Podcast Summary: Raging Moderates with Scott Galloway and Jessica Tarlov Episode: The Trump Comeback and the 2024 Election Results
Release Date: November 8, 2024
Host/Authors: Scott Galloway and Jessica Tarlov
Network: Vox Media Podcast Network

1. Introduction

In this episode of Raging Moderates, Scott Galloway and Jessica Tarlov delve into the aftermath of the 2024 election, focusing on Donald Trump's unexpected resurgence and its implications for the political landscape. The hosts bring their centrist perspectives to dissect why, despite elections often being decided in the middle, politicians seem out of touch with voter desires.

2. Election Night Reactions

[00:48] Scott Galloway: Scott opens the discussion by reflecting on the election night atmosphere, drawing parallels to the 2016 election. He expresses surprise at Trump's ability to flip traditionally blue states, particularly Florida, predicting a clear loss for Kamala Harris early on.

[00:51] Jessica Tarlov: Jessica shares her initial calm despite the Democratic Party's setbacks, contrasting it with the turmoil of 2016. She emphasizes the need for the Democratic coalition to undergo soul-searching and rebuilding.

3. Coping Mechanisms and Personal Reactions

[03:20] Scott Galloway: Scott humorously recounts his attempts to manage stress post-election, highlighting ineffective methods and ultimately finding solace in dancing and upgrading his attire—symbolizing a shift to a more relaxed state of mind.

[04:22] Jessica Tarlov: Jessica discusses the emotional impact of public humiliation tied to the election results, appreciating genuine acknowledgment of electoral realities from figures like Karl Rove. She notes the shifting dynamics in red and blue states, emphasizing unexpected strongholds for Trump.

4. Key Issues Influencing the Election

a. Inflation and Economic Messaging

[07:07] Scott Galloway: Scott identifies three primary issues in the election: inflation, immigration, and incumbency. He critiques the Democratic Party's failure to effectively communicate economic improvements and manage perceptions around inflation.

b. Immigration

Scott observes that Republicans successfully portrayed immigration as out of control, resonating with voters despite the current administration's handling. He suggests that this framing significantly contributed to Harris's loss.

c. Incumbency and Campaign Performance

Scott praises Harris's efforts but attributes her loss to broader party and incumbent challenges rather than personal shortcomings. He criticizes Joe Biden's administration for not fostering strong candidates through the primary process.

5. Demographic Shifts and Voter Behavior

[10:19] Jessica Tarlov: Jessica highlights the critical role of white women voters and Latino men in the election outcome. She points out that despite maintaining abortion rights, a significant portion of these demographics still supported Trump, challenging previous Democratic assumptions.

[15:32] Scott Galloway: Scott proposes branding the election as the "Kids Are Not All Right" and "Manosphere Election," emphasizing young voters' economic anxieties and the influence of manosphere media on masculinity perceptions. He notes the significant swing of Latino men towards Trump, marking a demographic earthquake.

[18:48] Jessica Tarlov: Jessica expands on the anti-elite sentiment, illustrating how Democrats' dismissive attitudes towards non-college-educated voters alienated key demographics. She underscores the importance of recognizing and valuing all voter groups equally.

6. Culture War and Common Sense Deficit

[20:55] Scott Galloway: Scott posits that misogyny may be more prevalent than homophobia in current political dynamics, questioning the likelihood of electing a female president before a gay one.

[21:33] Jessica Tarlov: Jessica counters by suggesting a female president is possible within the Republican Party. She critiques Democratic identity politics and emphasizes the growing appeal of anti-cancel culture sentiments leading to Republican gains.

[23:45] Scott Galloway: Scott comments that Vice President Harris needed a "sister soldier moment," hinting at missed opportunities for galvanizing support through personal or relatable actions.

[23:48] Jessica Tarlov: Jessica agrees, noting Harris's struggle to differentiate herself from Joe Biden and her missed opportunities to connect with voters on critical issues.

