
Loading summary
Narrator/Advertiser
This podcast is supported by the RealReal. Meet Christine. She loves shopping and this is the sound of fashion overload. Too many fabulous things, not enough space. So Christine started selling with the RealReal.
Advertiser/Promoter
I've always loved collecting designer pieces, Gucci bags, Prada heels. But my style keeps evolving.
Cindy Overton
Selling with the RealReal game changer.
Advertiser/Promoter
I earn more and they do everything.
Narrator/Advertiser
Seriously. Just drop off your items or schedule a pickup. We handle the photos, descriptions, pricing, even shipping. You just sit back and watch your items sell fast to our 38 million.
Advertiser/Promoter
Members and I get peace of mind knowing I earn more selling with the RealReal than anywhere else.
Narrator/Advertiser
Exactly this. That's the sound of your closet working for you. The RealReal earn more, save time, sell fast. And right now you can get an extra $100 site credit when you sell for the first time. Go to therealreal.com to get your extra $100. Therealreal.com that's therealreal.com Toyota THON Toyota Thon.
Toyota Announcer Jan
Toyota Thon is on. Oh what fun it is to drive a new Toyota today. Hey Jan from Toyota here reminding you Toyota Thon is on. Make your holiday wishes come true with a new Camry, RAV4 Tacoma and more. All right, let's sing it together this time. Toyota Thon Toyota Thon Toyota Thon is.
Woody Overton
Dealer Inventory may vary.
Toyota/Commercial Voice
Toyota thone ends January 5th.
Woody Overton
See your participating dealer for details. Toyota let's go Places.
Toyota/Commercial Voice
If you're a maintenance supervisor for a commercial property, you've had to deal with everything from leaky faucets to flickering light bulbs. But nothing's worse than that ancient boiler that's lived in the building since the day it was built 50 years ago. It's enough to make anyone lose their cool. That's where Grainger comes in. With industrial grade products and dependable, fast delivery, Grainger can help with any challenge, from worn out components to everyday necessities. Call click grainger.com or just stop by Grainger for the ones who get it done.
Advertiser/Promoter
When you think about businesses that are selling through the roof, sure you think about a great product, a cool brand and brilliant marketing. But an often overlooked secret is actually the businesses behind the business making selling simple for millions of businesses. That business is Shopify. Nobody does selling better than Shopify. They're the home of of the number one checkout on the planet and the not so secret shop pay that boosts conversions up to 50%, meaning way less carts going abandoned and way more sales happening. Businesses that sell more sell on Shopify. Upgrade your business and get the same checkout allbirds and skims use. Sign up for your $1 per month trial period at shopify.comstartselling or all lowercase go to shopify.comstartselling to upgrade your selling today. Shopify.com startselling.
Woody Overton
Hello, everybody and welcome to this episode of true crime. Time for Tuesday, December 23rd, 2025. And I'm Woody Overton.
Cindy Overton
I'm Cindy Overton.
Woody Overton
And it's Merry Christmas Eve Eve.
Cindy Overton
I know.
Woody Overton
The day before Santa Claus drops bombs. Yeah. And love. Love and cheer and all that. I don't shoot Santa Claus. The if the weather was better I probably would be hunting. And make sure I see a big old bug that it's not Rudolph. I don't want to kill Santa Claus shit.
Cindy Overton
It's not a good idea to kill Santa Claus's shit.
Woody Overton
Right? The But I'm sure there's some drunk asshole out there that's going to take shots at him.
Cindy Overton
I'm sure there's a lot of drunks that have ridden around shooting at all those things in people's yards over the years.
Woody Overton
I have never ever shot at a Christmas decoration.
Cindy Overton
I have. Wasn't saying Woody Overton or swim. I just said there's plenty of people that do.
Woody Overton
I'm sure there are. And shame on them. So the little bit of Christmas here and we love y' all and Merry Christmas and all that good shit. Right? All that good podcast or shit. Hashtag just for Bradley. Hashtag just for ao. Stay on track people. I didn't murder them. I took on this case. Never going to get off of it. The no matter how long it takes. If it ends tomorrow. For it ends 50 years from now. One in or however long I got left then never going to get off of it. So Continue calling your tips 313RLRC tips.
Co-host/Guest
They work.
Woody Overton
They work. They work. And I can't tell you anything. Wish I could. You don't think I'm working it? You don't like the route it's going. Turn this shit off now. But that being said, let's roll with some true crime time for the day before Christmas Eve.
Cindy Overton
All right.
Woody Overton
All right. Favorite Christmas present you ever got.
Cindy Overton
I'm going to go with my little strawberry shortcakes. I love them so much.
Woody Overton
You do like sweet salt.
Cindy Overton
Well, they were the little dolls that smelled. I was mesmerized by them.
Woody Overton
I totally know that. I'm just messing with you. Late night sweet attacks.
Cindy Overton
That's true.
Woody Overton
So.
Cindy Overton
Yeah.
Woody Overton
But we don't ever have strawberry shortcakes. I only had it a couple times. I do remember those dolls. You remember?
Cindy Overton
Yeah.
Woody Overton
I can remember all the big rages like the Cabbage Patch Kids. And I can remember. Oh my God. The very first computer that ever came out with a green screen. That was about my daddy's or I'm sorry Santa Claus's present to our whole family. We had to share that one. Yeah. But distinctly remember my favorite Christmases were the first compound bow I ever got. It was a Golden Eagle 3. And then my first big rifle ever got ruger mark or M77 270 with a Leopold golden ring 2x7 scope bolt action.
Cindy Overton
Yeah. Well I just remembered as you were saying that I think Underoos super. I mean Wonder Woman underooves were probably another one of my favorite.
Woody Overton
Spider man camera. I had a Spider man camera. I'm obviously made out of hard place but it had a 9 millimeter film. The. I had a Spider man doll. My GI Joes. And I got one I'm about to really fuck you up on. But I love My GI Joe's are big GI Joe's.
Cindy Overton
Yeah.
Woody Overton
The kung fu grip.
Cindy Overton
Dubs says.
Woody Overton
Oh and I had like the forts and shit. The headquarters and stuff for them. But then. Then no, not quite bad. My mama always made it a good Christmas or Santa Claus always made a good Christmas. But I got one for you. You ready for this? And it just hit me. One of my all time favorite toys. Wee Blaze.
