Real Life Real Crime: True Crime Time For June 26, 2025 | "Torture, Murder, and a Mother’s Betrayal"

Host: Woody Overton
Co-Host: Cindy Overton
Release Date: June 26, 2025

Introduction

In this gripping episode of True Crime Time For, hosted by Woody Overton and co-hosted by Cindy Overton, listeners are taken through a series of harrowing true crime cases that underscore the darkest aspects of human behavior. From cold cases seeking justice years later to chilling accounts of familial betrayal, this episode delves deep into the complexities of each case, offering poignant insights and raw emotions.

Case 1: The Cold Case of Christian Bagley

Background:
On June 21, 2015, Christian Bagley, a 30-year-old man, was fatally stabbed while walking home from visiting his 19-month-old daughter. Despite multiple arrests and thousands of witness statements over the years, the case remained unsolved, leaving his family desperate for answers.

Key Points:

• Unsolved Mystery: Despite several arrests, no suspect was formally prosecuted for Bagley's murder.
• Family's Plea: Now, ten years later, Bagley’s 12-year-old daughter has publicly begged anyone with information to come forward.

Notable Quotes:

• Cindy Overton [12:35]: “She said, somebody taking my dad away from me when I was little is something that can never be replaced.”
• Woody Overton [14:15]: “Some asshole stabbed her dad.”

Insight:
The emotional toll on Bagley’s family is palpable, especially the perspective of his young daughter who lost her father at such a tender age. The episode emphasizes the enduring pain of unresolved crimes and the relentless pursuit of justice by those left behind.

Case 2: Ally’s Betrayal – A Mother's Tragic Decision

Background:
Ally, a 29-year-old mother from Pelican Rapids, Minnesota, pled guilty to the second-degree murder of her three-year-old daughter on July 10, 2023. The heinous act was reportedly committed out of frustration over her child's incessant crying about being hungry.

Key Points:

• The Incident: Allies attempted to suffocate her daughter, leading to her tragic death. Additionally, Ally admitted to attempting to stab the toddler earlier that night.
• Legal Outcome: She was sentenced to 12 and a half years in prison, a verdict that drew significant backlash from the community and the hosts.
• Mental Health Concerns: Authorities noted that Ally suffers from mental illness and showed little remorse for her actions.

Notable Quotes:

• Woody Overton [26:38]: “She should be dead. She does not deserve to breathe.”
• Cindy Overton [27:07]: “She should be suffocated and stabbed.”

Insight:
This case highlights the tragic consequences of untreated mental health issues and the devastating impact they can have on innocent lives. The hosts express intense frustration and anger towards the lenient sentencing, questioning the effectiveness of the justice system in such grievous matters.

Case 3: The Torture and Murder of Thomas Campbell

Background:
On July 3, 2022, Thomas Campbell was brutally tortured and murdered in his Manchester, England apartment by John Bellfield and his accomplices, including Thomas's ex-wife, Colleen Campbell.

Key Points:

• Motivation: The perpetrators believed Campbell had hidden drugs, leading to the violent ambush.
• Aftermath: Bellfield fled to South America but was apprehended in March 2024 and deported back to England to stand trial.
• Legal Proceedings: While Stephen Klebworth received a life sentence for murder and conspiracy to rob, Colleen Campbell was sentenced to 13 years for manslaughter and conspiracy to rob.

Notable Quotes:

• Woody Overton [32:53]: “He ran like a little bitch. South America.”
• Cindy Overton [32:24]: “He said, this dog will die because he bit me.”

Insight:
This case underscores the severe repercussions of organized crime and the lengths to which individuals will go to achieve their illicit objectives. The successful apprehension of Bellfield after international pursuit also reflects the global commitment to justice.

Case 4: Dismembered Baby Remains Found in Spain

Background:
On December 12, 2024, the dismembered body of a five-day-old baby was discovered in bags at a recycling plant in Loaches, Madrid, Spain. The investigation, known as Operation Natal, revealed that the baby was of South American descent and had suffered a violent death, likely due to asphyxiation.

