The Irony of Whole Life Insurance

Summary

Ramsey Everyday Millionaires: The Irony of Whole Life Insurance

Host: Ramsey Network
Episode: The Irony of Whole Life Insurance
Release Date: May 2, 2025

---

Overview

In this episode of Ramsey Everyday Millionaires, hosts from the Ramsey Network delve into the complexities and misconceptions surrounding whole life insurance. Featuring insightful discussions between Dave Ramsey and Chris Hogan, alongside real-life inquiries from callers, the episode aims to demystify whole life policies and highlight more financially sound alternatives. The central theme focuses on how whole life insurance, despite its promises, often fails to deliver the intended financial benefits, especially when compared to term life insurance.

---

Key Discussions

1. Understanding Whole Life and Universal Life Insurance

The episode begins with a caller questioning the efficacy of whole life insurance versus universal life insurance. The caller mentions having a universal life policy and disputes common criticisms of whole life policies, particularly regarding cash value retention.

Chris Hogan clarifies the mechanics of universal life insurance:

“Universal B works like this. You pay, let's say you bought $100,000 policy and you build up a $20,000 cash value. ... the cash value amount in 100% of universal policies disappears at death 100% of the time.”
(00:59)

Hogan explains that while it might seem like universal life insurance offers lasting cash value, in reality, the cash value often diminishes over time as insurance costs rise.

2. Cost Comparisons: Whole Life vs. Term Insurance

A significant portion of the discussion revolves around the cost-effectiveness of whole life policies compared to term life insurance. The caller observes that their universal life policy costs nearly the same as a term policy, countering claims that whole life is exponentially more expensive.

Chris Hogan responds by highlighting common pitfalls:

“...if you go to Zander insurance and comp shop, you'll probably find it to be a lot less because they're shopping among a bunch of different companies that specialize in term and it's much, much cheaper.”
(01:53)

He emphasizes that term life insurance is typically more affordable and provides adequate coverage without the unnecessary investment component that often leads to higher costs over time.

3. The Irony of Whole Life Insurance

The core irony discussed is that whole life insurance policies often fail their primary purpose—the provision of lasting insurance coverage and investment benefits.

Chris Hogan elaborates:

“...the rising cost of insurance through the years eats up all of your premium. So that the very reason you bought it instead of buying term was to have an investment. And it doesn't occur, the longer you hang onto it, the higher chance it will implode on itself.”
(06:53)

He explains how the increasing cost of insurance premiums in universal and whole life policies can erode the cash value, leaving policyholders with diminishing returns despite their initial investments.

Dave Ramsey echoes this sentiment:

“With universal, there's flexible premiums. But here's the thing, if it's not enough to cover the insurance, they take it from your cash value. So you're not winning. They always win.”
(07:07)

This highlights the inherent disadvantage for policyholders, where insurance companies benefit from the structure of these policies at the expense of the insured.

4. Recommendations for Financial Planning

The hosts advocate for more straightforward and cost-effective insurance solutions, steering listeners away from the complexities of whole life policies.

Chris Hogan advises:

“...buy inexpensive term insurance, 10, 15, 20 year level term, and do your investing anywhere else. Don't put it in this crap.”
(05:38)

He reinforces that term life insurance, coupled with separate investment strategies, offers greater financial flexibility and benefits without the drawbacks associated with whole life insurance.

---

Notable Quotes

• Chris Hogan on the fallacy of cash value retention in universal policies:
  “...the cash value amount in 100% of universal policies disappears at death 100% of the time.”
  (00:59)

• Dave Ramsey on the inevitability of universal policies deteriorating:
  “It's exhausting. It's... the higher chance it will implode on itself.”
  (05:13)

• Chris Hogan emphasizing the financial traps of whole life insurance:
  “...the rising cost of insurance through the years eats up all of your premium.”
  (06:53)

• Dave Ramsey on the imbalance favoring insurance companies:
  “With universal, there's flexible premiums. But here's the thing, if it's not enough to cover the insurance, they take it from your cash value. So you're not winning. They always win.”
  (07:07)

---

Conclusions and Takeaways

1. Whole Life Insurance is Often Cost-Prohibitive: The initial allure of combining insurance with investment is overshadowed by escalating costs that can erode the policy's value over time.

