Loading summary
Transcript70 lines
- [00:00]
NPR Sponsor Announcer
This message comes from NPR sponsor Carvana. Your time is worth more than a waiting game. Carvana gives you a transparent offer for your car in minutes and picks it up from your door. Sell your car today@carvana.com pickup fees may apply.
- [00:16]
Aisha Harris
You're listening to Pop Culture Happy Hour, the podcast that keeps you plugged in about the latest and greatest in movies, tv, music and more. And if you're a pop culture junkie who's not following the show yet, we are recommending you fix that right now by following Pop Culture Happy Hour on
- [00:31]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
your favorite podcast app. And now onto the show.
- [00:38]
Aisha Harris
The cult favorite satire the Comeback has returned for a third and final season and we definitely needed to see this once again. The great Lisa Kudrow is Valerie Cherish, the resilient sitcom star who's always finding new ways to reinvent her career within
- [00:53]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
the fickle entertainment industry.
- [00:55]
Glenn Weldon
It's been more than a decade since we last checked in, so where is Valerie now? Well, the present is bleak. The new show she's starring in is being written by AI. But if we know anything about Val, it's that she'll always seize an opportunity, setbacks be damned. I'm Glenn Weldon.
- [01:11]
Aisha Harris
And I'm Aisha Harris. And today we're talking about the Comeback on Pop Culture Happy Hour from npr.
- [01:21]
BritBox/Progressive Insurance Announcer
This message comes from Britbox presenting on the Box, a new podcast taking listeners inside the world of BritBox and British TV with talent interviews and behind the scenes stories hosted by Edith Bowman and Michelle Collins. Available now wherever you get your podcasts. This message comes from Progressive Insurance. Do you ever think about switching insurance companies to see if you could save some cash? Progressive makes it easy to see if you could save when you bundle your home and auto policies. Try it@progressive.com Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates. Potential savings will vary. Not available in all states.
- [01:56]
NPR Sponsor Announcer
This message comes from NPR sponsor Carvana Making buying a car 100% online with real transparent pricing and customizable financing that fits your budget. Browse thousands of cars and get yours delivered. Visit Carvana.com today. Delivery fees and terms may apply.
- [02:15]
Aisha Harris
Joining us today is freelance music and culture journalist Rihanna Cruz.
- [02:18]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
Welcome back, Rihanna.
- [02:19]
Rihanna Cruz
Happy to be here. How's that?
- [02:21]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
How's that?
- [02:24]
Aisha Harris
That's great.
- [02:25]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
I love it.
- [02:26]
Aisha Harris
So in the Comeback, Lisa Kudrow plays Valerie Cherish, a 90s sitcom star who's gone through many career ups and downs over the years. Season one aired in 2005 and was a mockumentary inspired by the Em emerging reality TV craze. A camera Crew followed Valerie around as she returned to tv, starring in a network comedy series called Room and Board. Nine years later, season two followed Valerie's role playing a fictionalized version of herself on an HBO drama inspired by Room and Board's tumultuous behind the scenes production.
- [02:56]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
Meta, meta so, so, so meta. Now in season three, Valerie's career is on the downswing again, especially now that
- [03:03]
Aisha Harris
she's a woman of a certain age.
- [03:05]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
Those are not my words. That is the show words. I'm just going to clarify that right now.
- [03:10]
Aisha Harris
Her newest gig is as the star of how's that? A multicam sitcom where she plays a single woman of a certain age running
- [03:17]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
a bed and breakfast with her nephew.
- [03:19]
Guest or Producer (possibly Mike Katsuff or another contributor)
How's that such a good hook? You know, you can say it so many different ways, right? How's that? How's that? How's that right? Oh, so good.
