Radio Atlantic: Trump and the Crown Prince – Episode Summary
Release Date: May 15, 2025 | Host: Hanna Rosen | Guest: Hussein Ibish
Introduction
In the episode titled "Trump and the Crown Prince," Radio Atlantic delves into former President Donald Trump's recent diplomatic engagements with Gulf states, specifically Saudi Arabia, Qatar, and the United Arab Emirates (UAE). Hosted by Hanna Rosen, the episode features an in-depth conversation with Hussein Ibish, a senior resident scholar at the Arab Gulf States Institute and a contributor to The Atlantic. Together, they explore the dynamics of Trump's relationships with Gulf leaders, the transactional nature of these interactions, and the broader implications for Middle Eastern geopolitics and U.S. foreign policy.
Trump's Visit to the Gulf States
Hussein Ibish begins by highlighting the significance of Trump's recent visit to Saudi Arabia, where he was warmly greeted by Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman (MBS). The lavish welcome, complete with lavender carpets, golden swords, and Arabian horses, was a stark contrast to MBS's previous status as a Western pariah due to human rights concerns.
Hussein Ibish [01:08]: "The pictures that we're referring to show Trump at the airport tarmac in Saudi Arabia being greeted by Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman in a royal welcome."
Ibish posits that Trump's relaxed demeanor during the visit signifies a strategic alignment with Gulf leaders who operate within patron-client frameworks, where authority is rarely questioned—an environment in which Trump is inherently comfortable.
Hussein Ibish [02:22]: "The word that seems to summarize Trump's approach is transactional. That's the word that a lot of people use."
Transactional Relationships and Mutual Benefits
The discussion pivots to the transactional nature of Trump's relationships with Gulf countries. Ibish explains that while Gulf states seek U.S. military protection and weapons sales, Trump benefits from lucrative deals that bolster both his personal business interests and the broader U.S. economy.
Hussein Ibish [02:38]: "Middle Eastern countries are buying lots of American stuff, which is a big boon to Trump's bid to revitalize American manufacturing."
Furthermore, Trump’s personal gain is evident through various business ventures linked to his presidency, including Trump Towers in Riyadh, Jeddah, and Dubai, as well as a Trump International golf course in Qatar.
Hussein Ibish [04:00]: "The amount of financial clout that's coming to his family-owned, privately held business is just amazing."
Impact on U.S. Foreign Policy and Regional Stability
Ibish articulates that Trump's approach in the Gulf aims to reduce American entanglement in regional conflicts by facilitating deals that encourage Gulf states to handle their own affairs more independently. This strategy is exemplified by the U.S. ceasefire agreement with the Houthis in Yemen and the lifting of sanctions on Syria.
Hussein Ibish [15:54]: "I think he's trying to reduce American exposure and involvement in regional conflicts."
He further explains that such moves are intended to capitalize on Iran's weakened state, seeking a comprehensive deal that restricts Iranian influence in the region.
Human Rights and Shifting Norms
A significant departure from previous administrations is Trump's indifference to human rights issues in his dealings with Gulf states. Ibish contrasts this with past U.S. rhetoric that often spotlighted Saudi Arabia's human rights violations.
Hussein Ibish [11:00]: "Trump doesn't at all [bring up human rights]."
He provides context on MBS's evolution, noting that while Saudi Arabia continues to perpetrate human rights abuses, there has been a slight improvement compared to the period surrounding the murder of journalist Jamal Khashoggi.
Hussein Ibish [12:16]: "Saudi Arabia remains a real human rights violator from the point of view of human rights norms."
Implications for the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict
The episode addresses the delicate balance between U.S.-Saudi relations and the ongoing Israeli-Palestinian conflict, particularly the dire situation in Gaza. Ibish expresses concern over Israel's aggressive stance in Gaza, describing it as a potential war crime and a path toward long-term insurgency.
Hussein Ibish [19:18]: "What the Israelis are proposing to do is to go back into Gaza with full force... It's a crime."
He suggests that Trump's unique position and his strengthened ties with Gulf leaders could enable him to moderate Israel's actions, preventing further humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza.
Hussein Ibish [22:13]: "He is the only person in the world at the moment who has real leverage over Netanyahu because of the nature of the Israel, US Relationship."
Conclusion
The episode concludes with Ibish emphasizing the transformative nature of Trump's Middle East policies, underscoring the shift toward more transactional and less ideologically driven foreign relations. This realignment has significant ramifications for regional stability, U.S. foreign policy, and the humanitarian landscape in conflict zones like Gaza.
Hussein Ibish [23:21]: "Such a pleasure to be here. Thank you."
Key Takeaways
-
Transactional Dynamics: Trump's relationships with Gulf leaders are fundamentally transactional, benefiting both U.S. national interests and his personal business ventures.
-
Reduced Human Rights Emphasis: Unlike previous administrations, Trump does not prioritize human rights concerns in his diplomatic engagements with Gulf states.
-
Implications for Regional Conflicts: Trump's approach seeks to minimize U.S. involvement in Middle Eastern conflicts, leveraging Gulf investments to stabilize the region indirectly.
-
Potential Influence on Israeli Policies: Trump's unique position may afford him the leverage needed to temper Israeli military actions in Gaza, potentially mitigating further humanitarian crises.
This episode of Radio Atlantic offers a comprehensive analysis of Donald Trump's strategic maneuvers in the Gulf, highlighting the intricate balance between personal gain, national interests, and the broader geopolitical landscape.