Real Life Real Crime — "True Crime Time For December 16, 2025 | When Abuse, Betrayal, and Justice Collide"

Hosts: Woody Overton & Cindy Overton
Date: December 16, 2025

Overview

This episode of Real Life Real Crime with Woody and Cindy Overton delivers a series of intense, true crime stories centered around the themes of abuse, betrayal, and the pursuit (and sometimes failure) of justice. Woody’s direct, sometimes irreverent style blends with Cindy’s compassion and insight as they tackle cases of parental abduction, bizarre repeat offenders, shocking child abuse, institutional betrayal by authorities, and international justice. The episode oscillates between deeply troubling and strangely humorous, all delivered in their signature candid, Southern tone.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Lighthearted Banter & The “Cold” Open

(03:36 - 09:07)

• Woody and Cindy kick off with jokes and banter about the freezing weather, swapping “colder than” euphemisms, setting a relaxed and personal tone.
  • “Colder than your heart.” — Cindy Overton [06:00]
  • “Colder than a brass toilet seat in the Yukon.” — Woody Overton [07:07]

2. Family Matters: Utah Parental Abduction

(09:28 - 12:49)

• Case: A Utah man, Benjamin Despain, abducted his 5-year-old son, James, after a visitation, aiming to prevent him from undergoing routine surgery (adenoid removal).
• Despain sent an email to the child’s mother, Natalie, explaining his motivation. He was found and arrested two days later.
• Woody and Cindy relate with personal anecdotes about their own son’s similar surgery, noting how medical interventions can dramatically improve a child’s life.
  • “So he just stole the son.” — Cindy Overton [11:10]
  • “They handed him to me, he’s coming out of anesthesia… bloody murder, screaming. …You’re not leaving, this shit’s not normal!” — Woody Overton [12:33]

3. The Serial “Butt Sniffer”: A Lighter—But Disturbing—Criminal

(12:54 - 24:12, continued at 23:20)

• Case: Kelise Crowder, notorious for following women in public spaces, crouching behind them, and sniffing their butts. Despite a documented history, he is repeatedly released after complaints, only to reoffend.
• Detailed testimony from a recent victim who filmed Crowder in a bookstore. Victims express frustration at the system’s failure to intervene.
  • “He was right under me… he said he was tying his shoe, supposedly, which he wasn’t. …It’s honestly infuriating.” — Victim Testimony [13:48]
  • “Some people deserve to be in jail cells.” — Woody Overton [15:04]
  • “Do you want your wife, your daughter, your granddaughter, having their butt sniffed by this asshole?” — Woody Overton [15:37]
  • Extended, humorous riffing from Woody and Cindy about the absurdity of a “serial butt sniffer,” usage of excuses, and how he keeps getting caught.
• Notable Moments:
  • “If you were a serial butt sniffer, I’d take you to Murder Bayou.” — Woody Overton to Cindy [24:20]
  • “He’s got a $100,000 bond for butt sniffing!” — Cindy Overton [23:57]

4. Family Matters: Pennsylvania Child Abuse Horror

(25:11 - 29:21)

• Case: Two women in Pennsylvania (Amy Billett, Sarah Lynn Faber) arrested and charged with over 950 counts after horrifically abusing their adopted teenage son: duct taping him to the floor, starvation, forced cold showers, keeping him confined and under surveillance, even physically mutilating him.
• School officials initiated the investigation after noticing the boy was malnourished.
  • “They forced him to stand up for long periods… withheld food… lost 20 pounds.” — Cindy Overton [25:27]
  • “Slicing the genitals… yeah, I’m pretty sure they’re fucking twisted.” — Woody Overton [29:36]

5. Effed Up Professionals: Rape, Grooming, and Murder by a Cop

(29:46 - 35:24)

• Case: Former Massachusetts police officer Matthew Farwell accused of sexually abusing a girl he met at 13 (he was 26), grooming her, impregnating her, and ultimately murdering her when she threatened to go public. He staged her death as a suicide.
  • “He began molesting when she was 15… So it makes it a little worse, right?” — Woody Overton [30:33]
  • “Her death was originally ruled a suicide. …But that was later reversed.” — Cindy Overton [33:50]
• The episode highlights the frustration and outrage that Farwell will not face the death penalty due to a prosecutor’s discretion.
  • “You start raping a girl when she’s 15, you’re a police officer…” — Woody Overton [34:26]
  • “Most honorable thing you could do, you start raping her when she’s 15, you get her pregnant, and because you don’t want to tell your wife or whatever… you strangle her to death.” — Woody Overton [34:49]

