The Department of Homeland Security Theater

Summary

Podcast Summary — Radio Atlantic: "The Department of Homeland Security Theater"

Date: March 26, 2026
Host: Hanna Rosin
Guests: Nick Miroff (The Atlantic immigration staff writer), Janae West

Brief Overview

This episode of Radio Atlantic delves into the evolving role and perception of the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), with a focus on the recent and controversial deployment of ICE (Immigration and Customs Enforcement) agents at U.S. airports amid a TSA staffing crisis. The episode critiques what the hosts describe as the "theater" of DHS policy, evaluating both political optics and operational reality. The conversation also explores the agency’s ongoing rebranding under its new Secretary, Markwayne Mullin, and how mass deportation policy is shifting to become more effective—if less visible—in the public eye.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. ICE at Airports: Origins and Intentions (01:05–10:22)

• Trigger Event:
  ICE agents were deployed to airports during a lapse in DHS funding, prompted by a suggestion on a conservative radio show, quickly adopted by President Trump.
  • “He loved it enough that he brought it up on Fox News later that day.” — Hanna Rosin (01:37)
• Political Theater vs. Practicality:
  The move was largely symbolic—a show of toughness amid TSA shortages—rather than an effective operational solution.
  • Quote:
    “My first thought was, this isn’t gonna help. Second was that this is consistent with the way the President views ICE as more than like, a personal army, kind of like a personal errand corps.” — Nick Miroff (04:01)
• ICE's Real Role at Airports:
  ICE officers primarily stood around, providing a PR opportunity rather than substantial security assistance.
  • “All week, what we’ve seen is imagery of ICE officers mostly standing around. And ironically, it’s kind of a nice PR opportunity for an agency that has obviously been widely vilified over the past year for its role in places like Minneapolis.” — Nick Miroff (05:15)
• Split Public Perception:
  For some, the presence of ICE arouses fear—raising concerns about civil rights—while others find reassurance.
  • Incident Highlight:
    A viral video showed an ICE arrest at San Francisco airport, raising concerns about increased inter-agency data sharing and targeted operations, but not a sweeping change to ICE’s operational scope.

2. The Politics and Optics of Immigration Enforcement (10:22–16:15)

• Temporary Fixes, Long-term Consequences:
  ICE presence at airports is not a sustainable or efficient fix for TSA shortages and damages TSA recruitment.
  • “ICE…are supposed to be investigating drug cartels and human traffickers. And they’re out there standing around in the airport making five times as much as the TSA agents are supposed to be replacing.” — Nick Miroff (10:22)
• Rebranding & New DHS Leadership:
  Markwayne Mullin’s appointment as DHS Secretary signals a shift in tone—if not policy—after the controversial Kristi Noem era.
  • “He does have this reputation as a kind of jocular, back slapping, friendly guy...most importantly, the career workforce at the department...have been telling me that they’re very eager for a fresh start and that Mullen is saying all the right things to win them over so far.” — Nick Miroff (13:58)
• Mullin’s Background and Tensions:
  Former MMA fighter and Oklahoma Senator/congressman, seen as personally close to President Trump, has bipartisan rapport but is also experiencing internal Republican tensions.
  • Memorable moment: A play-by-play of a heated Senate exchange between Mullin and Rand Paul (12:07–12:14).

3. Rebranding ICE and Shifting Strategies (15:52–19:01)

• Quiet Reform, Same Goals:
  Under Mullin and "border czar" Tom Homan, the strategy is to carry out mass deportations—but more quietly, with less spectacle than under previous leadership.
  • “This is about delivering on the President’s mass deportation agenda, but more quietly, you know, without the kind of spectacle that the GNOME team has been producing.” — Nick Miroff (17:47)
• Change in Public Messaging:
  Moving away from overtly nativist and white nationalist messaging in recruiting and public affairs.
• Continued Influence Behind The Scenes:
  Tom Homan remains influential, focused on making the agency appear less aggressive in public while maintaining its core enforcement agenda.
  • “Tom Homan…has been trying to turn down the temperature…reassure Americans the uglier scenes…are gonna go away.” — Nick Miroff (16:15)