Cindy Overton
Oh like weevils wobbles and we don't fall down.
Woody Overton
Is it webways.
Co-host/Guest
Whatever the.
Woody Overton
They were like little egg shaped dudes. It wasn't ball down.
Co-host/Guest
So I had this little tree house.
Woody Overton
And had a hidden door on it. You could put your weeblo behind it.
Cindy Overton
I don't want to steal. I. I would have to agree. That was a pretty cool Stompers.
Co-host/Guest
What about stompers? Stompers were the.
Woody Overton
These little. These little. I must have been like 7 years old little vehicles. They ran off a single double A battery and that it would go underwater. It would. Yeah. It was like a big truck but a miniature big truck. Yeah. And we'd go out there and make a mud puddle and just let our stoppers run through it. And my army men.
Cindy Overton
Yeah.
Co-host/Guest
Oh my God.
Woody Overton
I had boxes full of little plastic green armor.
Cindy Overton
Yeah.
Woody Overton
Yeah.
Cindy Overton
I actually liked my big wheel too. That end.
Woody Overton
Oh.
Co-host/Guest
Big wheels and bicycles.
Woody Overton
Holy. Yeah.
Co-host/Guest
Good times.
Woody Overton
And it's Christmas time and I hope y' all all get what you want and love and peace and all that good stuff. Oh and let's let this be the last Christmas the bad people that took Bradley and Austin from us that they get to breathe free Christmas air? My death or incarceration, I don't give a fuck. And the spring Bradley home. All right, that's enough about me. Okay, you better. We gotta hurry up so you can get in the kitchen, make me some savory treats. Oh my gosh. I'm getting this. A shrimp. Wow. Do y' all know what pick a pepper is?
Cindy Overton
Yeah.
Co-host/Guest
You found it. Yeah. Oh, so you were a falsehooder last year?
Cindy Overton
There were. They weren't. There was none.
Woody Overton
I was secretly having a panic, hell, my entire life. Pick a pepper. It's got two uses. One, you pour it over cream cheese and eat it with a Ritz cracker. Two, it goes in my shrimp dip.
Cindy Overton
Yes.
Woody Overton
And Cindy told me unequivocally last year they did not make pick a pepper.
Cindy Overton
Anymore because last year they literally did not.
Woody Overton
They didn't have a website, they didn't have.
Co-host/Guest
I'm not disputing it.
Woody Overton
I'm just saying what you told me last year, I didn't dispute. I didn't dispute it. But thank you Jesus for sweet baby Jesus for bringing pickled pepper back.
Cindy Overton
Yes. Because when I went to I actually bought extra bottles because I'm so afraid of happening what happened last year to happen again.
Woody Overton
Why don't you buy them a bottle of crime?
Cindy Overton
We're going to Tennessee for this one.
Woody Overton
Which part?
Cindy Overton
Dixon. And There was a 17 year old girl who was fatally shot on Tuesday, December 16th. She attempted to escape from her ex boyfriend's vehicle while it was obviously in motion. So that's why it's a Planes, trains and automobiles. And so according to Dixon Police Department, the victim, who's Taylor Cheyenne Rattery, she was picked up from her former boyfriend Hunter Jackson, who was 18 years old, after she left work around 8pm and during that ride, apparently they got into a heated argument and she tried to get out of the moving vehicle. But Jackson prevented her from getting out and during the struggle he shot her inside of his car. Officers were dispatched to the area near the intersection of Highway 70 east and Hensley Drive. And because they had received multiple phone calls, including a report of a reckless driver, followed shortly by a report of a traffic accident, according to the local news station wkrn. And when police arrived at the scene, they located Rattery suffering from the gunshot wounds and she was transported to Skyline Medical center for emergency treatment. But despite all of the medical effort, she didn't make it. Authorities have not released any additional details about the moments leading up to the shooting, Nor have they publicly stated what prompted the confrontation. But the relationship history between the two is being described as just former romantic partners. In the most recent reports, Hunter Jackson was identified as the shooter and the investigation remains ongoing.
Woody Overton
There you have it. Another domestic, domestic death murder. Not death, murder. Murder murder. It's time for effed up professionals. Well, speaking of murders, what do you do when someone gets murdered and you find the body?
Cindy Overton
Call 91 1.
Woody Overton
Okay, and what does 911 do?
Cindy Overton
They talk to me until police arrive or first responders or someone comes.
Woody Overton
What do they do with the body?
Cindy Overton
911 doesn't do anything with the body.
Woody Overton
You said the police came.
Cindy Overton
Yes.
Woody Overton
What do they do with the body, Captain Obvious?
Cindy Overton
They call an ambulance or the coroner and have them bag it and tag it and take it to get an autopsy.
Woody Overton
Then what do they do with the body?
Cindy Overton
The people that are doing the autopsy, whoever.
Woody Overton
What happens to the body?
Cindy Overton
Well, it either gets put in a casket and buried in the ground or it gets cremated.
Woody Overton
Thank you. Now to my story. We're going to San Jose, California. We're going to San Jose, California and I'm gonna tell you about effed up professional. So this guy son had died, his name, his name Alexander Pinion. Okay. And he died by how or however he died. Right. And the. And so he has to go. You know, they pay, the family pays for a fuel full funeral. They sign a contract for the mortuary for a full $10,000 full service memorial tribute package which included embalming, dressing, casketing, transportation of the remains and a funeral service. Right. So in the. The young man Pinion died back in May.
Co-host/Guest
So.