2. Term Life Insurance as a Superior Alternative: Term policies offer affordable coverage without the hidden costs and complexities associated with whole life or universal life insurance. They allow individuals to allocate funds more effectively toward separate investment vehicles.

3. Financial Advisors Caution Against Whole Life Policies: Professionals outside the insurance sales realm rarely recommend whole life insurance, reinforcing the notion that these policies are more beneficial to insurers than to policyholders.

4. Importance of Financial Literacy: Understanding the intricate details of insurance policies is crucial. Consumers are encouraged to consult with fee-based financial planners or investment advisors who advocate for transparent and cost-effective financial strategies.

5. Avoiding Common Pitfalls: Recognizing the structural disadvantages of whole life insurance can prevent financial setbacks. Opting for term life insurance and disciplined investing aligns more closely with the principles of building and maintaining wealth.

---

Final Thoughts

This episode of Ramsey Everyday Millionaires serves as a critical examination of whole life insurance, unraveling the financial intricacies that often deceive policyholders. Through expert insights and practical advice, Dave Ramsey and Chris Hogan guide listeners towards more prudent financial decisions, emphasizing the importance of simplicity, transparency, and strategic investing in the journey to building and sustaining wealth.

---

For more insights and assistance with your financial planning, connect with a SmartVestor Pro at RamseySolutions.com/SmartVestor.

Transcript

[Dave Ramsey]

This episode is brought to you by SmartVestor. Connect with an investing pro near you at RamseySolutions.com SmartVestor Christopher is in Richmond, Virginia.

[Chris Hogan]

Hi, Christopher, how are you?

[Caller]

Hello, Mr. Ramsey. Thanks for taking my call.

[Chris Hogan]

Sure. What's up?

[Caller]

I've heard you yell at quite a few people about whole life policies. I have a universal life policy and when I started hearing how terrible the whole life where I looked into it and I don't think it has all the same bad things to it. Their whole life does. Like the cash value doesn't go away when I die.

[Chris Hogan]

Yes, it does.

[Caller]

With the policy.

[Chris Hogan]

Yes, it does.

[Caller]

I called, I called the company and asked and they said no, it does not.

[Chris Hogan]

Yes, it does.

[Dave Ramsey]

Well, they sometimes will claim they can set it up in such a way.

[Chris Hogan]

In A, very few have a universal.

[Caller]

B. I don't know if it's A or B.

[Chris Hogan]

Universal B works like this. You pay, let's say you bought $100,000 policy and you build up a $20,000 cash value. Okay? Universal B charges you for $120,000, the face value plus the cash value worth of insurance. So you're purchasing extra insurance that makes it look like you get the cash value upon death, but you don't. You're just buying more insurance and B, that's all that you're doing the equivalent of the cash value amount. The cash value amount in 100% of universal policies disappears at death 100% of the time.

[Caller]

Okay? The other thing you said was that whole is 20 times as expensive. And I just did some comp shopping and my universal policy was about the same exact amount it would cost me to get term rates. Now, I've had it for a while, but.

[Chris Hogan]

