The Charlie Kirk Show – Real America’s Voice
Episode Date: October 16, 2025
Host: Andrew Colvett (Executive Producer, in for Charlie Kirk), with Jack Posobiec
Special Guests: Senator Tommy Tuberville, Dr. Gad Saad
Episode Overview
This episode of The Charlie Kirk Show centers on preserving Charlie Kirk’s legacy following his recent assassination, the ongoing challenges to American and Western values, and the contemporary political and cultural landscape. Co-hosts Andrew Colvett and Jack Posobiec broadcast from Washington, D.C., and are joined by Senator Tommy Tuberville and Dr. Gad Saad. The conversation moves through reflections on Charlie’s influence, increasing political violence, the rise of Islam in the West, contemporary left-wing tactics, current debates on free speech, and the path forward for American conservatism.
Main Themes
- Honoring and continuing Charlie Kirk’s mission and legacy
- The increasing political, media, and cultural polarization in America
- The danger and dynamics of contemporary left-wing violence and discourse
- The rise of Islam/Islamism in the West as perceived by the hosts
- Concrete actions being taken to preserve American values and institutions (Turning Point, legislative initiatives)
- Maintaining hope, unity, and resilience within the conservative movement
Segment Summaries & Key Insights
1. Opening Reflections on Charlie Kirk and the Show’s Mission
[11:02]
- Andrew Colvett opens by reflecting on Charlie's legacy, the support following the White House show, and the show's commitment to carrying on his work.
- Jack Posobiec jokes about Blake being "on assignment" in Italy, adding lightness amid the somber context.
- Discussion of J.D. Vance (now Vice President), taking up the mantle via public, unscripted university events in the spirit of Charlie.
Notable Quote
“Nobody can replace Charlie. … As the Bible said, we are unfit to tie the sandals of Charlie, but here we are and we’re attempting to do our best.”
— Andrew Colvett [16:13]
[12:44]
- JD Vance’s unprecedented campus Q&A event at Ole Miss (Oct 29) is highlighted as a model for transparency and leadership, emulating Charlie’s approach: "the courage it takes... the second most powerful man in the world... to sit in front of students... taking questions for probably like an hour" (Colvett).
2. Political and Cultural Violence: The Left/Antifa and Campus Threats
[17:21]
- Jack Posobiec recounts the controversy around Mark Bray (“Dr. Antifa”): a Rutgers professor accused by conservative students of advocating violence, especially in the wake of Charlie’s murder.
- Colvett and Posobiec criticize universities' response to campus threats, arguing that authorities focus on investigating conservative students while ignoring left-wing advocates of violence (specifically Mark Bray's paid leave to Spain).
- Discussion of the need for legal defense and support for conservative campus chapters.
Notable Quote
“He cannot exist in the world which he advocates for… these kids are meanwhile getting doxed on campus. The university is launching an investigation on the kids—not him.”
— Andrew Colvett [19:23]
[19:35]
- The broader theme is the rise in political violence, with the show positioning itself and the conservative movement as under continuous threat from leftist radicalization.
3. Viral Moments & Political Discourse: Civil Dialogue Suffers
[24:35]
- Andrew recounts attending a civil debate, expecting reasoned discussion and instead being blindsided by accusatory demands to “disavow young Republicans."
- John Fetterman’s refusal to call Republicans “fascists” sparks his own party to consider primaring him—a sign of “purity spirals” on the left.
Notable Quote
“You are no longer allowed to live civilly with your political opponents.”
— Jack Posobiec [27:24]
4. Media Narratives: The Rhetoric of Violence and Antifa
[29:46]
- Clip/discussion lampooning Jimmy Kimmel’s claim that “Antifa is not a real organization” and downplaying leftist unrest.
- The hosts offer pointed rebuttals and recount personal/vicarious experiences of left-wing violence (journalists attacked, “cement milkshakes,” etc.).
- Frame Antifa as intentionally decentralized and thus dangerous.
Notable Quote
“The whole point of Antifa… is that it is intentionally decentralized… an amorphous, flexible, loose network of left-wing militants.”
— Andrew Colvett [30:10]
5. Honoring Charlie via Action: Upcoming Events and Legislative Initiatives
[38:28]
- Senator Tommy Tuberville joins, reflecting on Charlie’s mentorship and friendship, and touts his role in continuing campus activism and anti-Sharia legal efforts in Charlie’s name.
- Tuberville previews a November 5th Turning Point event at Auburn University (with Eric Trump, Lara Trump, and Benny Johnson), originally planned with Charlie, now recommitted in his honor.
- Tuberville discusses introducing legislation to ban Sharia law in the U.S., framing it as a defense of assimilation and American values.
Notable Quotes
“We have to continue that ministry on college campuses. That’s where it starts. That’s where we’re going to change our country. And Charlie was on the right track.”
— Coach Tommy Tuberville [40:30]
“You have the right to come here and be a part of this country… The thing you don’t have the right to do is to attack our constitution. Other religions speak out against America, speak out against Americans. Death to America. …Sharia law is not going to fit here. Got no chance.”
— Tommy Tuberville [44:17]
6. The State of Political Negotiation: Shut Down, Democrats, and GOP Fractures
[48:43]
- Tuberville addresses the ongoing government shutdown and budget debates in D.C., claiming the Democrats are “worried more about politics, power” than the American people.
- Discussion of leftward shift in the Democrat party and political infighting.