Woody Overton
You know, we're very fortunate. The, the people that buried my whole entire family and bury almost everybody in this part of the of Louisiana are very dear friends of ours. Uncle George, Southern term. Y' all know my not blood relation was my daddy's best friend and he died. And then of course they buried my dad. They buried everybody I know and they're the best. We could call them up on the ph now, right? Well, unfortunately they have some assholes who are not that good and don't take their job as personally as the Charlie say. So let me tell you about this family said the issue began when they decided they want to bury opinion in different clothes than what he had died in. So they called funeral home and, and say hey look, can we do that? Bring y' all some clothes and. And Pena's father, the funeral director was like, yeah, yeah, her name's Annette Anita Singh. And so Pena's father picks out some clothes. I just had to do that for my dad. Pretty tough deal. And goes to the mortuary, meets the lady who does very nice. And took Pinion's clothes. And she handed that they had a bag back, which was red label, said biohazard material on it. And she said, here are your sons. You just see son's clothing, right? And I'm sure they, you know, they picked out caskets and did all that shit. And then, well, dad got home sooner or later, and he's like, I guess, you know, being sentimental and want to take care of his son's clothes. And he goes to the washing machine and he opens it up, and he opens a bag up and he dumps it in the washing machine. Well, it really wouldn't be an issue, but the bag is. According to the father, the bag did not contain any clothing, but it contained human brain matter. And dad. So now looking at his. The c. Son's brain in his washing machine. Can you imagine?
Cindy Overton
You sure this isn't Cobb County?
Woody Overton
Yeah, sorry. You should. Hey, y'.
Co-host/Guest
All, I want to take a moment to recommend another podcast called Mind of a Monster, the Killer Nurse. Mind of a Monster is a podcast series from ID that dives into minds of notorious serial killers like Jeffrey Dahmer.
Woody Overton
Ted Bundy, and more.
Co-host/Guest
This season, they explore the chilling story of Kristen Gilbert, a nurse who murders four of her patients between 1989 and.
Woody Overton
1995 and is suspected of killing dozens more.
Co-host/Guest
Criminal psychologist Dr. Michelle Ward takes us inside Kristen's twisted mind, uncovering why she kills and how she manages to do it right in front of her colleagues. The entire season is out now, so you can binge it wherever you get your podcasts. And coming up next, they're covering Israel Keys, a serial killer who picks his victims at random across the US and covers his tracks with terrifying precision. That new season drops early next year. Don't miss it, lifers. I know you love to get inside.
Woody Overton
The mind of evil, just like I do.
Co-host/Guest
And the Mind of a Monster podcast.
Woody Overton
Series from ID Is fire. You are going to love it.
Co-host/Guest
Listen to A Mind of a Monster, the Killer Nurse. Wherever you get your podcasts. You know, there was a stretch where I just couldn't figure out why I felt so drained all the time. No matter how much I slept, I was exhausted, foggy, and even little things like keeping my focus felt harder than they should. I brushed it off, thinking it was just stress or being busy, but it turned out my iron levels were way.
Woody Overton
Lower than I realized.
Co-host/Guest
That's why I was excited to learn about Sideroll. It's not your typical iron supplement. It's powered by something called Sucrosomil technology which helps your body actually absorb three to four times more iron while avoiding the common issues you hear about with.
Woody Overton
Traditional iron like nausea or stomach upset.
Co-host/Guest
It's backed by over 150 clinical studies and trusted worldwide. Siderol is actually Italy's number one supplement brand and is now available here in the US. I love that it's just one capsule a day with vitamin C included so it easily fits into my routine. Plus it's vegan, gluten free and allergen free so it works for just about anyone. Ever feel like no matter how much you rest, you're still running on empty?
Woody Overton
You're not alone.
Co-host/Guest
Over 2 million people worldwide have already discovered Cedarol and it could be the support you've been looking for. Head to pharmanutral-us.com and use code RLRC for 10% off your first order of Citirol. That's P H A R M A N U T R a-us.com promo code RLRC for 10% off today. You know, folks talk a whole lot about women's hormones, but hardly anybody explains what that actually means for them. Most women end up confused, overwhelmed and not sure what to do next. And as we head into the holidays, nobody needs more confusion piled on top of everything else. I've watched Cindy deal with this herself. You hear people say your health starts in your gut, but for women it really starts with their hormones. When those levels aren't what they should be, everything just feels a little off. Your energy, your comfort, your mild mood shifts, even how steady you feel day to day. So as the new year gets closer, imagine being able to hip reset and support your body and maintaining optimal hormone levels. That's where Hormone Harmony comes in. An award winning German nutrition scientist created a powerful herbal formula that brings together 12 plant based adaptogens in one capsule. Every ingredient is chosen based on scientific evidence and proven effective in clinical studies for women of all different ages and hormone profiles so you can feel your best through the holidays. Cindy's been taking Hormone Harmony and I've noticed a difference. She feels more balanced, more steady and more like herself. Even with everything going on with the shows, our travel and the holiday rush, it's a real game changer for women who want science backed support that brings comfort, clarity, consistent energy, confidence and an overall sense of, well, being. Happy Mama, the company behind Hormone Harmony has zero compromise policy. No GMOs, no artificial fillers, no artificial flavors, nothing unnecessary, only science backed ingredients in clinically proven amounts and They've helped over 2.4 million women feel more like themselves again, even after years of feeling off. They surveyed 1831 women who tried Hormone Harmony and the Results were incredible. 86% noticed easier weight management, 77% said it supported their mood and overall well being and 100% said they're feeling like themselves again. What makes Hormone Harmony stand out is that it supports multiple hormone imbalances at the same time, creating a wave of benefits throughout the body from more steady energy to a better overall mood to reduce occasional bloating and greater daily comfort. And the reviews don't lie. Over 50,000 women are talking about better energy, deeper sleep, feeling more balanced and calm, reduced occasional bloating and easier weight management alongside a healthy lifestyle. That's the kind of gift any woman deserves Heading into the new year this holiday season, give yourself or the woman in your life the gift of wellness. For a limited time, you get 15% off your entire first order at Happy Mammoth.com just use the code RLRC at checkout. You can try Hormone Harmony risk free and get 15% off your first order with code RLRC at checkout. This time of the year can be tough and the holidays are near and they're supposed to feel joyful, but for so many they bring stress around. Food, weight and body image. Add in all the talk around weight loss medications and it can feel overwhelming.
Woody Overton
To know what's best for you.
Co-host/Guest
That's why hers is here to support your journey so you can feel your best. Look, I see it every day with Cindy. She's running her businesses, handling the podcast, taking care of everybody else and trying to keep her own health on track. Hers makes it easy for her to get real support without adding one more.
Woody Overton
Thing to her plate.
Co-host/Guest
Hers is transforming women's health care by providing access to weight loss treatment plans for every budget. They connect you with a medical provider who will work with you to determine the best treatment option for you. If prescribed, you get medication as part.
