Pod Save America: "Has Anyone Seen the Democrats?"

Release Date: January 28, 2025

Introduction

In this episode of Pod Save America, hosts Jon Favreau, Jon Lovett, Dan Pfeiffer, and Tommy Vietor delve into the tumultuous first weeks of Donald Trump's presidency. They examine his aggressive moves against the federal government, his foreign policy stances, especially towards Colombia, Mexico, and Canada, and the sweeping executive orders targeting diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) programs. The discussion also touches on the Democratic Party's current state and the ongoing race for the Democratic National Committee (DNC) chair.

Trump’s Foreign Policy and the Colombia Incident

Timestamp: 02:46 - 08:08

The hosts begin by analyzing Trump's confrontation with Colombian President Gustavo Petro over the deportation of migrants. Trump attempted to send military planes carrying deported migrants to Colombia, which Petro resisted, demanding dignified treatment for the migrants. In retaliation, Trump imposed a 25% tariff on Colombian imports, threatening to increase it to 50% within a week. Petro countered with similar threats against U.S. goods.

• Jon Lovett (04:39): "It's like classic Trump, right? He's the arsonist and the firefighter."
• Tommy Vietor (05:35): "Petro screwed up here. He gave Trump a win. He overreacted."

The hosts critique Trump's strategy as bullying smaller nations to assert dominance, risking long-term alliances and economic repercussions. They highlight the inefficacy and self-serving nature of imposing tariffs without clear policy objectives.

• Jon Favreau (07:07): "The White House, they must have been like, are you fucking kidding me? This is awesome."

Immigration Policy and Executive Orders

Timestamp: 58:18 - 87:18

Tommy Vietor hosts Dara Lind, a senior fellow at the American Immigration Council, to discuss Trump's aggressive immigration policies. Key points include:

1. Ramp-Up of Interior Enforcement: Tightening deportation policies, especially against individuals previously protected under Biden's administration.

   • Dan Pfeiffer (58:30): "Trump has changed regulations so that anyone who is apprehended... could be deported without a court hearing."

2. Logistical Challenges: Ombudsman Dan discusses the astronomical costs ($88 billion annually to deport 1 million people) and the logistical hurdles in executing mass deportations.

   • Dan Pfeiffer (60:27): "There are four major steps... arresting, detaining, court proceedings, and deportation."

3. Executive Orders Targeting DEI: Trump signs multiple executive orders aimed at dismantling DEI programs across federal agencies and private contractors, leading to confusion and resistance within organizations.

   • Jon Lovett (21:11): "They're empowering government agencies... to go after private companies that may have DEI policies."

4. Impact on Federal Agencies: Orders to pause critical research at the National Institutes of Health (NIH) and cease collaboration with the World Health Organization (WHO) create uncertainty and hinder public health responses.

   • Dan Pfeiffer (18:00): "There was a memorandum trying to clear things up... but there's confusion among researchers."

5. Political Ramifications: The aggressive stance on immigration and DEI fosters fear and instability within federal institutions, potentially leading to long-term detrimental effects on governance and societal equity.

   • Tommy Vietor (25:03): "These people... just want to destroy these institutions."

Impact of DEI Executive Orders

Timestamp: 21:04 - 29:57

The discussion focuses on Trump's executive orders aimed at eliminating DEI programs, which were designed to promote diversity and prevent discrimination in the workplace. The hosts argue that these orders not only hinder progress toward equitable workplaces but also create an environment of fear and uncertainty for private companies and federal contractors.

• Jon Lovett (21:11): "They're empowering government agencies to... go after private companies that may have DEI policies."
• Tommy Vietor (25:03): "Power to take down private businesses that have a DEI program."

The elimination of DEI programs has tangible negative effects, such as the removal of educational content about the Tuskegee Airmen and other underrepresented groups in military training, undermining historical awareness and inclusivity.

• Jon Lovett (25:55): "Now they're not allowed to teach about the Tuskegee Airmen."

Democratic Party's Current Challenges and DNC Chair Race

Timestamp: 34:13 - 54:37

The hosts shift focus to the Democratic Party's apparent lack of leadership and strategic direction in the face of Trump's maneuvers. A notable segment features a viral clip of sports commentator Stephen A. Smith critiquing the Democrats for not effectively responding to Trump's actions, arguing that the party lacks a clear voice and impactful response.

• Stephen A. Smith (34:57): "When you try to do something about it, he's gonna say, look at them now. They’re concerned about these issues."

Jon Favreau and Tommy Vietor express frustration over the Democrats' passive approach, emphasizing the need for proactive and emotionally resonant responses rather than mere resolutions and strategic planning.

