
In this Pod Save The World Special, Tommy and Ben discuss Donald Trump and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky’s disastrous meeting at the White House that erupted in a yelling match and resulted in Zelensky being told to leave. They dig into JD Vance’s role as instigator, the revealed motivations for attacking Zelensky in front of the press, and what Zelensky’s options are for pursuing peace from here.
Loading summary
Tommy Vitor
Pod Save the World is brought to you by Sundaze. Sundaze is a fresh dog food made from a short list of human grade ingredients. Sundaze was co founded by Dr. Tory Waxman, a practicing veterinarian who tests and formulates every version of each recipe. Sundaze contains 90% meat, 10% superfoods and 0% synthetic nutrients or artificial ingredients. Dog parents report noticeable health improvements in their pups including softer fur, fresher breath, better poops and more energy after switching to Sundays. Here's how I've known for years that Luca, my dog, loves Sundays. John Favreau, you guys might have heard of him. He and Emily feed their dog Leo Sundays and have for years and years and years, long before they were a sponsor. And so whenever we go to the Favreau's house, Luca literally sprints as fast as she can into their home directly for the dog bowl because she wants to steal Leo's Sunday. So that's how you know it's good. And like other fresh dog food, Sundays does not require refrigeration or preparation because their air drying process you just pour and serve. When you start a Sunday subscription, you'll automatically get 20% off and free shipping on every reorder. Cancel or pause your subscription anytime. With our 100% satisfaction guarantee, every order ships right to your door so you'll never worry about running out of dog food again. And it's super easy to store and then serve it to your pup. Get 40% off your first order of Sundays. Go to Sundays for dogs.com world or use code world at checkout. That's sundays4dogs.com world code world hey guys, it's Tommy Vitor.
Ben Rhodes
By now you've probably all seen footage of the disastrous meeting between Donald Trump.
Tommy Vitor
And Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky.
Ben Rhodes
Friday they were supposed to do a.
Tommy Vitor
Quick pool spray, which is when the.
Ben Rhodes
Press comes in, shots a question and leaves, and then have a meeting about rare earth minerals, hold a press conference and then figure out the future of the US Ukrainian relationship. But instead, Trump and JD Vance erupted on Zelenskyy. They ended up throwing the Ukrainian delegation out of the White House. And it was truly a meeting unlike anything I've ever seen before.
Tommy Vitor
So what you're about to hear is.
Ben Rhodes
A quick reaction episode that Ben Rhodes and I recorded for Pod Save the World. We'll be covering this again next week on Wednesday. Subscribe to Pod Save the World wherever.
Tommy Vitor
You get your podcasts or on YouTube.
Ben Rhodes
And here is that episode. Welcome back to Pod Save the world. I'm Tommy Vitor.
John Favreau
I'm Ben Rhodes.
Ben Rhodes
We are doing a little YouTube exclusive episode today based off of President Zelensky's meeting with Donald Trump just now. We were going to plan to do this regardless, but, Ben, I didn't expect it to be the worst. The worst meeting ever in the Oval Office. I'm trying to think of an example of a meeting that went worse. I mean, there was the infamous Bibi Netanyahu Obama meeting that you and I were both in the room for, but it was nothing even close to what she.
John Favreau
Not even close. Yeah. This is unlike anything that has taken place in my entire lifetime. Uh, and, you know, I have to mine my brain. I mean, I assume there were some tough meetings, you know, in the Civil War, but. Yeah. Never. Never. We've never seen anything like it. Never seen anything.
Ben Rhodes
Well, we'll cut to the chase and start to play you some of that. We have a very long clip and we're gonna play some excerpts, pause and talk about them, and then play some more. Because I honestly, it was just impossible to cut it down. It was that much of a train wreck. So with that, here is a clip from Zelensky and Trump's meeting in the Oval office today, Friday, February 28th.
Volodymyr Zelensky
He broken the ceasefire. He killed our people. And he didn't exchange prisoners. We signed the exchange of prisoners, but he didn't do it. What kind of diplomacy, jd, you are speaking about what. What you are. What do you mean?
J.D. Vance
I'm talking about the country of diplomacy that's going to end the destruction of your country. Yes, but, Mr. President. Mr. President, with respect, I think it's disrespectful for you to come into the Oval Office, try to litigate this in front of the American media. Right now, you guys are going around and forcing conscripts to the front lines because you have manpower problems. You should be thanking the President for trying to bring it into this conflict.
Volodymyr Zelensky
To Ukraine, that you say what problems we have.
J.D. Vance
I have been to come one. I have actually. I've actually won, watched and seen the stories. And I know what happens is you bring people, you bring them on a propaganda tour.
Ben Rhodes
Mr. President.
John Favreau
Okay, stop.
Ben Rhodes
Yeah, okay, stop. This is the worst. Okay, stop. Episode in history. So what you can hear there is Zelensky does his windup where he's talking about how we can't trust Putin to implement a ceasefire because he breaks every agreement he's ever signed. And actually, I was just watching Mike Pompeo on Fox News talking about how the United States pulled out of all these arms control agreements during the first Trump administration because Trump. Because Putin was breaking the terms of the deal. But, you know, it was hard to tell exactly what kind of sets the meeting off here, Ben. But I do think J.D. vance is kind of the chief arsonist, because Zelinsky pretty quickly calls him out and is like, okay, you seem to know a lot about my country. Have you ever been there? And obviously, obviously, J.D. vance has not. And he flips out about it and just, I guess, says that any visit to Ukraine is a propaganda tour now.