Woody Overton
Of a doctor developed weight loss program.
Co-host/Guest
Complete with ongoing care check ins, dosage and medication adjustments and access to 247.
Woody Overton
Online support at no additional cost, no hidden fees and no membership fees.
Co-host/Guest
Weight loss by hers is realistic, not restrictive. Hers provides access to affordable weight loss plans built around oral medication kits and GLP1 injectable options with oral medication kits starting at just $69 per month with.
Woody Overton
The 10 month plan when paid upfront, in full.
Co-host/Guest
I love that they put your health and your goals first. Cindy can stay on top of everything without even leaving the house. Real medical providers making sure she's got.
Woody Overton
What she needs to feel her best.
Co-host/Guest
Right from the comfort of her own chair. Whether you want to lose weight, grow thicker, full of hair, or find relief for anxiety, hers has you covered. Visit forhers.comrlrc to get a personalized affordable.
Woody Overton
Plan that gets you.
Co-host/Guest
That's F O R H E R S.com RLRC Forhers.com RLRC Weight loss by hers is not available everywhere. Compounded products are not approved or reviewed.
Woody Overton
For safety, effectiveness or quality by the fda. Prescription required.
Co-host/Guest
See website for full details, important safety information and restrictions. Actual price depends on product and plan purchase.
Woody Overton
Can you imagine?
Cindy Overton
No, I can't.
Woody Overton
Okay, you're looking at your dead kid's brain matter in your washing machine. And then what does he, what does he do? He scooped the brain matter out of his washing machine. And at that time he wasn't even aware it was his son's brain. It just knew it's a brain and he puts it back in the red bag. Well, come to find out he's like what the. Calls the scene back up. And guess what? The dad over the rest of Pinion's family was not aware that the coroner had performed a cranial autopsy nor that part of his brain had been removed.
Co-host/Guest
That's just Pena's father brought the bag.
Woody Overton
Back to the funeral home. At which point our Lovely Funeral director, Ms. Singh, Anita Singh. You know, y', all, wherever this town is, I told you, don't fucking use them in San Jose, California. It's a big ass building. It's not like it's a fly by night cheap place. Dad brings the brain back and gives it to Ms. Singh. And machine not only did not apologize, she did not provide any explanation for the mix up. And did not give Pinion's father the clothes he initially went there looking for. I'm pretty sure you gave me the brain in the bag. You don't know where the fuck the clothes are.
Cindy Overton
Yeah, yeah.
Woody Overton
And the brains don't even end up in bags. Figure it out. Right, yeah. So naturally filed a lawsuit and they. They claim that Pena's brain was left in a bag and hidden somewhere in a funeral homes courtyard for weeks for an unknown reason. And quotations. Discovering one's child brain matter in a washing machine and then having to scoop it out is a horror no family should ever endure. And the plaintiffs have Suffered shock, grief, nightmares, anxiety, depression, and other lasting physiological injuries. And you know what? I hope they have a fucking hundred million dollar insurance policy on that place. Or I hope they end up owning it and get into the Morse worry business. That's just fucked up.
Cindy Overton
Yeah.
Woody Overton
Pretty sure I'd have gone back and beat him with a brain.
Cindy Overton
I was gonna say, like, what is their son.
Woody Overton
Your son's brain? So you don't really do that, but you're his brain.
Cindy Overton
But how traumatic.
Woody Overton
That's.
Cindy Overton
I mean.
Woody Overton
And you gotta scoop it out, Right?
Cindy Overton
That's horrible.
Woody Overton
There you have it. Got all kinds of professionals in the world. Yeah. Thankfully we're not up professionals.
Cindy Overton
Thankfully.
Woody Overton
How much you got?
Cindy Overton
Thankfully there are some good professionals. Like Charlay Funeral Home.
Woody Overton
Right. Love y'.
Co-host/Guest
All.
Woody Overton
It's time for family matters.
Cindy Overton
We're going to Florida. We haven't been there in a couple days. I don't think.
Co-host/Guest
Florida.
Cindy Overton
Citrus County.
Woody Overton
Citrus County. So Florida woman, she got some urn just down there, right.
Cindy Overton
Has been arrested and is facing homicide investigations in two counties after authorities say that she shot and killed two of her ex husbands in separate incidents on the same day.
Woody Overton
Nice.
Cindy Overton
She's been identified as Susan Erica avalon, and she's 48 years old. And according to law enforcement, the shootings occurred on Wednesday, December 17, and one of the shootings was in Manatee county, and the other is in Hillsborough County.
Woody Overton
Okay.
Cindy Overton
Investigators with the Manatee County Sheriff's Office said Avalon is accused of shooting and killing one ex husband at his residence in Manatee.
Woody Overton
I bet. You know what? I bet she's a real bitch of a wife.
Cindy Overton
Oh, can you imagine?
Woody Overton
That's why they're exes. Well, wait, I'm probably going to limb and say it was her. She was just a bitch.
Cindy Overton
Well, authorities allege that she lured the victim to open his front door by taking him food from Panera Bread pickup. She's like, come here.
Woody Overton
Come on in.
Cindy Overton
Come here, ex husband.
Woody Overton
I got you some Panera Bread, A good old treat.
Cindy Overton
And she didn't even. She went to do the Panera Bread pickup and she just picked up food that was on a shelf. Like she didn't order it. She just went and grabbed a bag of food from there. Does that make sense? Like, people order and it's waiting for them on a shelf. They just go in and grab it. Some people might not know that.
Woody Overton
That's like you asked me. Go ahead.
Cindy Overton
So when the man answered the door, Avalon opened fire on him, killing him at the scene. And license plate reader data showed Avalon silver Honda Odyssey traveling from Citrus county into Manatee county and later returning north after the Manatee county shooting. Detectives located Avalon at her home in Citrus county, and authority said she was observed cleaning her vehicle with bleach and rags when they arrived. So investigators began to speak to her, and they asked her about her ex husband, and she said, which one.
Woody Overton
Of the bullets? Yeah.
Cindy Overton
According to law enforcement, that response immediately raised concern and prompted them to request a welfare check on her other former spouse.
Woody Overton
Right.
