Pod Save America – Episode Summary

Title: Trump Has James Comey Indicted
Date: September 26, 2025
Hosts: Jon Favreau, Dan Pfeiffer, Tommy Vietor

Main Theme

This episode tackles a critical escalation in the Trump Administration’s authoritarian tactics: the political indictment of former FBI Director James Comey and an aggressive expansion of retributive investigations against Trump opponents. The hosts dissect how the Department of Justice is being weaponized for political revenge, implications for democracy, and broader trends in criminalizing dissent and suppressing the media. The show also covers the latest “escalator-gate” saga, White House communications drama, the looming government shutdown, and features an in-depth conversation with Senator Jon Ossoff on corruption and the fight for democracy.

Key Discussion Points and Insights

1. Trump’s Weaponization of the Justice Department

(02:23–07:44, 14:40–17:32)

• Political Indictment of Comey: Trump installs a loyalist as US Attorney in Virginia who pushes forward with an indictment against James Comey—despite a lack of evidence and prior refusals by career prosecutors.

• Broader Pattern: Simultaneous efforts to resurrect investigations into NY AG Letitia James, to pursue charges against former CIA Director Brennan, and fishing expeditions against George Soros’s foundation.

  • “The new normal is…the president gets to pick who law enforcement goes after, regardless of the evidence. You pick the opponent first, the crime second, and the evidence follows, which is the exact opposite of the way it's supposed to go.” — Dan Pfeiffer (05:17)

• Danger to Democracy: The hosts emphatically frame these actions as a “five-alarm fire” for the rule of law.

  “If this was happening in any other country, we would call it for what it is, which is the end of democracy and it’s happening here and it’s happening right now.”
  — Dan Pfeiffer (07:36)

• Criminalizing Dissent: It’s not just about political enemies in power; the broader risk is extending these tactics to regular dissenters and activists.

  “He’s trying to criminalize dissent in this country.”
  — Jon Favreau (14:40)

2. Targeting George Soros and Left-Leaning Groups

(07:44–12:34)

• DOJ memo instructs prosecutors to find a way to charge Soros and his foundation, listing far-fetched possibilities ranging from arson to “material support for terrorism.”

• Trump’s justification: seeing Soros’s name “connected to progressive liberal organizations” is enough for suspicion.

• Pfeiffer highlights that the right’s aim is to “gum up the works” for democracy-funding groups, using investigations as a weapon.

  “They want to create some pretext to begin investigation, to go rooting through all of their stuff so that they can exact revenge and gum up the works through law enforcement... make it hard for them to do good in the world. That's what this is about.” — Dan Pfeiffer (11:51)

3. Democratic Strategy and Resistance

(12:34–14:40, 30:07–36:02)

• Democrats’ power to stop these actions is limited but must be leveraged by making the abuses a central narrative—both for oversight and electoral strategy.

• Importance of making nonviolent resistance a core “brand” and strategy for fighting back.

  “The most effective response to an authoritarian regime is nonviolent resistance.”
  — Jon Favreau (31:41)

• Need for Democrats to lead with facts, call out the abuses without overblown language, and offer a vision for what Democratic power would deliver.

4. White House, Media, and Free Speech

(37:55–43:02)

• Jimmy Kimmel Censorship Battle: Kimmel is removed from air by broadcasters following FCC pressure, only for Trump and VP Vance to deny government involvement while Trump simultaneously threatens lawsuits and legal action for “in-kind campaign contributions.”
• Kimmel’s return gets record-breaking ratings, and his monologue is praised by the hosts for being “calm, forceful, [and] powerful” in defense of free speech.
  • “He made it clear that he was not back on the air because he agreed to soft pedal his criticism… We need more people in our politics who can speak that authentically, that honestly.” — Dan Pfeiffer (42:31)
• The censorship effort backfires, raising Kimmel’s prominence and the issue of free speech.

5. The Looming Government Shutdown

(52:03–62:40)

• Shutdown over healthcare subsidies, Medicaid cuts, and broader abuses of power; Trump’s team plans mass firings rather than furloughs.

• Democrats face challenges uniting around messaging and leveraging the moment for a bigger narrative about Trump’s corruption and economic harm.

  “We can’t play it safe. Playing it safe is a guaranteed loss... You have to take on high-variance strategies.”
  — Dan Pfeiffer (58:31)

6. Escalator-Gate & Right-Wing Media Outrage Machine

(62:40–69:01)

• Trump’s brief escalator malfunction at the UN becomes a right-wing cause célèbre, leading to feverish speculation about sabotage and calls to defund or even bomb the UN.
• Segment lampoons the overblown victimhood and constantly shifting MAGA grievances.

