Pod Save America: Stephen Colbert, South Park, and Donald Trump’s War Against the Media
Release Date: July 27, 2025
Host/Author: Crooked Media
Guests: Brian Stelter, Chief Media Analyst at CNN Worldwide

Introduction

In this episode of Pod Save America, hosts delve deep into the tumultuous relationship between Donald Trump and the American media. The discussion centers around Trump's escalating lawsuits against major news outlets, the sudden cancellation of Stephen Colbert's Late Show, the potential influence of Bari Weiss joining CBS, and the broader implications for political media. Joined by media expert Brian Stelter, the conversation provides an insightful analysis of the current media landscape and its challenges.

Trump’s Legal Battles with the Media

Tommy Vietor opens the discussion by highlighting the surge in lawsuits initiated by Donald Trump against prominent media entities. Over recent months, Trump has filed suits against CBS, ABC, and most notably, a $10 billion lawsuit against the Wall Street Journal, News Corp., and Rupert Murdoch.

Notable Quote:

• Tommy Vietor [01:00]: "Donald Trump has initiated lawsuits against CBS and ABC over unfavorable reporting, leading to significant payouts and reputational damage for these networks."

Brian Stelter agrees, emphasizing the strategic nature of these lawsuits as a means to punish media outlets that Trump perceives as adversaries.

Notable Quote:

• Brian Stelter [18:33]: "Trump has been using legal battles as leverage to intimidate and control media narratives, creating a chilling effect on investigative journalism."

Cancellation of Stephen Colbert’s Late Show

The sudden cancellation of Stephen Colbert's Late Show by CBS becomes a focal point of the discussion. Despite CBS claiming financial reasons, the timing suggests possible political motivations linked to the pending merger with Skydance Media and appeasing Trump.

Notable Quotes:

• Tommy Vietor [05:42]: "CBS’s decision to cancel Stephen Colbert’s show right after his criticism of the network raises questions about political motivations."
• Brian Stelter [05:42]: "While the show was indeed unprofitable, the timing amidst the Trump merger pressure cannot be ignored."

Discussion Points:

• Declining profitability of late-night shows.
• Possible influence of Trump’s dissatisfaction on CBS’s decision.
• The broader cultural impact of losing iconic late-night programs.

Potential Hiring of Bari Weiss at CBS

Speculation about Bari Weiss, former New York Times journalist and founder of the Free Press, potentially joining CBS has stirred debate. Weiss is known for her stance against cancel culture and her center-right editorial approach.

Notable Quotes:

• Tommy Vietor [09:06]: "Bari Weiss's potential role at CBS could signal a shift towards a more centrist or right-leaning editorial direction."
• Brian Stelter [09:36]: "Hiring Weiss could be Paramount’s way of injecting new energy into CBS News, aligning with leadership’s political leanings."

Discussion Points:

• How Weiss’s editorial philosophy might influence CBS’s news coverage.
• The potential impact on CBS’s journalistic independence.
• The intersection of media consolidation and political influence.

The Dominance of Fox News

The conversation shifts to the enduring dominance of Fox News, contrasting it with other networks struggling to capture significant audiences. Fox's unique blend of news and opinion has cemented its position as the go-to source for conservative viewers.

Notable Quotes:

• Brian Stelter [24:52]: "Fox News operates as a hybrid of news and opinion, making it more of an entertainment product, which has contributed to its sustained popularity."
• Tommy Vietor [26:46]: "Despite its lack of factual reliability, Fox News remains highly entertaining and financially successful."

Discussion Points:

• The differing business models between Fox News and other networks.
• Fox’s ability to cater to a specific demographic, ensuring consistent ratings and profits.
• The challenges faced by left-leaning networks like MSNBC in replicating Fox’s success.

South Park’s Provocative Episode and CBS Merger

An analysis of a controversial South Park episode depicting Trump highlights the tensions between creative freedom and corporate interests. Paramount's swift merger approval with Skydance Media before the episode's release suggests strategic maneuvering to avoid PR fallout.