John Favreau
Yeah. Two things stand out to me about this. First, just so people know what Zelensky is talking about, he's talking about the Minsk agreement that was reached in the late Obama administration to essentially freeze the conflict and have some kind of process whereby the Ukrainians had autonomous regions in these places where the Russians had invaded in Eastern Ukraine. And what he's saying is Putin broke the ceasefire the last time someone tried to do what Trump's doing. You know, Putin is the one that violated the agreement and reinvaded the country and dramatically escalated. And that's just a fact. It's not an opinion. You know, so this is going to be a reoccurring theme here, that Zelensky's saying facts, and J.D. vance and Trump are just basically offering Kremlin talking points in response. And then, Tommy, I said this to you, but for J.D. vance to refer to visits that people make to Ukraine as propaganda tours was one of the most triggering things and many that were said today, because what people do when they go to Ukraine is they. They often visit Bucha, for instance, where there were war crimes committed, where innocent civilians were massacred, where children were killed. And to call that a propaganda tour is so beyond the pale, it's essentially him calling the truth propaganda. When people go to Ukraine, what they see is the reality of a country that's been invaded and bombarded and had terrorists, tens of thousands of children kidnapped and tens of thousands of people killed. And J.D. vance calls that the propaganda. And it's. It's up is down. It's, you know, black is white. It's just 180 degrees wrong. And I agree with you, Tommy. It felt like JD Vance was setting a trap, like he was getting. Trying to provoke Zelensky to say something that would piss off Trump.
Ben Rhodes
Yeah.
John Favreau
Which is a pretty fucking dark role for him to be playing.
Ben Rhodes
But just to be clear, this meeting was ostensibly about signing some sort of deal between the US and the Ukrainians about rare earth minerals. In reality, it seems like it was a setup to get to exactly this moment so JD Vance and Donald Trump could harangue Zelensky in front of the cameras and show what a tough guy they are and, you know, you know, beat their chest on Fox News later. But, Ben, I'm glad you mentioned Bucha, because, you know, that's another triggering thing for me, because you often hear these same conservatives, actually Democrats, too, talk about how there were some early peace talks between the Ukrainians and the Russians, but they blew up. And they often blame Zelensky for pulling out of those talks. In fact, those talks blew up because the atrocities that occurred at Bucha were revealed. And it became impossible for anyone in Ukraine to imagine cutting a deal with Putin and the Russians in that moment.
John Favreau
Yeah. And this context was entirely missing. They seemed to be offended by Zelensky pointing out that his country was invaded by Putin. That. That seemed to offend Trump and J.D. vance and, and I think another piece of context here, Tommy, is. Zelensky is. Is a profoundly exhausted person, you know.
Ben Rhodes
And you can see it on his face.
John Favreau
You can see on his face. I've heard this from some Europeans. Like, he, you know, this. This guy probably barely sleeps at night. He has been besieged by the Trump administration, bullied into trying to sign this absurd deal for critical minerals. And he flies to Washington because he feels this thing slipping away from him, this thing being US Support as kind of a Hail Mary. And then he sits down and they bring the cameras in, and he just starts getting insulted to his face by people who can demonstrate no degree of empathy. I mean, like, they don't even. Not even a perfunctory, you know, tribute to what the people of Ukraine have done. And they insulted not just Zelensky. This is important. They insulted the Ukrainian people. He said the only people you can get to fight are conscripts that you force to the front line. So that's insulting the troops. That's insulting the Ukrainians that have been fighting and saying they don't want to be there. They're only there because Zelensky made them go there, when, in fact, Putin is the one that conscripts people. Putin is the one that did the mobilization. And so we can talk later about whether Zelensky erred tactically here, but I'm. I have a great deal of empathy for what he had to go through.
Ben Rhodes
Yeah, I mean, look, you're. You're Trump being offended by reality and people insulting Zelensky is going to be a theme of this thing. The press corps even gets in on the action. But we'll get to that in a minute. But let's keep rolling that clip.
J.D. Vance
Do you disagree that you've had problems bringing people into your military and do you think that it's respectful to come to the Oval Office of the United States of America and attack the administration that is trying to trying to prevent the destruction of your country?
Volodymyr Zelensky
A lot of questions. Let's start from the beginning.
Ben Rhodes
Sure.
Volodymyr Zelensky
First of all, during the war everybody has problems, even you. But you have nice ocean and don't feel now but you will feel it in the future. God bless.
Marco Rubio
You don't know that.
Volodymyr Zelensky
God bless. God bless you.
Marco Rubio
Don't tell us what we're going to feel. We're trying to solve a problem. Don't tell us what we're going to feel.
Volodymyr Zelensky
I'm not telling you because you're in.
Marco Rubio
No position to dictate that.
Tommy Vitor
Remember this.
Marco Rubio
You're in no position to dictate what we're going to feel. We're going to feel very good. We're going to feel very good and very strong.
Volodymyr Zelensky
You will feel influenced.
Marco Rubio
You're right now not in a very good position. You've allowed to be in a very bad position and he happens to be.
Volodymyr Zelensky
Right about from the very beginning of the war.
Marco Rubio
You're not in a good position. You don't have the cards right now with us. You start having cards right now. You don't. You're gambling with the lives of millions of people. You're gambling with World War iii. You're gambling with World War iii. And what you're doing is very disrespectful to the country. This country. That's back to you. Far more than a lot of people said they should have.
J.D. Vance
Have you said thank you once this entire meeting? No, in this entire meeting. Have you said thank you. You went to Pennsylvania and campaigned for the the opposition in October offer some words of appreciation for the United States of America.
Ben Rhodes
OK, J.D. vance just gave up the whole game there. They are offended by a campaign period visit by Zelensky to Pennsylvania where which was perceived as an endorsement or support for Joe Biden. Geez, Ben. I wonder why Zelinsky might have thought he'd be better off if Joe Biden was president or Kamala Harris was president and not Donald Trump as he's lecturing him in the Oval Office about how he's gambling and about to start World War Three.
