
Loading summary
A
So there's this thing called the engagement leak and it's the reason you are losing users despite a record breaking marketing spend. Now, I know this sounds crazy, celebrating growth while you're actually bleeding out, but here is how the math of behavioral science actually works. Most analytic tools will tell you where people are leaving. They show you they're dropping out at step X, but they are silent on the why. And today we're looking at three world class examples to reveal the leaks that traditional data misses and how to plug them using the octalysis framework. You are currently pouring money into a sieve. Yeah, that is actually a real word. S I E V E. Look it up. Acquisition is getting more expensive, yet retention remains as a black box at the octalysis group. These kinds of problems are what we solve on our daily basis through our consulting. We have over 170 clients, which is the biggest client base of any gamification consultancy. And we've done this not only for small companies, not only for this or that. We've done it for Fortune 500, we've done it for startups, we've done it in the crypto sector and web 3. We've done pretty much everything and everywhere, FCMG, education, we've done so many things. And in this video I will show you how to transition from a product that people start to to use to one that they stay with. We will analyze things like the onboarding leak, the novelty leak, and the end game leak. But before we dive into the first story, if you want to see what the octasis core drives look like in real businesses, go ahead and grab our free drive core drives in the wild. I break down examples, real examples from past episode guests through the lens of each of these core drives and show you how these core drives translate into practical business outcomes like retention, referrals and revenue. Find it on the link in the description, skim the first day's example and then come back to see how the three engagement leaks in this episode map to the exact same framework. I want to start by an example of this app that did something that most experts said it was a waste of time because there was no way that you could scale this thing with. When they launched, they didn't send you the download link. Instead they put a massive wall. They didn't just let you go in, they said you need to be on a 30 minute one on one video call. We're talking about superhumans unscalable onboarding. They were not teaching the features to the user, they were engineering Coredrive 2 development and accomplishment. By the end of that call, the user hit inbox zero. That's a first major victory. If what you're doing for an onboarding looks like either VCR manual or one of those videos that nobody wants to watch, you are most probably having a massive leak on your onboarding. So I just want to ask you, does your user feel like a superhuman like the app within the first three minutes, or just as an admin of the software you're selling to them? The second story is about this app, this trading app that famously used digital confetti to celebrate every single trade. Initially, for sure, it was a massive hit. You give them confetti and people trade more, right? Eventually, that magic starts to completely wear off. The confetti became absolutely invisible. You clicked on the button of the trade and you knew your brain already knew confetti was coming out, so it literally disappeared in front of your eyes. And then, of course, the habit was never able to stick. Initially, that confetti was hitting core drive 7. Unpredictability and curiosity. It's a black hat. It's an. It's an intrinsic motivation. It's a core drive. It's intrinsic motivation creates, however, what we can call a novelty hangover. After you do it many times, there's no more novelty. You enter the hangover stage to bridge that gap after, you know, a month or even a few weeks or two months, you need to start introducing things like Core Drive 3, empowerment of creativity and feedback. When this shiny concept starts wearing off, the user needs to feel they're getting a better skill. They're. They're getting better at something. They're able to make their own decisions. You need to transition as well to more white hat motivations. They're not just watching a light show. You're thinking of these apps that are not just a thing that you use for a few minutes and then are done with. You're thinking about apps that keep people coming back. Think of a trading app like Robinhood, which is the one that we've been discussing. So after the novelty fades from your ui, what meaningful choice is keeping your user in that flow state? So let's move on to our third example. And here I'm gonna straight up front tell you the company that it's about. It's about Harley Davidson. These, you know, the big motorcycles, very noisy that have, you know, massive fans and people who just don't like it because it's too noisy or whatever. In Harley Davidson, they don't just sell these bikes, they sell the Hog or the Harley Owners group. Veterans become mentors when they reach a level cap. They go so far as far as they can. In a normal game that hasn't thought about this, people would just abandon. They would just leave because they get bored. In this case, you give them core drive four ownership and possession core drive five. You give them a bunch of motivations so that they stay and they go beyond that scaffolding phase and you actually design for their end game. If your two year power user is treated the same way as your day 10 user, they actually rather find a new mountain to climb. What is the status? What is the mentorship role that is available to your most loyal and long living users? If any of these stories feel a bit too familiar, it's a sign that your leaks aren't technical. They are entirely behavioral. You can't really patch a hole if you don't really know if the pipes are broken or how to fix them. That's why I want to invite you to click on the link below and get our free guide Core Drives in the wild. Once you go through it, or actually while you're going through that guide, you will find how some of these implementations are actually familiar things that you could be doing right now. And of course if you want expert help, you will definitely find a way to get us for a strategy call or whatever it is that you are needing. And there we'll map your core drives, we'll look into your specific situation and figure it out. So right now what you need to do immediately is stop guessing why your users are leaving you. You want to go ahead and find that leak. And as always, as we like to say in the end of the podcast, as you know, at least for now and for today, it is time to say that it's game over.
Podcast: Professor Game Podcast
Host: Rob Alvarez
Episode: 441
Date: April 20, 2026
In this solo episode, Rob Alvarez tackles a counterintuitive but crucial problem: the "engagement leak" — why companies can achieve impressive user growth yet still lose users at alarming rates. Exploring the behavioral side of retention, Rob explains how standard analytics only tell part of the story and demonstrates how gamification (specifically the Octalysis Framework) reveals and helps close these leaks. He shares three case studies across different industries to illustrate onboarding, novelty, and endgame leaks, providing actionable lessons for product leaders, educators, and innovators.
On the Analytics Gap:
"Most analytic tools will tell you where people are leaving... but they are silent on the why." — Rob ([00:17])
On Superhuman's Onboarding:
"By the end of that call, the user hit inbox zero. That's a first major victory." — Rob ([02:01])
"Does your user feel like a superhuman... or just as an admin of the software?" — Rob ([02:14])
On Novelty Wearing Off:
"Eventually, that magic starts to completely wear off... your brain already knew confetti was coming out, so it literally disappeared." — Rob ([02:44])
On End Game Design:
"If your two year power user is treated the same way as your day 10 user, they actually rather find a new mountain to climb." — Rob ([04:51])
On Behavioral Leaks:
"If any of these stories feel a bit too familiar, it's a sign that your leaks aren't technical. They are entirely behavioral." — Rob ([05:03])
Rob Alvarez delivers a fast-paced, insight-packed solo episode revealing the hidden behavioral cracks that can drain user engagement despite strong growth. Using vivid case studies and Octalysis-inspired analysis, he equips listeners to spot and fix onboarding, novelty, and endgame leaks. The episode is an essential listen (or read) for anyone invested in lasting user engagement, revealing that the true retention battle is psychological, not technical.
"Stop guessing why your users are leaving you... go ahead and find that leak."