Caught Stealing

Summary

Pop Culture Happy Hour – "Caught Stealing"

Date: September 2, 2025
Host: Glen Weldon
Guests: Tre’vell Anderson (journalist & podcast host), Kate Young (podcast producer, film & culture critic)

Episode Overview

This episode centers on a lively roundtable discussion of the new film Caught Stealing, directed by Darren Aronofsky. The group explores the film’s effectiveness as a throwback crime thriller, its heavy reliance on tropes and cliches, its cast, pacing, and the overall lack of artistic innovation. The conversation examines not only the film’s strengths and weaknesses, but also what it says about Aronofsky’s evolving directorial style.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. The Setup: A Familiar, Trope-Laden Crime Caper

• Caught Stealing follows Hank (Austin Butler), a down-on-his-luck bartender in 1990s New York’s East Village, whose life unravels after he agrees to cat sit for his neighbor and stumbles into a violent criminal feud over stolen cash.
• The cast includes Zoe Kravitz, Bad Bunny, Regina King, Liev Schreiber, Vincent D'Onofrio, Matt Smith, Griffin Dunne, and Carol Kane.
• The team notes its homage quality: “Think Hitchcock’s The Wrong Man meets Reservoir Dogs,” with clear genre influences.
  (Introduced by Glen Weldon, 02:53–05:02)

2. General Impressions & Tone

• Kate Young: Enjoyed the cast and “watching the film,” but uncertain what to expect from Aronofsky; finds it “a significant improvement” over The Whale but says many plot points “don’t all fit.”
  (04:14)
  • Quote: “Did I like this film? I didn’t not like this film.” – Kate Young (04:14)
• Tre’vell Anderson: Describes it as a “Sunday Afternoon movie”—mildly entertaining but not memorable. The film evokes nostalgia for channel-surfing, but “doesn’t stick to you in any real way.”
  (05:14–05:47)
  • Quote: “You enjoy it, you watch it, and then at the end, you’re like, huh, okay.” – Tre’vell Anderson (05:47)
• Glen Weldon: Calls it “very simplistic, but satisfying,” engineered with classic screenwriting cliches (“Screenwriting 101”), likening it to a rollercoaster that’s “hilariously obvious and kind of artless.”
  (06:18–08:01)
  • Quote: “They’re going full Robert McKee at this thing, and I’m like, okay, this is what we’re doing. All right? I kind of respect that. It never tries to hide the fact that it’s pushing your buttons.” – Glen Weldon (07:12)

3. Predictability and Pacing

• The film is “extremely predictable” and “artless,” with every plot twist easily anticipated.
  • Quote: “By the halfway point, we’re just getting a hat and a hat. It’s the same stuff over and over and over again.” – Kate Young (09:09)
• The movie’s structure is compared unfavorably to music “to solve rather than enjoy,” reducing engagement.
  • Viewers found the repeated tropes and length led to disengagement—even questioning where they were in the story due to perceived faux-endings and slow pacing.
  • Quote: “It’s just too long. I’m not against a particular runtime, but you feel every single minute of this movie.” – Kate Young (11:39)

4. The Cast: A Saving Grace Amidst Weakness

• All agree the impressive cast is a highlight, with standouts like Regina King and fun cameos (Griffin Dunne).
• However, even star power can’t elevate the script’s limitations, and some cast were underutilized.
  • Quote: “I think the cast is the reason why I was, like, excited to check it out... even Regina King has to fill in the roles between the major, you know, career-defining ones as well.” – Tre’vell Anderson (10:51)
  • Regina King is praised, but it’s noted even she can’t fully overcome the writing (“…she can do no wrong in my book… will I mention Caught Stealing? Probably not.” – Anderson, 10:51)

5. Representation and Use of Characters

• Kate voices frustration at the use of Black female characters as narrative devices—a tired trope that “is very easily avoided if you pay attention.”
  • Quote: “The way that he uses the Black female characters... was the biggest black mark for me.” – Kate Young (12:35)
• Tre’vell echoes this criticism, calling it “disappointing to see yet another trope,” especially in portrayals of people of color—“definitely leaves you with a sour taste.” (12:45)