• Jon Favreau (43:43): "Just fucking do it."
• Tommy Vietor (49:05): "We just want somebody who sees this happening and is like, fuck, I got to get out there."

The conversation then moves to the upcoming DNC chair race, with the hosts endorsing Ben Wickler for his effective strategies in Wisconsin, a state pivotal in swing elections. They highlight his relentless organizational efforts and inclusive politics as key strengths.

• Jon Lovett (53:17): "If we were voting members of the DNC, he would get our vote."
• Tommy Vietor (54:13): "Ben has no off switch. He’s always organizing, always building."

Guest Segment: Dara Lind on Immigration Policy

Timestamp: 57:52 - 87:18

Tommy Vietor engages in an in-depth conversation with Dara Lind from the American Immigration Council, exploring the complexities of Trump's immigration policies.

1. Aggressive Enforcement Measures:

   • Trump administration's efforts to strip protections from individuals under various parole programs.
   • Utilization of multiple agencies (DEA, ATF) and military assets to enhance deportation capabilities.

2. Logistical Constraints:

   • Deporting large numbers of individuals is financially and logistically challenging.

   • Reliance on countries like Mexico to accept deportees is crucial but precarious.

   • Dan Pfeiffer (58:30): "The more options they have, the easier it’s going to be for them to enforce deportations."

3. Legal Challenges:

   • Efforts to end birthright citizenship faced immediate legal pushback.

   • Supreme Court's historical stance on citizenship rights is likely to undermine Trump's EO.

   • Dan Pfeiffer (68:52): "There is a century-old Supreme Court precedent that the child is still a citizen regardless of parents' status."

4. Legislative Response:

   • Introduction of the Lake and Riley Act aims to expand immigration enforcement but raises due process concerns.

   • The act's potential to allow states to sue the federal government for not deporting specific individuals introduces unprecedented legal battles.

   • Dan Pfeiffer (71:39): "The Lake and Riley Act requires the federal government to expeditiously take custody of individuals charged with certain crimes."

5. Political Implications:

   • Increased immigration enforcement siphons resources away from other critical areas.

   • Potential for international diplomatic tensions, especially with countries unwilling to accept deportees.

   • Tommy Vietor (66:01): "The Trump administration is trying to use tariffs as leverage, but this could push allies toward China."

Dara Lind emphasizes the humanitarian and ethical crises that could arise from Trump's policies, highlighting the severe consequences of deporting individuals to war-torn regions like Sudan.

• Tommy Vietor (79:51): "The idea that you would just put someone on a plane back to Khartoum right now is just like unthinkable from a moral level."

Conclusion and Final Thoughts

Timestamp: 87:18 - End

The episode wraps up with the hosts reiterating the dire state of federal institutions under Trump's administration and the Democratic Party's struggle to effectively counter his policies. They call for proactive and emotionally driven leadership within the Democratic ranks to restore credibility and advocate for the American people's interests.

• Jon Favreau (45:26): "Democrats aren't saying what we want Trump to do or what we would do."

The hosts encourage listeners to support leaders like Ben Wickler who demonstrate unwavering commitment and effective strategies to combat the current political climate.

Notable Quotes

• Jon Favreau (07:07): "The White House, they must have been like, are you fucking kidding me? This is awesome."
• Tommy Vietor (25:03): "These people... just want to destroy these institutions."
• Dan Pfeiffer (60:27): "There are four major steps... arresting, detaining, court proceedings, and deportation."
• Stephen A. Smith (34:57): "What promises did you keep? Now you might know the answer to that."
• Tommy Vietor (43:43): "Just fucking do it."
• Dan Pfeiffer (68:52): "Century-old Supreme Court precedent ensures child citizenship regardless of parents."

Key Takeaways

1. Trump's Aggressive Policies: The administration's moves, particularly against Colombia and in immigration, are viewed as bullying tactics that undermine long-term alliances and federal institutions.

2. Impact on DEI Programs: Executive orders targeting DEI initiatives disrupt efforts toward workplace equity and create an atmosphere of fear and uncertainty.

3. Democratic Struggles: The Democratic Party is criticized for lacking a clear and impactful response to Trump's actions, highlighting the need for proactive leadership.

4. Immigration Challenges: Trump's policies present significant logistical, legal, and ethical challenges, with potential humanitarian crises and strained international relations.

5. Call for Leadership: Emphasizing the importance of leaders like Ben Wickler, the episode underscores the need for relentless and inclusive strategies within the Democratic Party to effectively counter the current political landscape.

For more detailed discussions and exclusive content, consider subscribing to Friends of the Pod at crooked.com/friends or on Apple Podcasts.