4. Policy vs. Optics: Targeted Enforcement and Mass Deportation (19:01–23:39)

• Underlying Agenda Remains:
  Despite softer rhetoric, the resources and legal mandate remain in place for ramping up mass deportations, including controversial tactics from the Trump administration’s first term.
  • “It isn’t like they’re going to really back off of mass deportations…and they are going to fulfill this agenda. They’re just going to manage the politics much differently.” — Nick Miroff (19:01)
• “Gentler Face,” More Effective Operations:
  Policy levers are being pulled with less visibility but more efficiency.
  • “You just can go and do it because you have the money and you have the personnel and you know how to execute these deportations. And that’s what Tom Homan represents.” — Nick Miroff (20:45)
  • “So the era we are entering is one in which ICE could have a gentler face, but is actually more effectively carrying out the President’s policies.” — Hannah Rosin (22:24)

5. Democratic Negotiation and Internal Reforms (23:39–25:35)

• Democratic Policy Demands:
  Democrats are pushing for limits on ICE tactics—like ending the use of masks and requiring warrants for home raids.
  • “You saw Mark Wayne Mullen, during the confirmation hearing say that he would return to the policy requiring ICE to have a judicial warrant to go into someone’s private home.” — Nick Miroff (24:28)
• Mask Policy Sticking Point:
  Despite concessions, ICE is holding onto mask-usage for officer anonymity, citing concerns over doxxing and safety for officers’ families.

6. Looking Forward: Mass Detention Centers (25:35–27:46)

• Agency Expansion:
  ICE is in the midst of a multibillion-dollar initiative to acquire and convert warehouses into mass detention centers across the country to meet aggressive deportation targets.
  • “They’re planning to convert them into large mass detention centers with capacity for, in some places, for up to 10,000 detainees…They have $38 billion to convert these facilities and to operate them through the rest of Trump’s term.” — Nick Miroff (25:55)
• Local Backlash:
  Even in Trump-friendly regions, there’s pushback against new detention centers, complicating permit approvals needed for expansion.

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• “ICE was my idea. I called. First person I called was Tom Homan. I said, what do you think?” — Quoting Trump, via Tom Homan (02:32)
• “This is consistent with the way the President views ICE as more than like, a personal army, kind of like a personal errand corps...” — Nick Miroff (04:01)
• “What he represents is this institutional—think of it as institutional ICE on steroids. You don’t have to go out and troll people visually or online…you just can go and do it.” — Nick Miroff (20:45)
• "My goal is for people to understand we’re out there, we’re protecting them, and we’re working with them. My goal is to make every one of you guys proud.” — Secretary Markwayne Mullin (17:33)
• “Because they’re worried about being doxxed and...their families being harassed. And, you know, I’m sorry, but that’s a real thing.” — Nick Miroff on mask policy (25:29)
• “That’s what I signed up for.” — Nick Miroff, reflecting the ICE officer mindset (23:30)

---

Important Timestamps

• 01:05 — Opening: Context, radio call, birth of the ICE-at-airports idea
• 04:01–05:47 — Nick Miroff explains the policy's symbolic nature and PR function
• 07:24–09:52 — ICE’s actual scope at airports and the role of data-sharing
• 10:22–14:08 — Discussion of DHS leadership, TSA morale, and the Markwayne Mullin confirmation
• 15:52–17:47 — Beginning of the agency’s rebranding and Homan’s mentorship of Mullin
• 19:01–22:34 — ICE’s pivot: less visible, more efficient deportation efforts
• 25:55–27:46 — ICE’s mass detention expansion and local opposition

---

Conclusion / Main Takeaways

• The ICE deployment at airports is largely a political performance, not a long-term operational solution.
• Debate over ICE’s public presence reflects deeper divides in how Americans perceive DHS and its agencies: as protectors, invaders, or both.
• With new leadership, the agency’s tone is shifting—less inflammatory, more “professional”—but the underlying mission (mass deportation and detention infrastructure expansion) is not.
• Internal reforms are happening, but some secrecy and aggressive tactics (like mask-wearing) remain, justified as necessary for operational security.
• The episode warns of a coming era of more efficient, less visible mass deportations—a “gentler face” for policies that remain fundamentally aggressive.

