Real Life Real Crime: July 24, 2025 Episode Summary

Host: Woody Overton | Release Date: July 24, 2025

Introduction

In the July 24, 2025 episode of Real Life Real Crime, host Woody Overton delves into two harrowing true crime cases: the tragic disappearance and murder of 19-year-old Sadie Robinson in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, and a shocking incident involving the murder of a nun in Santiago, Chile. Woody's compassionate storytelling and meticulous attention to detail provide listeners with a comprehensive understanding of these disturbing events.

Case 1: The Disappearance and Murder of Sadie Robinson

Background and Disappearance

Sadie Robinson, a beloved 19-year-old working at Pizza Shuttle in Milwaukee, was known for her reliability and vibrant personality. On April 1st, Sadie went on a first date with Maxwell Anderson, a 33-year-old bartender. She had expressed excitement about the date, saying, "I want to go eat seafood. I'm feeling seafood" (00:XX).

The following day, Sadie failed to show up for her shift, causing concern among her coworkers and friends. Her manager noted, "That's not like her at all" (02:XX), highlighting her consistent attendance and cheerful demeanor.

Investigation and Evidence

The Milwaukee Police Department initiated a welfare check, which led to the discovery of Sadie's severely burned 2020 Honda Civic on April 2nd at West Lipson Avenue and North 29th Street. Despite the extreme fire damage, firefighters identified Sadie's attire and parts of her damaged iPhone, confirming the vehicle's ownership (07:XX).

Later that day, authorities found a severed human leg on Warnermount Park Beach, identified through DNA analysis as belonging to Sadie Robinson. Detective Nathan Spittenmeister's team recovered surveillance footage showing a vehicle entering the park area shortly before Sadie's leg was found, indicating suspicious activity (09:XX).

Further evidence emerged when Maxwell Anderson was captured on surveillance video entering and leaving the area where Sadie's remains were discovered. Witnesses reported Anderson disposing of the vehicle and fleeing the scene, leading to his arrest on charges including first-degree intentional homicide, mutilating a corpse, and arson (25:XX).

Legal Proceedings and Aftermath

Maxwell Anderson, a former employer of the establishment Sadie frequented, was charged with life imprisonment if convicted of first-degree murder—a charge that carries an automatic life sentence in Wisconsin. Anderson's defense attorney maintains his client's innocence, stating, "He is presumed innocent. We will fight this matter vigorously in court" (25:XX).

Sadie's family, particularly her mother Sheena Scarborough, expressed relief and a desire for justice, stating, "Justice for Sadie" (25:XX). The community mourns the loss of a promising young woman and stands united in supporting Sadie's memory.

Case 2: The Murder of a Nun in Santiago, Chile

Incident Overview

Woody transitions to a chilling case from Santiago, Chile, where an 80-year-old nun, Lorenzo Ramirez, was found dragging a suitcase containing the body of her 58-year-old colleague down the streets at night. Surveillance footage captured the elderly nun struggling with the heavy suitcase, culminating in the discovery of her friend's lifeless body inside (33:XX).

Investigation and Motives

Authorities are baffled by the motive behind the heinous act, as both individuals were part of the same religious order. The stark contrast between Lorenzo Ramirez's age and the nature of the crime raises questions about underlying tensions or possible disputes within the community.

The police have launched an extensive investigation to uncover the reasons behind the murder, examining the personal lives and relationships of those involved. As Woody remarks, "Evil exists in all forms" (35:XX), emphasizing the unpredictable nature of such crimes.

Conclusion

In this episode, Woody Overton masterfully unravels the complexities of two separate yet equally disturbing true crime cases. Through detailed narratives, he highlights the profound impact these tragedies have on the victims' families and communities. Woody's dedication to uncovering the truth and seeking justice shines through, providing listeners with both compelling stories and thoughtful reflections on the nature of evil and the pursuit of justice.

As Woody concludes, he reflects on the unpredictability of life and the omnipresence of crime, urging listeners to remain vigilant and supportive of those seeking closure and answers.

Note: Timestamps (00:XX) are indicative based on the provided transcript and correspond to the moments when specific information or quotes were mentioned.