Well, there's one of two possibilities that run there. One is you did your comp shopping with the same stupid company that sold you the universal and they generally have very expensive term. If you go to Zander insurance and comp shop, you'll probably find it to be a lot less because they're shopping among a bunch of different companies that specialize in term and it's much, much cheaper. The other possibility is universal life works like this. The premium go that the portion of your premium that you're paying monthly that buys your life insurance goes up every year. Your premium stays the same. But let's say that, let's just make up a number. Let's say Your premium is $100 and the first time, the first year you bought it, you were 26 and you're. And of the $100, $10 went to insurance cost and $90 went to the investment. Later on, as you get older, the amount going towards insurance goes up, okay, because every year you're older, you're more likely to die. And so what can happen with a universal policy that's worse than whole life even is the lines can cross and actually the insurance cost becomes more than the premium. And they'll start using part of your cash value to cover the insurance cost because you're upside down in the policy. And then that thing, it'll actually disappear, It'll actually deteriorate, kill itself. It turns in on itself mathematically. So what's happening is that you were doing more investing in the old days and now almost all of your premium is simply buying insurance. Now in the term insurance world, Christopher, there's a thing, there's term life insurance, which means the length of the term. So you can buy a one year term, a five year term, a 10 year term, a 15, a 20, a 30 year term. And if it's level term, the premium stays level throughout that period of time, which is an average of all the years before. Pure insurance, technically speaking would be annually renewable once a year. The insurance premium goes up because you get older. And every year you're older, you're more likely to die, percentage wise. Does that make sense? So an art is what that's called an annual renewable term. And the cost of insurance goes up every single year. It's not level. When you buy an art. And that's what's built into the universal policy is an art. And so the universal go, the cost of insurance, more of your premium is going to insurance every single year, thereby less is going to the investment. And that may, if you've had it for many years now, you're just buying insurance. You're not putting anything into investment or worse, you're not even covering the cost of the insurance. And they're using up some of your investment to cover the difference because you've the, the, you've crossed the lines on it. And if that's the case, then that would also explain why you find term insurance to be about the same cost. Cause really all you've got now, honey, is term insurance. Because the art has raised in price every year and caught up with the actual premium that you've been paying. Whew, I'm dizzy.

[Dave Ramsey]

It's exhausting. It's. And here's the thing, most I've never heard of someone who isn't selling insurance, say that whole life or universal is good it's only coming from the salespeople. And so the people that get swindled by this, usually from a friend who explained to them, the wealthy do this, they invest through their insurance policy and you can borrow against your own money tax free. And they explain all these crazy loophole, quote, quote, unquote advantages.

[Chris Hogan]

So in the financial planning realm, fee based financial planners, investment advisors like our smartvestor pros, anywhere you go to for financial planning help, the only people that tell you to buy cash value insurance are people that sell it. No one else tells you to do it. No one in the entire the rest of the financial world looks at it and goes, buy inexpensive term insurance, 10, 15, 20 year level term, and do your investing anywhere else. Don't put it in this crap. Because what ends up happening, see, let's go back and revisit the barrel of fish hooks. I just unpacked a minute because it's frustrating as crud. When you were 26 and you bought that $100 premium I was talking about a minute ago and I made that number up, okay, you bought that because you wanted some insurance and because you wanted some investments. And the irony is that the rising cost of insurance through the years eats up all of your premium. So that the very reason you bought it instead of buying term was to have an investment. And it doesn't occur, the longer you.

[Dave Ramsey]

Hang onto it, the higher chance it will implode on itself.

[Chris Hogan]

Yeah, it eats itself out. And so the very reason that you did it is systematically, annually disappearing. That's the irony of how bad this is. It just sucks.

[Dave Ramsey]

With universal, there's flexible premiums. But here's the thing, if it's not enough to cover the insurance, they take it from your cash value. So you're not winning. They always win.

[Chris Hogan]

And again, the insurance is going to go up every single year because it's the equivalent of an art built in. Now the truth is on a 15 year fixed level payment, right, you're paying more in the early days than you would for an art because all the 15 year is, is the average of the art, but less. Because arts have low persistence, very few people keep them and they drop them because they go up every year and they get oh God, I got to get out of this thing. But they keep the 15 so it's cheaper for the insurance company to run the 15, so they give you a break. So it's less than the average of 15 arts and it's simpler to manage.

[Dave Ramsey]

There's no investments in cash value to deal with.

[Chris Hogan]

But you're still paying it. You're still paying for the coverage.

[Dave Ramsey]

Thanks for tuning in to Ramsey Everyday millionaires Need help with your investments? Connect with a Smartvestor Pro at ramseysolutions. Com smartvestor or click the link in the show notes. Ramsey Solutions is a paid non client promoter of participating pros. Learn more at ramseysolutions. Com Smartvestor.