---

For Further Listening

Listeners left with questions about the humanitarian, legal, or logistical ramifications of ICE’s new direction are encouraged to follow The Atlantic's ongoing coverage of immigration policy and look for future episodes addressing mass detention and local reactions.

---

Transcript

[TikTok Advertiser]

So good, so good, so good.

[Nordstrom Rack Advertiser]

Spring styles are at Nordstrom Rack stores now and they're up to 60% off. Stock up and save on Rag and Bone, Madewell, Vince, All Saints and more of your favorites.

[Nick Miroff]

How did I not know Rack has Adidas?

[Radio Atlantic Host]

Why do we rack for the hottest?

[Nick Miroff]

Still just so many good brands.

[Nordstrom Rack Advertiser]

Join the Nordy Club to unlock exclusive discounts. Shop new arrivals first and more. Plus buy online and pick up at your favorite Rack store for free. Great brands, great prices. That's why you rack.

[Venmo Advertiser]

Score more with the College branded Venmo debit card and earn up to 5% cash back with Venmo Stash. Got paid back with the Venmo debit card. You can instantly access your balance and spend on what you want like game day snacks, gear, tickets and more. The more you do, the more cash back you can earn. Plus, there's no monthly fee or minimum balance. Sign up [e-mail] collegecard the Venmo MasterCard is issued by the Bancorp Bank N.A. select schools available. Venmo Stash terms and exclusions apply at venmo me stashterms max $100 cash back per month.

[Hannah Rosen]

The Department of Homeland Security is now weeks into its funding lapse. Last Friday, with TSA lines at airports growing, a woman named Linda called into a conservative radio show to offer a thought.

[Linda (Caller)]

Clay, I think I have a solution to the TSA problem. What we need to do is we need to supplement where we're missing out on TSA agents who can't afford to work for us anymore. We need to bring in ICE agents.

[Hannah Rosen]

The host, Clay Travis, loved the thought.

[Clay Travis]

Linda, that's I'm going to say it's

[Nick Miroff]

kind of a brilliant idea.

[Hannah Rosen]

He loved it enough that he brought it up on Fox News later that day.

[Clay Travis]

I had a caller on the show, the Clay and Buck show today. Charlie had an interesting idea. What if President Trump announced that ICE agents were now going to be supplementing TSA agents inside of all of the

[Hannah Rosen]

airports by the next morning? Trump floated the idea on Truth Social, threatening that if Democrats don't give in and fund dhs, he'd send ICE agents into airports, which he soon did.

[Radio Atlantic Host]

The White House deploys ICE agents to

[Hannah Rosen]

airports around the country today.

[Clay Travis]

Happening now. ICE agents have arrived at Hartsville Jackson International Airport and they love it because

[Tom Homan]

they're able to now arrest illegals as they come into the country. That's very fertile territory, but that's not why they're there. They're really there to help.

[Hannah Rosen]

Trump took credit for the ICE idea himself.

[Tom Homan]

Mine. That was mine. That was like the paperclip. You know the story of the paperclip? 182 years ago, a man discovered the paperclip. It was so simple. And everybody that looked at it said, why didn't I think of that? ICE was my idea. I called. First person I called was Tom Homan. I said, what do you think?

[Hannah Rosen]

I'm Hanna Rosen. This is Radio Atlantic. If ICE is now showing up at airports helping out tsa, then what even is ice? Their new role comes at a time when DHS has a new head. Mark Wayne Mullen.

[Tom Homan]

We're in. Our new Secretary of Homeland Security. Great American patriot, to put it mildly,

[Hannah Rosen]

who took a more conciliatory position during his confirmation hearings. When the Kristi Noem, Greg Bovino era of shooting citizens on American streets has come to an end. An act of domestic terrorism, the ICE officer fearing for his life, and the other officer. So does this mean that we're heading into a new era for ICE and dhs? And if so, what will it look like? To help me think through this, I talked to staff writer Nick Miroff, who covers immigration. Nick, welcome to the show.

