Podcast Summary: Real Life Real Crime - "True Crime Time For February 12, 2026 | Missing Persons, Corruption & Murder"

Host: Woody Overton
Date: February 12, 2026
Run Time (excluding ads/intro/outro): Approx. 46 minutes
Theme: A gripping ride through recent and historical true crime cases, blending expert insight, anecdotal context, and Woody’s signature Southern storytelling. Woody discusses missing persons, bizarre murders, police corruption, and unsettling family tragedies, intertwined with broader reflections on justice and community involvement.

Episode Overview

This episode of "True Crime Time For" (a spinoff of the "Real Life Real Crime" podcast) features Woody Overton solo-hosting (his wife Cyndi will return next week). Woody marks the anniversary of Real Life Real Crime and extends gratitude to the “lifers” (loyal listeners) before delving into chilling and complex cases—ranging from missing persons, calculated murders for gold coins, police corruption, mental illness-driven tragedies, family crimes, and small-town scandals. His signature blend of personal experience, empathy, and critical analysis is present throughout.

Major Topics & Discussion Points

1. Anniversary Reflections and Community Engagement

Timestamps: 00:00 - 02:30

• Woody thanks listeners for years of support.
• Shouts out active cold cases: Barbara Blunt, #JusticeForBradley, #JusticeForAO.
• Encourages tip line usage and stresses the importance of communal action in pursuing justice.
  • Quote: “You gotta believe that every dog has his day, right? And these dogs deserve their days.” (01:15, Woody)

2. “This Day in Crime” — The Pravin Varughese Case

Timestamps: 02:32 - 03:07

• On Feb 12, 2014, Pravin Varughese attended an off-campus party at SIU, was reported missing, and was later found murdered.
• Woody uses anniversaries to contextualize crime’s ongoing impact.

3. The Alleged Kidnapping of NBC Host’s Mother

Timestamps: 03:09 - 06:55

• Discusses headline kidnapping of the mother of an NBC host, recorded a week ahead of release (uncertain if solved at recording).
• Skeptical about the ransom motive, mentions Bitcoin demands, and familial involvement as a recurring pattern.
• Offers a candid, empathetic take, reflecting on his own mother’s age.
  • Quote: “It doesn’t really compute on why you would take this lady... it’s not like she had a billion dollars in the bank.” (04:30, Woody)
  • Expresses hope for a positive resolution but is doubtful.
  • Discusses law enforcement tactics during ransom situations.

4. Gold, Silver, and Murder: The Case of Chavez Gustan

Timestamps: 07:00 - 10:50

• Explains rising crime linked to skyrocketing precious metals prices.
• Covers Indiana case: Chavez Gustan, 22, sentenced to 55 years for murdering 67-year-old Roger Swindzinski, stealing American Eagle gold coins, then selling/trading them at a pawn shop.
• Explains traceability of collectible gold and “blood gold” black market issues.
  • Quote: “Get a job, buy your own gold coins. Don’t steal... Rather deal with a murderer than a thief.” (10:40, Woody)
• Emphasizes how violent theft devastates families.

5. “Effed Up Professionals” — Veteran Cop Turned Drug Criminal

Timestamps: 10:53 - 13:50

• Plays audio of police raid: former Daytona Beach cop and current teacher, Amber Williamson, arrested alongside notorious drug dealer boyfriend, Marcus Plowden; found with fentanyl and narcotics paraphernalia.
• Sheriff Mike Chitwood’s statement: “Amber, the good guys always win, don’t you?”
  • Quote: “It's sickening that somebody who used to protect these streets is out there peddling this poison, destroying families.” (12:00, Sheriff Chitwood via audio)
• Woody reflects on the haunting intersection of law enforcement betrayal and community damage.

6. Mental Illness and Random Tragedy — The Murder of Lilia Valutyte

Timestamps: 13:51 - 19:23

• Recounts the English case (Boston, Lincolnshire): Dividas Skibas, schizophrenic, stabs 9-year-old Lilia Valutyte through the heart as she played with a hula hoop.
• Explains how courts must determine if the act was murder or “manslaughter by diminished responsibility.”
• Shares personal anecdotes about similar cases, the challenge of treating mental illness in and out of prison.
  • Quote (Prosecutor): “He knew his conduct was wrong. He knew he was killing a child... deliberate murder, clearly a wicked act.” (16:05, prosecutor's statement, paraphrased)
• Woody’s emotional reaction: “I can’t imagine, young kid waiting on her mom, doing a hula hoop in an alley, and he just runs up and stabs her through the heart... for no reason.” (18:55, Woody)

