Real Life Real Crime: True Crime Time For March 26, 2025 | Cruise Ship Crime, Cold Case Solved, Teacher Exposed

Hosted by Woody Overton and Cindy Overton, "True Crime Time For" delves into gripping true crime stories with detailed discussions and insightful commentary. In this episode, the hosts explore a harrowing cruise ship incident, a tragic case of negligence and animal cruelty, an unsettling assault by a medical professional, and the resolution of a long-standing cold case.

1. Cruise Ship Crime: Lewd Behavior with a Minor

Timestamp: 07:06 – 09:36

Woody and Cindy Overton open the episode by discussing a disturbing incident aboard the Royal Caribbean's Independence of the Seas. On March 20th, two Mexican nationals, Jose Diaz (36) and Ricardo Leal (37), were arrested upon the ship's arrival in Miami for "lewd and lascivious behavior with a minor" and molestation.

Key Points:

• Location and Timing: The incident occurred in the ship’s sauna on March 20th, with arrests made the following day in Miami.
• Charges: Diaz faces sexual battery, while Leal is charged with failing to disclose his HIV status.
• Victim’s Account: The minor reported being forced into sexual acts without consent, leading to the arrests.
• Legal Proceedings: Both men were denied bond and are currently held in custody pending immigration hearings.

Notable Quotes:

• Woody Overton (07:06): "The two men were arrested when the cruise ship pulled into the dock in Miami. They are accused of lewd and lascivious behavior with a minor."
• Cindy Overton (08:15): "He didn't tell the minor that he had HIV. Absolutely not."

2. Assault by a Doctor in Hawaii

Timestamp: 18:33 – 36:08

The hosts shift focus to a tragic incident in Hawaii involving Dr. Gerhardt Koenig, a 46-year-old anesthesiologist from Pittsburgh. On March 24th, Koenig brutally attacked his 36-year-old wife during a hike in the Pali Lookout area of Oahu, Hawaii.

Key Points:

• Incident Details: Koenig struck his wife with a rock and attempted to push her off a cliff after she refused to take a photograph with him.
• Aftermath: His wife is in critical condition, having sustained multiple injuries.
• Arrest and Charges: Koenig was apprehended shortly after the attack and is facing charges of assault and attempted manslaughter.
• Professional Repercussions: He has been suspended from his medical practice pending the investigation.

Notable Quotes:

• Woody Overton (18:06): "He struck his wife with a rock and then tried to push her off a cliff because she didn't want to take a picture with him."
• Cindy Overton (35:27): "She suffered multiple injuries to her head and face as a result of the attack."

3. Colorado Negligence and Animal Cruelty

Timestamp: 30:14 – 36:08

Woody and Cindy discuss the case of Jessica Hoff, a 47-year-old woman from Colorado City, who was arrested for criminal negligence and animal cruelty following the death of her 76-year-old mother, Lavon Hoff.

Key Points:

• Background: Lavon Hoff suffered from dementia and required 24-hour care. Jessica left her mother home alone to run errands, resulting in her mother's death from dog attacks.
• Animal Cruelty: Authorities found Jessica's home overflowing with 54 dogs and seven birds in deplorable conditions, leading to multiple charges.
• Legal Consequences: Jessica faces criminal negligence charges for her mother's death and 54 counts of animal cruelty. She is currently held in Pueblo County Jail with a bond set at $50,000.

Notable Quotes:

• Cindy Overton (30:14): "Detectives said they searched for another property owned by Jessica where they found 54 dogs and seven birds living in unsanitary conditions."
• Woody Overton (35:42): "If you're in that stage of dementia, come on man, you know, it's just bad."

4. Cold Case Solved: The Murder of Anita Knutson

Timestamp: 36:30 – 45:51

In a heartening turn of events, the hosts cover the resolution of a 15-year-old cold case involving the brutal murder of 18-year-old Anita Knutson in Minot, North Dakota.

Key Points:

• The Crime: On June 3, 2007, Anita Knutson was found stabbed twice in her off-campus apartment. The crime scene showed no forced entry, and a window screen had been cut, complicating the investigation.
• Progress Over Years: Despite numerous interviews and DNA testing, the case remained unsolved, leaving Anita’s family seeking justice.
• Breakthrough: In March 2022, the show "Cold Justice" revisited the case, leading to the arrest of Nicole Rice, Anita’s former roommate.
• Trial Developments: In March 2025, Nicole Rice, now 37, stood trial. The prosecution presented testimonies from witnesses who claimed Rice confessed to the murder during heated arguments over minor issues like an alarm clock.
• Court Proceedings: Key witnesses, including a friend and a former partner, provided statements implicating Rice, strengthening the prosecution's case.

Notable Quotes:

• Cindy Overton (39:01): "Nicole Rice was Anita's roommate, and their shared apartment was the setting for the tragic events."
• Woody Overton (44:57): "They went for it. Right. And if you got nothing else, here's an example of Haley's case."

5. Upcoming Live Event and Future Topics

Timestamp: 47:00 – 48:10

Wrapping up the episode, Woody and Cindy promote their upcoming live show scheduled for Saturday, July 19, 2025, at Southeastern Louisiana University’s main campus in Hammond, Louisiana. They highlight the event's features, including alcohol and food sales, an unscripted show, and a VIP reception at the nearby Suites by Hilton.

Key Points:

• Event Details: Live performance with original content, raw and unscripted, followed by a VIP reception.
• Accommodations: Discount codes for attendees to stay at the Suites by Hilton, encouraging out-of-town guests.
• Collaborations: Partnership with Tangy Tangipahoa Tourism for creating maps and QR code-based guides for attendees.

Notable Quotes:

• Cindy Overton (46:12): "They are doing a map of the town with all the different places to go."
• Woody Overton (47:06): "They won't be there for long. It’s going to be a hell of a great night."

Conclusion

In this episode, Woody and Cindy Overton navigate through a spectrum of true crime stories, from heinous crimes on cruise ships and disturbing assaults by trusted professionals to heartbreaking cases of negligence and the eventual redemption of a cold case. Their engaging storytelling, combined with insightful commentary, offers listeners a comprehensive look into the complexities of real-life crimes and the pursuit of justice. The episode concludes with an invitation to their dedicated listeners to join them live, promising an evening filled with riveting content and community engagement.