[Nick Miroff]

Thank you, Hannah.

[Janae West]

Good to be with you.

[Hannah Rosen]

Okay, let's start with airport hell. As we know, there's a shortage of TSA agents, and then this idea comes seemingly out of nowhere to deploy ICE at airports to help alleviate these security lines. What did you think when you first heard this idea?

[Nick Miroff]

Well, my first thought was, this isn't gonna help. Second was that this is consistent with the way the President views ICE as more than like, a personal army, kind of like a personal errand corps, where if he needs some kind of, you know, job done and he wants the optics of toughness, he just calls on ice, which, once again, is just a gross misunderstanding of what that law enforcement agency's role is. And so over the course of last weekend, I initially wrote to some of my ICE sources, and they had no information about it. They had no idea what the operational plans were going to be. And then you kind of saw it take shape over the course of the weekend with the border czar, Tom Homan, going on the Sunday shows and seemingly doing a kind of damage control, like, oh, we're going to have them watching the exits and supporting tsa, which was an acknowledgement that they are not trained to do the core functions of tsa, which are the things that obviously slow the lines down.

[Tom Homan (continued)]

We're simply there to help TSA do their job in areas that don't need Their specialized expertise, such as, you know, screening through the X ray machine, not training that we won't do that, but there are rules.

[Nick Miroff]

All week, what we've seen is imagery of ICE officers mostly standing around. And ironically, it's kind of a nice PR opportunity for an agency that has obviously been widely vilified over the past year for its role in places like Minneapolis. They are in the airports without masks. They're handing out water bottles, they're smiling, and of course, they're getting some of the favorable coverage from people saying, oh, wow, they're actually really nice. They just walk by, hey, they're here to help, and I'm all for it.

[Janae West]

No problem.

[Nick Miroff]

You know, a lot of people have rightly commented that ICE officers in the airports remind them of the role that the National Guard is playing on the streets of Washington, D.C. because they just see National Guard troops kind of standing around and not really doing anything. You know, the kind of darker interpretation of this is that this is a test run for the President to deploy ICE officers to polling stations and intimidate voters in November. That's yet to be seen, but it is a reminder of the way the President views dhs, but specifically ICE as a kind of personal federal force that is at the beck and call of the President. And he can just deploy whenever he needs a tough job done.

[Hannah Rosen]

Right. Okay, so I want to split the darker and lighter interpretations, because I'm sure even at the airport, there are some people who are freaked out by the presence of ICE and other people who are happy and going over and shaking their hands. So to start with the freaked out, we did see, and then this polarization shows up in social media. So in the first days was this video of a woman at the San Francisco airport being pinned down by ICE agents while her daughter looked on. I'm asking for your badge number, sir. And then later, reports that TSA had shared information about this woman with ice. So, which brings up the specter of, oh, are airports going to become like, Minneapolis Streets or something? Like, you're not safe anywhere. ICE could just pop up at any place where all Americans do their business. So what do you think of that?

[Nick Miroff]

Yeah, good question. Let me try to add some context here. So, first thing to keep in mind is that there are already or were already ICE officers in international airports. Just like Customs and Border Protection is in the international airports, there are ICE officers there. In most cases, they're there for a specific purpose. But since the start of this administration, they have fulfilled the President's executive orders for DHS agencies to cooperate more on sharing information about potential immigrant targets that they want to arrest. Right. So you already have TSA doing more to share information with ice, flagging for ICE passengers who may have outstanding deportation orders or maybe people who ICE is looking for. And that was the case of this mother and daughter traveling through the San Francisco airport. It's important to point out that their arrest took place the day before the President sent the ICE officers out into the airports. And the tell that I noticed immediately was that the ICE officers who carried out this arrest were not only in plain clothes, they were undercover officers. They were wearing, like, hoodies and backpacks. And the presence of undercover ICE officers in international airports is not new. And in this case, they had been alerted to this family by tsa. The mother and her daughter reportedly had a final deportation order. So they're on this wider list of people who ICE is looking for. And so this was what the administration and Tom Homan calls a targeted enforcement operation, a targeted arrest.

