Pod Save America

Episode: Trump's Indefensible Pardons
Release Date: January 24, 2025
Hosts: Jon Favreau, Dan Pfeiffer, Jon Lovett, Tommy Vietor
Guest: Faz Shakir, DNC Chair Candidate

Introduction

In this episode of Pod Save America, hosted by Jon Favreau and Dan Pfeiffer of Crooked Media, the hosts delve into the tumultuous first week of former President Donald Trump's second term. The discussion centers around Trump's flurry of executive orders, with a particular focus on his controversial pardons of individuals involved in the January 6th Capitol riot. The episode also features insights from Faz Shakir, a candidate for DNC chair, who shares his vision for revitalizing the Democratic National Committee.

Trump's First Week: A Deluge of Executive Orders

Timestamp: [01:46]

Trump's return to the Oval Office was marked by an unprecedented onslaught of 48 executive orders and actions aimed at reshaping American governance and societal norms. Highlights of these orders include:

• Revisiting Biden's Investigative Actions: Trump ordered a review to "correct past misconduct related to the weaponization of law enforcement and the weaponization of the intelligence community."
• Withdrawal from International Agreements: The U.S. exited the World Health Organization and the Paris Climate Agreement.
• Environmental Policies: Suspension of leases for offshore wind farms and incentives for electric vehicle purchases.
• Immigration Crackdowns: Deployment of U.S. troops to the southern border, establishment of a mass deportation force, and directives to prosecute state and local officials opposing these actions.
• Policy Overhauls: Attempts to end birthright citizenship, suspension of asylum and refugee programs, dismantling diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives, and freezing federal hiring with the intent to replace non-political civil servants with Trump loyalists.
• Security Clearances: Granting top-secret clearances to White House staff without proper background checks and revoking clearances of 51 individuals associated with the Hunter Biden laptop controversy.
• Emergency Price Relief: An order directing all executive branches to provide price relief to Americans, notably affecting sectors like egg pricing.

Jon Favreau summarizes, “That's a lot. We're gonna spend some time on the pardons and immigration in a bit.”

Focus on Trump's Pardons

Timestamp: [05:02]

The pardons issued by Trump, particularly those related to the January 6th defendants, have sparked significant controversy. Hosts analyze the breadth and implications of these pardons:

• Dan Pfeiffer emphasizes the symbolic danger of these actions, stating, “...it all sends a message to the Project 2025 goons who be running this government about what they should do.”
• Jon Favreau criticizes the sincerity of Trump's price relief measures, labeling them as "window dressing" and highlights the broader impact of the pardons on societal safety and trust in law enforcement.

Case Study: Michael Fanone

Timestamp: [08:37]

A poignant example discussed is the case of Michael Fanone, a D.C. police officer severely injured during the January 6th riot. Fanone's ordeal, including the physical and psychological trauma he endured, serves as a stark contrast to the leniency shown to his assailants through Trump's pardons.

Jon Favreau narrates Fanone's suffering, “He suffered burns, a concussion, traumatic brain injury and a heart attack... And now he is free.” This leniency has left Fanone seeking protective orders against pardoned rioters who now pose ongoing threats.

Political Implications of the Pardons

Timestamp: [11:54]

The hosts delve into the ramifications of Trump's pardons on the Republican Party and broader political landscape:

• Dan Pfeiffer articulates the polarization within the GOP, referencing Frank Woolhoit's quote about conservatism and the differential application of law based on political alignment.
• Jon Favreau warns of the potential for increased political violence, noting, “...right-wing extremists who were armed, who committed violence... are out of prison.” This scenario fosters an environment where extremist groups feel emboldened to act with Trump's implicit support.

Immigration Directives Under Trump

Timestamp: [28:15]

Trump's aggressive immigration policies are scrutinized for their impact on national security and societal cohesion:

• Dan Pfeiffer explains, “He is trying to remove all obstacles to anyone who will stand up against him.”
• Jon Favreau adds that Trump's directives aim to redefine American identity, targeting not just illegal immigration but also legal immigrants on visas, thus broadening the scope of immigration control beyond traditional boundaries.

