Real Life Real Crime | Shawn Grate Part 2: The Whisper That Stopped a Killer

Summary

---

Real Life Real Crime | Shawn Grate Part 2: The Whisper That Stopped a Killer

Hosts: Cindy Overton (with Woody Overton)
Date: June 22, 2026

---

Episode Overview

This gripping episode—part two of the Shawn Grate series—delves into the final days of the Ohio serial killer’s reign of terror, culminating in the extraordinary survival and rescue of his last intended victim. Cindy and Woody Overton guide listeners through the psychological build-up to Grate’s capture, the detailed timeline leading to the pivotal 911 call, and the profound impact of "the whisper that stopped a killer." Beyond recounting gruesome crimes, the hosts focus on honoring the victims, analyzing the psychology of control-driven serial offenders, and reflecting on the vulnerabilities that allowed such horrors to persist—and, ultimately, the remarkable act of courage that brought them to light.

---

Key Discussion Points and Insights

1. Review of Part One & Transition to New Victim

• Recap of Grate's Background: The episode opens with a summary of part one, recounting Shawn Grate’s troubled upbringing, criminal history, and the stories of previous victims: Dana Lowry, Rebecca Lecy, Candace Cunningham, Elizabeth Griffith, and Stacy Stanley. Grate’s method of operating "in plain sight" is emphasized.

  • Quote, Woody (05:29): “You know this story is about far more than a serial killer... The women need to be remembered for who they were and not simply for how they died.”

• The Final Victim’s Critical Role: Listeners are reminded the turning point comes with a woman who survived, an act which unraveled Grate's entire operation.

  • Quote, Woody (07:14): "What nobody knew was that his freedom was, thank goodness, only measured in days. Because the next woman...would do something extraordinary, and she would survive."

2. The Psychology of Serial Killers: Escalation and Compulsion

• The Cycle of Violence and Control: The hosts explore why serial killers continue, focusing on the psychology of compulsion, fantasy, and the ever-shortening “cooling off periods.”

  • Quote, Cindy (09:33): “The first murder may satisfy the fantasy for years. The next one may only satisfy for a few months...then weeks, then days.”

• Power/Control Offender Profile: They discuss how Grate fits the "power-control offender" archetype, with killing serving the need for domination and fantasy fulfillment.

  • Quote, Woody (09:56): “The murders appeared to be getting closer together...He was becoming more confident...that cockiness leads to being more dangerous.”

3. The Day Everything Changed: The Survivor’s Ordeal

• Establishing Trust: The soon-to-be survivor knew Grate from local community centers, had meals and conversations about faith with him, and trusted him (12:26–13:00).

  • Quote, Cindy (12:38): "To her, Shawn wasn't a romantic interest...she described him more like a friend...someone she believed was safe."

• The Attack: On September 11, 2016, Grate lures her to the abandoned house, attacks her, and holds her captive for 48 hours.

  • Quote, Cindy (14:12): "She fought and she resisted...but Shawn overpowered her...He punched her, he choked her, he restrained her."

• Imprisonment and Resilience: For two terrifying days, the woman endures repeated assault, forced captivity, and the foreboding knowledge that other women's bodies are hidden nearby—yet she “waited and watched,” searching for any chance to survive.

  • Quote, Woody (15:04): "She was looking for an opportunity to survive."

4. The Whisper That Saved Lives: The 911 Call

• The Call: Grate eventually falls asleep, and the captive woman manages to quietly call 911, whispering her predicament while still lying beside her captor.

  • Quote, Woody (26:07): “She made a decision...that decision ultimately saved her life. And ultimately, she exposed a serial killer...because Shawn Grate slept while she reached for a cell phone and she dialed 911.”
  • Quote, Cindy (26:48): “Fear. Silence. And then she whispered. She explained she had been kidnapped and she was being held against her will…”

• Critical Moments

  • (27:02–29:52) The hosts stress the immense courage required, noting she was not calling after escaping but while still “within arm’s reach.” They praise her calm, composure, and ability to assist law enforcement in locating her.
  • Quote, Woody (29:11): “She remained remarkably calm during this whole situation...to focus and to answer the questions to stay composed enough to help save her own life.”

5. Law Enforcement Response and Discovery

• Rapid Police Action and Shocking Scene: Police quickly respond and, upon entry, rescue the survivor and arrest Grate—unwittingly stepping into a house containing two other murdered women.

  • Quote, Woody (32:07): “She had found a way to call for help, and now all she could do was wait. And...police entered the residence...Shawn Grate, he was finally taken into custody; just like that, years of freedom ended in a matter of minutes.”

• Unfolding Horror: As the investigation unfolds, police find the remains of Elizabeth Griffith and Stacy Stanley, realizing they are not dealing with an isolated kidnapping or assault.

  • Quote, Cindy (34:15): “They located Elizabeth Griffith and Stacy Stanley...and at that point, detectives knew they weren’t dealing with an isolated crime.”

6. Building the Case: Interviews and Confessions

• Grate’s Manipulation: Grate initially withholds, then slowly divulges, information to investigators. His confessions help connect him to multiple unsolved cases.

  • Quote, Cindy (34:49): “Unlike many offenders who spent years denying anything, Grate eventually began providing information.”

• Victim Identification and Expansion of Scope: Further investigation ties Grate to the murders of Dana Lowry, Rebecca Lecy, and Candace Cunningham. The survivor’s story is the key to opening these cases.

7. Trial, Conviction, and Sentencing

• The Trial (2018): The trial focuses on the murders and the testimony of the survivor, whose courage in recounting her ordeal is repeatedly highlighted.

  • Quote, Cindy (39:44): “One of the things that stood out during the trial was the courage shown by the survivor...because without her testimony, this case would have been very different.”

• Death Penalty and Beyond: Grate is sentenced to death for the murder of Stacey Stanley and Elizabeth Griffith and later pleads guilty to other homicides.

  • Quote, Woody (43:13): “After deliberations, the jury did recommend the death penalty. And the judge agreed.”

8. Lessons, Reflections, and Legacy

• Ordinary Monster, Invisible Victims: The hosts reflect on how Grate appeared ordinary, and how societal disregard for vulnerable women enabled his crimes to go undetected for so long.