John Favreau
Yeah, there's a lot that one too, Tommy. I mean first of all, boy, to say that Zelensky is the one that's gambling with World War iii, when Putin is the one that invaded the country. I mean, the Ukrainians didn't want, they don't want to be in this war.
Ben Rhodes
And Trump is pulling out support for NATO, which has prevented World War Three.
John Favreau
Yeah, yeah. Like, what's so bonkers about this is like the, the, all the things that Trump advanced say presuppose that Zelensky somehow wants this war and wanted this war when he was just invaded by Russia. They're the ones that raise the risks of World War iii. Then to hear them lecture him about needing to thank Mr. Trump. You know, first of all, Zelensky always thanks the United States repeatedly. He's done it, by the way, since Trump has been president, express gratitude for the support the United States supplies. Even though, by the way, Donald Trump is not the one that provided that support. It was Joe Biden and the United States Congress, by part on a bipartisan basis. But they want Zelensky to behave like, you know, a Trump staffer there. Thank you, Mr. Trump, for being such a great president. And they don't do this to other leaders. You know, they don't hector other leaders like this in the Oval Office. They, you know, they, they, they, they're picking on him. They're like schoolyard bullies picking on a small injured person to impress their friends.
Ben Rhodes
And it's like three on one. You can hear all of them, like, chatting, him being like, yes, you were mean. Yes, you did say that. It literally sounds like a schoolyard taunting.
John Favreau
And he didn't insult. When did he insult? Did you hear? Do you know what they're referring? Because he shouldn't insult the US he just explained facts. Facts are insulting to.
Ben Rhodes
Trump is mad. It's earlier on in this Oval Office meeting because this was a very, very long pool spray. And just like to give folks a little context, what usually happens is the two leaders go into the Oval Office, they sit down, you bring the pool, the White House press pool, in for like a minute or two. Sometimes there's a shouted question, they take photos, and then they get them the hell out of there. They have the real meeting. There was supposed to be a lunch, and then there was supposed to be a press conference. Trump has started doing this thing where he takes, like, 45 minutes worth of questions during the pool spray, and then they do the press conference just because he needs to be on TV all the time. So what. What you didn't hear that happened earlier was, you know, Trump's entire shtick about Ukraine is the war never would have happened if he was president. But Zelensky, when he was walking through all the times the Russians broke ceasefire agreements, talks about how the Russians were occupying Ukraine throughout the duration of the Trump presidency, and people were getting killed during the Trump presidency, and Trump really didn't like that because it undercut his whole fucking argument that none of this would have happened if I were in charge. Because he acts like he wasn't actually the president for four years and isn't responsible for anything.
John Favreau
Yeah. And, and he needs everything to be about himself and not about, like, the reality of what is happening in the world, particularly a reality that is counter to his narrative and inconvenient to him in any way, shape, or form. And Zelensky is this guy who's only trying to share facts, you know, and each time he does, they act as if he has personally offended them and come down even harder on the guy. And, and it. By this point in the clip, they're just picking on him, like, and, and, and to say that because, you know, he's not kissing Trump's ass, he's insulting the whole country, just shows you what Donald Trump's view of this country is, that. That he is the only thing that matters. He, the leader. You know, he. Der Fuhrer is the only guy. He's the symbol of the nation or something. It's. It's absolutely grotesque. And what we can see here is, like, little Marco Rubio on the couch, like, shrinking deeper and deeper into his seat.
Ben Rhodes
J.D. vance is, like, sitting on the edge of his seat. He's the happiest little boy in town because he was allowed to go to the big boy meeting and say something. And Marco Rubio, every photo of Marco Rubio that I've seen in the context of these, these Russia, Ukraine talks, he looks like his soul is. Is drifting out of his body in that moment. He looks like he is dead inside. He knows what is happening is so profoundly wrong, but he just sits there silently and then afterwards tweets an attaboy at the boss. And look, there's all these reports that Rubio is like the Secretary of State in name only and actually has a bunch of little kind of maga supplicants who, who work for him on the org chart, but are actually running the show over at State, so who knows?
John Favreau
Yeah.
Ben Rhodes
Well, let's listen to the rest of this clip.
J.D. Vance
Who's trying to save your country.
Marco Rubio
It's going to be a very hard thing to do business like this.
J.D. Vance
Thank you.
Volodymyr Zelensky
I said a lot of times, except.
J.D. Vance
That There are disagreements and let's go litigate those disagreements rather than trying to fight it out in the American media. When you're wrong, we know that you're wrong.
Marco Rubio
But you see, I think it's good for the American people to see what's going on. I think it's very important. That's why I kept this going so long.
Ben Rhodes
Trump ends the meeting later and says, this is going to be great television. So again, giving up the game. This is all about politics for them. They don't care about Ukraine. They don't actually care about anything, Zelensky said. This is just domestic politics.
John Favreau
Yeah. And they're just, you know, like, what is he wrong about? You know, like, like nothing that Zelensky said we can again, we'll talk later about like what his tactical decision making was, but like nothing he said was wrong. And J.D. vance doesn't know what the fuck he's talking about. He's not some expert on like Ukraine and Russia. He's just some guy who listened to some podcasts and tries.
Ben Rhodes
Nothing wrong with that. Yeah, nothing wrong with that. Sorry that all of you people.
John Favreau
This is you. This is YouTube.
Ben Rhodes
Yeah.