[Hannah Rosen]

Okay. So if there's anything to fear there, in the long term, it's the increased data sharing between government agencies. It's not this temporary story about ICE agents at airports.

[Nick Miroff]

Yeah, ICE agents are not gonna be, like, sweeping through the airports looking for people to arrest.

[Hannah Rosen]

How do you know?

[Nick Miroff]

Because those are not their operational orders. Look at the images that we've seen so far. They're standing around chatting with each other, and they're handing out water bottles, and they're doing a soft PR campaign. What would be the political backlash after Minneapolis of having ICE agents sweeping through the airports, grabbing people and confronting U.S. citizens and harassing U.S. citizens? There doesn't seem to be a lot of appetite in the White House for that right now.

[Hannah Rosen]

Right. Okay, so everything you're suggesting, what I'm picking up is that this is kind of a PR campaign, a new part of a PR campaign. And I want to get to that in a minute. But first I want to close this off, which is this is just because of a temporary partial government shutdown. You know, Congress is currently negotiating. So are they just going to leave? Like, is this very temporary, is your impression? Sort of. Once we resolve the TSA funding, ICE will just leave?

[Nick Miroff]

Yeah, I mean, I think there's some long term damage being done to tsa. Right. This is like, what, the third time that they've not gotten paid? You know, reportedly hundreds of officers have quit. And what kind of message does this send as a recruitment? I mean, one of the crazy things about this is that TSA officers, they're not really, law enforcement officers, they're performing this vital function, but. But they're making like 40 to 50 grand a year. Meanwhile, you have ice, in some cases Homeland Security special investigators who are making 150 to $200,000 a year and who are supposed to be investigating drug cartels and human traffickers. And they're out there standing around in the airport making five times as much as the TSA agents are supposed to be replacing. So this is not a good solution and it's certainly not a long term solution. And yes, I would think that once they come up with a fix, ICE will get pulled back out of the airports because let's not forget, they're supposed to be carrying out the President's mass deportation campaign.

[Hannah Rosen]

Okay, so back to your specialty. Let's talk about ways that ICE is evolving, like the new leader of dhs, Mark Wayne Mullen. He was confirmed by Congress this week, sworn in. Who is he? What do you know about him?

[Nick Miroff]

Well, Mark Wayne Mullen was a senator from Oklahoma. He was a five time congressman from Oklahoma before that. He's got hardcore conservative credentials. And most importantly, he is someone who is personally close to President Trump and who obviously President Trump thinks fondly of and has served as a kind of go to ally. And you know, Mullen, his profile is that of a tough guy fighter, kind of a macho man.

[Mark Wayne Mullen]

You want to do it now?

[Nick Miroff]

I'd love to do it right now.

[Mark Wayne Mullen]

Well, stand your butt up then.

[Nick Miroff]

You stand your butt up. Oh, hold up.

[Tom Homan]

Stop it.

[Hannah Rosen]

Is that your solution?

[Tom Homan]

Every.

[Mark Wayne Mullen]

Pull it.

[Nick Miroff]

He was an MMA fighter. He's one of the only senators who didn't go to college for four years. He inherited his father's plumbing business and then, you know, expanded it. And he's attracted scrutiny for some of the investments that he's made over the years that have made him personally wealthy while he's been in Congress. But one thing that was notable during his confirmation hearing is that if you looked past the kind of personal animosity between Mullen and the chairman of the committee, Senator Rand Paul, fellow Republican, those two have a simmering beef. You offer no apology, sir, and you

[Tom Homan]

offer no apology today and no regrets.