Cindy Overton
And that welfare check led officers to a residence in Hillsborough county, and they discovered a second man dead with multiple gunshot wounds. Investigators believe that the two shootings are connected and occurred within hours of one another. An authority said Avalon had been divorced from the Manatee county victim for approximately 11 years. But court records referenced by investigators indicated that there's been an ongoing dispute, especially over child support. But they haven't listed, like, they haven't named what they think the motive is, but it doesn't matter. Avalon was taken into custody and booked into Citrus county jail. In the Manatee county case, she's been charged with second degree murder, though prosecutors indicated they plan to seek an upgrade to first degree murder and pursue enhanced penalty.
Woody Overton
Well, I hope they don't, because if they do, then Florida has the ultimate punishment. Yeah, there you have that. All right.
Co-host/Guest
Well.
Woody Overton
Wouldn'T be fitting if I didn't tell a little bit about Christmas. Crime says Christmas crime time on true crime time for. And you know, I always say, blood hits the ground on the holidays. And never forget me and Brian Paul being on call. We were the weekend shifting. Christmas was on a weekend, and he took the night part, and I took the days we rotated out, and he called me late, and the guy was burned up in a car. And I was like, and this is Christmas light early Christmas morning when they found him, and. And I was like, yeah, maybe it won't be a homicide. Right. Because we were off. Like, when we got off the day after Christmas, we were off. It was the rut for hunting season. We were all for the whole. We were gonna hunt our ass off. And he was like, yeah, yeah, yeah. Hopefully it won't be a. It won't be a homicide. I don't think the autopsy was scheduled until Tuesday because Dr. Cornham would come in on Monday. But so anyway, Brian Paul called me, and I was like, literally on the deer stand. And he's like, motherfucker, you got to come. We got to roll out. And that's what happened. He said he was stabbed to death before they burned him up.
Cindy Overton
Goodness.
Woody Overton
And so it's just a time when the blood hits the ground and tis the season for the reason. But we'll go all the way back to 1996 and probably this case has been covered more than anyone the world. J. Ramsey.
Cindy Overton
Yeah, right.
Woody Overton
And the six year old beauty queen was found murdered in the basement or family's home in Boulder, Colorado on December Twix 26, which is also Haley's murder bursary. And despite decades of investigation, the case remains unsolved. And so we know that. 1996, I was 26 years old. First homicide school I went to, we studied the handwriting and studied the case and whatever the FBI was here and what have you just goes on and on and on. I know who did it. That's one of those. You got to be able to prove it. So, all right, tell you about one you probably didn't knew about the Solder children. The parents disappearance, okay. Happened in 1945, the year World War II ended. And on Christmas Eve they had a fire in the Solder family home in West Virginia. And the one second, because I need to have something else on about here. The long, the long and the short of it is once the fire was done and was put out, the five of the children had vanished and none of their remains were found. Now they had other ones that were there, the mom and dad and all that, but these five kids were just gone in 1945.
Cindy Overton
Wow.
Woody Overton
There's no Internet or no call you outside on Dickle D app or whatever it may be called that people are using now.
Cindy Overton
Dickle Dickel.
Woody Overton
I just made something out so they make up. What are the some of those apps names?
Cindy Overton
I have no idea.
Woody Overton
You know, I'm talking about like WhatsApp or Tinder or whatever the fuck, right? Anyway, they didn't have any of that bullshit. And those five kids, poof, gone. All right, let's go, let's take it up a notch. Notorious massacres and spree killings on Christmas One dude, Ronald Jean Simmons over the Christmas period. You know what Mr. Simmons did? He murdered 16 people in Arkansas, including 14 members of his own family, right? He sat in the house with the bodies for four days before he said, you know what? I'm kind of tired sitting with these dead bodies. I'm going to go out. And he did. He went out in the public and went on a shooting spree on December 28th.
Cindy Overton
Well, goodness. So he killed his whole family.
Woody Overton
Ronald Jean Simmons, Murder Massacre, Arkansas. I gotta know if they kill this motherfucker. So December 22, 1987, Ronald Jean Simmons began a killing spree that we be the worst mass murder in Arkansas history and the worst crime involving one family in the history of the country, United States, America. His rampage ended on December 28, 1987, leaving dead 14. Oh, you know what? That's one of my favorite Christmas songs. First day of Christmas. Yeah, I was like that.
Cindy Overton
If they they do the estimated of how much each thing would cost this year and the the crazy.
Woody Overton
It's expensive. They couldn't afford it.
Cindy Overton
Yeah.
Woody Overton
All right, so back to sorry to interrupt on that squirrel. His rampage ended on December 28, 1987, leaving dead 14 members of his immediate family. And he blessed two of his former co workers by killing them. He blessed him in evil way. Now, Ronald Jean Simmons, who was born on July 15, 1940, so he was two years older my dad in Chicago, Illinois. And it goes on and gives his whole family and how who his mom was and his daddy was there from Chicago and blah blah, blah, whatever. So then they moved to Little Rock and Pulaski county in 1946, the first of several transfers that would take the family across central Arkansas. Blah, blah, blah. He's, he's joined the US Navy. Blah blah blah. Damn, they give it everything on this. Hey y'. All. You know I don't do the laundry.
Co-host/Guest
In our house, but even I noticed something changed with our detergent. One day I pulled out a shirt and just smelled fresh and not like chemicals just smelt clean. Turns out Cindy switched us over to Earth Breeze. Instead of those big heavy jugs or messy pods is these little pre measured sheets that come in a slim sleeve, doesn't take up any space and you just toss one right in the washer. What surprised me is how good the clothes came out. Clean, soft and fresh without that harsh chemical smell I was used to. And I feel better knowing we're not bringing all of those unnecessary toxins into the house. Earth Breeze is free from dyes, parabens, phosphates, and those weird optical brighteners that stick to your clothes. It's just an easy sheet that dissolves and gets the job done. Right now you can try Earth Breeze for up to 40% off plus get four free gifts@earthbreeze.com RLRC that's earthbreeze.com RLRC real life, real crime. The podcast is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. Fiscally responsible financial geniuses, monetary magicians. These are the things people say about drivers who switch their car insurance to Progressive and save hundreds. Because Progressive offers discounts for paying in full owning a home and more. Plus you can count on their great customer service to help you when you need it. So your dollar goes a long way. Visit progressive.com to see if you could save on car insurance, Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates. Potential savings will vary. Not available in all states or situations.