- [03:32]
Aisha Harris
But here's the the network producing the show is secretly relying upon an AI app to write the script. Despite her reservations about this, Valerie commits to the part and even signs on as an executive producer and puts her reputation and career on the line. This season sees a return of a lot of familiar faces, including Damien Young as Val's weary but supportive husband Mark Laura Silverman as Jane, Val's steadfast documentarian and Dan Bukatinsky as Billy, Val's shrewd publicist turned manager. The plus, there are some new additions like Andrew Scott as the network head and John early and Abbi Jacobson as the sitcoms human writers. They've been hired as cover to keep the public from knowing about the AI script. The final season of the Comeback is airing on HBO and streaming on hbo Max and Rihanna.
- [04:18]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
We're gonna start with you. Are you happy that the Comeback is back?
- [04:22]
Rihanna Cruz
Absolutely. I mean, I love the Comeback. I think Valerie Cherish is an icon. I see the Comeback as perhaps the greatest comedic character study of the 21st century. In my opinion, it's used as a prism to understand Hollywood, you know, And I think the first season was about forging who Valerie Cherish was, the Valerie Cherish Persona. The second season for me was cracking that visage. You know, you watch her kind of short circuit and in this season we see who Valerie Cherish is picking up the pieces and rebuilding herself after the past decade. And I thought the season was really funny. I think there's a lot of elements to it that call back to the first two seasons, particularly the first season's use of chaos. You know, there's a lot of shots in this season that they have a lot going on. There's a couple moments in this season where I felt like it was very uncut gems coded, you know, like people talking over each other. You're trying to listen to three different conversations at the same time. There's so many issues at once. But it really leans into the dramedy aspects that I think the second season nailed. The third season, again, it's funny. I have some weird tonal whiplash with the issues that they do in this season. There's conflicting messaging at times. I think it suffers at points from the Michael Patrick King problem where it was kind of giving in just like that to me at times where characters were having strange motivations and plots kind of appear and disappear. But that's okay. I don't come to the Comeback to save the world. I come to it to make me laugh.
- [06:17]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
Yeah. As you know, Michael Patrick King is known for the In Just like that Sex and the City world, but he
- [06:23]
Aisha Harris
also co created this show with Lisa Kudrow.
- [06:26]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
And there's a lot of, like, a little bit of overlap there in terms of how they think about women and women of a certain age. But I think the show handles it a lot better than and Just like that. But we're not talking about that. Glenn, I know you are a huge fan of this show. Are you happy that this has come back?
- [06:44]
Glenn Weldon
Oh, so happy. Look, a new season of the Comeback is something of note in the wider world, in the gay community. It's an event. I've said it before. The Tonys are the gay Oscars. The Oscars are the gay Super Bowl. Eurovision is the gay Olympics. I'm going to add to that and say that a season of the Comeback is the Gay World Series, Something we tune into, we follow over successive nights. We invest in it deeply. Now, that metaphor doesn't hold up, of course, because the Comeback only comes back once every 10 years, like the census. And like the census, it kind of always finds a way to kind of situate us. Right. It's like the Census. It's always an appraisal, a taking of stock. It always comes at a crossroads in the entertainment industry. Now, admittedly, I have never been a Sex and the City gay. I've always been a Comeback gay. And I don't judge Sex in the City gays except in the sense that I very much do. I mean, I think there are Andrew Lloyd Webber gays and there are Sondheim gays, and Andrew Lloyd Webber is hugely popular. He's left a much bigger cultural footprint than Sondheim ever will. Sondheim is just better. I think that kind of extends here. And because of. And just like that, I imagined having to watch this show the way people watch that show. Hate watching this show. Hooting at it. With the original, I didn't want to do that, but this is perfect. It's not the same show that it was in the first two seasons because we've changed, and Valerie has changed in ways I hope we're going to talk about. I just think it's richer. I think the satire hasn't gotten soft, but it has grown, it has adapted. But we still get jokes about Real Housewives in Chicago and jokes about people watching epics on Roku. To answer your question, yes. And please, I'm also mostly relieved.
