Podcast Summary: Raging Moderates with Scott Galloway and Jessica Tarlov Episode: Team Resistance vs. Restraint (feat. Rep. Ritchie Torres)
Release Date: June 13, 2025
Host/Author: Vox Media Podcast Network

Introduction to the Episode

In this compelling episode of Raging Moderates, hosts Scott Galloway and Jessica Tarlov delve into the intricate dynamics of contemporary American politics through a centrist lens. Featuring a special guest appearance by Congressman Ritchie Torres of New York's 15th district in the Bronx, the discussion navigates the fine line between resistance and restraint within the Democratic Party amidst the challenges posed by the Trump administration.

Condemnation of Riots and Public Safety Concerns

The conversation kicks off with Torres addressing the recent riots in Los Angeles, emphasizing the need for unequivocal condemnation of civil disturbances while critiquing the Democratic Party's handling of public safety.

"We have to be crystal clear that we are by no means on the side of civil disturbance."
  — Richie Torres [01:52]

Torres asserts that Democrats have inadvertently ceded public safety to Republicans, leading to situations like the LA riots that only serve to benefit their political adversaries.

Analysis of Political Tactics and Trump’s Influence

Scott Galloway presents a provocative thesis derived from a fascist handbook, suggesting that creating an overstated crisis environment benefits authoritarian responses. Torres responds by comparing Trump's tactics to those of autocratic leaders like Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin.

"Donald Trump is spoiling for a fight... aspiring to be a fascistic leader in the mold of Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin."
  — Richie Torres [02:59]

Torres criticizes Trump's willingness to degrade democratic norms for personal gain, highlighting the dangerous path of unnecessary escalation.

Democratic Party’s Messaging and Strategic Focus

The discussion shifts to the Democratic Party's messaging shortcomings compared to Trump's straightforward and repeatable slogans. Torres advocates for a more idea-driven approach rather than merely opposing Trump.

"It's not enough for us to stand against Donald Trump. We have to stand for something."
  — Richie Torres [05:25]

He suggests the creation of a "Contract With America" for Democrats, emphasizing policies that resonate with voters, such as economic stability and workforce development.

Public Housing and Governance Reforms

Torlves highlights the pressing issues within public housing and broader governance challenges in blue states. Torres introduces the "Abundance Agenda" as a framework for reimagining effective and progressive Democratic governance.

"We should be the party of better and cheaper and faster government, a government that works, a government that builds."
  — Richie Torres [07:00]

He contrasts this with Republican approaches, advocating for infrastructure and economic policies that promote growth and efficiency.

Critique of the "Big Beautiful" Tax Bill

A significant portion of the episode focuses on Torres's vehement criticism of the Republican-led "Big Beautiful" tax bill, which he describes as detrimental to healthcare, clean energy, and national debt.

"I have almost no kind words to say about the bill. I do feel like Donald Trump has such an iron grip on the Republican Party that he will largely pass it."
  — Richie Torres [08:25]

He outlines the bill's potential to exacerbate the national debt and undermine essential services, portraying it as a fiscal catastrophe.

Path to Leadership and the Need for New Democratic Agendas

Torres discusses the importance of developing a strong, affirmative agenda for the Democratic Party, moving beyond mere opposition to fostering substantive policies that address voters' concerns.

"We have to offer something more substantive than resistance to Donald Trump because he will eventually be gone from our politics."
  — Richie Torres [36:55]

He emphasizes the necessity of strategic planning and leadership renewal within the party to ensure long-term success and resilience.

Personal Journey and Mental Health Advocacy

A poignant segment highlights Torres's personal story, detailing his struggles with mental health, substance abuse, and his journey from poverty to Congress. He underscores the importance of mental health treatment and advocates for work as a means to provide purpose and dignity.

"I would not be alive today... were it not for mental health treatment."
  — Richie Torres [23:56]

His narrative serves as a powerful testimony to overcoming adversity and the role of supportive policies in fostering individual resilience.

Support for Israel and Representation of Jewish Constituents

Torres elaborates on his steadfast support for Israel, drawing parallels between the security challenges faced by Israel and those in his Bronx district. He advocates for a nuanced understanding of Israel's geopolitical situation.

"I tell people, imagine if the United States had been invaded and thousands of American civilians... Can you imagine the overwhelming terror and fear?"
  — Richie Torres [30:27]

His commitment to Israel is rooted in personal experiences and a deep empathy for its security dilemmas, reinforcing his role as a representative who bridges diverse community concerns.

Challenges of Intersectional Identity in Politics

The episode delves into the complexities Torres faces as a non-white, gay politician supporting Israel—a stance that doesn't neatly align with typical far-left or far-right narratives. He discusses the pressures and perceptions within his caucus and the broader Democratic Party.

"I'm seen as a traitor to my race, which is an absurdity."
  — Richie Torres [27:29]

Torres candidly addresses the difficulties of maintaining his principles amidst conflicting expectations, advocating for authenticity over pandering.

Final Takes: Rage and Restraint

Concluding the episode, Torres shares his pet peeves and areas where he believes calm is necessary. He expresses outrage over the "Liberation Day tariffs," deeming them a significant act of national self-sabotage, while urging the public to temper fears surrounding artificial intelligence.

"The greatest threat to America is not China, Russia or North Korea or Iran. The greatest threat is Donald Trump."
  — Richie Torres [38:39]

He advocates for a balanced perspective on technological advancements, emphasizing optimism over apocalyptic predictions.

Closing Remarks

Scott Galloway and Jessica Tarlov commend Torres for his leadership and encourage him to consider higher political aspirations, reflecting the high regard his guests hold for his balanced approach and substantive policy focus.

"Representative Torres... I really do think there's a calling here for someone with your background and your courage."
  — Scott Galloway [40:04]

Key Takeaways:

• Strategic Democratic Messaging: Emphasizing affirmative policies over mere opposition to Trump to inspire and engage voters.

• Governance and Infrastructure: Advocating for efficient, proactive government initiatives that foster economic growth and public welfare.

• Personal Resilience: Highlighting the importance of mental health support and the role of personal experiences in shaping effective leadership.

• Balanced Identity Politics: Navigating the complexities of intersectional identities to maintain authenticity and broad-based support within the party.

• Patriotism and Global Perspective: Promoting a nuanced understanding of national security issues, particularly in relation to Israel, to build cohesive community support.

This episode offers a deep dive into the challenges and strategies facing moderates within the Democratic Party, presented through the insightful perspectives of Richie Torres, Scott Galloway, and Jessica Tarlov.