  • Quote, Cindy (46:25): “How did multiple women disappear before anyone connected the dots? Serial killers don’t look the way people expect...Many predators survive because they are ordinary looking and they can act ordinary.”

• Vulnerability and Power: Special attention is paid to Grate’s targeting of women who were marginalized by addiction, mental illness, homelessness, or poverty. The hosts urge listeners to remember the importance of supporting those living on the margins.

• The Survivor’s Defining Act: Ultimately, the survivor’s refusal to surrender agency is celebrated as the act that halted Grate.

  • Quote, Woody (49:49): “His crimes weren’t simply about killing. They were about domination, control, ownership...But that’s exactly why the survivor’s actions were so significant, because she took that control away from him.”

  • Quote, Cindy (50:00): “For years, he decided how every single one of these stories ended...That one woman changed everything with a whisper. Not a weapon...a whisper, a phone call.”

  • Quote, Woody (52:27): “This one ended with a victim who refused to become one. And there’s a difference.”

• Anonymity and Tribute: The survivor’s name is not public; she is known simply as “the survivor.” The hosts honor that, noting she rewrote the ending Grate had planned.

  • Quote, Woody (53:14): “He didn't get to do that to her. She wrote the final chapter for that segment of his life. She continues to write her own chapters.”

---

Most Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• “She whispered. She explained she had been kidnapped and was being held against her will—and that the man that took her was asleep beside her. Now, think about the courage that took.” — Cindy Overton (26:48)
• “The story changed because people started to look backward instead of forward...How did this happen? How did a serial killer operate for years without being caught?” — Cindy Overton (46:00)
• “The very things that should make people more deserving of protection sometimes make them less visible...Predators count on that because they understand when someone is living on the margins, they can disappear.” — Cindy Overton (48:45)
• “He didn't get to do that to her. She wrote the final chapter for that segment of his life. She continues to write her own chapters. He didn’t write that final chapter for her. And because she did that, the story ended very differently, much differently than what he intended.” — Woody Overton (53:14)
• “I think about one woman sitting in a room, hiding a cell phone, holding a cell phone, deciding, I’m going to survive today. And in the end, that’s what this story is about.” — Cindy Overton (53:51)

---

Important Timestamps

• 04:29–09:54 — Recap of previous episode and Grate’s psychological escalation
• 12:20–14:43 — The survivor’s relationship with Grate and the moment she is trapped
• 15:12–16:57 — Her captivity and calculated focus on survival
• 26:07–29:52 — The whisper 911 call and its critical impact
• 32:07–34:15 — Police intervention, rescue, and discovery of other victims
• 39:44–43:13 — The trial: survivor’s testimony, conviction, and sentencing
• 46:00–50:00 — Reflections on invisibility of victims, lessons for society
• 53:00–55:45 — Survivor’s anonymity and legacy, personal tributes from the hosts

---

Final Reflections

The episode closes with heartfelt messages of empowerment, remembrance, and a call to action: check on those who may be struggling, and remember that even the smallest act of courage—a whisper—can change lives. Cindy and Woody repeatedly center the victims, not the killer, urging listeners to honor those lost and to derive hope and vigilance from the example of the survivor.

---

Summary prepared for listeners who value in-depth true crime analysis, survivor-centered storytelling, and the complexities of seeking justice for the unseen and unheard.

Transcript

[Podcast Host (Talkspace Ad)]

This podcast is sponsored by Talkspace.

[Testimonial Speaker (Talkspace User)]

Last year I went through many different life changes. I needed to take a pause and examine how I was feeling in the inside to better show up for the ones who need me to be my best version of myself.

[Podcast Host (Talkspace Ad)]

When you're navigating life's changes, Talkspace can help. TalkSpace is the number one rated online therapy, bringing you professional support from licensed therapists and psychiatry providers that you can access anytime, anywhere.

[Testimonial Speaker (Talkspace User)]

Living a busy life, navigating a long distance relationship, becoming a first stepfather, Talkspace made all of those journeys possible. I could speak with my therapist in the office. I could speak with my therapist in the comfort of my home. I was never alone.

[Podcast Host (Talkspace Ad)]

Talkspace works with most major insurers and most insured members have a $0 copay. No insurance, no problem. Now get $80 off your first month with promo code space80 when you go to talkspace.com match with a licensed therapist today at talkspace.com save $80 with code space80 at talk

[Grainger Ad Narrator]

grainger knows when you're a procurement manager for an office park, you're not managing one building, you're managing all of them. And to stay ahead, you need to see through walls and around corners. Lights about to fail, Filters ready to clog H Vac on its last leg. If you wait until something breaks, you're already behind. Count on Granger for quality products, easy reordering and 24. 7 support. Call 1-800-GRAINGER call click grainger.com or just stop by Grainger for the ones who get it done.

[4 Patriots Ad Narrator]

Picture this the power goes out, your phone's at 50%, and suddenly your home is cold, dark, and you can't cook a thing. Oh, and it's the middle of winter. It's freezing cold air creeping in and you wrapped in blankets, hoping the heat kicks back on. Well, not anymore. Meet the new Patriot power generator 2200x from 4 Patriots, our biggest solar generator ever built to keep your essentials running through winter storms, rolling blackouts, ice outages, whatever hits next, it turns on automatically when the power goes out, can run a full size fridge for up to three days, and arrives fully charged. So you're ready the moment the lights go out. And right now, for the first time ever, you'll get a free 200 watt solar panel. And once this batch is gone, it's gone. Visit4patriots.com that's the number4patriots.com and claim your 2200x solar generator and free 200 watt solar panel. While this holiday offer lasts,

[Police/Legal Rights Voice]

You have the right to remain silent. Anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law. You have to write to an attorney prior to it during any question that you can't aff one the quarter point one for you. Do you understand your rights?

[Unknown (Possibly a Rap or Spoken Word Segment)]

That's for sure Already knows all about you Cut you down no matter by

[Police/Legal Rights Voice]

you

[Unknown (Possibly a Rap or Spoken Word Segment)]

now you better walk alive.