7. Family Tragedy & Attempted Murder-Suicide in Texas

Timestamps: 26:53 - 31:47

• In Liberty County, TX: Jessica Quintana indicted for attempting to drown her three children (ages 15, 11, and 6) after drugging them with alcohol and NyQuil.
• Outlines two “plans” uncovered in court records; highlights the distressing family circumstances.
• Notes husband Domingo’s arrest (not for child abuse but unrelated animal cruelty discovered during investigation).
  • Quote: “Giving your children NyQuil and alcohol and leading them into the water... that's crazy.” (29:00, Woody)

8. “Florida Man” Gone Wrong — Murder Over Public Urination

Timestamps: 31:48 - 34:41

• In the Florida Keys, Lloyd Preston Brewer III found guilty of first-degree murder for shooting Garrett Hughes after Hughes urinated on the side of Brewer’s building.
• Both men were reportedly intoxicated; Woody dissects the failed self-defense claim.
  • Quote: “Okay, you piss on the building, and I’m gonna murder you... Not victim shaming, but...” (32:20, Woody)
• Reflects on escalation and consequences of anger and intoxication.

9. Small-Town Louisiana Motel Murder

Timestamps: 34:42 - 39:32

• In Donaldsonville, LA: Matt Leonard convicted of second-degree murder at OYO Motel, based on clear surveillance footage.
• Woody discusses the prevalence of violent crime at low-budget hotels (“$39 a night, you better believe there's something wrong with it”), shares personal experiences with dodgy roadside motels.
• Explains local context and impact on small-town safety perceptions.

10. Community Scandal: The Case of “Rah Rah” – Accusations Against a Beloved Mascot

Timestamps: 39:33 - 45:07

• Clinton, LA (tiny town, no stoplights, close-knit): Ronaldo “Rah Rah” Robinson, 43, known mascot and local fixture, arrested and charged with two counts of first-degree child rape.
• Woody describes Rah Rah as mentally challenged, widely beloved, and central to community identity; shares reactions from Clinton Facebook group, including fundraising to make bond.
• Reflects on prevalence of both false accusations and tragic truths in child sex assault allegations, the high standards for police to arrest local figures, the pain of uncertainty.
  • Quote: “I hope... the allegations are false because I don't want any babies to have been raped and certainly don't want Rah Rah to be a rapist.” (44:38, Woody)

11. Closing Reflections on Crime and Community

Timestamps: 45:08 - 46:40

• Woody emphasizes the pervasiveness of crime: “Nowhere in America are you immune from crime. That’s a fact.”
• Announces regular programming resumes next week and signs off with gratitude.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• "You gotta believe that every dog has his day, right? And these dogs deserve their days." (01:15)
• “I can only imagine what they’re going through, but I pray that I’m wrong and I pray that it ends in a good way, but I just don’t think that. I just don’t think there's a happy ending coming.” (05:50)
• "He put the knife straight into the middle of Lila... That stab wound went straight through her heart and she fell in the street and he ran off." (17:22)
• “Get a job. People, don’t steal. Rather deal with a murderer than a thief.” (10:40)
• “If you find a hotel for $39 a night, you better believe there's something wrong with it.” (38:50)
• "I hope... the allegations are false because I don't want any babies to have been raped and certainly don't want Rah Rah to be a rapist." (44:38)
• “Nowhere in America are you immune from crime, right? And that’s a fact.” (45:08)

Additional Observations

• Woody often blends humor with dark subject matter to lighten grim realities but never detracts from victims’ suffering.
• His candid asides about law enforcement culture, criminal motives, pawn shop ethics, and small-town dynamics give a unique behind-the-scenes feel.
• Repeated emphasis on community responsibility—whether calling in tips, supporting families, or remaining vigilant.
• Genuine empathy is present, especially in discussing the potential for both tragedy and wrongful accusation.

Suggested Listening Timestamps

• Anniversary reflection & national case updates: 00:00–07:00
• Chavez Gustan/killed for gold coins: 07:00–10:50
• "Effed Up Professionals" police scandal: 10:53–13:50
• Schizophrenia & random violence: 13:51–19:23
• Texas attempted murder-suicide (Family Matters): 26:53–31:47
• Florida strip mall murder: 31:48–34:41
• OYO Motel / Louisiana case: 34:42–39:32
• Rah Rah community crisis: 39:33–45:07

Final Thoughts

This episode is a quintessential “Real Life Real Crime” blend of the bizarre, tragic, and sometimes surreal realities of criminal justice, as told by an experienced, straight-talking investigator. It’s equal parts cautionary tale and community call to action, delivered with Woody’s unmistakable style.