Real Life Real Crime: RLRC Original | Screwdriver Red: Murder Bayou Reboot

Release Date: May 2, 2025

Introduction and Content Warning

The episode begins with host Woody Overton issuing a stark content warning to listeners:

Mike Brown [01:10]: "Each episode of Real Life Real Crime... describes acts of violence or of a sexual nature and are for people that are 18 years or older. Heed my warning people. If you are going to get offended, turn this podcast off now."

This sets the tone for the intense and graphic true crime narrative that follows.

Shackling the Shouts: Recognizing Fellow Podcasters

Before delving into the main case, Woody Overton extends recognition to fellow podcasters, specifically celebrating the Canadian true crime duo behind Dark Poutine. He praises their unique approach and collaborative dynamic, fostering a sense of community within the true crime podcasting sphere.

Woody Overton [03:00]: "If you don’t find something interesting in Dark Poutine, well, maybe you need to get your temperature checked."

Case Background: The Murder of Kaitlyn Adell

The core of the episode centers on the chilling case of Mark Lewis, also known as "Screwdriver Red," and his conviction for the second-degree murder of Kaitlyn Adell. The narrative traces back to 1993, detailing the brutal murder of Janet Benoit in a Mormon Church parking lot in Denham Springs, Louisiana. Benoit was shot three times in the back after resisting her attacker, leaving behind critical evidence such as strawberry blonde hairs and DNA samples from her hands.

Woody Overton [07:30]: "He shot her three times in the back, but assume that means she was running away, probably after she beat his ass and yanked the hairs out of his head."

Reopening the Case: Breakthrough with DNA Evidence

Fast forward to the trial of Kaitlyn Adell, where new DNA evidence surfaces, linking Mark Lewis to the 1993 murder of Janet Benoit. This breakthrough propels detectives to revisit Lewis's history, uncovering his involvement in multiple violent crimes.

Woody Overton [12:45]: "DNA came back to a prostitute that was murdered in 1993... I can't fucking believe it."

Courtroom Confrontation: The Face-to-Face Encounter

A pivotal moment unfolds in the courtroom when Woody confronts Lewis directly. Drawing inspiration from the film "The Patriot," Woody challenges Lewis with a poignant line about the repercussions of one's past actions.

Woody Overton [14:20]: "Have you ever thought maybe the sins of your youth would come back to haunt you?"

Lewis's reaction is telling—his pallor and lack of response underscore his guilt and the weight of his crimes.

Verdict and Aftermath: Justice Served

The jury delivers a unanimous guilty verdict for second-degree murder, ensuring Lewis faces life imprisonment without parole. The courtroom is rife with emotion, with both the victim's family and the detectives visibly moved by the outcome.

Woody Overton [19:05]: "There were cries in the courtroom and I'll never forget this. I almost got teared up about it."

Detective Ben Ballard: A Pillar of Integrity

Highlighting the collaborative efforts in the investigation, Woody commends Detective Ben Ballard for his dedication and compassion towards the victim's family. Ballard's presence, holding the victim's mother's hand during the verdict reading, exemplifies the human side of law enforcement.

Woody Overton [20:10]: "It just goes to show what kind of character Ben Ballard has as a human being and as a detective."

Reflections on a Serial Offender

The episode delves into Lewis's history of violence, suggesting that his confession was driven by a desire to conceal a broader pattern of criminal behavior. Woody speculates on the psychological makeup of Lewis, painting him as a narcissistic and psychopathic individual whose manipulations ultimately led to his downfall.

Woody Overton [26:50]: "Why does he confess?... Because he already knew... he has more bodies on him."

Legacy of Justice and Closure

Concluding the series, Woody shares heartfelt messages from those affected by the case, emphasizing the lasting impact of justice served. He acknowledges the emotional toll the investigation has taken on both the victims' families and the detectives involved.

Woody Overton [35:25]: "She sent me a collage of pictures of her and Caitlin together. And then, you know, she... After all these years, it may brought a tear to my eye."

Conclusion: Moving Forward

As the episode wraps up, Woody reflects on the journey of the Screwdriver Red series, expressing gratitude to his listeners and patrons. He hints at exciting developments for the podcast's future seasons, promising fresh content and continued dedication to solving cold cases.

Woody Overton [42:00]: "Real Life, Real Crime is killing it. We made so many great connections... We're going to have a lot of new stuff, new audio, new formats, more information..."

This episode of Real Life Real Crime masterfully concludes the Screwdriver Red series, intertwining meticulous investigative detail with poignant human experiences. Woody Overton's compelling storytelling not only sheds light on heinous crimes but also honors the pursuit of justice and the resilience of those affected.