[Real Life Real Crime Warning Narrator]

Warning this episode of Real Life Real Crime. The podcast may contain descriptions of acts of violence or that of a sexual nature and should be for people that are 18 years or older. He my warning people, I do not

[Cindy Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

get the facts of these cases off

[Real Life Real Crime Warning Narrator]

of the Internet or for some television show. The facts I'm retelling you were presented to me by the victims of the crimes or or the perpetrators who committed the crimes against the victims. My descriptions of the crime scenes, what I saw with my own two eyes. If you're going to get offended, please turn this podcast off now. Thank you.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Hello everybody, and welcome to Real Life, Real Crime, a podcast by Woody Overton. But I am not Woody Overton. I'm Cindy Overton, and I am here to break the cycle. Usually Real Life, Real Crime episodes come on Saturdays, but this week we are doing part two of my Shawn Great series on Monday

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

so that Woody doesn't record today. And I don't mess up any stories

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

that he wants to talk about.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

So I just figured I would record a real life, Real crime, and

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

I

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

figured that I would record the second part of the series that I started on Saturday.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

So if you haven't listened to the first part, go back and do that before you come back here to listen to part two. But if you listen to part one

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

of our Shawn Great series, you know this story is about far more than a serial killer. I did that intentionally. I believe that the women need to be remembered for who they were and not simply for how they died. It was also about women whose lives intersected with a predator. And in part one, we talked about Shawn Gray's childhood and Marion, Ohio, his troubled path into adulthood, his criminal history and the years he spent drifting through Ohio. Well, basically hiding in plain sight. We talked about Dana Lowry, who was a young mother from Louisiana who traveled to Ohio, and she traveled there hoping to make a living selling magazine subscriptions.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

But she never made it home.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And then we talked about Rebecca Lecy, whose death initially failed to reveal the truth about the man responsible. And unfortunately, that led into Candace Cunningham, who was a woman who had developed a very trusting relationship. And then she ultimately became one of his victims. And it's hard to say. But then we talked about Elizabeth Griffith and Stacy Stanley. And these two women will ultimately be discovered inside an abandoned house in Ashland, Ohio. And this house in Ashland, Ohio, it's a house that Shaun Great had turned to his own private hunting ground.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And so when we left off with part one, investigators were searching for answers. Families were searching for loved ones.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And Shawn Great was still free. But what nobody knew was that his freedom was, thank goodness, only measured in days. Because the next woman, this woman that he targeted, would do something extraordinary, and she would survive.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Now, before we get into her history, I want to talk about something that criminologists and behavioral experts and things that

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

I love because I have a psychology degree they've studied for decades.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And so one of the questions people

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

ask in serial killer cases. There's many, many questions that people ask in serial killer cases. Why don't they stop? Why isn't one victim enough with that? Why do they keep going? And, of course, everyone is different. So that answer is fairly complicated.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

But for serial offenders, the killing itself

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

isn't really the goal. The goal is that feeling. Whatever feeling they get from the kill is what keeps them going. That's dark. It's twisted. And that feeling comes from the control that they get, the feeling of having the domination and ultimately living out whatever fantasy they've been playing over and over in their head, and they're making it come to life. And so with the control, you know, it's deciding what happens to another human life.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And for some offenders, those fantasies begin

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

years before their first murder even occurs. But over time, that fantasy grows and it becomes more important and more consuming. And then, of course, eventually, fantasy alone no longer satisfies whatever psychological need is driving the behavior. And that's when the escalation occurs.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

So the first murder may satisfy the fantasy for years.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And we saw that with Shawn.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

The next one may only satisfy for a few months.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And again, we saw that with Shawn, and then we saw the weeks, and now we're leading into the days.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And investigators often refer to this as

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

the cooling off period. The emotional reward fades, the fantasy returns, and the offender begins chasing that feeling again. And it's very much an addiction now to say that we have an idea of what was going through Sean GR's mind or any other habitual offender. We have no idea, truly. Do they even know what's going through their head? Because their life is full of lies. So I, you know, to know, we. We can't even begin to. To guess, honestly. But when investigators later examined his timeline, something did stand out. And sometimes the patterns and sometimes the actions,

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

you can say, show what was going on inside someone's mind.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

But sometimes actions don't equal mindset. But the murders appeared to be getting closer together, which we. That's what this has been leading up to. The gaps were shrinking, the risk were increasing. He wasn't just killing, he was becoming more confident. But in that confidence is cockiness. And that cockiness leads to being reckless, and it also leads to being more dangerous. Elizabeth Griffith was murdered, then Stacy Stanley. And only days later, basically you could count that as hours, simple hours to. To count. Another woman would find herself inside the same house.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

A house where two murdered women were already hidden. A house where Shawn Gray seemed to believe he was untouchable. What he didn't know was that the

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

next woman he targeted would become the reason his entire world collapsed. And interestingly enough, this happened on September 11, 20, 2016. Again, it was two days after Stacy Stanley disappeared. A 38 year old woman who met Shaun Gray for what she believed would be an ordinary interaction.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

The two had met previously at the

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Salvation Army Croc center in Ashland.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And they shared meals, he's grooming talk. They had taken walks, talked about life,

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

talked about faith, they talked about the Bible.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

To her, Shawn wasn't a romantic interest. Obviously, he wasn't someone he wanted to date. In later testimony, she described him more like a friend. Someone she trusted, someone she believed was safe.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And that trust would almost cost her everything.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

At some point that day of September 11th, Shawn told her he had a

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

bag of clothes that she could have.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

She also wanted to show him some Bible passages.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

So they went together to the abandoned house on Covert Court. The same house where Elizabeth and Stacy were both hidden.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

The same house that Sean was living in. And she obviously had no idea. And she walked through the front door

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

and she was honestly entering a crime scene, a house of horrors.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And she sat on a bed and she opened her Bible and she began showing Sean passages of scripture. Then, without warning, everything changed.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

His demeanor changed, his expression changed.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And the man she thought she knew completely disappeared.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

That veil came off the mask.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

So he grabbed the Bible from her hands and told her she wasn't leaving. She wasn't leaving that day. She wasn't ever leaving.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

But she fought and she resisted and she tried to escape, but Sean overpowered her. He punched her, he choked her, he restrained her.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Now, according to court testimony, over the next, the next two days, he repeatedly

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

sexually assaulted her while holding her captive inside the house for 48 hours. She lived with the knowledge that she might not ever leave that house alive.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And somewhere inside that same structure were the bodies of the two murdered women. What Shawn Gray didn't realize was that this victim hadn't given up. She didn't give up mentally, emotionally, physically. She was waiting. She continued to watch him.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And she was looking for an opportunity to survive.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

it paid off. Eventually, that opportunity came.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And on the morning of September 13, Shawn Gray fell asleep beside her.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

He eventually got worn out. And what happened next would become one of the most remarkable 911 calls in modern criminal history.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Now, the whole goal for this is,

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

as you're listening, you picture the scene, right?