Notable Quotes:

• Tommy Vietor [27:38]: "South Park’s episode critical of Trump came right before Paramount’s merger approval, indicating a possible attempt to minimize backlash."
• Brian Stelter [28:55]: "The timing of South Park’s delayed premiere aligns with the merger review, showcasing the intricate dance between content creation and corporate strategy."

Discussion Points:

• The balance between creative expression and corporate political pressures.
• The significance of South Park’s satirical take on Trump within the broader media narrative.
• Paramount’s investment in South Park despite its provocative content.

White House Press Pool Changes

The episode also examines how the Trump administration has restructured the White House press pool, limiting access for certain major news outlets like the Associated Press and the Wall Street Journal. This move is perceived as an attempt to control the narrative and suppress unfavorable reporting.

Notable Quotes:

• Tommy Vietor [34:39]: "The White House takeover of the press pool restricts major outlets, potentially silencing critical voices."
• Brian Stelter [35:34]: "Trump’s exclusion of the Wall Street Journal from press events exemplifies his strategy to punish dissenting media."

Discussion Points:

• The implications of the White House controlling press access.
• Potential long-term effects on journalistic independence and accountability.
• The deterioration of traditional press relations and the rise of propaganda.

Impact on Investigative Journalism

Brian Stelter addresses concerns about the chilling effect these legal battles and press pool restrictions may have on investigative journalism. While some outlets continue fearless reporting, others may self-censor to avoid repercussions.

Notable Quotes:

• Brian Stelter [21:15]: "Despite challenges, some media outlets persist in delivering rigorous investigative work, maintaining a semblance of journalistic integrity."
• Tommy Vietor [37:46]: "If press events become platforms for Trump allies rather than genuine journalists, the quality and accountability of reporting will suffer."

Discussion Points:

• The resilience of investigative journalism amid political pressures.
• The potential decline in aggressive reporting on Trump’s administration.
• Strategies newsrooms might adopt to navigate these hostile environments.

Unionization and Media Coverage

A brief exploration of media unionization reveals its impact on how labor issues and COVID-related topics are covered. Increased union efforts have led to more nuanced and extensive coverage of labor movements.

Notable Quotes:

• Tommy Vietor [41:11]: "Unionization efforts have enriched media coverage, providing deeper insights into labor dynamics and COVID-related challenges."
• Brian Stelter [41:25]: "There’s a noticeable increase in detailed and balanced reporting on labor issues, thanks to the push from unionized journalists."

The Rise of AI in Media

The episode concludes with a discussion on the integration of AI in media, particularly in local news and newsletters. Hosts express concerns about AI replacing human jobs and the authenticity of AI-generated content.

Notable Quotes:

• Tommy Vietor [51:11]: "AI is encroaching on media jobs, raising questions about the future of authentic journalism."
• Brian Stelter [52:16]: "AI-generated content undermines trust in media, flooding platforms with unreliable information and complicating discernment of truth."

Discussion Points:

• The potential for AI to disrupt traditional media roles.
• The importance of human-driven journalism in maintaining credibility.
• Strategies to mitigate the negative impacts of AI on news authenticity.

Conclusion

Tommy Vietor and Brian Stelter offer a sobering analysis of the current state of American media. From Trump’s aggressive legal tactics to the evolving dynamics of media conglomerates, the episode underscores the fragility of journalistic integrity in the face of political and technological challenges. The hosts emphasize the importance of supporting reliable, human-driven journalism to preserve the democratic fabric of society.

Final Thoughts

For those seeking to stay informed amidst the chaos, Pod Save America serves as a crucial resource, dissecting complex media issues with clarity and depth. By engaging with knowledgeable guests like Brian Stelter, the podcast provides listeners with the tools to navigate and understand the shifting landscape of American politics and media.

Subscribe to Friends of the Pod!
Your subscription supports Crooked Media and grants access to ad-free episodes, exclusive content, and a vibrant Discord community. Learn more and subscribe at crooked.com/friends or on Apple Podcasts.