6. Effed Up Professionals: The Demonic Pediatrician

(35:38 - 47:44)

• Case: Dr. Ernesto Cesar Torres, a Maryland pediatrician, convicted of sexually abusing dozens of young female patients over decades. He tried to blame the victims, saying they were possessed by “demonic entities.”
• The hosts, especially Woody, are incensed by his manipulation, lack of remorse, and the length of his abuse.
  • “He said he was a prophet in a previous life. And that there were demonic entities possessing these young girls into lying on him.” — Cindy Overton [40:55]
  • “Only young pre-pubescent girls are filled with the devil? Didn’t you know that?” — Woody Overton [41:02]
  • Victim’s statement: “Now I can’t trust male authority. My childhood was taken away from me.” — Cindy Overton relaying victim’s words [45:26]
  • Woody’s wrath: “When he goes house prison, he’s 70 years old. I hope they butt him every day.” [41:39]
• Legal efforts ongoing to prosecute further offenses and ensure a sentence far exceeding the remainder of his life.

7. Worldwide Crime: Iran’s Swift and Final Justice

(48:57 - 53:01)

• Case: In Iran, a stepmother is executed by hanging at dawn for the murder of her four-year-old stepdaughter. The family of the victim is allowed to demand the death penalty (“Qisas” law).
• Woody contrasts the Iranian response with the long, procedural justice in the US, musing that such swiftness might be warranted in the most egregious abuse cases.
  • “Iran… they wish they had a pediatrician like that out there. They took care of his ass.” — Woody Overton [49:47]
  • “This is the only time in the history of my entire life… you’re ever gonna hear me give Iran [credit].” — Woody Overton [53:01]

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On abduction and medical neglect:
  • “Our son had the trifecta… tubes in his ears, adenoids removed, tonsils removed. Changed his life for the better.” — Cindy Overton [12:04]
• On the limits of justice and repeat offenders:
  • “He’s doing it again. Some people deserve to be in jail cells.” — Woody Overton [15:04]
• On shocking child abuse:
  • “It's like the witch fattening up Hansel and Gretel before she eats them.” — Woody Overton [28:45]
• On predatory officials:
  • “Age of consent in Massachusetts… that needs to be changed.” — Cindy Overton [32:37]
  • “Imagine strangling the woman that you got pregnant. The most personal form of death that there is.” — Woody Overton [35:07]
• On the demonic defense:
  • “And there were demonic entities possessing these young girls into lying on him.” — Cindy Overton [40:55]
  • “I hope they butt him every day.” — Woody Overton [41:39]

Timestamps for Major Segments

• 03:36 – Opening exchanges; “cold as” euphemisms, banter
• 09:28 – Utah parental abduction/medical interference
• 12:54 – Serial butt sniffer case w/ victim testimony
• 23:20 – Continued discussion of Crowder’s serial offenses
• 25:11 – Pennsylvania child abuse/duct tape case
• 29:46 – Massachusetts cop grooms, impregnates, and murders teen
• 35:38 – Maryland pediatrician child sexual abuse, “demonic possession” defense
• 48:57 – Iran: stepmother executed for child murder; host commentary on retribution

Tone & Style

• Candid, coarse, Southern storytelling: Woody’s language is often unfiltered, with plenty of dark humor and outrage.
• Supportive dynamic: Cindy provides empathy and perspective, and acts as a check/balance in particularly sensitive segments.
• Victim-focused: Despite the rough-edged humor, the show is forthright about the trauma to victims and critical of institutional failures.

For Listeners

This episode is a blend of twisted tales, moments of gallows humor, and unapologetic outrage. It exposes patterns of failed justice—where abusers are enabled by institutions, or punishment simply doesn't fit the crime—and contrasts it with places where justice is swifter (even if controversial). For anyone interested in true crime that doesn’t shy away from tough questions and emotional intensity, this episode offers a compelling and deeply human perspective.

End of summary.