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

We want you to be able to

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

feel it, see it. We don't want you to live it, but we want you to actually be able to picture it.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

So now the whole goal, as you're

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

listening to this, of course, is we want to invoke all of the senses, right?

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And so we want you to be

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

able, unfortunately, to picture it.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

We don't want to sensationalize it, and we don't want you to feel like

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

you're reliving what this woman went through,

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

but we want you to be able

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

to picture the scene.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And sometimes when we hear about a crime years later, we already know the ending. We know that this one survived, and we know that Shawn Gray was arrested. We know justice eventually came, but she didn't know any of that. So just for a moment, put yourself in that room. Don't put yourself in that place. Put yourself in the room. So It's September of 2016. She's in an abandoned house. The curtains are drawn. The house is quiet, eerily quiet. There's no television because there's no electricity. There's no neighbor stopping by, no family expected to stop by. No reason for anyone to come through that front door.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

No reason for hope that she might survive.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

It's the kind of house that most people would drive past without a second glance. But upstairs in a bedroom, there's a woman who's been held captive for two days. And she's exhausted. She's injured, and she's terrified. And somewhere else inside that house are two other women that didn't survive.

[Sponsor Ad Narrator (Shopify/BetterHelp/Chilipad)]

Hey, y'.

[Testimonial Speaker (Talkspace User)]

All.

[Cindy Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Starting something new isn't just hard. It can be really scary.

[Sponsor Ad Narrator (Shopify/BetterHelp/Chilipad)]

When Cindy and I first started real

[Cindy Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

life, real crime, we didn't know if anybody would listen. We had all the same doubts people have when they start a business or chase a dream. What if it fails? What if nobody cares? What if we put everything we have into it and it goes nowhere. But sometimes you just gotta take that leap of faith. And honestly, having the right tools and the right partners can make all the difference. If something like Shopify had been around

[Sponsor Ad Narrator (Shopify/BetterHelp/Chilipad)]

when we first started building out our

[Cindy Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

merch and online side of the business, it would have saved us a whole lot of stress. Shopify is the commerce platform behind millions of businesses around the world and 10% of all e commerce in the US from household names like Heinz, Mattel and Skims to brands that are just getting started. Accelerate your efficiency. Whether you're uploading new products or trying to improve existing ones, Shopify is packed with helpful AI tools that write product descriptions, page headlines, and even enhance your photography. Plus, Shopify helps you get the word out with easy to run email and social media campaigns whenever your customers are scrolling or strolling. Best yet, Shopify is your commerce expert with world class expertise in everything from managing inventory to international shipping, to process and returns and beyond. Everything's all in one place which makes running your business so much smoother. And if you ever get stuck, Shopify's award winning 247 customer support has your back. It's time to turn those what ifs into with Shopify today. Sign up for your $1 per month trial today at shopify.com RLRC go to shopify.com RLRC that's shopify.com RLRC

[Sponsor Ad Narrator (Ruggable)]

in case y' all don't know, Cindy is big and making her house feel like a home from all the seasonal decorations which y' all know I love to tease her about to the ruggable rugs she puts on floors making her house feel warm, welcoming and comfortable. That's really important to her. And Cindy has found several ruggle rugs

[Cindy Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

that really fit our home and our

[Sponsor Ad Narrator (Ruggable)]

style, especially in those high traffic areas

[Cindy Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

that deal with the everyday life around here.

[Sponsor Ad Narrator (Ruggable)]

Dogs running through the house, muddy boots during hunting season and just life me in general. One of our biggest high traffic areas is the kitchen and putting a ruggable rug under the table and one by the door really changed the whole look of the space while helping protect the floors where we get the most traffic. Then add in visits from our grandbaby and holidays and a full house. Y' all know those ruggable rugs take a beating. That's what's great about ruggable. They look great but they actually built for real life. They're stain resistant, machine washable, non slip and easy to clean. Which is huge for us because when you've got dogs, family and people constantly in and out. You need something that can hold up and still look good. And if something gets spilled on the rug, rugs, Cindy can literally throw it in the wash. And there are so many styles to choose from. Modern, cozy, classic, bold, whatever fits your vibe. Sydney loves it. She can make the house look beautiful without stressing over every little mess or spill. So refresh your home at Ruggable. Get 10% off your first order sitewide with promo code [e-mail] that's r u

[Cindy Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

g g a b l e dot

[Sponsor Ad Narrator (Ruggable)]

com and use code rlrc at checkout.

[Police/Legal Rights Voice]

Hey y'.

[Sponsor Ad Narrator (Shopify/BetterHelp/Chilipad)]

All.

[Cindy Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

You're listening to a show about the darkest corners of human behavior. And let's be Honest, it's probably 11pm you're in bed with the lights off, slightly more aware of every sound in your house than you were an hour ago. And here's what I know about you. You're not sleeping great. Not because of the show. Well, maybe because of the show, but because your bed is hot, you're restless, and your brain does not know how to turn off. The good news is that one of those things is completely fixable.

[Sponsor Ad Narrator (Shopify/BetterHelp/Chilipad)]

And it's not the brain.

