The Nancy Guthrie Case Just Got More Complicated—Here's Why Profilers Are Concerned More than 33 days into the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie, investigators are now turning to criminal profilers as the case enters a critical new phase. What are experts like Mary Ellen O’Toole, Jim Clemente, and Joseph Scott Morgan saying about the offender’s behavior, the negative DNA results, and the shifting direction of the investigation? Tonight on Police Off The Cuff, we break down the profiling insights, the downsized task force, and what these developments could mean for finding Nancy.