Tommy Vitor
This podcast is sponsored by Squarespace. Squarespace is the all in one website platform for entrepreneurs to stand out and succeed online. Whether you're just starting out or managing a growing brand, Squarespace makes it easy to create a beautiful website, engage with your audience and sell anything from products to content to time. All in one place. All on your terms. Introducing design intelligence from Squarespace. Combining two decades of industry leading design expertise with cutting edge AI technology to unlock your strongest creative potential. Design Intelligence empowers anyone to build a beautiful, more personalized website tailored to their unique needs and craft a bespoke digital identity to use across one's entire online presence. Start a fully custom on brand website with Squarespace's latest AI enhanced website builder, Blueprint AI. After a few questions, our interactive design system transforms basic information about your brand or business into an elevated online presence with curated premium quality content automatically added and matched to your profile and esthetic. Upload video content, organize your video library and showcase your content on beautiful video pages. You can even sell access to your video library by adding a paywall to your content. Can you make us a website without Squarespace? I feel like it's like the only thing I've heard of.
Cash Patel
Yeah, I don't know what else you would do.
Tommy Vitor
Why would you even bother?
Cash Patel
Draw a picture and show it to.
Tommy Vitor
People on the street just to print out hard paper?
Ben Rhodes
Head to squarespace.com for a free trial. When you're ready to Launch, go to squarespace.comworld to save 10% off your first.
Tommy Vitor
Purchase of a website or domain.
Ben Rhodes
That's squarespace.com World Pod Save the World.
Tommy Vitor
Is brought to you by Rocket Money. You sign up for something, you forget about it after the trial period ends. Then you're charged month after month after month. The subscriptions are there, but you're not using them. In fact, 85% of people have at least one paid subscription going unused each month. Thanks to Rocket Money, you can see all your subscriptions in one place and cancel the ones you're not using anymore. Saving more Money Rocket Money is a personal finance app that helps find and cancel your unwanted subscriptions, monitors your spending, and helps lower your bills so you can grow your savings. Rocket Money's dashboard gives you a clear view of your expenses across all of your accounts. You can easily create a personalized budget with custom categories to help keep your spending on track. See your monthly spending trends in each category to know exactly where your money is going. Get alerts if bills increase in price, there's unusual spending activity, or if you're close to going over budget. The new Goals feature automatically saves money for you so you don't have to think about it. Pay off credit card debt, put away money for a house, or just build your savings. Rocket Money makes it easy. Rocket Money is over 5 million users and saved a total of 500 million in canceled subscriptions, saving members up to 740 bucks a year. When using all of the app's premium features, Rocket Money is what we all wish Elon Musk and the Doge guys were doing. You know what I mean? Actually cutting spending in a smart, thoughtful way, not rampaging through the US Government. I've saved money with Rocket Money, bent roads to save money with Rocket Money. It's a great service. Give it a shot, cancel your unwanted subscriptions and reach your financial goals faster with Rocket Money. Go to RocketMoney.comWorld Go today. That's RocketMoney.comWorld RocketMoney.comWorld Podcast of the World is brought to you by Simply safe. Every 26 seconds, a burglary takes place in the U.S. according to FBI data, that means by the time this podcast ends, dozens of homes will be targeted. Protect your home before it's too late. With Simply Safe's proactive security system, Simplisafe helps stop threats before they even have a chance to break in. We love SimpliSafe. I probably love it even more now that the entire FBI is being politicized and we can't count on the justice system to protect us at all.
Cash Patel
Yeah, that's right.
Tommy Vitor
But John Lovett's throwing up himself. I did great sensors.
Cash Patel
Yeah.
Tommy Vitor
Turn it on and off with his phone.
Cash Patel
That's right. You use the app. The app is great. It's great to have an alarm system. It's great. Peace of mind. It's. Simplisafe is easy to set up and once you set up, it's completely reliable. Customer service works. The app works highly. Recommend it.
Tommy Vitor
Cash Patel. Not involved.
Cash Patel
Not involved.
Tommy Vitor
Traditional security systems only take action after someone has already broken in and that's too late. SimpliSafe's Active Guard Outdoor protection can help prevent break ins before they happen. If someone's lurking around and acting suspiciously, those agents see and talk to them in real time, activate spotlights, and even contact the police. All before they have the chance to get inside your home. No long term contracts or cancellation fees. Monitoring plans start affordably around a dollar a day. There's a 60 day satisfaction guarantee or your money back. SimpliSafe is named best home security system by U.S. news and World Report. Five years in a row. Dollar a day. Keep yourself safe. Come on, that's nothing. Visit simplisafe.com crookedworld to claim 50% off a new system with professional monitoring plan and your first month free. That's simplisafe.com crookedworld the there's no safe like SimpliSafe.
Ben Rhodes
It's worth noting, like, the meeting didn't start terribly. Again, like we said, there was like a 30 minute pool spray. There was actually some like kind of chummy moments. Let's just play a quick clip of that.
Volodymyr Zelensky
Because Europe really helped. President Trump said that they made less support. But they have our friends and they are our very supportive partners. They really gave a lot. Misprint.
John Favreau
Really.
Marco Rubio
They did, but they gave much less.
John Favreau
No, much less.
Ben Rhodes
No, no, don't argue. No.
John Favreau
Okay, okay.
Ben Rhodes
So right there, you know, Zelensky's talking about contributions from the Europeans to Ukraine. This is like the third time in a week that Trump has been corrected in the Oval Office about the European contribution to the Ukrainian side. Remember in the, in the meeting with French President Emmanuel Macron, Macron like grabs his arm and is like, actually, no. 60% of what we gave them was a grant. Not alone. Keir Starmer made the same point yesterday, I believe, Thursday and then Zelensky today. But you know, it was kind of like, look, Zelensky had a look on his face. Where, as you said, Ben, he looked exhausted by the end of this conversation. He looks like he wants to cry. But it didn't start terribly. Like things just escalated and got worse and worse.