[Cindy Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

It's the temperature of your bed. Today's episode is brought to you by chilipad2 oh by sleep me. Chillipad 2.0 is a water based mattress topper that actively controls your bed temperature from 55 to 115 degrees all night long. It works on top of your existing mattress. No overhaul needed. You said your temperature, it holds it and your body finally gets the cool, stable sleep environment it needs to drop into deep restorative rest. The 2.0 is a full redesign. The new dock is significantly quieter, important when you're already sleeping with one ear open. Now with an easy to use twist lid and a large internal tank for less refills. The topper is now premium waterproof cover that unzips for easy wash and is built to last. The nightstand remote is the feature I keep coming back to your side of. The bed gets its own dedicated physical thermostat with sensors that detect the moment you get in and automatically start your program sleep schedule. No reaching for your phone, no fumbling in the dark. You just get in, it detects you and it handles the rest. Dual temperature zones are available. If you share a bed, you want it 60 degrees and your partner wants it 75. Well, usually someone loses. With our dual zone tech, you both win. Control each side fully independently. No compromises. And if you want a completely phone free bedroom. You never have to open the app at all. No subscription. You own it. Two year warranty designed and assembled in the US just north of Charlotte, North Carolina. Y', all, I can tell you all the time. I wake up in the middle of

[Sponsor Ad Narrator (Shopify/BetterHelp/Chilipad)]

the night and I'm hotter than I

[Cindy Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

was when I laid down to go to sleep. I and then I have to get up and turn the air conditioner down colder. It just messes up everything I have going on when I'm trying to rest. Temperature regulation that I don't have to mess with is awesome. So visit www.sleepme.rlrc to get up to $255 off your Chilipad 2.0 with code RLRC. The special office is available for the real life Real crime listeners and only for a limited time. Order it today with free shipping and returns. Try it out for 30 days and you can return it for free. If you don't like it with their sleep trial, visit www.sleepsleep.me RLRC and see why Cool sleep is worth every cent.

[Sponsor Ad Narrator (Shopify/BetterHelp/Chilipad)]

This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. You know, may is Mental Health Awareness Month and it's a good reminder that whatever you're going through, you don't have to go through it alone. Life can get overwhelming. Some days feel manageable, some days don't. And a lot of times the things that keep you up at night are the things you don't talk about with anyone. It's easy to feel like you're supposed to figure it all out on your own, but the truth is, nobody has all the answers and you shouldn't have to carry everything by yourself. Having someone to talk to, someone who will listen and help you work through what's going on, can make a real difference.

[Cindy Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Therapy is a way to check in

[Sponsor Ad Narrator (Shopify/BetterHelp/Chilipad)]

with yourself and understand where you are and what you need. Better help makes it easier to get started. They match you with a licensed therapist based on your needs and preferences and if it's not the right fit, you can switch at any time. It's about finding the right support for you. And during Mental Health Awareness Month, it's a good time to pause and really check in with yourself because you don't have to navigate things alone. You don't have to be on this journey alone. Find support and have someone with you in therapy. Sign up and get 10% [e-mail] that's

[Cindy Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

B E T-T E R H E

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

L P.com she doesn't know where they are. She doesn't know the full horror of what happened there. But she knows one thing. If she doesn't find a way out,

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

she's not going to survive either.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

So then you're picturing that. Let's look across the room.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Actually, maybe you don't want to, but she had to.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And right there was a man responsible

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

for all of this, right beside her, close enough to hear her breathe, close

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

enough to wake up at any moment,

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

and close enough to stop whatever she tries next.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

But somehow, despite all of that, I

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

guess she figured, I'm going to die either way, right? So despite all of that fear and despite all of what she had endured the last 48 hours, she made a decision. And that decision ultimately saved her life. And ultimately, she exposed a serial killer. Because Shawn Grate slept while she reached for a cell phone and she dialed 91 1.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

So she dialed 911 and the dispatcher answered. And for a moment, there was almost nothing. They couldn't hear anything.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

There was just some breathing going on.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Fear, Silence.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And then she whispered.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

She explained she had been kidnapped and

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

she was being held against her will

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

and that the man that took her

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

was asleep beside her. Now, think about the courage that that took.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Now, we've all called.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Not we've all, but a lot of

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

us have called 911 for emergencies.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And I know that when I'm excited and I'm scared or whatever, my voice gets loud. So to control the volume, I cannot imagine. And I hope that none of you will ever experience what this woman was experiencing at that moment. And I know that some of you have. And to those of you that have, my heart goes out to y'. All. And I don't know you, but I

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

am very proud of you. And please tell your story

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

so that other women have hope. But let's get back to this story.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Sorry, again, she wasn't calling from safety like she.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

She was.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

She wasn't even calling from another room. She wasn't calling after she escaped, running. I'm.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

You know, she was.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

She was still trapped. She was literally right beside him inside that house, within arm's reach of the man who held her captive for two days. And any wrong move and that call would be over, and she would be dead. So the dispatcher, trained as they are,

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

immediately understood the seriousness of the situation, and they began asking questions.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

What's your name?

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Where are you? Can you see an address?

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Who is holding you? But there was a problem. She didn't know where she was. She knew she was in a house, and she knew it was somewhere In Ashland. And she knew the man's name was Sean. But she couldn't simply just walk outside and check a mailbox. Every movement carried risk. Every sound mattered. So as the dispatcher continued speaking with

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

her, law enforcement began trying to identify the location of the cell phone. And somewhere deep inside, she remained remarkably calm during this whole situation. And I think that is one of the most incredible parts of this story. Not just that she called, but that she was able to think during this time and to focus and to answer the questions to stay composed enough to help save her own life. Because fear, ultimately, with a lot of

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

people, shuts them down.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

We have flight. Flight. Freeze, Fawn. Of course, terror can freeze people.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

But somehow, she kept going While officers

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

were working to locate her.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Thank goodness Shawn Gray remained asleep, at least for the moment.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And every minute that passed had to feel like an hour.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Imagine staring at the person who had

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

kidnapped you, sitting on 91 1, trying to.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

One answer, trying to.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

To not let the dispatcher be heard through the phone.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

I know someone sitting next to me

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

oftentimes can hear what the person on

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

the other side of the phone is saying, you know, so trying not to

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

have the dispatcher heard, and you're wondering if that person's about to wake up. Wonder if actually help is coming. Wondering if you get out of there in time. And outside the house, police officers were quickly moving what they believed at that point was serious enough. They believed a woman was being held hostage. They believed a kidnapping victim was inside