[Nick Miroff]

If you look beyond that, he got a lot of kind of warm, supportive statements from Democrats. He obviously has friends among the Democrats. Are you a yes or a no on Senator Mullen's confirmation? Well, I came up with an open mind and I'm going to maintain that. That was always my. He got Senator Fetterman and Senator Heinrich from New Mexico to support his confirmation. And he does have this reputation as a kind of jocular, back slapping, friendly guy. And I think that that is the Persona he's trying to bring into DHS at a time when the department is looking for a kind of, you know, reset and a rebranding of its own. And most importantly, the career workforce at the department that has been demoralized by what they've seen over the past year where a lot of people were very disgusted with Kristi Noem and most importantly her chief advisor Corey Lewandowski. A lot of those people have been telling me that they're very eager for a fresh start and that Mullen is saying all the right things to kind of win them over so far.

[Hannah Rosen]

After the break how this next phase of DHS and ICE could be just as effective in the campaign of mass deportations without as many people noticing.

[Janae West]

Are you stuck staring at your W2? Are tax refund worries holding you back? You probably have FOMO the fear of messing up the fix. Using TurboTax on Intuit credit Karma, they find every credit and deduction to help you get every refund dollar you deserve or your money back. It's time to overcome your fear of messing up and get your taxes done right. Start filing today in the Credit Karma app.

[Hannah Rosen]

Chronic migraine is 15 or more headache days a month, each lasting four hours or more.

[Radio Atlantic Host]

Botox Onobotulinum Toxin a prevents headaches in adults with chronic migraine before they start. It's not for those with 14 or fewer headache days a month. It prevents on average 8 to 9 headache days a month verses 6 to 7 for placebo.

[Botox Advertiser]

Prescription Botox is injected by your doctor. Effects of Botox may spread hours to weeks after injection, causing serious symptoms. Alert your doctor right away as difficulty swallowing, speaking, breathing, eye problems or muscle weakness can be signs of a life threatening condition. Patients with these conditions before injection are at highest risk. Side effects may include allergic reactions, neck and injection site pain, fatigue and headache. Allergic reactions can include rash, welts, asthma symptoms and dizziness. Don't receive Botox if there's a skin infection. Tell your doctor your medical history, muscle or nerve conditions including als, Lou Gehrig's disease, Myasthenia gravis or Lambert Eaton syndrome and medications including botulinum toxins as these may increase the risk of serious side effects.

[Hannah Rosen]

Why wait? Ask your doctor, visit botoxchronicmigraine.com or call 1-800-44-BOTOX to learn more. Let's get into the rebrand because that could be superficial. It could be at the level of staff happiness, or it could be at the level of genuinely shifting policies. So what's his relationship with Tom Homan?

[Nick Miroff]

Well, it's been very interesting because, you know, Mark Wayne Mullen has never run a federal bureaucracy. He doesn't have a law enforcement or military background. And so he's coming into dhs, you know, as a newbie and clearly needs some kind of mentor. It's no surprise that the border czar, Tom Homan, who retains a lot of support among the kind of DHS workforce and represents a kind of institutional continuity at dhs, and who clashed bitterly with Noem and Lewandowski. So it's no surprise that Homan seems to be kind of taking Mullen under his wing. He's been talking to Mullen multiple times a day. And so I think this signals that, you know, Homan is going to retain a lot of influence at DHS this year. And what has been Homan's job since the President put him in charge of Minneapolis after the debacle there? Homan has been trying to turn down the temperature. He's been trying to make these kind of conciliatory statements. He's been trying to reassure Americans that the uglier scenes that have been politically damaging to the White House and the President's deportation agenda are gonna go away. And that's why you saw Mark Wayne Mullen during his confirmation hearing say, look, in six months, my goal is for DHS not to be at the headlines every day.

[Mark Wayne Mullen]

My goal is for people to understand we're out there, we're protecting them, and we're working with them. My goal is to make every one of you guys proud. My goal for those that don't support me, regret not supporting me.

[Nick Miroff]

And so this is about delivering on the President's mass deportation agenda, but more quietly, you know, without the kind of spectacle that the GNOME team has been producing.

[Hannah Rosen]

Okay, that's complicated. First of all, you said delivering on the agenda. I mean, do any of these personnel changes then matter if the person setting the agenda is still Stephen Miller, who still has quota demands?