John Favreau
Yeah, but it felt like that, that J.D. vance and Trump wanted some version of this outcome. They didn't want to go exactly like this, but they wanted to smack him around and same he was say he was ungrateful and tell them to thank Mr. Trump. And again, what I find so appalling about it, but it's interesting, we have to understand this, is that, you know, Trump's, you know, the headline in foreign policy is he's completely switched sides and it's now the US And Russia against Europe and Ukraine. The US Wanting to be in this alignment with big autocratic countries, Russia, China, the Gulf, et cetera. But it also mirrors Tommy, like, what Trump does at home, like, he doesn't really pick on people's own size. You know, it's, it's, it's undocumented people, it's trans people. You know, it's a country that's been invaded, like Ukraine. It's people in Gaza that he's dunking on and posting, you know, weird videos about, you know, the Riviera of that he's going to build. Like, this guy is not tough. Tough people, like, would pick on Putin. Tough people would, like, not be terrified of Putin and beating the shit out of Zelensky on television and then telling him it's his fault. And guess who sees that. The world sees that. Like, MAGA base will, you know, be like, oh, this is great. Look at Trump. Own. Own the libs. Because they think Zelensky. I mean, your point about Pennsylvania, it's not just that it's, you gave up the game on that, but they also equate like Ukraine with kind of libs or something, you know, like, which is super weird, by the way, because it used to be the opposite that, like.
Ben Rhodes
Yeah, then Obama was weak because he didn't give enough support to Ukraine talking point forever.
John Favreau
You know, now Obama looks like, you know, much different light compared to Trump. But I mean, these, the rest of the world doesn't live in the Magaverse, you know, the rest of the world lives in reality and they're just seeing like a bully picking on someone smaller to make himself look tough.
Ben Rhodes
Yeah. So again, this was supposed to be the pool spray before the lunch meeting, before the press conference. The Trump people ended up canceling the rest of the itinerary. And, you know, according to the readouts, they're giving to Fox News or whoever else. It sounds like the Rubio and Mike Waltz basically kicked Zelensky out of the White House and said, come back when you're ready to cut a peace deal. They were supposed to sign some sort of rare earths agreement. This, the text of this agreement has evolved so much over time. Like, initially it was reported as just, like, extortion. The US demanding half of Ukraine's rare earths, or up to $500 billion worth of rare earths. Now it seemed like there would just be some sort of joint effort to mine these rare earths and put it into a fund that would then be used for Ukrainian reconstruction. But the US Would have some sort of oversight over it and maybe get some of the profits. I don't know. I'm not sure that we'll ever know. Caitlin Collins from CNN asked a very smart question during this press conference, which is that something like 40% of Ukraine's rare earths are in the Far East. So in Russian occupied areas, she was like, are you going to be able to get access to those who will protect those? There's been a lot of reporting today about how, you know, the sort of mining process for these rare earth elements is. Is unbelievably energy and labor intensive and incredibly dirty. And setting up, you know, a giant lithium mine, for example, can take a decade. So the idea that this is some sort of immediate U.S. ukrainian cooperation on the ground that serves as a de facto deterrent from the Russians invading is just, like, sort of nonsensical on its face, if you actually understand the details. But, Ben, I don't know that we'll ever need to know the details of this one because it doesn't seem like it's happening.
John Favreau
Yeah, I mean, the whole purpose of this was to, again, further make Trump look tough, like he got Ukraine to bend to his will and give us access to these rare earth materials that, as you said, take. You know, these would not be mined in Trump's presidency. And if and when they are. So what, what is it? What on earth does this have to do with ending the war? It has nothing to do with ending the war. It's not a security guarantee to Ukraine to say that, like, there might be some joint ventures down the line to get some rare earth materials that Trump probably doesn't even know what they do. You know, I mean, so this always felt like this kind of weird facade. And I do just, you know, to put a point on it, like Waltz and Rubio, for them to be going along with this charade, like fucking, you know, Ribbentrop, the Nazi foreign minister, like, they, these guys were talking tough about Ukraine like a year ago. They were. You know, this is what happens when you sell your soul to Donald Trump. You know, and if there's one thing that Zelensky's visit achieved is exposed the full truth of what he's dealing with.
Ben Rhodes
Yeah, I mean, look, there is sort of, there is a, there is a national security challenge for the US which is that I think China has something like 70% of the rare earth elements supply. They also have something like 90% of the refining capacity. So. So there could be a scenario where the US really needs access to these rare earth minerals. But like you just said, I mean, this is like a decade long process. And Ben, I remember having a very similar conversation about, you know, people saying there were massive deposits, like trillion dollar deposits in Afghanistan, that none of those have been mined even as of today. So all of this just seems like very vaporware made up.
John Favreau
It's a huge issue. But ironically, Tommy, I know a lot about this issue from the prism of climate change because these are critical to battery technologies, to solar panels and the Chinese wind turbines. And the reality is, if you really cared about it, you wouldn't dismantle USAID because you'd be trying to be in Africa, where there's a ton of these critical minerals or place in South America there are a ton of critical minerals. And in places that are not currently invaded by Russia, like, you know, making agreements with Chile, which has a lot of these deposits, would be a lot more rational than saying we're going to solve our rare earth materials by getting mining rights in Ukraine, you know, that has currently been intact. It's purely for show for Trump.
Ben Rhodes
Yep, purely for show. Okay, well, like we mentioned earlier, Zelensky wasn't just insulted by J.D. vance and Rubio and Waltz and Trump. There were a bunch of moron reporters in the Oval Office because as you might have heard, the White House is taking over control of the White House press pool. And instead of having like real serious journalists in there from places like Reuters or Bloomberg, they're swapping in right wing zealots who are just their little propagandists. So let's hear an example of what kind of questions those people ask. Do you ever. Why don't you wear a suit?
Marco Rubio
Why don't you wear a suit?
J.D. Vance
You're at the highest level in this.
John Favreau
Country'S office and you refuse to wear a suit. Just want to see if you do.
Marco Rubio
You own a Suit.