Toyota Announcer Jan
Toyota Thon Toyota Thon Toyota Thon Is on. Oh what fun it is to drive a new Toyota today. Hey Jan from Toyota here reminding you Toyotathon is on. Make your holiday wishes come true with a new Camry RAV4 Tacoma and more. All right, let's sing it together this time. Toyotathon Toyota Toyota Thon Toyota Thon Dealer inventory may vary.
Toyota/Commercial Voice
Toyota Thon ends January 5th.
Woody Overton
See your participating dealer for details. Toyota let's go Places.
Toyota Announcer Jan
If you're an H Vac technician and a call comes in, Grainger knows that you need a partner that helps you find the right product fast and hassle free. And you know that when the first problem of the day is a clanking blower motor, there's no need to break a sweat. With Grainger's easy to use website and product details, you're confident you'll soon have everything humming right along. Call 1-800-GRAINGER clickgranger.com or just stop by Granger for the ones who get it done.
Woody Overton
They had seven children. Blah blah. I'm trying to see if they killed this he fathered a child with a 17 year old. He fled the blah blah blah. Simmons worked in a string of low paying jobs. Okay.
Co-host/Guest
All right.
Woody Overton
So evidence indicates that Simmons bludgeoned and shot his wife on 12-22-87. Simmons also bludgeoned and shot his visiting son, 29 year old Ronald Jeans Simmons Jr. He then strangled his three year old granddaughter. All three bodies were later found in a shallow pit. Simmons had instructed the children to dig the pit months before.
Cindy Overton
So he had it all planned.
Woody Overton
Yeah, but he called it the family outhouse. So later the same day the Dover school bus dropped off the younger Simmons children for their Christmas break from school. And based on the crime scene investigation it is believed the Simmons children. Here comes the tears. Age 17, 14, 11 and 8. They were separated and killed individually by strangulation and or drowning in a rain barrel, brah. Their bodies were also found in the hole for the outhouse. Now the older Simmons children have been invited to the Simmons home on December 26th of 87 for an after Christmas dinner. 23 year old William H. Simmons II, his 21 year old wife Reneta May Simmons and their 20 month old son and they're all from Dallas county were likely the first to arrive and William and Renata were shot and their bodies were left by the dining room table and covered with their own coats and some bedding. The child was killed in place in the trunk of the car behind the Simmons home. I mean this roll. I wonder why nobody's ever made this one. The movie the next to arrive because we're not done for Simmons 24 year old daughter Sheila and her husband 33 year old Dennis Raymond McNulty as well as their children 7 year old Sylvia and 21 month old Michael. Sheila was shot and her body was laid on the dining room table and covered with a tablecloth. Simmons shot Dennis and strangled Sylvia. Michael was strangled and placed in the trunk of yet another parked car. Later the same day Simmons drove to Russellville where he stopped at a Sears store and picked up Christmas gifts that he had ordered but had not made it in before the holiday. Later that night. He's got all these dead bodies, right?
Co-host/Guest
Yeah.
Woody Overton
Later that night he drove to a private club in Russellville. Then he went home and waited out the weekend. On Monday, December 28, 1987, Simmons drove a car that it belonged to his son Ronald Jr. To Russellville. He purchased a second gun from Walmart. His next stop was the Peel Eddy and Gibbons law firm. And he enters the law firm and after entering the building Simmons shot and killed the receptionist Kathy Cribbins Kendrick. And then he next went to the Taylor Oil Company where he shot and wounded Russell Rusty Taylor who's the owner of Sinclair Mini Mart where he had worked. And then he's not stopping. He shot and killed JD Or Jim Chaffam who's a fireman part time truck driver for Taylor Oil. Simmons shot at and missed another employee. Before exiting the building, Simmons went to the Sinclair Mini Mart where he shot and wounded Roberta Woolery and David Slater. His last stop was the Woodline Motor Freight Company. Simmons located his former supervisor Joyce Butts and wounded her in the head and the chest. He then took worker Vicki Jackson at gunpoint into the computer office and advised her to call the police. Simmons told Jackson, I've come to do what I wanted to do. It's all over now. I've gotten everybody who wanted to hurt me. He then surrendered to the Russellville police when they arrived. You can't make this shit up.
Cindy Overton
No.
Woody Overton
So they sent him to the state mental hospital to see if he was sane enough to stand trial. And he was found sane enough to stand trial by a bunch of different doctors and the prosecuting attorney. He went to trial. Jury selection took less than six hours. He was convicted on May 12, 1988, and in the Franklin county circuit court for the deaths of Kendrick Chaffis. So they only tried to. On May 16, Judge Samuel Peterson sentenced Simmons to death by lethal injection plus 147 years. Simmons refused all rights to appeal, and he was found guilty of 14 counts of capital murder. In the deaths of God and everybody else he killed. God bless them all. So they offered a possible motive when he presented an undated note that was discovered in a safe deposit box in Russellville bank. And the letter seemed to indicate a strong love hate relationship between Simmons and his daughter Sheila. After the judge ruled the letter admissible, Simmons lashed out at buying him and punched him in the face. And then unsuccessfully struggled for the deputy's handgun. This dude just won't stop. All right. Officers rushed him out of the courthouse and changed. He was sentenced to death by lethal injection. And on March 16, 1989, he waived all his rights to appeal. Let's see if they kill. Actually killed him now. Because Gerald Borlong, right. Waved out of his. And it took him like seven years to prove he was saying enough. Let's see. Boom. Oh, check this out. So they're appealing and stuff, and he. He thinks he's getting off the. It came back a 72 vote. But then for some reason, the. The supreme court came back really fast. And they said Simmons was watching television. And oh no, this fucking. He got to stay. He was watching television, eating what he thought he would be his last meal when he got a new stay of execution. Then we go to 1990. Governor Bill Clinton signed his execution warrant again. And this was the quickest sentence to execution of death in the United States history since the death penalty was reinstated in 1976. Simmons refused all visitors, including legal counsel and clergy. His last words were quotations. Justice delayed. Finally being done is justifiable homicide. And no family members claiming the body save is buried in a pauper slide at Lincoln Memorial long in Lincoln County. And there you have my Christmas gift to you.