7. Interview with Dave Weigel

[24:27] Scott Galloway: Scott introduces Dave Weigel, Semaphore's senior political reporter, to provide a deeper analysis of the election results.

a. Election Outcome and Polling

[25:16] Dave Weigel: Dave explains that Democrats engaged in "magical thinking," expecting last-minute shifts that never materialized. He attributes Republican success to continuous support among young men and Latino voters, with minimal unexpected movements.

b. Media Influence and Desensitization

[27:11] Jessica Tarlov: Jessica emphasizes that pollsters accurately predicted voter behavior, contradicting Democratic beliefs of returning to normative support.

[28:23] Dave Weigel: Dave discusses the asymmetrical media responses to offensive statements from Republicans versus Democrats. He argues that Republicans, including Trump, have desensitized the public to controversial remarks, diminishing the impact that previously would have led to widespread condemnation.

c. Economic Factors and Republican Messaging

[31:17] Scott Galloway: Scott inquires if the election was fundamentally about the economy.

[31:25] Dave Weigel: Dave agrees, highlighting that despite improved economic indicators, Democrats failed to effectively communicate their achievements. He criticizes Republican messaging for oversimplifying economic issues and leveraging immigration fears to consolidate support.

d. Future Trump Administration Policies

[33:22] Scott Galloway: Scott asks about potential policy changes under a Trump administration.

[33:30] Dave Weigel: Dave predicts immediate actions on immigration, such as deportations and policy reversals. He anticipates further cultural initiatives via executive orders, with significant focus on immigration and social issues, while tax and economic policies will require congressional approval.

[35:08] Jessica Tarlov: Jessica highlights Trump's aggressive stance on transgender issues, noting significant ad spending that may have swayed votes. She critiques the Democratic Party's lack of effective counter-messaging on culture wars, advocating for a common-sense approach to resonate with voters.

[36:41] Dave Weigel: Dave reiterates that Republican media strategies, including appearances on podcasts like Joe Rogan's, have effectively reached and influenced voters. He emphasizes that Democrats need to engage more directly with these new media channels to connect with skeptics and undecided voters.

[38:51] Scott Galloway: Scott asks Dave about potential senior appointments in a Trump administration.

[38:58] Dave Weigel: Dave outlines possible appointments, suggesting individuals like Bill Hagerty and Rick Grinnell for foreign policy roles. He expects appointments from Silicon Valley's conservative-leaning figures, emphasizing a shift away from traditional establishment Republicans.

8. Conclusion

Scott and Jessica wrap up the episode by reflecting on the comprehensive analysis provided by Dave Weigel. They underscore the significance of demographic shifts, media influence, and the culture war in shaping the 2024 election outcomes. The hosts emphasize the need for the Democratic Party to reassess and rebuild their coalition, adopting more inclusive and relatable messaging strategies to address the evolving political landscape.

Notable Quotes

• Jessica Tarlov [00:51]: "This feels like a big soul searching moment and I'm more comfortable as a highly educated elite. I get like going back to school, right? Like I gotta fix this."

• Scott Galloway [00:48]: "I thought she could hold her head high. But Joe Biden should be buried in a crypt next to Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Dianne Feinstein."

• Jessica Tarlov [10:19]: "Both chose Donald Trump. I think some of that is that Trump has always seemed like a more moderate person, no matter what."

• Scott Galloway [15:32]: "The kids are not all right. And then the other thing is what I'll call the manosphere election."

• Dave Weigel [25:16]: "Trump is correct. I think the people around him are correct that just things that would have got you maybe taken off the air or condemned for days as a Republican 10 years ago, they're not."

• Jessica Tarlov [33:30]: "Trump was spending the most on anti trans ads of any category. He was spending less on the economy, less on immigration."

• Dave Weigel [36:41]: "But Republicans won. So the conversation with Democrats are more interesting because they've explained what got screwed up."

Final Thoughts

Raging Moderates provides an insightful analysis of the 2024 election, highlighting the complexities of voter behavior, media influence, and policy impact. Scott Galloway and Jessica Tarlov, alongside Dave Weigel, offer a comprehensive breakdown that is both engaging and informative for listeners seeking to understand the intricate dynamics of modern American politics.

For more episodes of Raging Moderates, follow the Vox Media Podcast Network and subscribe to their feed available on all major podcast platforms.