Interaction with Elon Musk on AI Initiatives

Timestamp: [31:53]

A lighter yet telling segment covers the public spat between Elon Musk and Sam Altman over Trump's AI initiative:

• Dan Pfeiffer comments on Musk's feud with Sam Altman, suggesting it stems from personal disagreements rather than genuine concerns over AI.
• Jon Favreau humorously portrays Musk's involvement in government AI projects as petty, highlighting the absurdity of billionaires engaging in high-stakes tech rivalries reminiscent of a "high school cafeteria."

This exchange underscores the chaotic intersection of technology, wealth, and politics in Trump's administration.

Republican Response to the Pardons

Timestamp: [14:01]

The episode highlights the lack of unified Republican support for Trump's pardons:

• Jon Favreau points out that even some Republicans find it challenging to defend the pardons, noting, “I think every elected Republican should be asked that question.”
• Despite this internal discord, the majority of the GOP remains silent or dismissive, concerned more with maintaining allegiance to Trump than addressing the moral and legal issues posed by the pardons.

Democratic Strategy and Response

Timestamp: [27:35]

The conversation shifts to the Democratic Party's response to Trump's actions and the broader political strategy:

• Jon Favreau critiques the Democratic approach, arguing that the party often prioritizes economic issues over addressing the ramifications of Trump's aggressive policies and pardons.
• Dan Pfeiffer emphasizes the need for Democrats to tell a cohesive story that not only condemns Trump's actions but also highlights the long-term threats they pose to American democracy and societal stability.

Insights from Faz Shakir, DNC Chair Candidate

Timestamp: [66:34]

In an insightful interview, Faz Shakir outlines his vision for the DNC to become a more grassroots, working-class oriented organization:

• Faz Shakir highlights the necessity of rebuilding the Democratic coalition by engaging directly with economic justice movements and leveraging media to amplify grassroots struggles.
• He criticizes the current DNC's lack of ambition and proposes a more community-centric approach, “...membership to our organization is not merely a contribution, it is us being in community with you.”
• Shakir also addresses media asymmetry, advocating for the DNC to enhance its media presence by producing compelling, non-partisan content that resonates with everyday Americans.

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

1. Dan Pfeiffer:
   “It is deeply dangerous... We're going to spend some time on the pardons and immigration in a bit.”
   [05:02]

2. Jon Favreau:
   “I think the pardons are the fullest expression of that famous quote from Frank Woolhoit... Conservatism consists of exactly one proposition...”
   [13:48]

3. Dan Pfeiffer:
   “These pardons are very unpopular... Most voters are not going to know this happened or understand exactly who he pardoned and what those people did and what the consequences are.”
   [15:38]

4. Faz Shakir:
   “We have to have solidarity within a structure to have some power. This is what unions are about.”
   [66:35]

5. Jon Favreau:
   “If the pardons do not raise awareness, they are doing more harm than good.”
   [27:21]

6. Faz Shakir:
   “If you are a working class party, you associate with the working class struggles in all different fronts...”
   [68:06]

Conclusion

The episode of Pod Save America presents a critical examination of Donald Trump's initial actions in his second term, particularly his expansive use of executive orders and controversial pardons. The discussion underscores the potential long-term threats these moves pose to American democracy and societal harmony. Additionally, the insights from Faz Shakir provide a roadmap for the Democratic Party to rejuvenate its grassroots connections and improve media strategies to effectively counteract Trump's influence. The episode serves as a call to action for Democrats to adopt a more unified, community-focused approach in the face of growing political polarization and extremism.

Listen to the full episode on YouTube or your preferred podcast platform every Tuesday and Friday. Subscribe to Friends of the Pod for exclusive content and ad-free listening at crooked.com/friends.