Planet Money: What "Made in China" Actually Means

Planet Money, hosted by NPR, delves into the intricate world of economics, unraveling complex topics to help listeners understand the forces shaping their lives. In the episode titled "What 'Made in China' Actually Means," released on May 7, 2025, the podcast explores the nuances of country of origin labeling, its implications on international trade, and the challenges businesses face amidst evolving tariff policies.

1. Introduction to Maureen Thorson

The episode introduces Maureen Thorson, a unique blend of a poet and one of America's top international trade lawyers. Maureen's dual expertise allows her to approach trade law with a philosophical perspective, questioning the very essence of products and their origins.

“As a poet, Maureen often finds herself puzzling over, you know, the fundamental nature of things like what makes a chair a chair or a hat a hat, what makes this this and that that.” (01:17)

2. The Significance of Country of Origin

At the heart of the discussion is the country of origin—a label that has profound implications for businesses, especially in the context of tariffs. Following President Donald Trump's executive order in 2025 to impose hefty tariffs on Chinese products, the determination of a product's origin became crucial for businesses to avoid substantial financial penalties.

“Whether something is a product of Canada or Germany or China could soon mean the difference between no tariffs or 20% tariffs or more than 145% tariffs.” (03:12)

3. Understanding U.S. Country of Origin Rules

The United States employs a distinct set of rules to determine a product’s country of origin, differing significantly from other nations.

• American Products ("Made in USA"): To label a product as "Made in USA," it must be entirely American in terms of parts, ingredients, and labor. Exceptions exist for certain categories like clothing and specific meats.

  “Made in USA means this is pretty much fully USA, down to the soles of its little American shoes. And it doesn't have almost any foreign material in it.” (06:27)

• Imported Products ("Product of [Country]"): Any product imported into the U.S. must display its country of origin, a requirement dating back to an 1890 law aimed at informing consumers.

  “You can think of country of origin as kind of like a product's citizenship.” (07:57)

4. The Substantial Transformation Test

Central to U.S. regulations is the Substantial Transformation Test, which determines a product's origin based on where it underwent a significant change.

“A substantial transformation is processing from which the article emerges with a new name, use or character.” (11:21)

Historical Applications:

• 1908 Corks Case: The Supreme Court ruled that merely cleaning and stamping corks did not change their origin from Spain to the U.S. because there was no substantial transformation.

  “They started out as corks, and they were still corks here in the US.” (13:28)

• 1940s Hairbrushes Case: Adding bristles to Japanese wooden handles in the U.S. was deemed a substantial transformation, making the final product "American."

  “The judge said there is a substantial transformation here. What you now have is an American hairbrush.” (15:19)

• 1980s Uniroyal Boat Shoes Case: Despite assembling Indonesian uppers with American rubber soles, the court ruled the shoes remained Indonesian products because the essence of the shoe—the leather uppers—originated from Indonesia.

  “According to the judge, the essence of the shoe was not substantially transformed and it remained a product of whatever country that upper came from.” (18:29)

5. Modern Challenges: The Sticky Note Dilemma

In 2020, Staples faced a perplexing issue determining the origin of their sticky notes. Despite multiple countries involved in the production process—Japan or Indonesia for paper, Taiwan for glue, and China for assembly—U.S. Customs classified the sticky notes based solely on the paper's origin.

“When you get down to it, we think that the essence of a sticky note is really the paper.” (21:44)

This ruling ignited debates about the Substantial Transformation Test's applicability to modern, complex supply chains, highlighting its limitations in addressing products with multifaceted origins.

6. The Impact of Trump's Tariffs

Trump's administration intensified the focus on country of origin, especially concerning Chinese products. Businesses scrambled to redefine their manufacturing processes to mitigate tariff obligations. Maureen Thorson became a critical advisor for companies navigating these turbulent changes.

“The substantial transformation test is still, by and large, the law of the land in the U.S. for one, this is just the way we've always done it.” (25:07)

7. Future Directions and Free Trade Agreements

The podcast touches upon how individual free trade agreements require more precise origin determinations compared to the broad Substantial Transformation Test. These agreements often mandate specific rules based on labor contributions, value of parts, or key manufacturing processes.

“Depending on the product, the Rules might have to do with how much labor came from a country, or the value of the parts that came from a country, or even whether a key chemical reaction happened in a given country.” (24:43)

8. Conclusion: Navigating a Complex Landscape

As global manufacturing becomes increasingly intricate, the traditional methods of determining product origins face significant challenges. Companies rely heavily on legal experts like Maureen Thorson to interpret and navigate these complexities, ensuring compliance and financial viability in an ever-evolving trade environment.

“Lawyers who can, you know, wax poetic about the real, deep down essences of things. This episode of Planet Money was produced by James Sneed...” (27:18)

Key Takeaways

• Country of Origin Matters: Especially in contexts with significant tariffs, understanding where a product is deemed to originate is crucial for businesses.

• Substantial Transformation Test: This U.S. standard focuses on the last substantial change in a product's name, use, or character to determine its origin.

• Complex Supply Chains: Modern manufacturing, involving multiple countries and stages, complicates origin determination, often leading to legal ambiguities.

• Evolving Legal Landscape: Free trade agreements and changing administration policies continue to shape how countries enforce origin-based regulations.

Notable Quotes

• “A substantial transformation is processing from which the article emerges with a new name, use or character.” – Maureen Thorson (11:21)

• “When you get down to it, we think that the essence of a sticky note is really the paper.” – Customs Official (21:44)

• “What makes a Chinese product Chinese and when does it stop being Chinese?” – Maureen Thorson (03:12)

Conclusion

This episode of Planet Money illuminates the often-overlooked complexities behind a simple label like "Made in China." Through expert insights and historical contexts, listeners gain a deeper understanding of international trade laws, the intricacies of supply chains, and the profound impact of globalization on everyday products.

For more insightful episodes and in-depth economic analyses, consider subscribing to Planet Money+.