- [08:21]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
Yes. Yes. I love so much shade thrown to the streaming epics. Yeah, I love that. I'm gonna show my hand here and also admit something embarrassing, which is to say that I was not a comeback fan before this new season was announced. And that's not because I had seen it and decided it was not for me. It just slipped me by. I was in College in 2005 when the first season dropped. So, like, I was not on hbo. Like, that was not my world. Like, could not afford it. And that just wasn't something I was paying attention to. And then, you know, in 2014, I felt it came and went, and I didn't tap in then. And so to prepare myself for this, I binged the first two seasons ahead of watching the third season. And my goodness, a show that was meant for me, and it took me this long to find it.
- [09:11]
Glenn Weldon
I knew it. I told you.
- [09:12]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
What the hell? What the hell? Like, this is my catnip. And Lisa Kudrow, she is just so brilliant. And everything you've said about the way this show has built upon itself and really kind of just become more rich with each season, I think is absolutely true. What I find interesting about this is, you know, I've written in the past about, you know, something I've called Hiatus Brain, which is like, shows that come and then go way too long in between. You know, I'm thinking of your better call saws, your Atlanta's. You're like, shows that kind of, to some extent, depend upon you being able to follow them regularly because there's too much stuff that gets forgotten. And when they go away for two, three, sometimes even longer years, you have to pick back up, and it takes a long time to get there. And I admit I did not have that experience with this show because I Binged it all at once. But I think this show absolutely actually is like the rare piece of work that actually benefits from having so much time in between, even if that wasn't the creator's choice. Because having this season be about AI first, of course, it's inevitable. Like, what else would you really do about that? Michael Patrick King has talked about how the first thought was like, this made it into the first episode of this season. It focusing on her, Valerie having the natural progression for an actress of a certain age who also is, like, in her, like, kind of B listy, cusp of a list territory, being in a production of Chicago. Of course, she would be the next person to step into the lead of
- [10:46]
Rihanna Cruz
Chicago, the dumbed down version, as they call it.
- [10:49]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
Yeah, yes, yes, of course. That is what it is, but that can't be the focus. They recognize that Chicago would not sustain itself. And I think the AI of it all really, really works. I mean, what I will say, though, is there is a tweak in the format of this season because the first two seasons, they commit completely to the mockumentary style. Like the Comeback. The first season, it is, you know, you are seeing the raw footage of that show and that is how you view it. And so there's a lot of moving around, moving parts, and, like, people who are like, what is this? Like, you have to sign a waiver. Like, there's all those moments. And in season two, you know, it's kind of a similar thing. Here we have the tweak because of the setup, where we instead get sort of a single camera comedy, like a straightforward comedy, and then it brings back in the mockumentary style, but it keeps jumping back and forth. So, like, what do you make of that tweak here? Like, do you think it still works?
- [11:48]
Rihanna Cruz
No, Absolutely. I noticed immediately because there's a lot of weird shots of, like, the iPhone, you know, and it's like somebody holding the iPhone in the shot is the screen of the iPhone. I'm of two minds on the cameras. I don't know if I like the look of them. It feels a little strange to me, But I do like what they do. And I think the implementation of diegetic camera versus removed camera showcases the distance that Val keeps between her public and private Personas, which is something that they started to get to at the second season. And here you fully see that distance and that divide. And I do like that move in what the cameras represent. And you could see Lisa Kudrow flip a switch on in Valerie when she's being filmed versus when she's not being filmed. And I think it's a very subtle character move that I appreciate. And it's something that we haven't seen before, except for the end of the second season.