[Nick Miroff]

Yes and no. I mean, you know, what I'm talking about is a tactical change in the politics of immigration enforcement.

[Hannah Rosen]

In the visuals or the politics in

[Nick Miroff]

both in the visuals and the way that it's talked about. Right. I mean, during Nome, we saw the public affairs office of the Department of Homeland Security issuing these, like, weird white nationalist tweets, you know, about American history and culture and, you know, delivering nativism and delivering these sermons on, you know, what Americans should think about their history. I mean, just this kind of stuff that is just way out, you know, outside the norms.

[Hannah Rosen]

For example, calling on potential ICE recruits to, quote, defend the homeland from outsiders while featuring heroic images of white men, often from a bygone era.

[Nick Miroff]

I don't think we're going to see that anymore. At least this year. I mean, I think that we are moving into a second year midterm political strategy that seeks to produce high numbers of deportations so the White House can point to results and say, look, I'm doing the thing that I said I was going to do, that President Trump said he was going to do, but no longer is geared to satisfying the President's base. And the most hawkish right wing forces that delighted in the scenes of ICE agents and Border Patrol agents going around these liberal cities and kicking ass. The politics of that have changed. And so it isn't like they're going to really back off of mass deportations. And they can't. They have $170 billion from the one big beautiful bill. That's the law. They have to hire all these ICE officers. They have to build out the detention capacity of ice. They have to build the border wall. The money has already been appropriated and they are going to fulfill this agenda. They're just going to manage the politics much differently.

[Hannah Rosen]

I guess I'm still trying to gauge if that's a genuine policy shift because Tom Homan, who we now talk about as the calm professional, was very involved, as this magazine reported, in family separation policies. So I don't know what he represents actually politically when he's executing mass deportations. Like, does he just represent the. Not Greg Bovino, but actually his policies are pretty similar, his tactics.

[Nick Miroff]

Yes. So what does it mean when Tom Homan says they want to do targeted enforcement? It means you're not going to have Greg Borvino strutting around Los Angeles and Chicago like a rooster. But Tom Homan has been an advocate of mass deportations pretty much his entire 40 year career in federal law enforcement. He knows how to pull the levers. And what he represents is this institutional. Think of it as like institutional ICE on steroids. You don't have to go out and troll people visually or online with the mass deportation agenda you're trying to carry out. You just can go and do it because you have the money and you have the personnel and you know how to execute these deportations. And that's what Tom Homan represents. So when some of the border hawks who were lamenting the demise of Greg bevino described Tom Homan as like, some softy. It's almost comical because, yeah, he was one of the architects of the family separation policy during the first term. Everyone who has seen him on Fox News for the last several years knows that he's an unapologetic, unabashed enthusiast for mass deportations and for what President Trump wants to do. But I think he can both be more effective because he knows how to actually make the machines run. And he's not backing off of this. He's just managing the politics and the optics differently because the broader public has turned. Has soured on mass deportations since Minneapolis. It's. The optics of it are bad.

[Hannah Rosen]

So the era we are entering is one in which ICE could have a gentler face, but is actually more effectively carrying out the President's policies.

[Nick Miroff]

Exactly. But it isn't even a gentler face. It's just like, what does targeted enforcement mean? It means they're gonna use all their resources, all the money that they have, to develop target lists to go and find the people that they want to arrest, who they can arrest, and take them into custody. They're just going to do it in a less visible way and in the way that ISIS has traditionally operated. And that's why the Kristi Noem, Corey Lewandowski, Greg Bevino approach of the first term was also really disorienting for most career ICE officers, because it wasn't the way they're used to operating. They didn't like it. They don't want to be performing for television cameras and social media. That's what the masks were about in a lot of ways. And so if you tell ICE officers you're just gonna do the job that you have been doing for most of your career, but with less of the spotlight on you, they'll be like, great.

[Hannah Rosen]

That's what I signed up for.

[Nick Miroff]

That's what I signed up for. And I think they will. Ultimately, they will get bigger numbers. You will see a lot more deportations.

