WavePod Logo

wavePod

← Back to Pod Save America
Podcast cover

AOC Loses to the Gerontocracy

Pod Save America

Published: Wed Dec 18 2024

House Democrats choose not to elevate Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, arguably the party's most compelling messenger, to Ranking Member on the House Oversight Committee—instead selecting 74-year-old Gerry Connolly, a committee lifer with no national reach. Jon and Dan discuss the magnitude of this missed opportunity, House Republicans laying the groundwork for an FBI investigation of Liz Cheney, whether Democrats should play ball on government funding, and a new effort to clamp down on progressive fundraising spam. Then, longtime immigration advocate Cecilia Muñoz stops by to talk with Jon about how Democrats found themselves out of the mainstream on the issue, and how we can win back voters' trust without compromising our values.

Summary

Pod Save America: "AOC Loses to the Gerontocracy" – Detailed Summary

Release Date: December 18, 2024
Hosts: Jon Favreau, Dan Pfeiffer
Guest: Cecilia Munoz

Overview

In this episode of Pod Save America, hosts Jon Favreau and Dan Pfeiffer delve into recent political developments affecting the Democratic Party, particularly focusing on Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (AOC) losing her bid for the top Democratic position on the House Oversight Committee to seasoned Representative Gerry Connolly. The discussion also explores the broader implications of this decision on the party's communication strategy and effectiveness. Additionally, they highlight positive strides within the party, such as efforts to reform Democratic fundraising practices. The episode culminates with an insightful interview with Cecilia Munoz, a veteran immigration advocate, who analyzes why Democrats have struggled with the immigration issue and offers strategies for building a more effective reform agenda.

Republicans Targeting Liz Cheney [05:20]

Jon Favreau opens the discussion by addressing the latest House Republican report, which alleges that former Representative Liz Cheney colluded with Cassidy Hutchinson, a star witness, without Hutchinson's attorney's knowledge. The report suggests potential federal witness tampering and calls for an FBI investigation into Cheney.

Notable Quote:

  • "Cheney should be investigated for potential criminal witness tampering by the FBI and might have broken numerous federal laws." ([04:58])

Favreau and Pfeiffer dismiss the allegations as baseless, emphasizing that Cheney acted in her capacity as a member of Congress and that Hutchinson approached her independently. They criticize the Republican strategy of targeting Cheney singularly to avoid broader uproar, suggesting it reflects an authoritarian approach to suppress dissent within the party.

Dan Pfeiffer:
"This is exactly how it happens. You get a pretext for an investigation run by a bunch of political cronies who will do what the authoritarian wants." ([05:20])

House Democrats Appoint Gerry Connolly Over AOC [17:59]

The hosts transition to a significant internal Democratic decision: the House Democrats voted 131 to 84 to appoint 74-year-old Gerry Connolly as the top Democrat on the Oversight Committee instead of 35-year-old AOC. Connolly's appointment replaces Jamie Raskin in this influential role.

Notable Quotes:

  • "Picking seniority over the ability to deliver a message is exactly how we've gotten this mess to begin with." ([18:41]) – Dan Pfeiffer
  • "It is insane. You think the NRCC is going to just forget she's a member of Congress and not run ads against her?" ([21:10]) – Dan Pfeiffer

Pfeiffer and Favreau critique the decision, arguing that prioritizing seniority over communicative prowess undermines the party's ability to connect with voters. They highlight AOC's effectiveness as a modern communicator who can garner significant attention, which is crucial in today's media landscape.

Jon Favreau:
"What really bothers me about it, right, is that it just gets to your point. It reveals a mindset among Democrats that they are missing that attention is the only thing that matters right now." ([23:46])

Democratic Strategy and Messaging [26:29]

The hosts discuss the broader implications of sidelining effective communicators like AOC. They argue that the Democratic Party's failure to prioritize attention and clear messaging contributes to its struggles in elections. Favreau emphasizes the necessity of creative and authentic communication to engage voters effectively.

Dan Pfeiffer:
"AOC can get attention. She has proven that when she has attention, she can deliver a more compelling message than most people in the party." ([23:44])

Favreau adds that without leveraging figures who can attract and maintain public interest, the party's messages risk being drowned out in a crowded media environment.

Government Funding and Legislative Leverage [32:26]

Favreau and Pfeiffer analyze the ongoing struggle within the Republican-controlled House to pass a government funding bill. With Speaker Mike Johnson holding a narrow majority, Republicans face challenges in securing unanimous support for legislation. This dynamic presents an opportunity for Democrats to extract concessions or influence legislative outcomes despite being outnumbered.