7. The Rise of Islam in the West: Warning and Reaction
[55:28] – [58:37]
- Colvett and Posobiec revisit Charlie’s warnings about the demographic and cultural impacts of Islam in the West, citing his tweets and public statements.
- Discussion highlights Charlie's reflections after visiting London and his concern at “Islam rapidly taking over the West.”
Notable Quotes
“The conservative movement needs to focus more time, energy, and focus on how Islam is rapidly taking over the West.”
— Charlie Kirk (quoted tweet) [57:30]
“Islam is the sword the left is using to slit the throat of America.”
— Charlie Kirk (quoted tweet) [57:54]
- Posobiec frames this as a civilizational struggle he saw firsthand, underscoring the “Save the West” mantra.
8. Dr. Gad Saad: Legacy, Suicidal Empathy, and Remedies for Wokeness
[69:18] – [113:49] (spanning remaining episode time)
- Dr. Saad joins and reflects on Charlie’s multi-generational impact, his “honey badger” spirit, and how he inspired youth activism.
Notable Quotes
“He is a unique individual in that he had the intellect, he had the political ability to organize, he had the warmth... Truly one in a generation type of fellow.”
— Dr. Gad Saad [73:51]
- Discussion pivots to the psychological and cultural vulnerability of the West to illiberal ideologies. Dr. Saad expands on his “suicidal empathy” thesis, warning that empathy without discernment (especially toward those who exploit it) leads to downfall.
- Saad draws on his research to describe the left’s tendency toward consequentialism over deontological ethics (ends justify means), contextualizing the targeting of Charlie and leftist violence.
- Conversation deeply examines how tribalism, emotional discourse, and identity politics have replaced shared American identity, and considers if there is a path back to unity.
- Saad is skeptical about how easily people can change their deeply entrenched beliefs ("It takes a Herculean effort..."), emphasizing the need to reach youth early, which Turning Point's expansion to high schools aims to address.
- On the left’s loss of the social media narrative, Saad and Posobiec argue that progressive ideas collapse under scrutiny and conservatives now thrive simply because the algorithm is more neutral post-Elon Musk/Twitter.
Notable Quotes & Moments (with Timestamps)
-
On Charlie’s Legacy
“Nobody can replace Charlie. As the Bible said, we are unfit to tie the sandals of Charlie, but here we are and we’re attempting to do our best.”
— Andrew Colvett [16:13] -
On Left-Wing Double Standards
“This guy… advocates for preemptive violence… The second the temperature gets turned up on him… he flies straight to Spain. Absolute coward.”
— Andrew Colvett [19:23] -
On Civility in Politics
“You are no longer allowed to live civilly with your political opponents.”
— Jack Posobiec [27:24] -
On American Unity
“If you are American, you believe in our foundational principles, then welcome in, my brother. If you don’t, don’t let the door hit your ass on the way out.”
— Dr. Gad Saad [113:49] -
On Suicidal Empathy
“Suicidal empathy takes this beautiful virtue and then… because it becomes dysregulated, it becomes hyperactive and it targets the wrong targets, leads to the demise of the West.”
— Dr. Gad Saad [75:57] -
On Social Media and the Marketplace of Ideas
“Elon [Musk] didn’t come in and start boosting conservatives… he just stopped banning them… That for some reason to them, made them so upset…”
— Jack Posobiec [101:33]
Timestamps for Key Segments
- [11:02] – Opening reflections, Charlie’s legacy, JD Vance event
- [16:52] – Outpouring of support for Charlie, carrying the torch
- [17:21] – Mark Bray, Antifa, campus violence, and university inaction
- [24:35] – Civil debate breakdown, viral leftist attacks
- [27:11] – John Fetterman, Democrat primary threats
- [29:46] – Jimmy Kimmel, Antifa, and media denial of left-wing unrest
- [38:28] – Sen. Tuberville on Charlie’s impact, anti-Sharia law bill
- [48:43] – Budget fight, Democrats' motives
- [55:28] – Charlie Kirk’s warnings on Islam, "Save the West"
- [69:18] – Dr. Gad Saad: Charlie's intellectual legacy, "honey badger" courage
- [75:57] – Suicidal empathy and the West's vulnerabilities
- [87:25] – Deontological vs. consequentialist ethics, violence against dissenters
- [94:38] – Reaching the "radicalized": Is there hope?
- [110:19] – Politics and hypocrisy: AOC and the tribal mind
- [113:49] – Closing remarks, one American identity, optimism for the future
Takeaways for Listeners
- The episode is a tribute and call to action in the wake of tragedy, emphasizing perseverance through unity, duty, and resilience.
- Listeners are encouraged to remain vigilant regarding threats to Western and American values—perceived as coming from left-wing radicalism and ideological Islam.
- The discussion repeatedly highlights generational transmission: both the vulnerability of youth to “parasites” of radical progressive ideology and the need for early inoculation (“mind vaccine”) with strong, confident conservatism.
- The tone is both somber and combative: mournful over Charlie's loss, but defiant and hopeful about carrying his torch, embodied by pragmatic activism and legislative engagement.
- Despite warning against pessimism, there is steadfast belief in the power of good ideas, gratitude, and faith—themes repeatedly referenced as the foundation of a happier, more resilient conservative movement.
Concluding Quote
“Charlie’s mantra at the end was, save the West. Save the West. Save the West.”
— Andrew Colvett [59:45]
For those who missed the episode, this summary captures the heartfelt remembrance, current events analysis, and strategic direction voiced by the show’s hosts and guests. It provides both the factual contours and emotional underpinnings that defined this pivotal post-assassination broadcast.