6. Aronofsky’s Directorial Choices and Tone

• The panel explores how this film feels at odds with Aronofsky’s typical work (usually “tough to sit through” or challenging the audience).
  • Here, he plays it for genre satisfaction and catharsis: “not hand wringing at the nature of violence” but seeking to “deliver satisfaction at the end.”
  • Glen: “I think it makes it a fascinating movie from Darren Aronofsky, who does not do that.” (14:24)
• There’s surprise at the humor and tonal inconsistency: the film is unexpectedly funny but also graphically violent, creating “wild” swings in mood.
  • Quote: “A lot of this is really funny... but for me, as someone who does not like to see people get beat up, I had to cover my eyes a few times.” – Kate Young (14:24)
  • The violence and multiple false endings left viewers restless and disengaged. “Is the movie over yet?” (15:02–15:49)

7. Period Authenticity and Production Design

• Glen brings up the film’s evocation of 1990s New York, noting the “authenticity”—black-walled bars, band stickers, grimy settings, payphones. The team generally agrees these details felt right, though younger panelists can only judge by perception.
  • Quote: “I could feel Paul’s bar. I could smell Paul’s bar. He got the details right.” – Glen Weldon (17:17)

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

| Timestamp | Speaker | Quote | |-----------|-------------------------------|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------| | 04:14 | Kate Young | “Did I like this film? I didn’t not like this film.” | | 05:47 | Tre’vell Anderson | “You enjoy it, you watch it, and then at the end, you’re like, huh, okay.” | | 07:12 | Glen Weldon | “They’re going full Robert McKee at this thing, and I’m like, okay...I kind of respect that.” | | 09:09 | Kate Young | “By the halfway point, we’re just getting a hat and a hat. It’s the same stuff over and over and over again.” | | 10:51 | Tre’vell Anderson | “I think the cast is the reason why I was, like, excited to check it out...even Regina King has to, you know, fill in the roles between the major...career defining ones as well.” | | 11:39 | Kate Young | “It’s just too long. I’m not against a particular runtime, but you feel every single minute of this movie.” | | 12:35 | Kate Young | “The way that he uses the black female characters... was the biggest black mark for me.” | | 12:45 | Tre’vell Anderson | “It’s actually quite disappointing to see yet another trope.” | | 14:24 | Glen Weldon | “It makes it a fascinating movie from Darren Aronofsky, who does not do that.” | | 17:17 | Glen Weldon | “I could feel Paul’s bar. I could smell Paul’s bar. He got the details right.” |

---

Timestamps for Key Segments

• 02:53 – Introduction to the film, cast, and premise.
• 04:14 – Kate shares her reaction and comparison to other Aronofsky films.
• 05:14 – Tre’vell offers a “Sunday Afternoon movie” analogy.
• 06:18 – Glen deconstructs the film’s reliance on storytelling cliches.
• 09:09 – Predictability and repetitive tropes discussed.
• 10:04 – The ensemble cast is dissected.
• 11:39 – Criticism of pacing and structure.
• 12:35 – Discussion on problematic depictions of Black female characters.
• 13:03 – Aronofsky’s track record and this film’s place within it.
• 14:24 – Surprise at tonal shifts and violence.
• 15:49 – “Artless” execution and production design.
• 16:56–17:17 – The authenticity of New York, 1990s setting.

---

Final Thoughts

The group broadly concurs: Caught Stealing is entertaining in the way of an old fashioned, trope-heavy genre film, technically proficient but ultimately uninspired and unmemorable. Its modest pleasures are largely due to a game cast and solid period details, but it’s held back by a predictable script, meandering pace, reliance on cliches, and underwhelming representation choices. As an entry in Aronofsky’s filmography, it’s a surprising (if forgettable) experiment with convention.

Consensus: Worth watching only if you’re in the mood for a low-stakes crime romp or are devoted to the cast. Otherwise, likely to fade from memory as the credits roll.

Transcript

[A]

This message comes from NPR sponsor Capella University. Interested in a quality online education. Capella is accredited by the Higher Learning Commission. A different future is closer than you think with Capella University. Learn more at capella. Edu.

