Real Life Real Crime: True Crime Time For - April 14, 2025

Hosted by Woody and Cindy Overton

1. Justice for Hailey: The Kyren Lacey Tragedy

Timestamp: [01:23] - [06:11]

Woody Overton opens the episode by addressing the ongoing efforts to seek justice for Hailey through the hashtag #JusticeForHailey. He updates listeners on the case of Kyren Lacey, a promising LSU wide receiver whose promising career was tragically cut short.

• Incident Overview: Kyren Lacey, at 24 years old, was involved in a severe vehicle crash on LA20 that resulted in the death of 78-year-old Herman Hall. Authorities have charged Lacey with negligent homicide, citing speeding and illegal passing as contributing factors. Additionally, he faces charges related to a hit-and-run and reckless operation of a vehicle.

• Legal Proceedings: Just before his case was to be heard by a grand jury, Lacey was charged and subsequently found dead in Houston, leading to speculations of suicide. His father, Kenny Lacey, emphasized the importance of mental health awareness, stating, “Mental health is real. For the most part, it's invisible. Don't ignore the signs, even if they may be small.”

• Impact and Reflections: The tragic end to Kyren’s life not only halts his entry into the NFL draft but also leaves the Hall family without closure. Woody reflects, “Life is definitely short,” underscoring the profound loss and the complexities surrounding justice and mental health.

2. Jordan Love Animal Cruelty Case

Timestamp: [09:49] - [13:01]

Cindy introduces a harrowing case from Detroit involving Jordan Love, a 29-year-old accused of extreme animal cruelty.

• Incident Details: Love posted a video on social media showing her stabbing her dog multiple times, claiming the animal had attacked her and a cat. Authorities responded swiftly after the video went viral, rescuing the injured dog and other animals from her home.

• Legal Actions: After fleeing to Greenville, South Carolina, Love was extradited back to Michigan and arraigned on multiple charges, including second-degree killing, torturing animals, and abandonment. She faces up to nine years in prison and is currently under GPS monitoring as she awaits trial.

• Community and Legal Perspectives: Woody criticizes Love's actions vehemently, stating, “You took the time to put it on camera. Fuck you,” highlighting the brutality and irresponsibility of using social media to broadcast such violence. Cindy emphasizes the broader issue of animal abuse and the importance of holding perpetrators accountable.

3. South Carolina Execution: The Case of Mikal Motty

Timestamp: [16:16] - [22:36]

Woody and Cindy discuss the execution of Mikal Motty in South Carolina, marking the first firing squad execution in the U.S. in 15 years.

• Case Background: Mikal Motty was convicted for a multi-state crime spree in 2004, which included the murder of an off-duty police officer whom he shot and set on fire. His execution involved a firing squad, which he chose over other methods, reportedly perceiving it as the "lesser of the evils."

• Execution Details: On April 9th, Mikal consumed a substantial last meal consisting of a ribeye steak, mushroom risotto, broccoli, collard greens, cheesecake, and sweet tea. During the execution, witnesses reported that Motty cried out and groaned as the first bullets hit him, leading to his death at 6:05 PM.

• Legal and Moral Reflections: Woody critiques the justice system's handling of the case, expressing frustration over Motty's choice of execution method and the severity of his crimes. Cindy touches on the broader implications of capital punishment and its application in heinous crimes.

4. The Menendez Brothers' Ongoing Legal Battle

Timestamp: [23:13] - [25:45]

The discussion shifts to the high-profile case of the Menendez brothers, who remain in legal limbo despite ongoing discussions about their release.

• Current Status: The Menendez brothers are nearing the conclusion of their legal proceedings, with hearings scheduled. Woody expresses skepticism about their potential release, questioning the fairness and consistency of the justice system.

• Public Perception and Media Influence: Woody criticizes the media's portrayal and public support for the brothers, arguing that fame should not influence the outcomes of justice. He states, “What about the people who really deserve a shot?” emphasizing the need for equitable treatment regardless of notoriety.

5. Heartbreaking Death: A 97-Year-Old Woman Left in the Snow

Timestamp: [25:45] - [29:17]

Cindy narrates the tragic story of Corey Brewer, a 97-year-old woman with dementia, who was intentionally left outside in freezing temperatures in Peyton, Colorado.

• Incident Overview: Corey Brewer, suffering from cognitive impairments, was abandoned outside without adequate clothing or shelter during a cold snap with temperatures dropping to 16 degrees. Her family reported her missing the following day, only to discover her deceased due to hypothermia.

• Emotional Impact: The couple reflects on the cruelty of leaving an elderly, vulnerable person exposed to the elements. Woody shares insights from his personal experiences, emphasizing the gravity of neglecting those who depend on others for care.

• Community Response: Brewer's grandson is actively speaking out, attempting to hold accountable those responsible for her abandonment. The case highlights systemic issues in elder care and the dire consequences of neglect.

6. Baker, Louisiana: Horseback Riders Cause a Stir at Walmart

Timestamp: [37:12] - [43:35]

Woody and Cindy cover a bizarre incident in Baker, Louisiana, where four horseback riders caused a commotion inside a Walmart store.

• Incident Details: On April 11th, three adult men and one minor rode horses through Baker's Walmart, capturing the event on social media platforms like TikTok, X, and Facebook. The videos went viral, prompting multiple arrests for misdemeanors related to disturbing the peace and unlawful posting of criminal activity.

• Law Enforcement Response: Baker Police Chief Carl Dunn explained that the riders, dubbed the "Cutthroat Cowboys," turned themselves in after the video gained attention. The charges are relatively minor, reflecting the nature of the stunt rather than any intent to cause serious harm.

• Public and Media Reaction: The community and listeners are both amused and concerned about the potential dangers of such reckless behavior, with Cindy questioning the riders' awareness of the risks involved. Woody humorously imagines the chaos if the horses had behaved unpredictably, reinforcing the irresponsibility of the act.

7. Community Engagement and Fundraising in Louisiana

Timestamp: [34:10] - [36:22]

Woody shares a successful fundraising event held in Baker, Louisiana, where the team raised over $1,000 for the Louisiana Oregon Procurement Agency through community support and local businesses.

• Event Highlights: Collaborating with Walk Ons Bistro and local supporters like Sid Gotro and Matt Wisdom, Woody and Cindy hosted an impromptu fundraiser that involved serving beer and engaging with the community. The event showcased the power of local support and collective effort in aiding non-profit organizations.

• Community Impact: Cindy emphasizes the significance of such initiatives in helping others, reflecting on the positive outcomes achieved through dedicated community involvement and the generosity of local businesses and individuals.

Notable Quotes

• Woody Overton ([01:23]): “Life is definitely short.”

• Kenny Lacey ([03:47]): “Mental health is real. For the most part, it's invisible. Don't ignore the signs, even if they may be small.”

• Woody Overton ([22:22]): “You took the time to put it on camera. Fuck you.”

• Cindy Overton ([28:48]): “Can you imagine dying at 97 years old with cognitive impairment? You don't know what's going on. You don't know.”

Closing Remarks

Woody and Cindy wrap up the episode by reflecting on the discussed cases and emphasizing the importance of justice, community support, and accountability. They also tease upcoming episodes that will feature shows from the road, promising fresh content and continued dedication to uncovering the truth behind real-life crimes.

Stay Connected:

For more detailed discussions and updates on these cases, listeners are encouraged to tune into the "Real Life Real Crime" podcast and engage with the community through social media channels.