Volodymyr Zelensky
Yeah. You have problems.
Brian Glenn
A lot of Americans have problems with United.
Volodymyr Zelensky
I don't have such office. I will wear costume after this war will finish.
John Favreau
Okay.
Volodymyr Zelensky
Yes, maybe one. Maybe something like yours.
John Favreau
Yes.
Volodymyr Zelensky
Maybe some. Something better. I. I don't know. We will see. Maybe something cheaper than. Yeah. Thank you.
Ben Rhodes
That was a reporter named Brian Glenn. He's the chief White House correspondent for Real America's Voice. There was a reporter from One America, which is another right wing outlet, Ben, that asked what gave you the moral courage and conviction to lead on a peace agreement. Apparently a reporter from TASS snuck into the Oval Office pool spray. For those who don't know, TASS is a Russian state owned news agency founded in the 1900s. So interesting move to let the Russian state owned media, you know, the country bombing the, the country you're meeting with into the Oval Office spray. They. Apparently the White House staff said he snuck in there somehow. It doesn't give me a lot of confidence in their, in their security. I'm not sure how you sneak into the Oval Office, but I don't know, man. Like, this is, this is bleak shit.
John Favreau
Well, you know, first of all, the real American news guy was probably slobbering over Elon Musk in the cabinet meeting yesterday when he was not wearing a suit, was wearing a T shirt, was wearing a hat and was like amped up on God knows what.
Ben Rhodes
Good point.
John Favreau
Standing up, jumping up and down, being a fucking lunatic. Right. So why is Elon Musk allowed to like, you know, in this guy's view, denigrate the White House, the Oval Office by not wearing a suit? I mean, like, can you imagine, can you imagine being Ukrainian and looking at this? I mean, Zelensky dresses like that in solidarity with people in his country. You know, he wears military colored clothes to express solidarity with troops who are fighting the front line. You don't have to think that's a great, you know, sartorial choice but to, to just pick on him. Who's. What danger has that guy ever been under? Zelensky could have been assassinated in the early days of the war. Like there was.
Tommy Vitor
Yeah.
John Favreau
Credible reports or all kinds of bounties on his head. And this kind of complete fucking loser from Real America News is picking on him to make himself look good in front of Mr. Trump and whoever his audience is. And then the toss thing, let's just be very clear here, like Russian state media, which I think was like sanctioned or designated.
Ben Rhodes
Like, I know I was trying to remember that they were definitely like a.
John Favreau
Part of some, you know, One of the things the Biden administration rolled out. But Russian state media is allowed in the Oval Office and the Associated Press, the wire service for more American newspapers than anybody else, is not because they won't call it the Gulf of America. Like, this is where we are people. Like, we are in a reality in which Russian state media and Russian propaganda is in the Oval Office berating a democratically elected leader of a country under attack, you know, who's being insulted for not wearing a suit. I mean, we just have to get our minds around this thing because we're only six weeks into it, you know.
Ben Rhodes
Yeah, I know. Like, American politics are so unserious. It's so frustrating. But this moment really drove home for me. I just, I can't imagine, you know, this is an existential meeting for the people of Ukraine and for Zelensky, literally. And, you know, suddenly he's getting berated about his appearance. I mean, it's just like, truly outrageous.
Tommy Vitor
So, Ben, I mean, the big picture.
Ben Rhodes
Question is like, where do we go from here? Because this meeting was a disaster. I mean, I'm sure Zelensky will try to kind of mop it up. He's doing a TV appearance with Bret Baier on Fox News later tonight that I think he knows will be a sort of a direct line back into the Oval Office to communicate with Trump. It's been interesting to watch. This week you had Macron, Keir Starmer and Zelensky all have White House meetings and then all go on Bret Baer's show. It's become kind of the car wash equivalent. Like when you go to espn, you do a bunch of shows. Now Bret bears the car wash. But yesterday, Putin was speaking, he was praising the new U.S. administration for, quote, pragmatism, a realistic worldview, discarding menu, stereotypes, so called rules, and messianic ideological cliches of their predecessors. You had Dmitry Medvedev cheering and tweeting in English about how great it was to see the Lenski treated like shit. And then yesterday, when, when Trump was meeting with Keir Starmer, the British Prime Minister, Trump refused to say that the US would backstop a European peacekeeping force if one were to be put in Ukraine after some sort of peace deal, he also seemed to once again suggest the US wasn't fully committed to Article 5. When he was asked about it, he was like, oh, the Brits, they don't need much help. They can take care of themselves. And then at one point he said to Keir Starmer, could you take on Russia by yourselves? You know, like, kind of joking, but not really. So. I know. Pretty dark, man. Like, where do you think we go from here?
John Favreau
Again? I think if there's any utility in. In this, you know, because you might say Zelensky should have just shut his mouth and taken it and then tried to sign his rare earth deal. And, you know, but actually, I think it's something useful in just surfacing this, you know, and just clarifying. This is where we are. We've learned that Trump has flipped 180 degrees to the Russian side. We've learned that his approach to peace is to bully Ukraine and ask nothing of Russia. We've learned that the Republican Party in the United States has completed the process of not having any spine and capitulating to Trump's foreign policy. And so what does it mean going forward? If I'm Europe and Ukraine, I'm saying we need to develop a shared position for this war that is separate from the United States of America and actually sees that this is the United States and Russia sitting on one side of the negotiating table and Europe and Ukraine sitting on the other. And as dark and as extreme as that sounds, I think that's where we are. And so they. The. Because Ukrainians, by the way, don't have to stop fighting. You know, there were reports early in the. In the invasion when Russia thought they were going to roll over Kiev, that they were going to have a guerrilla warfare type approach. So the Ukrainians don't have to, like, agree to Trump's terms that he strikes with Moscow. I think the Ukrainians need to figure out what the Europeans, what are their positions? What are they insisting on? They're going to have to give a bunch of stuff, including territory. But what can they. What can they insist on in terms of, like, a credible ceasefire line, essentially? And then what is a peace force that has, you know, British and French troops? There was an interesting comment from Turkey that they might get involved with troops on the ground. What is a credible European force that can provide some security guarantee and some presence there? And then how do you build a European defense and foreign policy that is totally separate from the United States? Because the United States has switched sides, you know, and, And I, I wish that wasn't the case, but I think that's where we are. And I don't know that just like signing some dumb rare earth thing is going to make Trump be nicer to them. It's not. So figure out your own interest and act accordingly. It's what all of us are going to have to do in these. Trump Years.
