Real Life Real Crime

Episode Title: Justice For Hailey: Call To Action
Host: Real Life Real Crime Productions (Woody Overton)
Release Date: April 4, 2025

Introduction

In the poignant episode titled "Justice For Hailey: Call To Action," Real Life Real Crime delves into the deeply troubling case of Hailey, seeking to spotlight the miscarriages of justice that have plagued her case. Hosted by renowned true crime expert Woody Overton, this episode marks a significant turning point, urging listeners—referred to as "lifers"—to actively participate in delivering justice for Hailey.

Background of Hailey’s Case

The episode begins with Woody Overton summarizing the harrowing events surrounding Hailey's untimely death. On December 26th, Hailey and her partner, Brooks Cleary, were involved in an incident that has since remained mired in controversy and legal ambiguity. The initial narrative suggested a possible suicide, but inconsistencies and emerging evidence have raised serious doubts about this conclusion.

Key Discussions and Evidence Mishandling

Inconsistent Statements and Evidence Discrepancies

Woody Overton and Hailey’s mother, Estella, along with Tyler, meticulously dissect the inconsistencies in the investigation. A critical point of contention is Brooks Cleary’s fluctuating narratives about the events leading up to Hailey’s death.

• Altered Apparel Description:
  “They never asked her what Brooks was wearing when they went over there,” Woody (07:32) highlights the lack of due diligence in verifying Brooks’s attire during the critical moment outside the apartment.
  “He wasn't wearing that short sleeve Champion shirt that he had on in the videos because it was freezing cold outside,” Estella (08:16) asserts, pointing out the improbability of Brooks's attire given the harsh weather conditions.

• Blood Evidence Mishandling:
  The handling of blood evidence has been a significant misstep.
  “He changed his story time and time again,” Woody (09:02) emphasizes how Brooks’s inconsistent accounts undermine the investigation's credibility.
  “Haley had blood on the bed, which means he had to go in there afterwards,” Estella (10:37) connects the presence of blood evidence to Brooks’s movements post-incident, suggesting foul play rather than suicide.

Prosecution’s Shortcomings

The prosecution's approach has been criticized for its lack of comprehensive evidence compilation and failure to present all relevant information to the grand jury.
“The prosecution's main problem is that they didn't have everything in one place,” Woody (06:41) explains, underscoring the fragmented nature of the case file presented to the authorities.

Pathologist’s Role and Autopsy Flaws

A pivotal flaw in the investigation was the pathologist's initial oversight: “The biggest mistake in the whole case is them sending Haley for an autopsy without having the complete information to give the pathologist,” Woody (32:05) argues, stressing that incomplete data led to an inaccurate cause of death determination.

Insights from Hailey’s Family and Experts

Estella’s Perspective

Estella, Hailey’s mother, provides an emotional yet rational critique of the investigation: “I believe Haley was passed out or asleep. She was not quiet,” (26:07) she states, asserting that Hailey’s known behavior conflicts with the narrative of suicide.
She further criticizes the decision-making of the authorities, questioning, “Why did they not perform a lie detector test?” (37:13), highlighting an opportunity missed to ascertain truthfulness.

Barbara’s Observations

Barbara, another key family member, adds depth to the discussion by pointing out: “Haley was right-handed, yet she had a chunk of hair in her right hand. How is that possible?” (38:52) This observation suggests Hailey’s physical struggle, contrary to claims of death by suicide, implying possible resistance or conflict.

Tyler’s Contributions

Tyler complements the family’s perspective by addressing the procedural flaws: “When you present everything to the grand jury, then let the grand jury decide,” (12:15) he advocates, emphasizing the importance of a fair judicial process where all evidence is meticulously reviewed.

