Pod Save America: "Trump Promises Free Speech Crackdown"
Date: September 16, 2025
Hosts: Jon Favreau, Jon Lovett, Tommy Vietor
Notable Guest: Senator Chris Murphy
Episode Overview
This episode centers around the rapid political fallout from the assassination of Charlie Kirk and the Trump Administration’s announced crackdown on left-leaning groups and perceived "radical left political violence." The hosts break down the rhetoric from Trump, Stephen Miller, and Vice President J.D. Vance as they call for aggressive investigations and legal action against progressive foundations, media organizations, and activists. The show dissects the implications for free speech, the reality behind the administration's claims, and the risks of political violence in America. They also touch on developments regarding TikTok, a shakeup at CBS News, New York’s mayoral race, and interview Senator Chris Murphy for a sobering look at what might come next.
Key Discussion Points & Insights
1. The Aftermath of Charlie Kirk’s Assassination (01:55–17:46)
- Immediate Political Response:
Trump, Miller, and Vance, in public statements and on Kirk's show (guest-hosted by Vance), escalate rhetoric against "left-wing" organizations, vaguely threatening to designate them as domestic terror groups and pursue RICO charges. - Expanding the Blame:
Vance and Miller lump together journalists, donors, and foundations with those directly involved in violence, painting a vast left-wing conspiracy. - Rhetoric vs. Law:
The hosts highlight the lack of any legal mechanism for designating domestic groups as terrorists or launching RICO cases without clear, direct links to violence. - Notable Moment:
“With God as my witness, we are going to use every resource we have… to identify, disrupt, dismantle and destroy these networks and make America safe again for the American people. It will happen and we will do it in Charlie's name.” - Trump (imitated by hosts quoting administration statements, 03:17)
2. The Feud Over "Political Violence" and Stats (04:22–11:20)
- Disputed Data:
Vance claims, erroneously, that most "lunatics" in American politics belong to the far left, citing a single online poll, while the hosts rebut with FBI and ADL data showing a rightward tilt in politically-motivated violence. - Both-Sides Hazard:
The hosts articulate how over-amplifying partisan blame increases support for political violence on both sides.- “Studies find that Americans are more likely to support political violence if they think the other side also holds those views.” - Tommy Vietor (10:24)
3. Chilling Effects and Free Speech Concerns (13:14–16:16)
- Intimidation Campaign:
The administration discusses stripping tax-exempt status from progressive foundations (Open Society, Ford, etc.), potentially freezing assets and bankrupting organizations without convictions. - Historical Parallel:
The strategy mirrors the Bush-era civil asset forfeiture and lawfare against Muslim charities after 9/11.
4. Cancel Culture from the Right (19:11–23:22)
- Naming and Shaming:
MAGA influencers, emboldened by Musk, target social media users who post about Kirk’s death, advocating calling employers and organizing digital mobs—a sharp reversal from their free-speech posturing.- “Now free speech is out. Cancel culture is back, and it's good now, right?” - Jon Favreau (19:44)
5. Dysfunction in Law Enforcement Leadership (25:23–34:49)
- FBI Turmoil:
A comical/chaotic portrait of Cash Patel, the Trump-picked FBI director, bungling communications and facing backlash from inside and outside law enforcement. - Partisan Loyalty Tests:
Reports of career FBI agents being grilled about their loyalty to Trump for job security.
6. Trump Admin’s Global Moves & Media Dealings (35:01–50:24)
- Trump Visits the UK:
The hosts sardonically ponder how international right-wing solidarity rallies around Kirk’s assassination. - TikTok "Saved":
Trump announces a deal to keep TikTok operating in the US—potentially with continued Chinese control over its algorithm—prompting skepticism over data privacy and political motives. - Legacy Media Shakeup:
CBS News' merger with a Trump-allied company leads to mass resignations, the hiring of a partisan ombudsman, and rumors of Bari Weiss taking a leadership role; hosts note this as part of the administration’s ongoing campaign against critical media.