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

that residence, and that alone would be explanation for an urgent response.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

But what they didn't know was they were about to walk in to something much bigger and much darker. And luckily, officers eventually arrived at the house on Covert Court. And as they approached, they had no way of knowing exactly what they would encounter. Of course, they didn't know who the suspect was, but they certainly didn't know if he was armed or if he would fight, if he would barricade himself inside and possibly kill the victim once he knew of their arrival.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And these were all the questions that

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

any officer faces in times of situations like this.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

But this call was different, because somewhere inside that house was a woman who

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

had managed to do the impossible. She had found a way to call for help, and now all she could do was wait. And I'm sure she had a glimmer of hope inside of her. And ultimately, police entered the residence, what she had been waiting for, and they located her, and she was alive, and she was finally safe. And Shawn Grate, he was finally taken into custody just like that, years of freedom ended in a matter of minutes. The drifter, the manipulator, the predator who believed he could control everything, was suddenly in handcuffs and had control of nothing. Well, I say nothing. He will control conversations. He will control the narrative, he thinks. But he couldn't kill. So officers did what officers do. They blocked off the area. Well, first they scoured the scene, right? They want to figure out what else is going on inside this house. And what was going on quickly became apparent that this wasn't just a kidnapping case. This wasn't just. And I say just lightly or not lightly. I don't say just for this next one lightly. This wasn't just a sexual assault investigation because there were signs of something far worse that happened inside that house. And then as investigators moved room to room through the abandoned residence, they were

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

about to uncover a reality that would shock even seasoned law enforcement officers.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And they had not just captured a kidnapper. They found a serial killer.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

So Shawn Grates, now in custody, and investigators began processing the house.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And inside the residence, they located Elizabeth Griffith and Stacey Stanley.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And they were the two missing women

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

investigators had been searching for. And at that point, detectives knew they weren't dealing with an isolated crime. And then they started to question, how

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

many others are there?

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

So then investigators began interviewing Great, and

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

they discovered something that would become a recurring theme throughout the case. Now, he wanted to talk.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Not immediately and not all at once.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

But unlike many offenders who spent years denying anything, Great eventually began providing information. And over the course of multiple interviews,

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

detectives slowly pieced together a much larger picture. And as that picture developed, investigators began connecting him to other unsolved deaths and missing women. Cases that had previously seemed unrelated suddenly had a common denominator.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

One of the most significant developments involved

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Dana Lowery, which is the young woman

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

from Louisiana who was a mother that

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

we talked about in part one. Remember, Dana's case had remained unsolved, but now investigators had a suspect. And then they had Rebecca Lecy, then Candace Cunningham. And with each new confession and each new piece of evidence, the scope of the investigation expanded. And finally, investigators were able to notify families. But unfortunately for those families, old wounds were reopened. And then the uncertainty ended. But that doesn't necessarily mean peace. It doesn't mean peace at all.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

It just replaces one kind of pain with another.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Investigators would later describe Great as someone

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

who could be cooperative at one moment

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

and manipulative the next. And of course, that's not unusual. Even after they're caught, even after the

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

game is over, they still want to

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Be the person deciding what others know and when they know it. Like I said, he was being controlled by his movements with those handcuffs and being in jail, but he would continue to try to control the narrative. Now investigators began working through what they called confessions, which I put in quotation marks like confessions.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

But they were building a case, and it was a strong case because they had a survivor, and of course, they had a crime scene and physical evidence and witness testimony.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And then they began to increasingly get Great's own statements. By this point, there was little question about whether Grate would spend the rest of his life behind bars. The question was whether Ohio would seek the death penalty. And guess what? The answer was 100%, absolutely yes. The murders of Elizabeth Griffith and Stacy Stanley would ultimately become the centerpiece of the capitol murder case against him.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

But before a jury could hear the

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

evidence, the public was beginning to learn

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

details about a man behind the headlines. A man who for years had moved

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

through communities without drawing much attention. A man who looked ordinary again. A man who relied on trust, manipulation, and vulnerability. And now, for the first time, that full picture was coming into focus. Like I said, not just for investigators or prosecutors, but for those families who spent years searching for answers.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

As the case moved forward and toward

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

trial, prosecutors focused heavily on the murders of Elizabeth Griffith and Stacy Stanley, along with the kidnapping, rape, and attempted murder of the survivor.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And by this point, the evidence against

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Shang Great was overwhelming because they had the survivor that had identified him. Police had found him inside that house where the bodies of Elizabeth and Stacy had been discovered. They gathered lots of physical evidence, and,

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

of course, Grate himself made numerous statements

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

connecting him to the crimes. The trial began in 2018 in Ashland County.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And over the course of the proceedings,

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

jurors heard testimony from investigators, forensic experts, witnesses, and the survivor herself. And they heard about the abandoned house on covert court.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

They heard about the women who disappeared

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

and the days the survivor spent in captivity.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

They heard about the 911 call that

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

ultimately brought everything to an end. And one of the things that stood out during the trial

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

was the courage shown by the survivor. Imagine sitting in a courtroom describing one of the most terrifying experiences in your life. You sit there and you relive it in front of the man that did it to you. You have to answer questions about it. Look at the person responsible sitting just a short distance away. But she did it. She did exactly that. Because without her testimony, this case would

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

have been very different. It would have looked very different.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And after hearing the evidence, the jury

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

found Sean Gray guilty as charged.

[Sponsor Ad Narrator (Shopify/BetterHelp/Chilipad)]

You're listening to this podcast. I know you've got a curious mind. Here's a helpful fact you might not know yet. Drivers who switch and save are Progressives. Save over $900 on average. Pop over to progressive.com, answer some questions

[Cindy Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

and you'll get a quick quote with

[Sponsor Ad Narrator (Shopify/BetterHelp/Chilipad)]

discounts that are easy to come by. In fact, 99% of their auto customers earn at least one discount. Visit progressive.com and see if you can

[Cindy Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

enjoy a little cash back.

[Sponsor Ad Narrator (Shopify/BetterHelp/Chilipad)]

Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates national average 12 month savings of 946 buy new customers surveyed who saved with progress between June 2024 and May of 2025.

