Real Life Real Crime: True Crime Time For – April 21, 2025

Hosted by Cindy Overton of Real Life Real Crime Productions

In the April 21, 2025 episode of True Crime Time For, host Cindy Overton delves into a series of gripping true crime stories, including the tragic Florida State University shooting, groundbreaking breakthroughs in cold cases, and high-profile legal battles. Amidst these intense narratives, Cindy also shares personal updates, offering a heartfelt glimpse into her life and ongoing commitment to the true crime community.

1. Personal Reflections and Show Updates

Timestamp [00:45]

Cindy begins the episode with a poignant update, revealing that the Overton family is experiencing an extreme loss. Despite this hardship, she expresses determination to continue producing episodes and introduces an exciting new segment:

"One of the things that I thought about the other night and I thought it would be a really fun idea to implement was to have you, our wonderful lifers, tell stories of your own in a segment that we're going to call True Crime Time with the Lifers." (00:45)

She encourages listeners to submit their own true crime stories, fostering a collaborative and interactive community.

2. Florida State University Shooting

Cindy recounts the harrowing details of the April 17, 2025, shooting at Florida State University's student union, perpetrated by 20-year-old Phoenix Ichner.

Key Details:

• Incident Time: Approximately 11:56 AM
• Weapons Used: Handgun and shotgun
• Duration: Four-minute shooting spree
• Victims: Two fatalities (Robert Morales and Tiru Chaba) and six injuries

Notable Quotes:

"I'm just going to imagine what that four minutes felt like to everybody and how long and terrifying that was." (08:30)

Cindy reflects on the broader implications of gun violence in educational institutions and questions preventive measures:

"At some point are we going to be able to develop a profile and be able to hopefully see the tendencies in someone's behavior and help us to stop this?" (16:20)

She emphasizes the emotional toll on survivors and the community:

"I really hope that those students are getting the help and support that they need, all of them." (18:45)

3. Breakthrough in the Medford Cold Case

Transitioning to a cold case, Cindy narrates the resolution of the 2017 disappearance and murder of Phyllis Baylor in Medford, Oregon. Decades of investigative efforts culminated in 2025 with the identification of the suspect through advancements in forensic genetic genealogy.

Key Points:

• Disappearance Date: July 7, 1972
• Resolution: Identification and subsequent linking of Fred Allen Linneman to the case
• Impact: Provides closure to a five-decade-old tragedy

Notable Insights:

"This case underscores the power of forensic genetic genealogy in solving cold cases." (25:50)

Cindy highlights the emotional significance of finally providing answers to Phyllis Baylor's family, particularly the surviving daughter who was found unharmed beside her mother.

4. Sean "Diddy" Combs Faces Serious Allegations

Cindy covers the high-profile legal challenges faced by music mogul Sean "Diddy" Combs, detailing the timeline of his arrest and the charges against him.

Key Details:

• Arrest Date: September 16, 2024
• Charges: Sex trafficking, racketeering, and additional allegations from a former partner
• Trial Status: Judge Aaron Subramanian denied a two-month trial delay on April 18, 2025; trial set for May 5, 2025

Notable Commentary:

"He is a titan in the industry, and facing these grave allegations has captured national attention." (30:10)

Cindy outlines the seriousness of the charges and the potential implications for Combs's career and legacy.

5. Arrest of Canadian Drummer Joseph Paul Ciders

The episode also covers the arrest of Joseph Paul Ciders, a drummer for the Canadian indie rock band The New Pornographers, charged with possession and distribution of child sexual abuse materials.

Key Points:

• Arrest Date: April 9, 2025
• Location: Palm Desert, California
• Charges: Possession of child sex abuse materials, molesting a child, invasion of privacy
• Band's Response: Immediate severance of ties and public condemnation

Notable Reflections:

"There's just no way of protecting them. And thank goodness they reported it." (35:45)

Cindy emphasizes the importance of vigilance and reporting in protecting children from such heinous crimes.

6. Continued Advocacy and Community Engagement

As the episode draws to a close, Cindy reiterates her commitment to advocating for justice and supporting the true crime community amidst personal challenges.

Call to Action:

"We will continue to fight for justice for Haley as long as we have to." (39:10)

She urges listeners to remain engaged, participate in the new "True Crime Time with the Lifers" segment, and support ongoing justice initiatives.

Personal Note: Cindy shares a touching moment inspired by a local race event, highlighting the collective resilience and support within the community:

"I sat there and I cried. I wear my heart on my sleeve and I did." (40:20)

Conclusion

The April 21, 2025 episode of True Crime Time For offers a compelling mix of recent true crime cases, personal storytelling, and community involvement. Cindy Overton's dedication to uncovering the truth and supporting victims shines through, providing listeners with both informative and emotionally resonant content.

Listeners are encouraged to submit their own true crime stories for future episodes and to continue supporting the Overton family during their time of loss. The episode underscores the enduring impact of true crime narratives and the essential role of community in seeking justice and closure.