- [12:48]
Glenn Weldon
Right. And that's why I think it's a natural progression, narrative and character progression. Because in that last few scenes of the season two finale, we go from shaky cam to, you know, ostensibly filmed reality, like the actual objective reality. And that's a stepping into Oz kind of moment. That's like a big breakthrough moment. And it seems like that's a continuation of the way Valerie's changed. Because this performance as Valerie, I don't think it can be overstated. It's so layered, it's so nuanced. It always has been, but in a way that, especially in that first season, you might have been tempted to dismiss it as camp. And I understand that impulse because, you know, at the center of the show is a woman of a certain age who is desperate. And that's the formula for camp. That's drag. There's so much more going on because the physicality of Valerie remains funny. She goes through life nodding like a bobblehead at everyone and everything. And you heard it in that clip. We played every sentence out of her mouth. You is punctuated at the end with a yeah, or, you know, or. Right. And that's learned behavior. Right? Because that's such a great character thing. Because we know that Valerie has learned. The world's not going to affirm me in any way. It's gonna find new ways to dismiss me. I'm just gonna affirm myself like a habit, like a vocal tick. But what Kudru is doing in this season is different. She has tweaked the feel mixture a bit. And look, Valerie was never stupid. She was never obtuse. She's always been. She's always been aware of when she's being slighted, insulted, dismissed by people. She has just historically refused to acknowledge that. She swallows it, she rolls with it. She refuses to be humiliated. And that's what we love about her. But in this season, it's like she is slightly foregrounding the self awareness in a different way. And it's kind of matched to action. So she stands up for herself in ways that she never did before. We can't imagine her doing before. And that's on the stage with the dancers in Chicago with a costume designer, a little bit later in the season with network executives. That is such a smart progression. She's still funny. She's still starved for attention, but it's just that the nature of it, the attention she's craving has slightly changed. Because before, all she wanted was to be seen. And now she wants and expects and even demands to be heard. And that's why it's not better. It's just richer. And that's why I think it works so well.
- [15:08]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
Yeah, I mean, that's the thing, right? That's what comes with. I mean, something I'm slowly learning and something I've learned from the women who. In my life who are older than me by a decade or two. The older you get, the less. Insert word here you give. And to be able to see that progression of where she's at now and the fact that she is, like, insistent, you know, this is another aspect of this season, is her and Billy, her publicist, being the executive producers on this show. Now, does she understand what that means? No. Is she ready to step up to that challenge? Not exactly. And it plays out in very interesting ways this season, the way that she has to juggle both being the star and being the executive producer, which comes with more responsibilities than she is actually prepared for. But the way she handles it, it's handled in the way that you would expect her to handle it. But she's also learning and growing and getting better at it as it goes on. And it's just nice to see a character who. I mean, I've seen her described as delusional, and I think to some extent, that might be true, but not in the way that we often think about it. Not in the, like, disparaging way, but just in a way like she is Orphan Annie to some extent. Like, she is always gonna find a way to make things better and see things as good as she can, because that's all she has. All she has is herself. And of course, she has Mark, too, her husband. You know, she has people in her corner, but there are moments where, you know, she is not perfect. She's also kind of not mean, but she can be stern. And I think the way this show handles how Hollywood, from what I have been able to glean from the outside, it really does a good job of showing that everyone is on a different journey and everyone has different ways of interpreting this industry. There's a version of Valerie that could be awful and horrible and horrific. Look, she's had moments in the past. Season two was fueled by an incident that happened on the set of Room and Board with Pauly G, played by Lance Barber. And Paulie G, of course, was one of the Writers on room and board.
- [17:11]
Aisha Harris
She was not her best self.
- [17:12]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
I like the fact that everyone has where they're not their best self and not necessarily their greatest. But also the show overall has a sort of optimism and matter of fact way of approaching just like what it means to be someone working in the
- [17:26]
Aisha Harris
industry and not just actors too.
- [17:28]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
We hear from writers and directors, like, what did you think of the new characters? Especially, you know, we have Andrew Scott, as we mentioned, as the network executive. But then we also have Abbi Jacobson and John early playing, I think a married couple, which I find hilarious. They mentioned that they're married a couple times and I'm like, oh, sure. But like, do you think they're kind of integrated in a way that works this season?
- [17:51]
Rihanna Cruz
I don't know. I don't really think they're integrated very well. I think some characters work better than others. I particularly love Valerie's social media manager, Patience, who's a gen zer who always has some medical problem. Yes. She gets stung by a bee. She has Covid. Her leg is in a boot. Like these things I think are funny and contribute to the comedic energy of the show. I think the other characters that aren't Valerie and Mark and Billy, her manager and executive producing partner, they all kind of exist to serve the show's messaging. I don't really think they exist as characters. Yeah, the new characters.
- [18:37]
Aisha Harris
Gotcha, Gotcha.