Cindy Overton
Thank you.
Woody Overton
To tell you about Mr. Simmons and all the love he spread in world. What a great guy. You know, I never knew about that story.
Cindy Overton
Yeah.
Woody Overton
Is it crazy?
Cindy Overton
But that would be a movie. I mean, like.
Woody Overton
Well, I'm gonna end it on two short, short, short funny nights. Okay. So go ahead and say your name.
Cindy Overton
Cindy Overton.
Woody Overton
And I'm Woody Overton. Naked chimney break in in 2010, man in Seattle decided he was going to break into the house. Gotta steal some presents, right? And he. All the doors and windows are locked, but guess what was open? The chimney. Yeah. And he was like, I'm pretty sure I could fit, but not quite sure. So he took off all his clothes.
Cindy Overton
That's smart.
Woody Overton
He got naked.
Cindy Overton
Real smart.
Woody Overton
And climbed down the chimney until he couldn't climb anymore and he got stuck.
Cindy Overton
Good for him.
Woody Overton
Can you imagine coming home like, what's their names? On Christmas vacation? And they come in from working out.
Cindy Overton
Yeah.
Woody Overton
Margo and Todd. And coming in and doing your. Maybe putting on your music and hearing, Help me, Help me. Because, you know, it's cold as Seattle at that time of year.
Co-host/Guest
Help me.
Woody Overton
And I'm like, what do you. What does that sound come from? And you look up and you're thinking, there's a dinghy. Oh, I was gonna say Harry Bubblegum, but there's Harry Bubblegum. There's hairy Christmas toy sacks hanging in your face. So they call the cops. And he was arrested. You know, he told the cops, he said, I wasn't trying to break in. No, he said, I am Santa Claus. Yeah. Okay.
Co-host/Guest
All right, one more.
Woody Overton
This dude is called the Grinch of Ontario. Now, you would think it's going to be about all murders and all the bad he did and he did bad, but it ain't that kind of bad because we ended on a light note. And the Grinch, Ontario, well, in Kingston, Ontario, they had a Christmas parade. Big deal, right? Everybody rolls out for my stuff, ride him all the time. Big deal. People turn out. And not as big as Mardi Gras, but, yeah, you know, Santa's always the feature. Everybody's happy, happy, jolly as.
Cindy Overton
Yeah.
Woody Overton
And all that good stuff. Well, same thing happened in Kingston, Ontario, until the Grinch of Ontario showed up. And he was drunk as.
Cindy Overton
What year was this?
Woody Overton
2012. He was drunk as fuck. And he decided he was going to walk along the Christmas parade route. And you know what he did? Every kid he came to, he told him, he said, hey, Santa Claus ain't real. It's your mama and your daddy or whoever's taking care of you.
Cindy Overton
Oh, that is disgusting.
Woody Overton
And he. He walked along the whole route and told children that Santa wasn't real.
Cindy Overton
Why didn't they stop him at some, like. I mean, I'm surprised no parent, like, went and like, attacked him or said something to him and stopped him before he got through the whole route.
Woody Overton
That is a wonderful question.
Cindy Overton
And you don't remember.
Woody Overton
I never do that to a kid.
Cindy Overton
You only did it to Gately.
Woody Overton
It's my own kids.
Co-host/Guest
Yeah.
Woody Overton
No, I used to. My kids, when I was single, they had Kate. I was like. She was at that age. I don't know what age is appropriate. But anyway, I was like, here I am. Give her all this Santa Claus getting credit for it. But. But she was old enough. I think she knew anyway.
Cindy Overton
She was like 7, baby.
Woody Overton
Well, she knew and. But I used to. She was like, daddy. She did ask me the year before. She said, daddy, are you really Santa Claus? And I said, no. So the next year, I was like, she in the nose, right? And. And. But I would mess with her. I'd be like, so you want such and such? Oh, yeah. Yeah, I want that. And I said, well, you just gotta let me know. I'll put in a word with the old fat boy. They were tight. He said, really? Yeah, I talk to him all the time. Actually, I talk to him more than anybody every day. Right. There's nobody better to talk to. But she knew, and then. Yeah, she did.
Cindy Overton
I know.
Woody Overton
Yes, she did. Let me call her right now. She's not gonna answer.
Cindy Overton
She did not want to know.
Woody Overton
She is not gonna answer that. Well, she's got to work and stuff, right? And this is her busy time. I don't know how long it's appropriate to do a FaceTime ring before you hang up.
Cindy Overton
I don't either.
Woody Overton
I don't FaceTime. I'm scaring myself. Look at my own face. I got Honda season face.
Cindy Overton
You do.
Woody Overton
I'm gonna let that grow. All right, she's done. Anyway, I'm officially going on record saying I did not tell her.
Cindy Overton
You just said you told her.
Woody Overton
No, I didn't. I told her that I was talking to Santa Claus every day. Maybe it's a short deal. You would get switches and ashes in your stocking.
Cindy Overton
Well, that's better than nothing.
Woody Overton
I can get switches and ashes real easy. I gotta do is scoop out the.
Cindy Overton
Fireplace, saying, most years there's nothing.
Co-host/Guest
So nothing. Everybody that everybody in the family, including boyfriends and girlfriends. I tell you, don't buy that Christmas present.
Woody Overton
They won't be here next year.
Co-host/Guest
And I'm right. You buy presents for everybody.
Woody Overton
How is that nothing?
Cindy Overton
I'm not buying myself presents exactly, but everybody got presents. You're saying you're putting.
Woody Overton
You're the.
Cindy Overton
You get to be in my.
Co-host/Guest
You get to be Mrs. Claus and bless everybody.
Woody Overton
You love doing that shit.
Cindy Overton
I do.
Woody Overton
There you go. Merry Christmas.
Cindy Overton
Thank you. Thank you for thinking of me.
Woody Overton
People be. I have to be like that, y'. All. She gets Christmas every day, 365 days a year. As do I. Did you get coffee in bed this morning for me? There you go. It isn't all bad on Overton Ship. And you already know.
Cindy Overton
Get defensive. You're the one that.