[Cindy Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Potential savings will vary when you're a

[Grainger Ad Narrator (Alternate)]

maintenance engineer in a beverage manufacturing plant, you keep production lines moving and quality on track because there is no room for slowdowns. With Grainger's vast selection of high quality motors, sensors, belts and hard to find parts, you can get what you need fast and all in one place. So nothing gets in the way of getting the job done. Call 1-800-GRAINGER clickranger.com or just stop by Granger for the ones who get it done.

[4 Patriots Ad Narrator]

Picture this. The power goes out, your phone's at 50% and suddenly your home is cold, dark and you can't cook a thing. Oh, and it's the middle of winter. It's freezing, cold air creeping in and you wrapped in blankets, hoping the heat kicks back on. Well, not anymore. Meet the new Patriot power generator 2200x from 4 Patriots, our biggest solar generator ever built to keep your essentials running through winter storms, rolling blackouts, ice outages. Whatever hits next, it turns on automatically when the power goes out, can run a full size fridge for up to three days and arrives fully charged. So you're ready the moment the lights go out. And right now, for the first time ever, you you'll get a free 200 watt solar panel. And once this batch is gone, it's gone. Visit fourpatriots.com that's the number four patriots.com and claim your 2200x solar generator and free 200 watt solar panel while this holiday offer lasts.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

So then came the penalty phase.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And this is where the jurors had

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

to answer one final question. What's going to happen to him?

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

For the families of the victims, there

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

was no sentence, obviously, that could bring back the people they loved. No verdict would allow Stacey Stanley to return home.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

No sentence would allow Elizabeth Griffith another chance at life. And no punishment would give Dana Lowry's daughters their mom back but the legal

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

system still had a responsibility to act. And after deliberations, the jury did recommend the death penalty. And the judge agreed. So Shawn Grate was sentenced to death. Later, he would plead guilty to additional

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

murders, including the deaths of Dana Lowry,

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Rebecca Lacey, and Candace Cunningham. Over time, the picture investigators had suspected became reality.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

This wasn't, as we know, a single

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

murder, wasn't a crime of passion, a one time loss of control like when he was arrested when he was 18. This was a serial killer.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

One whose victims crossed multiple counties, stretched

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

across many years, and targeted vulnerable women. And that's who I think about when I think about this case. I don't think about Shawn Gray. When I picture. When I'm telling you this story and I'm picturing it as I tell it,

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

I've never once in my head pictured

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

what Shawn Gray looks like. But I can tell you I've pictured what Dana Lowry looks like. I could picture her leaving Louisiana to make a better life for herself. I've literally pictured what Rebecca looked like. Candace Cunningham, Elizabeth Griffith,

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Stacey Stanley.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And our survivor. Because if she had not made that call, we would never know the full extent of what the nasty Sean Grate had done.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And to be honest, there's probably more victims, there's probably more disappearances that weren't connected, and there's probably still more families waiting for answers.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And if he hadn't been arrested, there definitely would have been more.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

If the victim hadn't have stepped up

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

to do what she did, there definitely would have been more. And because of that, of what she did, a serial killer's freedom came to an end. That's the legacy of this case.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

So as the trial came to a close and the verdicts were returned, something interesting happened. Not the story. The story changed. The story didn't change in the courtroom or in the evidence or in the facts. The story changed because people started to

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

look backward instead of forward.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

So for years, Sean Gray had simply been another guy, you know, drifting around Ohio.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

He took up old jobs, he stayed

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

with friends, he moved from place to place. And he was a guy who most people wouldn't remember if they passed him in a grocery store. But now everyone was asking the same question. How?

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

How did this happen?

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

How did a serial killer operate for

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

years without being caught?

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

How did multiple women disappear before anyone connected the dots? And honestly, for those in law enforcement that are anywhere, the answer isn't simple. Part of it is because serial killers don't look the way people expect. It doesn't look like someone frightening or someone Obviously dangerous. But many predators survive because they are

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

ordinary looking and they can act ordinary. They just go on, just. They know how to have conversations. They know how to manipulate people to

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

make them feel comfortable and appear harmless.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And Shawn Grade appears to have understood that very well.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

But there was also another reason he

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

got away with it.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

His victims, as I've said many times in this, were vulnerable. And that's not a criticism to them.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

It's part of life. We're all vulnerable in different parts of our day. Even like if I go to a gas station, if I'm distracted and my

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

head's not on a swivel, I'm vulnerable. Unfortunately, a woman in society is vulnerable. So this isn't victim shaming at all.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

I want to bring light to one. If you have someone that is would be considered in a high risk lifestyle,

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

don't let them be alone.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Like, if you can't be the one to help them, you know, at least give them sources to where they can potentially get help.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And if you have to let them

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

go, you have to let them go.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

But anyway, I just want to make

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

it clear how easily at any given time, we are all vulnerable. And that vulnerability, in a split second can make us disappear from the public, from our families.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

So several of the women in the case struggled with difficult circumstances. And we just to review some of them, we had mental illness, housing instability, addiction, financial hardship, and isolation.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And those are specific to this case.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

The very things that should make people more deserving of protection sometimes make them less visible instead. And predators know that. Predators count on that because they understand that when someone is living on the margins, they can disappear.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

They can go over that margin very quickly.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

This doesn't mean that their families don't care.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

But the system often responds differently.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And when investigators began reviewing Shaun Gray's victims together, they saw a pattern over and over again. Not women who looked alike, not women from the same neighborhood, not even from the same background. But they were women who were accessible to him. They were vulnerable to him, and he was able to control them. And that's one reason criminologists often place

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Shawn Grate in the category of power control offender.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

His crimes weren't simply about killing. They were about domination, control, ownership, the

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

ability to decide what happened to another person. But that's exactly why the survivor's actions

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

were so significant, because she took that

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

control away from him.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Now think about it. For years, he decided how every single one of these stories ended. He decided who lived, he decided who died, who disappeared, who got to tell their Story that one woman changed everything with a whisper. Not a weapon, not a fight, not a dramatic escape, a whisper, a phone call.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Nine, one, one.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And that moment she made the call. Shawn Gray's control began slipping away.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And by the time police officers arrived, it was over. And he didn't know it yet. And I find that very fascinating. Throughout history, some of the most significant moments have been incredibly small in what the overall scheme, when they happened,