[B]

In the film Caught Stealing, Austin Butler is a sad sack bartender. Just by agreeing to cat sit for his neighbor, he gets dragged into a world of grisly violence as competing criminal faction threaten his life and his loved ones as they search for a huge wad of cash that they are wrongly convinced he is hiding. It's a throwback film, for whatever that's worth. It's the kind of film they don't make anymore. Think Hitchcock's the Wrong man meets Reservoir Dogs and then throw in a great cast. Zoe Kravitz, Bad Bunny, Regina King, leo Schreiber, Vincent D' Onofrio and Matt Smith. I'm Glen Weldon. This is NPR's Pop Culture Happy Hour, and we're talking about Caught Stealing.

[A]

This message comes from Apple Pay. Forget your wallet. It's all good because with Apple Pay, you can pay with a simple tap of your iPhone, the wallet you never forget at millions of places worldwide, including websites, apps and anywhere you see the contactless symbol. Security is built in with face ID so you don't have to worry about your cards getting lost or stolen. And the best part is you still earn the card rewards, points and cash back you love. So say goodbye to the bifold, add your card to Apple Wallet and start paying the Apple Way terms apply. This message comes from Schwab. Everyone has moments when they could have done better. Same goes for where you invest. Level up and invest smarter with Schwab. Get market insights, education and human help when you need it. This message comes from NPR sponsor Capella University. Sometimes it takes a different approach to pursue your goals. Capella is an online university accredited by the Higher Learning Commission. That means you can earn your degree from wherever you are and be confident your education is relevant, recognized and respected. A different future is closer than you think with Capella University. Learn more about earning a relevant degree at Capella.

[C]

Eduardo this message comes from Moises, proud supporter of NPR music and the 2025 Tiny Dess giveaway. You can win a trip for two to see a Tiny Dess concert live at NPR's headquarters. Enter for free by September 12th and increase your odds by donating to the NPR Network. Support comes from Moises, your AI powered studio created by Musicians for musicians. Learn more at Moises AI. No purchase or donation required for entry. Must be 18 years or older to enter links to the entry page and official rules can be [e-mail] tinydeskgiveaway.

[B]

Joining me today is journalist and host of the podcast Black Queer Canon Travel Anderson. Hey, Trevel.

[D]

Hello.

[E]

Hello.

[B]

Hello. And also joining us today is podcast producer and film and culture critic Kate Young. Welcome back, Kate.

[E]

Hi.

[B]

I am so curious what you thought of this film. Let's get into it. In Caught Stealing, Austin Butler is Hank, a bartender in an East Vill dive bar in the 1990s. His girlfriend Yvonne is an EMT. She's played by Zoe Kravitz. When his British punk neighbor Russ, played by Matt Smith, asks him to cat sit, Hank finds himself in the wrong place at the wrong time and gets brutally beaten up by a bunch of criminals led by Bad Bunny. When he turns to the cops for help, a sympathetic detective played by Regina King informs him that he's become entangled in a war between various crime families, including one that includes two Orthodox Jewish brothers played by Vincent d' Onofrio and Liev Schreiber. Hank's life comes as the criminal underworld becomes convinced that he knows where a huge cache of stolen cash can be found. Will Hank fight back? Can Hank fight back? It's directed by Darren Aronofsky, who's made great films like Requiem for a Dream, the Wrestler, and Black Swan, but who most recently made a very, very terrible film called the Whale. Which one of them showed up for Caught Stealing? We're gonna find out. Kate, what'd you think?

[E]

I mean, did I like this film? I didn't not like this film.

[B]

Okay.

[E]

I enjoyed the experience of watching this film. I mostly had a good time. I am fond of a good cross section of this cast, so it was fun to, you know, spend some time with them. But I'm not really sure what I was expecting from Aronofsky. I wanted to do crimes over the Whale, so I think that on that bit alone, this is a significant improvement. But there are a lot of points, I think, like bullets that he kind of checks off as he goes. And I don't know that they all fit. I think the individual pieces mostly work. I have some other quibbles, but, I mean, we'll get into those later.