Notable Quote:

  • "We have to do everything we can with a limited power. We have to fight Trump, vote against his nominees, use legislative tactics that we have to try to expose them to longer debates or a longer process." ([35:08]) – Dan Pfeiffer

They debate whether Democrats should leverage their limited power to negotiate better terms on critical issues like tax reforms and healthcare, even if it means allowing some Republican initiatives to pass in exchange for concessions.

Good News: Democratic Fundraising Reforms [40:30]

Shifting to a more positive note, Favreau and Pfeiffer discuss a significant effort within the Democratic Party to reform fundraising practices through ActBlue. Over 100 Democrats have pushed for changes to reduce spam and deceptive solicitation tactics that alienate potential donors.

Notable Quote:

  • "We should do it. It's so sketchy when you get, like, Barack Obama has spoken, and it's like a quote from Barack Obama, and, like, some of the appeals seem ridiculous." ([43:08]) – Jon Favreau

Pfeiffer commends the initiative, highlighting its importance in restoring trust and improving the effectiveness of Democratic fundraising by eliminating scam packs and enhancing donor experience.

Interview with Cecilia Munoz: Immigration Advocacy [48:40]

Background and Concerns [49:08]

Cecilia Munoz, a distinguished immigration advocate and former White House domestic policy overseer, discusses her journey into immigration advocacy shaped by her personal connections as the daughter and wife of immigrants.

Democrats Losing Ground on Immigration [50:34]

Munoz and co-author Frank Sherry argue in their Atlantic piece that Democrats have shifted too far left on immigration, abandoning comprehensive reform in favor of singular focus on enforcement. This shift has alienated voters who seek balanced solutions addressing both enforcement and pathways to citizenship.

Notable Quote:

  • "I have a lot of praise for the Biden administration... but I think it was pretty clear that he didn't want to talk about this issue until he had to, because it's a world of pain." ([53:12]) – Cecilia Munoz

Missed Opportunities and Strategic Failures [53:24]

Munoz criticizes the Democratic leadership for lacking a cohesive narrative and theory of the case on immigration, which hampers their ability to effectively communicate solutions to the public. She emphasizes the necessity of balancing enforcement with humanitarian pathways to restore public trust and support.

Notable Quote:

  • "We need to have a vision for what needs to happen and be able to persuade the American public that that's the right vision." ([57:23]) – Cecilia Munoz

Preparing for a Potential Trump Term [67:27]

Looking ahead, Munoz warns of exacerbated immigration challenges should Trump return to power. She advocates for Democrats to maintain a strong, clear narrative that emphasizes order and fairness, countering Trump's aggressive deportation tactics without adopting extreme positions.

Notable Quote:

  • "If we do not have a theory of the case for how to address the border situation, I really fear for our ability to take the country back from the autocrats." ([66:27]) – Cecilia Munoz

Concluding Remarks

Favreau and Pfeiffer underscore the critical need for the Democratic Party to revamp its communication strategies and policy frameworks to regain voter trust and effectively counter Republican maneuvers. They highlight the importance of leveraging internal reforms and embracing effective communicators to navigate the challenges ahead.

Dan Pfeiffer:
"Politics is a war for attention. AOC can get attention. She has proven that when she has attention, she can deliver a more compelling message than most people in the party." ([23:44])

Jon Favreau:
"The Democratic Party has still not figured out how important it is to get attention and what is required to get attention." ([26:29])

The episode concludes with anticipation for future discussions on political strategies and the ongoing evolution of the Democratic Party in response to internal and external pressures.

Key Takeaways

  • Internal Democratic Decisions: The appointment of Gerry Connolly over AOC signals a prioritization of seniority over effective communication within the party, potentially weakening its public messaging.

  • Republican Tactics: Republicans' targeting of Liz Cheney exemplifies authoritarian strategies to suppress dissent and maintain control.

  • Fundraising Reforms: Positive internal efforts to reform Democratic fundraising practices through ActBlue aim to reduce voter alienation and enhance donor trust.

  • Immigration Strategy: Democrats need to adopt a balanced, assertive approach to immigration policy that combines enforcement with pathways to citizenship to reclaim voter support.

  • Future Challenges: With Republicans gaining tighter control and potential strategies to hinder Democratic legislative efforts, the party must innovate its communication and policy strategies to remain effective.

Note: This summary excludes advertisements and non-content segments, focusing solely on the substantive discussions and interviews within the episode.

No transcript available.