Ben Rhodes
Yeah. I mean, look, the more we learned about the Rare Earths Agreement, the more it just seemed like nothing. You know, it like, initially just sounded like complete extortion, and now I don't even know what it was. I do think, you know, to your question, we should ask, like, did Zelensky screw up? I think I, I give him like, all, like, I have so much sympathy for him, but I think the answer is kind of, of course he did. I mean, challenging J.D. vance getting into that pissing match, like, it, like we, we can look at inputs. DC people look at inputs too much and they don't look at outputs. Like, the end result of that meeting was a fucking disaster for Zelensky, personally, politically, and for his country. So obviously he should have approached it differently. I think the challenge is he's got politics, Trump's got politics, right?
Tommy Vitor
Like, he's not going to walk in.
Ben Rhodes
There and make a bunch of sort of rhetorical concessions to Putin before negotiations actually begun, a negotiation that he's not part of, by the way. And Trump just wouldn't broke any dissent. Or, you know, actually, like, he mocked Zelensky at one point for saying, I don't want a ceasefire. But Zelensky's point was like, not that I don't want this, the fighting to stop. He was like, I don't want a ceasefire where Putin then breaks it over and over again and reinvades my country. So, I mean, look, yeah, we'd be like, I think, dishonest if we said that Zelensky had played that thing perfectly, but. Or even remotely well. But I do think it was a setup for domestic consumption here in the.
John Favreau
U.S. yeah, I think that like, like, by any measure, like, tactically, you don't get into a fight with JD Vance in the Oval Office. You don't allow yourself to be humiliated by the President United States to that extent. But I'm not saying this to give him credit, because I don't think it was a strategy. I think the, the utility in it is we know what we're dealing with now, right? Like, we have the hegseth, like laying down of terms without consulting Ukraine and Europe in which they surrender all their territory and can't be NATO. We have the JD Van speech in Munich endorsing the European far right. We've got Trump calling Zelensky a dictator. And now we have this. And so there can be no illusions that somehow some committee to save America is going to. Or Marco Rubio or whoever, or Lindsey Graham's going to the Oval Office. And convince Trump to suddenly get tough on the Russians. Like, so I'm not saying that Zelensky was, like, playing some chess and, you know, outed this. I'm saying he messed up by getting baited into this. But there may be something you. Worthwhile that comes out of just clarifying, okay, this is. This is actually where we are, you know, and. And I can tell you, like, from, you know, be having been in Munich and, you know, different Europeans, like, this is what the Trump people are like behind closed doors, too. You know, like, from what I hear, like, they're not. They're not just performing for the cameras. Like, they. This is. This. This is who they are. And so now he's got to go back. And I was thinking, too, Tommy, like, you know, he made that comment about, like, I will step down if it brings peace. Like, he's got to be also thinking about that, you know, not stepping down now, but, like, you know, like, what is what? Like, he. He's tired. He's clearly a lightning rod to Trump because Trump wrongly, unfairly sees him as some guy who's, like, aligned with things that Trump doesn't like, like democracies and Europeans and. And internationalists in this country. And. And so I think he's got to stand up to Trump and try to get the best deal for his people and from the Europeans, and then, you know, that's. That's his mission, and then he's done.
Ben Rhodes
You're right, though. I mean, this is really tough for Zelensky because he showed unbelievable, incredibly inspiring courage in the very early days of that war and by just sort of like, force of personality, brought the entire world to his side, helped rally support in the U.S. in Europe, everywhere, like, public opinion in capitals everywhere. And if he is seen now as having kind of lost that touch, I mean, I'm sure the shine faded during the Biden administration when a lot of Ukrainians felt like they were getting some of what they wanted, but getting it late and getting it slow and not getting enough of it. But this meeting, I think, is probably going to. I mean, maybe it'll rally people to his side, but it might also make them wonder whether he's the right person to be the interlocutor with the United States when they're so reliant on us. So very challenging political moment for him personally as well as for the country.
John Favreau
Yeah, Yeah. I mean, if I'm him, I'm going to take a breath and I'm gonna talk. I mean, I. I honestly, frankly, I guess you got to do the Brett Baer car wash. But he can't just go on there and grovel, you know, And Brett Baer will be an I as a side note too, Tommy. It's like, do you remember, like, you know, people would go to foreign leaders, go to China, they have to do cctv. The state media, like Fox News has become like the CCTV of the US no doubt. That's pretty dark too, you know, like that, that's not normal people. You know, like, there's a lot of other people that you could do interviews with, but they know that they like, have to to talk to Brett Baer and Fox News because that's who Trump wants him to talk to.
Ben Rhodes
Yeah, dear will be watching.
John Favreau
So I will, you know, I'm sure he'll kind of recalibrate this a little bit, but he can't fold or capitulate. And that's also not in his character. And I think you go back, you talked of Macron, you talked to Starmer, you talked to Mertz and Schultz and the Germans. If you're Zelensky and you kind of go back the drawing board. Okay, like what, what's our position, our being Europe and Ukraine and this negotiation with the U.S. and Russia.