- [18:38]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
Yeah.
- [18:38]
Glenn Weldon
I think I'm picking up on something that Rihanna mentioned because I think Valerie's still funny. But there's something about a self actualized Valerie that changes the comedic chemistry of the show. I can think of two occasions when the show descends into what I can only call abject sincerity. Cause on one occasion, there's this beloved kind of Hollywood legend who gets a monologue to explain to Valerie how AI will never write good comedy because good comedy needs broken people. Whether or not you agree with that. I happen to agree with that. But like we're just getting it flatly asserted. And on another occasion, much later in the season, a character from the first season shows up to. It seems to me to do one and only one thing, which is to just reassure Valerie that she's a good person, She's a wonderful person. She's completely in the right. I know this show. Right. I love this show. And I'm watching those scenes and I keep waiting for the reveal, the turn, the rug pull, and it never comes. And I'm like, well, there's no way this show would let the mask kind of slip like that. It would Just let the creator's true intent kind of come through, especially in a way that's so, like, basic, plain, direct. I was kind of stunned that we're not getting statements like that or approaches like that at an angle, because this show is all angle. But then I remembered something you mentioned at the top. Aisha, which. This is the final season. Kudora said, this is the final season. If it is. Those moments, they still stick out. They're a victory lap. They're the curtain call when the creators step out from behind the curtain and take a bow. That's kind of the way I felt.
- [20:12]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
I mean, I think about Jane, Laura Silverman's character as the director who's kind of always served as. Especially season two on. She kind of becomes the person who's always questioning, like, Valerie, why are you doing, like, you are being humiliated? What are you doing here? Like, I want better for you, I want better for me. And to see the arc of that sort of relationship come around and also just to see again, we learn, like, she's won an Oscar, right? But, like, she's working at Trader Joe's now. It's like, this is the reality of being in Hollywood and not being a list and not being the top 1% of Hollywood. This is the reality. I really appreciated those moments where we get to see all these people wrestling with that while also wrestling with, like, the doom that is already at our doorstep of AI Just kind of taking over. I also just think Andrew Scott, he's doing that Ripley thing again where he's just, like, kind of dead behind the eyes and it works.
- [21:09]
Glenn Weldon
Oh, those black eyes. Yes, those jet black eyes. The shark's eyes.
- [21:13]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
I enjoyed it a bit.
- [21:14]
Rihanna Cruz
Well, the Andrew Scott character gets at something for me that wasn't present in the first two seasons. And it's this bleak energy to everything. And I think it's because, you know, they're holding a mirror to what's going on in Hollywood right now. I think of the conversation in episode two where Jane and Valerie at Trader Joe's are talking about how they were affected by the fires.
- [21:37]
Guest or Producer (possibly Mike Katsuff or another contributor)
And then the fires happen.
- [21:39]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
All that craziness.
- [21:41]
Guest or Producer (possibly Mike Katsuff or another contributor)
I thought about you guys. Aw. Yeah. Well, we almost had to evacuate, so. Oh, wow. Yeah. Your house is good. No, our whole canyon burned because we didn't pay off the right fire department.
- [21:53]
Rihanna Cruz
It's a weird conversation. It's played for laughs, and I think it should be. But it kind of underscores this tone difference where they're trying to address these issues. Sometimes it comes off as flippant. In the sake of being funny, which is fine. Never before have I left a season of the Comeback feeling weirdly hopeless. Right. Like, I think at the end of each season, I come out of it feeling perhaps, I don't want to say hopeful, but, you know, feeling a little bit better about the state of Hollywood at the time. When this show ends, I, like, was sad. I have this empty feeling it is because it reflects Hollywood right now and things are not good. But that's an interesting thing that the show is trying to do. And I don't know if it's intentional or not, but the way that Michael Patrick King is weaving these issues into the show, it's inherently political. And when you contrast it with Val's apolitic, it's strange to me.
