlash over these tree laws, maybe property rights are gaining back some ground.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

And Sarah says, look, she loves trees. She loves living in a neighborhood filled with trees. She just wished that the city had listened to her when she said that their tree was unsafe.

[Jeff Guo]

Now, there is one piece of good news. Their cat, Binks, who went missing during the storm. They didn't give up on him. They left a can of food for him in the basement and about a week after the tree fell they found him shivering, a little dusty, but mostly okay. Hey, so we have got a special event for our engine NPR supporters. If you couldn't make one of our book tour events back in April, you're in luck. We are doing one more and this time it is a live virtual event. It's on Thursday, June 25th at 3pm Eastern. I'll be there. The main author of our book, Alex Mayasi, will be there and we will have some special guests. If you've already joined npr, we'll tell you how to register for the event in an upcoming bonus episode. If you haven't joined yet, make sure you you're signed up by June 24th. To get the invite, just go to plus.npr.org Again, that's plus.npr.org Signing up is a great way to support the show, to support npr, and to support independent non profit journalism. See you there.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

This episode of Planet Money was produced by James Sneed and Emma Peaslee. It was edited by Jess Jiang, Fact Checked by Vito Emanuel and engineered by Robert Rodriguez and Sina Lofredo. Alex Goldmark is our executive producer.

[Jeff Guo]

A special thanks to Professor Richard K. Norton at the University of Michigan and also to Sophie Peel. She's a reporter at the Willamette Week and she's been covering the Tree law fight in Portland extensively over the past couple years. I'm Jeff Guo.

[Amanda Aronczyk]

And I'm Amanda Aronczyk. This is npr. Thanks for listening.

[Jeff Guo]

Foreign

[Commercial Announcer]

this message comes from Capital One. Capital One offers checking accounts with no fees or minimums. What's in your wallet terms apply. See capital1.com bankguy for details. Capital1 NA Member FDIC this message comes from Capella University.

[Commercial Announcer 2]

That spark you feel? That's your drive. For more Capella University's flexpath Learning format lets you earn your degree at your pace without putting life on pause. Learn [e-mail] this message comes from Mint Mobile. If you're tired of spending hundreds on big wireless bills, bogus fees and free perks, Mint Mobile is for you. Shop [e-mail] Switch taxes and fees extra. See Mint Mobile for details.