Call to Action: Mobilizing the Community

A significant portion of the episode is devoted to mobilizing listeners to take actionable steps toward achieving justice for Hailey. Woody Overton outlines a multi-faceted strategy:

1. Contacting the New District Attorney:
   “We're going to provide you with a list of numbers. There'll be telephone numbers to offices like the district attorney,” (51:15) encouraging listeners to reach out to Stephanie Green, the newly appointed DA, to advocate for a thorough review of Hailey's case.

2. Engaging with the Media:
   “If you get a chance to talk, report, great,” (53:14) urges the listeners to leverage media platforms to amplify Hailey’s story, ensuring that the pressure is felt across all fronts.

3. Utilizing Social Media:
   Prominently featured is the hashtag #JusticeForHailey, aimed at unifying the community’s efforts and making the issue visible to both public and authorities.

4. Respectful Advocacy:
   “Please, I would ask that you try to do it in a respectful manner as you can so they'll take it seriously,” (53:57) emphasizes the importance of maintaining professionalism and respect when communicating grievances to prevent undermining the cause.

Estella adds a heartfelt plea:
“Please call and email,” (44:55) reinforcing the necessity for collective action to push for a grand jury indictment.

Appreciation and Final Thoughts

The episode concludes with heartfelt thanks to the listeners and the community that has rallied around Hailey’s case. Estella expresses profound gratitude:
“I cannot ever thank all of you enough,” (62:15) acknowledging the emotional support and active participation of the listeners in fighting for justice.

Barbara reinforces the human aspect of true crime:
“The real life, real crime community actually treats Haley like she was alive and like a person and almost like family,” (46:15) emphasizing the pivotal role of empathy and personal connection in the pursuit of justice.

Woody Overton leaves listeners with a stirring reminder of Hailey’s enduring presence:
“She's here,” (63:53) aiming to keep Hailey’s memory alive and driving the mission forward.

Conclusion

"Justice For Hailey: Call To Action" serves as a compelling culmination of meticulous investigation and heartfelt advocacy. By dissecting the procedural flaws and highlighting the emotional toll on Hailey’s family, Real Life Real Crime not only unravels the complexities of a potentially wrongful conclusion but also galvanizes its dedicated audience to take meaningful action. This episode stands as a testament to the power of community-driven justice and the relentless pursuit to honor Hailey’s memory.

Notable Quotes

• Woody Overton (07:32):
  “They never asked her what Brooks was wearing when they went over there.”

• Estella (08:16):
  “He wasn't wearing that short sleeve Champion shirt that he had on in the videos because it was freezing cold outside.”

• Woody Overton (09:02):
  “He changed his story time and time again.”

• Estella (10:37):
  “Haley had blood on the bed, which means he had to go in there afterwards.”

• Woody Overton (32:05):
  “The biggest mistake in the whole case is them sending Haley for an autopsy without having the complete information to give the pathologist.”

• Estella (26:07):
  “I believe Haley was passed out or asleep. She was not quiet.”

• Barbara (38:52):
  “Haley was right-handed, yet she had a chunk of hair in her right hand. How is that possible?”

• Woody Overton (51:15):
  “We're going to provide you with a list of numbers. There'll be telephone numbers to offices like the district attorney.”

• Woody Overton (53:14):
  “If you get a chance to talk, report, great.”

• Woody Overton (57:18):
  “That's what we want to change it to. And that just gave me God, boss.”

Action Steps for Listeners

1. Reach Out to the DA: Contact Stephanie Green, the new district attorney, to request a comprehensive review of Hailey’s case.
2. Engage with Media: Share Hailey’s story through interviews, social media posts, and other media platforms using the hashtag #JusticeForHailey.
3. Utilize Social Platforms: Amplify the call for justice by posting about Hailey’s case on social media, encouraging others to join the advocacy.
4. Maintain Respectful Communication: When contacting authorities or media, ensure that communication is assertive yet respectful to foster a constructive dialogue.

By following these steps, listeners can contribute to bridging the gaps in Hailey’s investigation and move closer to securing the justice she deserves.

Thank you for supporting Hailey’s pursuit of justice. Together, we can make a difference.