- [22:57]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
I can definitely see that if you think about the way the show has really been able to help make sense of different moments, different inflection points in Hollywood and in culture. I wonder, Rhianna, if you're like, well, how are you going to help us kind of parse out wherever we are in nine, ten years from now? Like, who knows where we're going to be nine, ten years from now? We might not even have HBO in nine, ten years from now. I don't want that. But you know how these things are going. I do wonder how much of that. I don't want to put anything on you, Rihanna, but like, at least to me, that's kind of how I felt totally. I do kind of want to keep revisiting this every five or ten years and like, there's just so much to say and knowing that this could be the final. It's just kind of like, well, who will help us explain everything? It's bleak. But also, I do think as the season progresses, it does a good job of not kind of falling necessarily on one side or the other, at least presenting different ideas and really sort of capturing a sense I get of what people in Hollywood might be feeling about AI and it's not all the same. People can understand the way things work and change is happening and some are more ready to adapt to it than others. And I liked that. I think it was important to show that because I've been very anti AI for many reasons, but I also understand that there are different versions of AI and ways to use them. So I'm trying to be open minded and I think this show does too.
- [24:25]
Glenn Weldon
I also think this show's relationship to its rabid gay fan base is pleasantly complicated because there's moments in this show where A little bit later in the season, Benito Skinner plays a costume designer who wants to reduce Valerie's character to a camp icon. And she pushes back on that in a way that she would never have done in season one. And in that scene in the first episode where she's on stage in Chicago, one of the dancers is totally in her corner. Yes. Diva Slayer. There's another who is just bitchy, Just Joan Crawford and the women. And there we go. There's the totality of gay men and straight women right there, encapsulated in a very cynical but very funny way.
- [25:13]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
Yeah. I mean, I would feel weird ending this episode without even mentioning the fact that Robert Michael Morris, who played Mickey, her hairdresser, who was just such a lovely character over those two seasons and has since passed away. Passed away in 2017. But I think the show does a good job of sort of, like, acknowledging that in ways that feel real. And also, again, that relationship was, yes, there's Mark, but also there was Mickey. And Mickey brought out so much of the best of Valerie in ways. And I think this season does a good job of both honoring his memory and also reminding us that Valerie is, yes, she could be all about herself, but she also cared about the people who really, really rode for her and loved her. And it's very sweet and pleasant, I think.
- [26:00]
Rihanna Cruz
I agree. I think the absence of Mickey also highlights Valerie's character change, you know, because if nobody's there to advocate for her, she has to advocate for herself.
- [26:10]
Glenn Weldon
That's a great point.
- [26:11]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
Oh, Mickey, we love you. The Comeback. Loved you. What a fun show. Well, that brings us to the end of our show. Brianna Cruz, Glen Weldon, thanks so much for being there. How's that? I think it was great. I think we did great.
- [26:25]
Rihanna Cruz
How's that?
- [26:26]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
How's that? Thank you.
- [26:29]
Aisha Harris
This episode was produced by Hafsa, Fatima
- [26:31]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
and Mike Katsuff and edited by our showrunner, Jessica Reedy.
- [26:35]
Aisha Harris
Hello.
- [26:35]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
Come in.
- [26:35]
Aisha Harris
Provides our theme music. And thank you for listening to Pop
- [26:38]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
Culture Happy Hour from npr. If you're not already following the show,
- [26:42]
Aisha Harris
do that right now.
- [26:43]
Host (possibly Linda Holmes or similar NPR host)
And I'm Aisha Harris. We'll see you all next time.
- [26:51]
NPR Sponsor Announcer
This message comes from Great Wolf Lodge, where there's family fun all under one roof, including an indoor water park, attractions, dining, and more. With 22 lodges across the country, you're only a short drive away from adventure. Learn more@greatwolf.com this message comes from a US bank. Simplify how you do business with business essentials. A powerful combination of no monthly maintenance fee, checking and card payment processing. Deposit products are offered by US Bank national association member fdic. This message comes from Grainger. For the ones who get it done, Grainger offers the professional grade products you need to get the job done with fast delivery and access to technical product experts ready to help you meet any challenge, call click grainger.com or just stop by.