Key Points:

• Investigation Details: The remains were traced back to the Puente de Vale district, with authorities seeking the mother’s involvement in the crime.
• Current Status: The case remains open, with police urging the public to provide any information that could aid in solving the mystery.

Notable Quotes:

• Woody Overton [40:57]: “You carried this baby. You birthed it. You gave birth to it. It’s alive. You kill it, probably by suffocation.”
• Cindy Overton [41:24]: “It's not our place. God, whatever. This isn't a religious show.”

Insight:
The brutal nature of this crime shocks listeners, emphasizing the vulnerability of infants and the depths of maternal betrayal. The ongoing investigation highlights the challenges law enforcement faces in uncovering truths in such heartbreaking cases.

Case 5: Richard Van Buren – Abuse in Animal Control

Background:
Richard Van Buren, the county's animal control specialist and a local politician in Waupun, Wisconsin, was arrested on June 19 for brutally mistreating a golden retriever. Upon arriving to assist a dehydrated dog, Van Buren assaulted the animal in front of its owner.

Key Points:

• The Incident: Van Buren, frustrated by the dog’s barking, placed a noose around its neck and dragged it out of the vehicle, leading to the dog biting him in retaliation.
• Community Reaction: The Humane Society of Dodge County condemned the act, leading to Van Buren’s arrest and subsequent charges.
• Legal Proceedings: As of the episode, details about court proceedings were limited, but the community remains outraged over the animal abuse.

Notable Quotes:

• Woody Overton [55:12]: “He said, and I quote, this is what we do on this farm when the dogs bite.”
• Cindy Overton [57:07]: “She should be suffocated and stabbed.” (Note: Likely intended for earlier context.)

Insight:
This disturbing account sheds light on the abuse of authority and the mistreatment of animals, prompting discussions about accountability and ethical standards within public service roles. The community's swift response underscores the collective demand for justice and compassion.

Final Thoughts and Announcements

Live Show Promotion:
Woody Overton and Cindy Overton announce an upcoming live show scheduled for July 19 at Southeastern Louisiana University in Hammond, Louisiana. The event promises an engaging experience with guest appearances, food, beverages, and opportunities for fans to interact directly with the hosts.

Community Engagement:
Listeners are encouraged to support ongoing justice campaigns, such as #JusticeForBradley, and participate in live events to foster a strong community dedicated to solving cold cases and advocating for victims.

Closing Remarks:
The hosts express gratitude towards their loyal listeners, emphasizing the importance of community support in their quest to uncover truths and seek justice for the victims discussed in each case.

Conclusion

This episode of True Crime Time For delivers intense and emotional narratives that highlight the enduring quest for justice in unresolved cases and the profound impact of tragic crimes on families and communities. Through detailed storytelling and candid discussions, Woody and Cindy Overton provide listeners with a deep understanding of each case's complexities and the human emotions intertwined with these dark events.

Notable Quotes Recap:

• Cindy Overton [12:35]: “She said, somebody taking my dad away from me when I was little is something that can never be replaced.”
• Woody Overton [14:15]: “Some asshole stabbed her dad.”
• Woody Overton [26:38]: “She should be dead. She does not deserve to breathe.”
• Cindy Overton [27:07]: “She should be suffocated and stabbed.”
• Woody Overton [32:53]: “He ran like a little bitch. South America.”
• Woody Overton [40:57]: “You carried this baby. You birthed it. You gave birth to it. It’s alive. You kill it, probably by suffocation.”
• Woody Overton [55:12]: “He said, and I quote, this is what we do on this farm when the dogs bite.”

Stay Connected:
Follow Real Life Real Crime on YouTube and TikTok for updates, additional content, and to engage with the community. Don’t miss out on upcoming episodes and live events that continue to shed light on unsolved mysteries and seek justice for those who need it most.