7. New York Democrats and the Mamdani Dilemma (52:13–58:00)
- Party Divisions:
Democratic leaders face pressure to unite behind mayoral nominee Zoran Mamdani, while Trump threatens to pull funding and the party risks being seen as divided and reluctant.- "Being dragged to it doesn't help anybody. First of all, it's embarrassing for you. It makes people feel like you're not doing it for any other reason than political expediency." - Jon Lovett (54:44)
Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments
-
On the Rhetoric of Crackdown:
“What they're doing, still kind of vague, still very terrifying.” – Jon Favreau (03:58) -
On Free Speech Hypocrisy:
“Remember when Elon bought Twitter as he said, it was because he was a free speech absolutist? … Now these guys are creating spreadsheets, and Elon Musk is helping unleash these online mobs on the platform that he purchased to be a free speech absolutist. And it's just like. It's absurd.” – Tommy Vietor (19:58) -
On Government Crackdown Precedents:
“There is no law that would allow the president … to designate a domestic group as a terror organization. … What you do is basically freeze the assets of a group that you think is part of a conspiracy and they can sue to get those assets back. But it basically ties them up for years in court.” – Jon Favreau (12:24) -
On the Broader Problem:
“Meanwhile, we have this toxic political culture that he (Vance) is of course contributing to by saying they're going to target the broad left and foundations. Because there was an article in the Nation he didn't like, an article nobody read.” – Jon Lovett (08:58)
Interview: Senator Chris Murphy (60:32–81:14)
Main focus:
Sen. Chris Murphy warns of a “very dark” period if the Trump Administration succeeds in using legal means to suppress the left. He details the risks, the mechanics of possible legal harassment, and the lack of Republican will to act as a meaningful check. Murphy underscores the importance of holding the line on budget negotiations to prevent DOJ abuse and challenges the left to organize, not retreat.
Key moments:
-
“Trump is … looking for a pretext all year in order to supersize his efforts to try to use the legal system in this country, which he now controls, out of the White House, in order to destroy his political opposition… What has already been a pretty dark year could get a lot darker.” (61:00)
-
On possible constraints: “I just don't believe that, that the Democratic Party has an obligation to fund the destruction of our democracy. … We need to start drawing lines in the sand about what kind of government we’re willing to fund and what kind we're not willing to fund.” (77:58)
-
On fighting despair:
“We need to actually see in the coming, coming weeks and months there being bigger protests, there being more people signing up for activists and mobilization efforts than ever. And if we do that, then you will … prove to folks who may be thinking of sitting on the sidelines now that the times are getting darker that there's safety, that there's sort of safe space to still remain involved in our democracy.” (70:07)
Timestamps for Important Segments
- 01:55 – Show begins, main topics introduced
- 02:57–06:58 – Breakdown of Trump/Miller/Vance rhetoric and threats
- 10:22–11:20 – Impact of political rhetoric on support for violence
- 13:14–16:16 – Legal mechanics of crackdown, civil forfeiture parallel
- 19:11–23:22 – “Cancel culture” from the right, Musk and Vance
- 25:23–34:49 – Law enforcement chaos, Cash Patel’s NBC performance
- 35:01–50:24 – International implications, TikTok deal, CBS shakeup
- 52:13–58:00 – New York Democratic drama and endorsements
- 60:32 – Interview with Senator Chris Murphy begins
- 77:58–81:12 – Murphy on defending democracy in Congress
TL;DR
This episode navigates the dangerous mix of political violence, escalating political crackdowns, and attacks on free speech in the wake of Charlie Kirk’s assassination. The hosts lay bare the bad faith, flawed legal strategies, and deep division permeating U.S. politics—and highlight just how vulnerable democracy becomes when power is wielded vindictively. The conversation with Senator Murphy further drives home how perilous and pivotal the coming months may be, making a passionate plea for Democrats and activists not to retreat, but double down on defending democratic values and institutions.