Ben Rhodes
Yeah. Dark day.
John Favreau
Well, historic, historic day, you know.
Ben Rhodes
Yeah. One of, one of many we've been covering recently. Well, I'm very glad that we decided to do this. I had no idea how horrendous it was going to be. But granted to talk to you, Ben.
John Favreau
I thought we'd be talking about like a rare earths agreement.
Ben Rhodes
I know. I did too. Trying to explain why that was important. All right, that's it for today.
Tommy Vitor
Thank you so much for listening.
Ben Rhodes
Subscribe to POD Save the World if you're not already. I'd really appreciate it. And we'll be out with a new Pod Save America on Tuesday.
Brian Glenn
Businesses that are selling through the roof like untuck it make selling and for shoppers buying simple with Shopify home of the number one checkout on the planet. And with shop pay you can boost conversions up to 50%. Businesses that sell more sell on Shopify. Upgrade your business and get the same checkout untuck it uses. Sign up for your $1 per month trial period at shopify.com podcastfree all lowercase go to shopify.com podcastfree to upgrade your selling today.
Pod Save America: "Trump and Zelensky's Disastrous Meeting" Summary
Episode Information:
The episode begins with a brief overview of the highly anticipated meeting between former President Donald Trump and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky. Hosts Ben Rhodes and John Favreau express their shock and disappointment over the meeting's outcomes, which deviated drastically from expectations.
Ben Rhodes:
"By now you've probably all seen footage of the disastrous meeting between Donald Trump and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky." [01:28]
Rhodes and Favreau dissect the meeting, highlighting the tension and conflict that erupted between Trump, JD Vance, Marco Rubio, and Zelensky.
Volodymyr Zelensky:
"He broken the ceasefire. He killed our people. And he didn't exchange prisoners." [03:16]
JD Vance:
"I'm talking about the country of diplomacy that's going to end the destruction of your country." [03:32]
The conversation swiftly escalates as Zelensky confronts Vance about Trump's administration's handling of Ukraine. The hosts emphasize how Vance's lack of understanding and empathy exacerbated the situation.
John Favreau:
"What does it mean going forward? If I'm Europe and Ukraine, I'm saying we need to develop a shared position for this war that is separate from the United States." [36:33]
Zelensky's attempts to outline the challenges Ukraine faces are met with personal attacks and misrepresentations by Trump and his allies. Vance's derogatory remarks about Ukrainian conscripts and Zelensky's leadership deeply offend both Zelensky and the audience.
JD Vance:
"Have you said thank you once this entire meeting?" [10:44]
Volodymyr Zelensky:
"You went to Pennsylvania and campaigned for the opposition in October or offer some words of appreciation for the United States of America." [10:56]
The hosts discuss the broader implications of the meeting, noting how Trump's behavior undermines international support for Ukraine and strains U.S. alliances.
Ben Rhodes:
"Mr. President, you guys are going around and forcing conscripts to the front lines because you have manpower problems." [03:32]
John Favreau:
"The Republican Party in the United States has completed the process of not having any spine and capitulating to Trump's foreign policy." [37:15]
The meeting also featured a barrage from right-wing journalists, further complicating the discourse and adding propaganda elements to the discussion.
Reporter from Real America's Voice:
"Why don't you wear a suit?" [29:23]
Volodymyr Zelensky:
"Maybe something better. I don't know. We will see." [29:45]
In an unprecedented move, a reporter from the Russian state-owned agency TASS infiltrated the press pool, highlighting security lapses and raising concerns about media manipulation.
Ben Rhodes:
"Russian state media and Russian propaganda is in the Oval Office berating a democratically elected leader of a country under attack." [30:59]
Zelensky is portrayed as being in an increasingly precarious position, faced with insensitivity from U.S. leaders and struggling to maintain international support amidst internal political battles.
John Favreau:
"Zelensky has to stand up to Trump and try to get the best deal for his people and from the Europeans." [36:33]
Ben Rhodes:
"This meeting was a disaster for Zelensky, personally, politically, and for his country." [37:15]
The hosts argue that Trump's actions signify a troubling shift in U.S. foreign policy, aligning more closely with autocratic regimes and undermining democratic alliances.
John Favreau:
"We've learned that Trump has flipped 180 degrees to the Russian side." [36:33]
Ben Rhodes:
"American politics are so unserious. It's so frustrating." [32:13]
Rhodes and Favreau discuss the necessity for Europe and Ukraine to recalibrate their strategies independent of U.S. influence, suggesting a realignment of international support systems.
John Favreau:
"Europe needs to develop a shared position for this war that is separate from the United States of America." [36:33]
Ben Rhodes:
"We need to develop a shared position for this war that is separate from the United States." [33:00]
The episode concludes with the hosts reflecting on the significance of the meeting, underscoring the urgent need for coherent and empathetic leadership in international relations. They express concern over the long-term ramifications of the meeting for Ukraine and global politics.
Ben Rhodes:
"This is a very challenging political moment for him personally as well as for the country." [40:09]
John Favreau:
"We've learned that they are the Trump people." [37:15]
Ben Rhodes:
"This meeting was a disaster for Zelensky, personally, politically, and for his country." [37:15]
John Favreau:
"We've learned that Trump has flipped 180 degrees to the Russian side." [36:33]
Volodymyr Zelensky:
"He broken the ceasefire. He killed our people. And he didn't exchange prisoners." [03:16]
JD Vance:
"I'm talking about the country of diplomacy that's going to end the destruction of your country." [03:32]
Final Thoughts:
"Trump and Zelensky's Disastrous Meeting" serves as a critical examination of a pivotal moment in international politics, illustrating the profound implications of leadership failures and the necessity for genuine, empathetic diplomacy. The hosts underscore the importance of steadfast alliances and coherent foreign policy in the face of global challenges.