[B]

Yeah, we will. I think in many ways, what's most interesting about this film is that it's a Darren Hornofsky film, if that makes sense. We'll talk about it. But, Trevel, I glean from the giggle that you're a little less sold on.

[D]

This film, you know, so you. One thing Interesting. I thought you said, Glenn, is that this is the kind of movie they don't make anymore, Right. For me, it was the kind of movie, you know how back in the day, you used to just scroll through the cable box to find something on TV when you couldn't. You couldn't self select, you know? And so it reminds me of just flipping through the channels, and then you stumble on something, and you're like, yeah.

[E]

Sure, I call this Sunday Afternoon movies.

[B]

Yeah, absolutely.

[D]

You enjoy it, you watch it, and then at the end of it, you're like, huh, okay. And then you just go on about your life like it doesn't stick to you in any real way. And, you know, maybe movies don't need to stick to people all the time, but it was something that I was just like, huh, okay. You had these people doing these roles. Interesting.

[B]

You know, before we started recording, we kind of gave, like, brief heads up, and I was like, oh, I'm more positive on this film than either of these two folks are. I don't know if that's true now. I think from the tone you both are giving me, I'm kind of there. I found this film very simplistic, but satisfying. And I think that is because that's exactly what it's engineered to be. You can feel Every single screenwriting 101 tenant maxim cliche. Let's just call them what they are. Cliche. Just the ways to get an audience on your protagonist's side. A way to win them over and make them care about your hero, including, but not limited to Save the Cat, which comes into play here. But they just keep piling up in a way that I found kind of hilariously obvious and kind of artless. I mean, they're going full Robert McKee at this thing, and I'm like, okay, this is what we're doing. All right? I kind of respect that. It never tries to hide the fact that it's pushing your buttons. I mean, I don't think. I would never call this film stylish or innovative in any way, but it is what those screenwriting cliches exist for it to be, which is effective for me. I mean, you get on the roller coaster, you start going up that first incline, you hear the gears kind of chunk into place. Tragic backstory, Chunk. Save the catch. Something in Hank's past has to be confronted, embraced, addressed, if the film's gonna allow him to stop suffering. Ka Chunk. I mean, it's very Old Testament, this film, right? Very Book of Job. We even get the Ka Chunk. Of you can't pull that trigger. You're not a killer. Which. It is the year of our Lord 2025. We cannot still be doing this. Cinema is over 100 years old.

[D]

But we are.

[B]

But we are in this film. Treyville. Exactly. But as things got worse and worse for Hank, I found myself just kind of shrugging like, okay, this is it. And Trevill, you're right. The second you leave this theater, this movie just dissipates. But when I was in that van or SUV or whatever, riding with Schreiber and d', Onofrio, I was along for that ride.

[D]

You know, this is the beauty of, like going to the movie theater to watch a movie, right? You have to be on the ride, you know, I mean, you could leave if you want to, but you kind of have to be on the ride. I kind of found myself wanting to be let off personally because to your point about these, you know, age old tropes that we see here after the first one or two fall into place, I think if you're used to watching these kinds of movies, then you can kind of peg some of the others that are going to come. Right.

[E]

Extremely predictable.

[D]

For me, it made it difficult to watch. Like, I was along for the ride and then I was also like, side eyeing everything. I was like, where's the next trope coming from? Because I feel it just around the corner.

[E]

I think in addition to the fact that the movie's so tropey, by about the halfway point, like, we're just getting a hat and a hat. It's the same stuff over and over and over again. And it really, it made me think of the way that we talk about music being something to solve as opposed to something to enjoy. Like, by the time we'd gotten there, I'm just sitting there being like, yep, call that.

[B]

Yep.

[E]

Call that. I knew that was gonna happen. Call that. There was no surprise really anymore. And I do think that, like, the performances are good enough to kind of make the runtime. Well, not quite worth it. That's a whole other issue. But to make it so that I could at least enjoy myself while I was there. I don't know that this is a movie that I would recommend to people. It is not the crime against humanity that the whale is, but it is also, like, honestly, even on a Sunday afternoon, I don't know that I would recommend to watch this. It's just. It's so artless.