7. Vice President Vance vs. Jon Favreau Twitter Feud

(19:36–26:06)

• VP J.D. Vance calls Favreau a “dipshit” on Twitter—a newsworthy escalation of the administration’s antagonism toward critics.
• Media struggles with how to handle the indecorousness, and hosts treat it as symptomatic of a larger campaign to delegitimize dissent.

Notable Quotes & Moments (with Timestamps)

• On trump’s weaponization of DOJ:
  “We are…a country where the Department of Justice is a political arm of the President of the United States. Their top responsibility is…to exact vengeance on the people the President…wants vengeance on.”
  — Dan Pfeiffer (16:10)

• On the White House’s criminalization of dissent:
  “He’s trying to criminalize dissent in this country.”
  — Jon Favreau (14:40)

• Kimmel monologue highlights:
  “This show is not important. What is important is that we get to live in a country that allows us to have a show like this.”
  — Jimmy Kimmel, quoted by Dan Pfeiffer (41:53)

• On Democrats’ challenge:
  “We can't play it safe. Playing it safe is a guaranteed loss.”
  — Dan Pfeiffer (58:31)

Interview: Senator Jon Ossoff

(74:01–111:13, selected highlights)

• Rule of Law Erosion:
  “The rule of law is hanging by a thread in the United States right now.” (74:44)

• Trump’s Corruption:
  “Trump…is weaponizing the Department of Justice and the entire federal government as a political instrument…to crush the opposition, destroy the pillars of authority that might oppose or criticize him, stifle dissent, make examples of his enemies…is so deeply UN American.” (75:12)

• Corruption and Money in Politics:
  “Trump…is a symptom of the deeper corruption in our politics. Like, how is it that we have a demagogue…elected twice to the presidency? It’s in part because much of the American public has lost faith in our political system…since Citizens United, this political system has been corruption on steroids.” (85:34)

• On Democratic Leadership:
  “We do have to wield the powers that we have as the minority in the opposition to limit the damage and try to contain this out of control executive.” (79:07)

• Media Freedom:
  “You’ve got the President standing on Air Force One, threatening to take news broadcasters off the air because he thinks their coverage is too negative. That’s like, this is North Korea.” (90:50)

• On the “Escalator-gate”:
  “I'm sure that all the folks in Georgia…losing access to labor and delivery services or maybe to an ICU because of these Medicaid cuts or whose groceries have gone up…will be relieved that the president's investigating escalator failures in New York City.” (76:28)

• Reelection & Democratic Mobilization:
  “We don’t have the luxury of despair right now. We cannot spend the next 15 months wringing our hands and in worry and depression. We have to win these elections. We need to win in a landslide.” (106:36)

Timestamps for Key Segments

• [02:23] Host analysis of DOJ weaponization, Comey indictment
• [07:44] Soros investigation, criminalizing dissent
• [14:40] Threat to ordinary dissenters, criminalizing protest funding
• [19:36] "Dipshit" Twitter feud: VP Vance vs. Jon Favreau
• [31:41] Authoritarianism, nonviolent resistance, Democratic messaging
• [37:55] Jimmy Kimmel censorship/monologue discussion
• [52:03] Looming government shutdown, Democratic tactics
• [62:40] Escalator-gate
• [69:01] Right wing “sexual matador” joke, media personas
• [74:01] Senator Jon Ossoff interview

Tone and Style

• The hosts blend urgency, disbelief, humor, and empathy; serious moments are punctuated with wry, sometimes gallows humor to underline the absurdity of events.
• The interview with Senator Ossoff strikes a hopeful yet sober tone, focusing on structural reform, persistence, and optimism in the face of clear threats to democracy.

Closing Thoughts

This episode of Pod Save America is a deep dive into the spiraling descent of American governance into overt political retribution and authoritarianism. The hosts highlight how each new act of bad faith by the administration becomes the “new normal,” and stress that the only way out is through nonviolent, broad-based resistance, smart messaging, and active defense of institutions and rights. The conversation with Senator Ossoff amplifies the urgency: corruption and threats to democracy are intertwined, and defeating Trumpism will require honesty about the system’s flaws, hope in collective action, and, above all, relentless determination.

For further resources or ad-free episodes, the hosts encourage support for Crooked Media’s work through a paid subscription.