[Hannah Rosen]

Okay, all right, so some specifics, because in the negotiations to fund dhs, the Democrats have made a handful of specific demand to reign in ice. And I don't know that any of them have been met or will be met. They're still being negotiated. But I'm curious about what you're hearing about whether in this new era, some of these things might or could change, like wearing masks. Like, is that a thing of the old era? Or what happens to that?

[Nick Miroff]

Well, you know, it's funny. Like, the White House, the Republicans, ICE leaders, seem to have already given ground on some of the other items on the Democrats wish list. You saw Mark Wayne Mullen, during the confirmation hearing say that he would return to the policy requiring ICE to have a judicial warrant to go into someone's private home.

[Mark Wayne Mullen]

I have made it very clear to the staff, and I think when you and I spoke, that a judicial warrant will be used to go into houses and a place of businesses unless we're pursuing someone that enters in that place.

[Nick Miroff]

Firing Kristi Noem was high on that list, restoring some of the oversight authorities. Mullen said that he would do that. So even in his confirmation hearing, outside of the scope of the negotiations, they were already agreeing to a lot of the stuff on the Democrats list. But what seems to be the big sticking point? It's the masks.

[Hannah Rosen]

Interesting. Why would they want to keep the masks if they're operating in the way that you described, which is the traditional ICE way of, you know, a name on a list and you go after the name on the list?

[Nick Miroff]

I think that this is something that in the course of their recruitment effort to more than double the size of the ICE workforce and add more than 10,000 new deportation officers, that this is something that has been a promise to the new recruits.

[Hannah Rosen]

Why? Why is this?

[Nick Miroff]

Because they're worried about being doxxed and they're worried about, you know, their families being harassed. And, you know, I'm sorry, but that's a real thing.

[Hannah Rosen]

Okay, so we're in this moment. ICE is about to do, you know, better job at mass deportation. What do you, as a reporter, track to see whether this is happening humanely in a way that, you know, protects rights or doesn't protect rights? Like, what are you watching in this new phase of ice?

[Nick Miroff]

I'm watching the plan that was set in motion several months ago to overhaul the ICE detention system. The agency has spent the last few months acquiring large warehouses around the country. They've already spent a billion dollars to buy 11 properties. They're planning to convert them into large mass detention centers with capacity for, in some places, for up to 10,000 detainees. I mean, this is stuff we've just never seen in this country before. They have $38 billion to convert these facilities and to operate them through the rest of Trump's term. These are central to their plan to carry out mass deportations and to reach their goal of a million deportations a year, which they fell far short of in Trump's first year. And yet Kristi Noem, Corey Lewandowski, as they were acquiring these warehouses and implementing this plan, didn't do any of the local political work. It would reassure jurisdictions, even in Republican dominated jurisdictions, to reassure local residents about what they were doing. And so they have been facing this backlash to the ICE plan from people who voted for Trump, but don't necessarily want a 5,000-person ICE detention center in their county. And ICE needs those jurisdictions to approve their permits for water and sewer and all of the renovations that they're planning to do. And so this is what I'm tracking, this plan and the possibility of, you know, mass detention centers being built out around the United States that are really going to facilitate their broader goals.

[Hannah Rosen]

Right, right. That's the next story. Well, Nick, thank you so much for joining us.

[Nick Miroff]

Pleasure. Thank

[Tom Homan]

you.

[Hannah Rosen]

This episode of Radio Atlantic was produced by Janae West. It was edited by Kevin Townsend. Rob Smersiak engineered and provided original music. Sam Fentress and Genevieve Finn fact checked. Claudina Baid is the executive producer of Atlantic Audio. And Andrea Valdez is our managing editor. Listeners, if you enjoy the show, you can support our work and the work of all Atlantic journalists when you subscribe to The Atlantic. At theatlantic.com listener, I'm Hanna Rosen. Thank you for listening.

[TikTok Advertiser]

Pet owner Save this TikTok has free training guides and behaviour tips. Potty training tricks, healthy diet ideas. No expensive classes needed. Just scroll and learn. Download TikTok now.