[B]

Yeah. You mentioned the cast, which is a saving grace this film has. Let's talk about that. Griffin Dunn is in this film as Paul, the owner of the bar that Hank works in. He's in it because he's Griffin Dunn and he's great. He's also in it because it's a shout out to After Hours, a film that this is definitely drafting off of. Regina King is in this movie playing a badass. What's going to be wrong with that? Roger Ebert used to say, if Harry Dean Stanton or M. Emmett Walsh is in a movie, it can't be a bad movie. I was going to update that with Regina King, then I went to her IMDb page and, you know, she's got a long career, let's just put it that way. She's been around a lot. So I'm not gonna say that because I'm not gonna be out here in these streets defending daddy daycare. But she's always fun. Schreiber, d'. Onofrio. Carol Kane is in this. They're having a ball. Trevel, did you have a ball with them at least?

[D]

I mean, I think the cast is the reason why I was, like, excited to check it out. You know, Regina King can do no wrong in my book, even in this movie, for the record, she could do no wrong. Now when I am recapping her brilliance on screen, will I mention caught stealing? Probably not. You know, but even Regina King has to, you know, fill in the roles between the major, you know, career defining ones as well. Right. But there are so many names that I think is going to pull people in. But I personally was let down. You know, you've got Zoe Kravitz, you've got Regina King, you've got Liv Schreiber. What are we doing here? And this is kind of what we get as the result.

[E]

I think one of the biggest issues I had with this one is that it's just too long. I'm not against a particular runtime, but, like, you feel every single minute of this movie to the point that, like, I don't even remember what the plot point was, but I was like, oh, right, we must be in like Act 3. And I looked at my watch, we were an hour in and it kept happening. Like, I think that the pace of this movie is really, really off. It doesn't make sense. There are like three different endings. I really wanted to like this. I am a huge Austin Butler fan. I was rooting for him after Elvis. Like, I loved him in Dune. Like, I do think that this is a really good role for him. That I think is the first thing. But this movie is not structured in such a way that it allows any of the people in this film to do any of their best work. They kind of can't. And I don't know that that is their fault. I think the one thing that I was really, really frustrated with is the way that he uses the black female characters.

[B]

Right.

[E]

And we don't necessarily need to get into that, But I think that was the biggest black mark for me. Mostly because it's the kind of thing that is very easily avoided if you pay attention.

[D]

It's actually quite disappointing to see yet another trope. Right. The way all the folks of color, you know, but particularly the black women are used in this narrative definitely leaves you with a sour taste, you know, if you come from a particular kind of intersection.

[B]

Right. This is an Aronofsky film. Now, I think it's safe to say that Aronofsky's film historically, are tough to sit through. He tests audiences. He doesn't go for crowd pleasing. That's not his thing. But this film has such a simple, pulpy formula. He makes the Hank character go through such crap that he's playing with fire. Because when you manipulate an audience's emotions to the extent that he does here, we all know we've seen movies before, Hank has to get something like a moment. He doesn't have to have a big Rambo retribution, but there has to be a moment of catharsis, and it needs to land. If you are torturing your protagonist to the extent that he does here, and by extension, torturing us, and you don't give us that moment of catharsis, we are gonna come after you with torches and pitchforks. Right. Unless you're going art house, I guess. Right. Unless you're doing Requiem for a Dream where the bleakness is the point, or you're doing, like, Michael Hennick of Funny Games, where your point is, let's indict the audience in their delight of violence. Blah, blah, moralistic bs. That's not. This, I think, is aimed squarely at the Cineplex, not the art house. I think there is plenty of moralistic BS in this film, all that Book of Job stuff. But it is in service to delivering that satisfaction at the end, not hand wringing at the nature of violence. I gotta respect it for that. I don't think it makes it a particularly interesting movie. I think it makes it a fascinating movie from Darren Aronofsky, who does not do that.

