Reading Glasses – Episode 459: Do You Have Bad Taste in Books?
Release Date: April 23, 2026
Hosts: Brea Grant & Mallory O’Meara
Episode Theme & Purpose
This episode delves into the anxiety many readers harbor about their "taste" in books. Inspired by a listener’s question, Brea and Mallory dissect what it means to have "good" or "bad" taste, discuss the subjectivity of book enjoyment, and offer perspective on how readers can own their preferences with confidence. The episode wraps in their signature wit, empathy, and candor, featuring book recommendations, a lively listener feedback segment, and a spirited discussion on the ethics of selling used books—plus a dash of Maximum Fun Drive excitement.
Key Discussion Points & Insights
What Are the Hosts Reading?
-
[02:01] Brea: "I'm reading the book for our next episode of Reading Smut. It is Lights Out by Nevesa Allen... a dark romance—emphasis on dark—about a trauma nurse with a mask kink..."
- Content warning: extreme themes, “so much knife play.”
-
[03:34] Mallory: "I'm reading A Place Both Wonderful and Strange: The Untold History of Twin Peaks by Scott Meslo… audiobook, narrated by Mark Tretky. I’m obsessed with Twin Peaks, and this book is already teaching me so much…"
Listener Feedback Highlights
-
[05:00] Lynn’s Reading Tip:
Keep a mini-dictionary or a notebook by your bed for looking up words or ideas—avoiding phone distractions.
- “Instead of doomscrolling, you can be, like, ‘what’s a mandolin slicer?’ I like that.” – Mallory [05:47]
-
[05:56] Rebecca’s Reading Journey:
Credits the show with helping her rediscover her love of reading post-pandemic. She’s read 9 books already in 2026, mixing audiobooks and paper, and praises the Reading Glasses book journal as a gift.
- “Your tips, reader questions, book recs, and overall attitude… helped me get totally back into it.” – Rebecca (read by Brea) [06:58]
- Rebecca’s Wheelhouse: Indigenous stories with strong female protagonists, Gen X celeb bios, sarcastic humor mysteries, Scandinavia/cozy British settings, and a “touch of witch” but not as the main focus. [07:31]
CORE DISCUSSION: Do You (or Anyone) Have Bad Taste in Books?
[13:20–28:49]
Inspiration:
- Listener Bayla wonders if being too critical—or insecure about recommending books—means she might have “bad taste.” She’s nervous someone will dislike her recommended book and judge her as a reader. [13:53]
Do the Hosts Consider Themselves as Having Good Taste?
-
Brea:
- “I do… but it is my taste… When someone is like, ‘I hated this book you recommended,’ I do have to be like, ‘is it bad taste?’ But… your taste is your taste… I don’t think there is good taste or bad taste.” [14:54]
- Uses negative feedback as a way to refine recommendations and learn about others’ preferences (“Oh, you like a vibe.”) [15:54]
-
Mallory:
- “I think I have very specific taste in books… and I’m actually really happy with that. It has taken me a long time to get to that point.” [16:50]
- Sometimes worries about not liking popular books—“Am I dumb? Do I not have good taste in books?”—but recognizes taste is shaped by life experience. [16:54]
- “So much of your taste in art is particular to your particular life experience… I wonder if my life has been so weird that it’s giving me like an off-the-beaten-path taste in books.” [17:44]
Can People Objectively Have Bad Taste?
Does Worrying About “Bad Taste” Even Matter?
Bookish Problem: Is it Unethical to Sell Little Free Library Books?
[Timestamps: 36:01–41:33]
Message from Tina: Bought "blind date books" from Etsy and found some were stamped from Little Free Library. Is it wrong to resell or keep these books?
Brea:
- “This is not on you… there are a number of ways a person could have gotten them… you’re not obligated to return this book to the Little Free Library. You don’t need to worry about this. This is your book now.” [37:47]
Mallory:
- “There’s nothing you can really do about it… If a person didn’t take the book and sell it, there’s a chance it would’ve just stayed in that little free library collecting dust next to all the other James Pattersons in there.” [40:30]
- Also ponders: What if the seller is in financial need? Maybe selling the books is their way to survive. [39:30]
Consensus:
- Once taken, Little Free Library books are the taker's property; it's not unethical to keep, donate, or resell, and buyers shouldn’t feel guilty if they acquire one downstream.
Romance Recommendation Request: Body Swap Romances
[Timestamps: 42:37–45:10]
Question: Are there spicy romance novels with the body swap trope?
Mallory Recs:
- Switched by Evangeline Anderson – Sci-fi, human/alien body swap, “quite spicy.” [43:22]
- My Lady, My Lord by Katharine Ashe – Historical, enemies-to-lovers who swap bodies. [44:00]
Brea Adds:
- Devil Inside by Clay McLeod Chapman – Horror/demo possession with body-jumping and sexy elements, out this fall. [44:31]
Notable Quotes & Moments
- “I think there are people who are able to identify and go, ‘this band is going to be big’… but I don’t know if that makes good taste necessarily, just [taste] more culturally palatable.” – Brea [20:22]
- “I love the Samantha Irby method… Who gives a shit? I like it.” – Mallory [26:20]
- On anxiety about taste: “Maybe that's also being a woman… sometimes, did this person know better than me about this thing?” – Brea [27:00]
- “The point of art is not to be perfect… If it makes you feel something, and you are enjoying the process of it, then it’s good.” – Mallory [27:37]
Structure Overview with Timestamps
- 00:00–01:32: MaxFun Drive intro (skip: fundraising/promotions)
- 01:32–02:00: Show introduction & episode theme
- 02:01–05:00: What Are You Reading?
- 05:00–08:00: Listener feedback & tips
- 13:20–28:49: Main Discussion—Taste in Books
- 36:01–41:33: Bookish Problem: Used/Free Library Book Ethics
- 42:37–45:10: Book Rec Request: Body Swap Romance
Episode Takeaways
- You Can’t Have Bad Taste in Books: Taste is subjective, tied to personality and lived experiences; “good” or “bad” taste is mostly a matter of perspective and social context.
- Be Proud of Your Preferences: Don’t let insecurity about “taste” stop you from enjoying or recommending books.
- Market Forces Shape Perception of Taste: Being a tastemaker doesn't mean your taste is objectively better.
- Don’t Stress About Little Free Library Book Ethics: Once a book has found its way into your hands, don’t overthink its provenance.
- There Are Body Swap Romances! Recommendations are out there for even the most specific reader requests.
For Further Engagement
- Personalized Book Recommendations: Join Maximum Fun during MaxFun Drive for tailored recs.
- Community Interaction: Participate in Discord, live events, and Reading Glasses’ Instagram for additional connection.
Closing Quote
“If it makes you happy, then it can’t be bad.”
— Mallory O’Meara, echoing Sheryl Crow [21:57]
Contact the show: readingglassespodcast@gmail.com
Join/Support: maximumfun.org/join
Instagram: @readingglassespodcast
Thanks for Reading!