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

could be a signature on a document.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

It could be a single decision, a vote, a single phone call. And in this case, a woman quietly speaking into a cell phone while the sleeper, while the serial killer slept nearby.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

That changed everything. Not just for her. It was a domino effect for every family connected to the case. I'm going to repeat them again because they are the people that are important here. For Dana Lowry's family, for Rebecca Lecy's family, for Candace Cunningham's family, for Elizabeth Griffith's family, for Stacy Stanley's family. Because once Shang Great was caught, answers finally started coming. Although painful, but they were answers. And they were answers that these families spent years hoping for. They allowed them to stop wondering. Not because Shawn Gray was unique. Unfortunately, history has seen serial killers before. But what makes this case remarkable is again, how it ended.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Most serial killers get caught because of a mistake.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And he was getting there, he was getting close. It comes down to a traffic stop or DNA, a fingerprint. This one ended with a victim who

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

refused to become one. And there's a difference.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And one thing that always stayed with

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

me about this case is that we

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

know the names of the women Shaun Gray murdered. But the woman who stopped him remains

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

unknown to the public.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Now, most court records identify her only as initials. Most media reports simply call her the survivor. And that's appropriate because Shawn Gray spent

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

years trying to take away other people's identities, reducing women to bodies, reducing lives

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

to secrets, reducing human beings to things he could control.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

He didn't get to do that to her. She wrote the final chapter for that segment of his life. She continues to write her own chapters. He didn't write that final chapter for her. And because she did that, the story ended very differently, much differently than what he intended.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

When people hear the name Shawn Graz

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

today, they think about a serial killer. I don't. I think about these women. I think about Dana, Stacy, Elizabeth. I think about the families.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

I think about one woman sitting in

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

a room, hiding a cell phone, holding a cell phone, deciding, I'm going to survive today. And in the end, that's what this story is about. And if I had this woman's name, I would have said it over and over and over again. But she doesn't need to hear it.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

She needs her anonymity.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

It took courage to do what she did. And sometimes courage is simply a whisper. And that's where we're going to leave the story. If you've listened to both parts of this series, thank you for joining me on my first, first real life real crime storytelling.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And you probably heard me choke up

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

a couple times in this.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

Because cases like this are difficult. They're heartbreaking and frustrating, and sometimes they're hard to understand. But it's important to tell these stories not for the killers, but for the victims, because all of them deserve to be remembered. And I know their family remembers them every day. There's not a day that goes that none of these victims families don't think of them. And the survivor whose courage changed everything.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

I hope you're listening to this because

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

you are a strong, powerful woman, and

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

I can't imagine what you've gone through

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

with dealing with this in life.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

The PTSD you struggle with, I can't imagine what you deal with. But I thank you and other victims

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

out there that are trying to potentially

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

get out of just a hard lifestyle that I hope are listening to this. Just a whisper. It's all it takes. And that whisper is so hard.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

I hope this gives you a little bit of hope and strength, and I

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

encourage you to keep these families in

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

your thoughts and prayers.

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

And if there's anything that I hope that you take away from any of

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

this is please pay attention to people, check on people, and reach out to people, because sometimes the people who are struggling the most are the easiest to overlook. And this is just life in general. Like, sometimes the people struggling are the quiet ones. Someone reached out to me and told me that they suffered for in a domestic abuse relationship. This is a strong woman, a very giving woman, and she was getting to spend time with her best friend for

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

life since junior high school, and they've

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

been friends for over 20 years. And when the woman that was going through the domestic abuse relationship, she never once told even her best friend. She went through it in silence until

[Woody Overton (Co-host, Real Life Real Crime)]

she got the courage to get out of there.

[Cindy Overton (Host, Real Life Real Crime)]

But do you know what that best friend would have done to help her move mountains? But people don't want to bother anyone. They want to do what they've got to do. And I understand that you can't trust the person that you love. They're abusing you. You. You lose trust in humanity sometimes. But please keep reaching for help. Call 91 1, do the whisper. Thank you for spending time with me and I'm Cindy Overton and this has been real life, real crime and I truly love and appreciate each and every one of you and take care of yourselves, take care of each other and never ever stop seeking the truth and as always, see you next time.

[Police/Legal Rights Voice]

You have the right to remain silent. Anything you say can and will be used against you in accordance court of law. You got a right to an attorney prior to it during any question. If you can't afford one, the quarter point one for you. Do you understand your rights.

[Unknown (Possibly a Rap or Spoken Word Segment)]

When the wolf is at your. Running over that's for sure you

[Police/Legal Rights Voice]

already

[Unknown (Possibly a Rap or Spoken Word Segment)]

know all about you cut you down no matter by you now you better walk.

[American Express Ad Narrator]

There's nothing like my American Express Platinum card. I love that I can earn hotel credits when I travel. I can also earn resi credits so you know I'm hitting the restaurants everyone's talking about. Plus with the digital entertainment credit, I'm even more excited to catch my favorite shows. All in all, I can access over $3,500 in annual value with benefits and eligible purchases across travel, entertainment and more. Learn more@american express.com Explore Platinum enrollment requirements monthly and other limits and terms apply.

[Grainger Ad Narrator (Alternate)]

When you're a maintenance engineer in a beverage manufacturing plant, you keep production lines moving and quality on track because there is no room for slowdowns. With Grainger's vast selection of high quality motors, sensors, belts and hard to find parts, you can get what you need fast and all in one place so nothing gets in the way of getting the job done. Call 1-800-GRAINGER Click grainger.com or just stop by Grainger for the ones who get it done. This is the story of the one As a maintenance engineer at a beverage manufacturing plant, he starts his day knowing every line is ready to run because Grainger delivers the industrial grade products he needs to keep mixers, conveyors and packaging equipment moving. With Grainger's vast selection of bearings, belts and motors, he keeps operations running smoothly so nothing grinds to a halt. Call 1-800-GRAINGER Click grainger.com or just stop by Grainger for the ones who get it done.