[E]

Yeah, I think that was probably the thing that I was most surprised about. It did not feel tonally like, something I would expect from him. And in returning to, like, the way that the rhythm of this film is off, the tone of this film is off, it just goes wildly from one end to the other. Because a lot of this movie is really funny. Yeah, right. And that's not something that you necessarily think is coming after the first, you know, inciting incident happens. Like, there is so much punching in this movie. And I'm not against that. I think for the most part, it actually makes sense. But for me, as someone who, like, does not like to see people get beat up, like, I had to cover my eyes a few times. People really get beat up.

[B]

Yep.

[D]

I'm not too into the fighting and the gore and all of that either. K. I definitely, you know, covered my eyes or closed my eyes a couple times as well. And yet that kind of stuff didn't keep me, you know, like, I kept seeing all of that and then just kind of feeling like, okay, is the movie over yet? Because like you mentioned earlier, there are a number of points that feel like endings, and yet we keep going. And maybe that gets to your point, Glenn, about kind of just the energy and the style that perhaps Darren was trying to convey with this film compared to some of his others, and the pacing with some of the others, but it didn't quite, you know, connect for me.

[B]

We've used the word artless a couple times in this podcast so far. I mean, that's what it feels like. It just feels like, let's get them to point B as quickly and as efficiently as possible. Which means we're sacrificing things like nuance and depth. Okay, so I have a weird question to ask you both about the production design of this film. I spent a lot of time in New York in the 90s. That is not a brag. I could have made better choices. But, you know, in and around the Lower east side, in the east village, in St Mark's Place, I have been to those dive bars with the same black walls covered in, you know, the white graffiti and the band stickers that are all kind of yellow because they're nicotine stained. And you walk in and you're hit with stale beer and broken toilets. And there's a shot in this film walking past a Kim's video. And y', all, I felt a physical. Like a pang of loss, a physical pang, like someone had poked me in the stomach. Now, y' all are young, and when you look at the New York of this movie, does the fact that they went the extra mile for some of that authenticity. Does that register with you in any way? Or do you look at this film and you just see it like, oh, well, this is a period piece.

[E]

I mean, I would have been eight at the time of this film.

[B]

That's what I was trying to allude to without saying it outright. But thank you.

[E]

So I can't really speak to you to the authenticity of it. I will say that there's a point in which Zoe Kravitz's character calls a cab. And I was like, why is she calling a cab? And I was like, right, no, but it's 998.

[B]

And the payphones. I was like, oh yeah, payphones. I can tell when he picked up a payphone, I knew that the earpiece was going to be greasy with somebody else's skin. I knew that the bar in Paul's bar was sticky. I could feel Paul's bar. I could smell Paul's part. He got the details right. That's what I'll say. I thought we were gonna fight over this movie, but I think we kind of all were in the same page at the end. I think we all arrived at exactly the same place. Well, tell us what you think, though, about Caught Stealing. You can do that on letterboxd or on Facebook if you're one of my angrier aunts and uncles. We'll have links in our episode description. That brings us to the end of our show. Get young Treyville Anderson. Thank you so much for being here.

[D]

Thank you, thank you.

[E]

Thank you so much for having me.

[B]

This episode was produced by Carly Rubin, Janae Morris and Mike Katsif and edited by our showrunner, Jessica Reedy. And hello. Come in provides our theme music. Thanks for listening to Pop Culture Happy Hour from npr. I'm Glenn Weldon and we'll see you all next time.

[C]

This message comes from Mint Mobile. Mint Mobile took what's wrong with wireless and made it right. They offer premium wireless plans for less and all plans include high speed data, unlimited talk and text, and nationwide coverage. See for [e-mail] Switch this message comes from NPR.

[A]

Sponsor 1Password Protect your digital life with 1Password if you're tired of family members constantly texting you for the passwords to streaming services, 1Password lets you securely share or remove access to logins access from any device anytime. 1Password lets you securely switch between iPhone, Android, Mac and PC with convenient features like autofill for quick sign inside. Right now, Get a free 2 week trial for you and your family at 1Password.com NPR this message comes from NPR sponsor Capella University interested in a quality online education. Capella is accredited by the Higher Learning Commission. A different future is closer than you think with Capella University. Learn more at Capella. Eduardo.