Woody Overton
Well, you're the one who cried yesterday.
Co-host/Guest
When they found out what?
Cindy Overton
Me?
Woody Overton
What Santa Claus got him for Christmas. Me.
Cindy Overton
Because I'm grateful.
Woody Overton
Well, if I need.
Cindy Overton
Very, very grateful.
Woody Overton
I don't have to always buy you a present to get you to cry. Just come in here and do real life, real crime, true crime time for.
Cindy Overton
You claim that you don't want me to cry, but then you say to get you to cry, like, what are you ever saying?
Co-host/Guest
Merry Christmas. Ho, ho, ho. Love y'.
Cindy Overton
All.
Co-host/Guest
Holler at you later.
Woody Overton
I got nothing else.
Cindy Overton
I don't.
Woody Overton
All right, you want to tell them? Merry Christmas.
Cindy Overton
Merry Christmas, Happy. Well, we'll see you before then. Merry Christmas. I hope y' all have the best. Well, I hope you have the best Christmas ever.
Co-host/Guest
Right?
Woody Overton
And I'm Woody Overton.
Cindy Overton
I'm Cindy Overton.
Woody Overton
Holler at you later. Merry Christmas. Peace.
Toyota Announcer Jan
Toyota thon. Toyota Thon. Toyota Thon is on. Oh, what fun it is to drive a new Toyota today. Hey, Jan from Toyota here reminding you Toyotathon is on. Make your holiday wishes come true with a new Camry RAV4 Tacoma and more. All right, let's sing it together this time. Toyota Thon. Toyota Thon. Toyota Thon.
Woody Overton
Dealer inventory may vary.
Toyota/Commercial Voice
Toyota Thon ends January 5th.
Woody Overton
See your participating dealer for details. Toyota, let's go places.
Advertiser/Promoter
While holiday shopping is almost always fun, credit can be confusing. Download the Myfico app now and shop with confidence, knowing that you can stay on top of your credit 24.
Narrator/Advertiser
7.
Advertiser/Promoter
Get your FICO score straight from the people that create. Plus free credit monitoring and a free credit report every month. No credit card required. FICO scores are used by over 90% of lenders, so trust the Myfico app to keep you in the know. Visit myfico.com free or download the Myfico app today.
Woody Overton
Believe me, the family that takes the Internet on vacation is the family that finds finds a better beach in peak crab mating season.
Co-host/Guest
Be prepared for anything with an ESIM from Airalo. An ESIM is a digital SIM card built into your phone. Download the Airalo app, activate your ESIM and get online in minutes, anytime, anywhere. No more surprising roaming fees. Weird public Wi Fi or fiddly plastic. Just super connectivity at your fingertips. That's Airalo.
Woody Overton
Airalo. Airalo.
Co-host/Guest
The world's most powerful ESIM provider, loved by 20 million savvy vacationers. It's as essential as packing your bathing suit for the beach.
Cindy Overton
Don't get caught in a pinch.
Woody Overton
Pack the Internet, download Airalo today. That's a I R a L O Airalo. And use code crab for 15% off. Your first ESIM terms apply.
Toyota/Commercial Voice
If you're a maintenance supervisor for a commercial property, you've had to deal with everything from leaky faucets to flickering light bulbs. But nothing's worse than that ancient boiler that's lived in the building since the day it was built 50 years ago. It's enough to make anyone lose their cool. That's where Grainger comes in. With industrial grade products and dependable, fast delivery, Grainger can help with any challenge, from worn out components to everyday necessities. Call clickgrainger.com or just stop by Grainger for the ones who get it done.
Hosts: Woody Overton & Cindy Overton
Release Date: December 23, 2025
Episode Focus: Exploring chilling Christmas crimes, family tragedies, and the peculiar uptick in violence during the holidays, with true stories, dark humor, and Woody & Cindy’s signature storytelling.
Woody and Cindy Overton gather for a raw, spirited episode on the cusp of Christmas, blending personal holiday memories with shocking, real-life crime stories surrounding the holiday season. The episode weaves together light-hearted recollections and dark tales, highlighting the disturbing reality that “blood hits the ground on the holidays.” Memorable cases—from fresh tragedies to infamous historic mass murders—are dissected with feeling, candor, and a touch of Southern irreverence.
Timecodes: 03:16–10:07
Holiday Cheer & Toy Stories:
Woody and Cindy open with playful banter about favorite Christmas toys, like Strawberry Shortcake dolls and GI Joes, interspersed with Southern humor and gentle teasing.
Ongoing Advocacy:
Woody briefly mentions the Bradley and Austin case, reaffirming his commitment to justice and advocating for listeners to keep sending in tips.
Timecodes: 10:07–12:16
Cindy spotlights a tragic, recent case out of Dixon, Tennessee:
Quote: “Another domestic, domestic death—murder. Not death, murder. Murder, murder.” – Woody (12:16)
Timecodes: 12:16–27:55
Woody tells of a California family’s traumatic experience with a mortuary following the death of Alexander Pinion:
Woody & Cindy reflect on the importance of caring professionals, contrasting this with their own positive experiences with local funeral homes.
Timecodes: 28:14–32:19
Timecodes: 32:34–49:49
Holiday Homicide as a Pattern:
Woody reflects as a retired investigator, noting: “Blood hits the ground on the holidays.” He recalls working a Christmas homicide where a man was found burned in a car—tragically, not an isolated event.
Infamous Cases:
JonBenét Ramsey (34:16)
The unsolved 1996 murder of the 6-year-old beauty queen is discussed as an infamous holiday crime still haunting the public and law enforcement.
The Sodder Children Disappearance (34:44):
In 1945, five children vanished following a Christmas Eve house fire in West Virginia. Their bodies were never found, spawning decades of speculation and sorrow.
Notorious Massacre: Ronald Gene Simmons (37:01–49:49)
Timecodes: 49:49–55:17
The Naked Chimney Burglar (2010, Seattle):
The Grinch of Ontario (2012):
Personal Stories:
Woody jokes about how long to keep Santa's secret with his own kids and shares family Christmas dynamics with Cindy, affirming the joy of giving.
Timecodes: 55:17–56:55
Merry Christmas from Real Life Real Crime!