Real Life Real Crime – Episode Summary: True Crime Time For May 21, 2025

Hosted by Woody and Cindy Overton

Introduction

In this gripping episode of Real Life Real Crime, hosts Woody and Cindy Overton delve into a trio of compelling true crime stories, blending their unique dynamic and extensive investigative insights. From solving cold cases using advanced DNA technology to uncovering intricate fraud schemes and previewing a new human trafficking series, this episode offers a deep dive into some of the most intriguing criminal cases of recent times.

Karen Stitt Cold Case Solved by DNA

Timestamp: [05:14] – [11:15]

The episode opens with the heart-wrenching story of Karen Stitt, a 15-year-old girl whose life was brutally cut short in 1982. On [06:15], Cindy narrates how Karen was last seen after a date when her boyfriend allegedly dropped her off near a bus stop but failed to ensure her safe return home. Tragically, Karen’s body was discovered the following morning, brutally stabbed 56 times—evidence of overkill that left detectives baffled.

Despite extensive investigative efforts, the case went cold for decades with no significant leads. However, in a breakthrough moment highlighted at [07:53], detective Matt Hutchinson of the Sunnyvale DPS revisited the case in 2019 with advancements in DNA technology. By analyzing familiar DNA, they narrowed down the suspect pool to four brothers from Fresno.

In late 2022, further DNA analysis pinpointed Gary Ramirez as the likely perpetrator. As discussed around [09:36], Ramirez, a 78-year-old former Air Force serviceman, was residing peacefully in Maui, Hawaii. Detectives traced Ramirez’s whereabouts and ultimately apprehended him in August 2022. At [10:15], Ramirez pleaded no contest to Karen’s murder, receiving a 25-year sentence. Cindy emphasizes the relentless dedication of the detectives:

“...he’s doing 25 years... Thank you to the detective that didn’t give up on it.” ([10:46])

Though Ramirez is now serving his sentence, the Overtons ponder the motive behind such a heinous crime, noting at [11:15]:

“Do they ever say what the motive was or anything...?”

The resolution of Karen Stitt’s case serves as a testament to the power of modern forensic science and the unwavering pursuit of justice.

Human Trafficking Series Preview

Timestamp: [02:19] – [05:09]

Woody and Cindy take a moment to preview an upcoming series focused on human trafficking, underscoring their commitment to shedding light on this pervasive issue. Woody shares his anticipation for the first episode featuring Barbara Johnson and Haley’s case:

“...we are going to have a real life victim of human trafficking and sex trade... helping start a nonprofit that’s helping other victims...” ([03:26])

The series aims to provide victims' perspectives, offering a raw and honest portrayal of their experiences and the complexities of the legal system. Woody hints at the challenges in production:

“...hadn't quite figured it out, the placement and everything yet...” ([04:49])

Listeners can expect powerful narratives that highlight advocacy and the fight for justice, reinforcing the podcast’s dedication to not only recounting crimes but also contributing to their resolution and prevention.

Bourbon Street Hustler – Carlos Torres

Timestamp: [23:31] – [27:28]

The Overtons transition to a gripping tale set in the vibrant yet perilous environment of New Orleans’ French Quarter. Cindy introduces Danette Colbert, a 48-year-old Louisiana woman known as the "Bourbon Street Hustler." Convicted of multiple fraud offenses, Danette was recently sentenced to 25 years in prison for her latest scam.

Cindy outlines Danette’s criminal activities:

“...her criminal history includes multiple fraud offenses, particularly targeting tourists in New Orleans French Quarter...” ([24:11])

In 2024, Danette was convicted of theft, computer fraud, and illegal transmission of monetary funds, receiving an initial 10-year sentence. However, due to her status as a quadruple habitual offender with five prior felony convictions, Governor Jeff Landry intervened to extend her sentence without the possibility of parole:

“She was locked up and sentenced properly, she wouldn’t have never got out.” ([25:41])

Woody humorously reflects on their personal experiences in New Orleans, sharing anecdotes about avoiding scams:

“...I don’t wear jewelry, of course. I don’t carry a purse unless it’s a cross body...” ([27:07])

The story underscores the cunning nature of seasoned fraudsters and the challenges law enforcement faces in curbing their activities. Cindy and Woody commend the authorities for upholding habitual offender laws, ensuring that individuals like Danette face the consequences of their repeated transgressions.

Additional Highlights

While the primary focus of the episode revolves around Karen Stitt’s cold case, the human trafficking series, and the Bourbon Street Hustler, the Overtons also touch upon other intriguing stories, including the execution of serial killer Glenn Rogers and the bizarre case of a 22-year-old man biting a cat's ear off in Kentucky. These segments, though brief, add depth and variety to the episode, showcasing the wide range of true crime stories the podcast covers.

Conclusion and Future Engagement

As the episode wraps up, Woody and Cindy encourage listeners to engage through reviews, suggestions, and joining their Patreon for exclusive content. They also preview an upcoming call with Cold Case Files producers, promising more riveting stories and updates:

“...we have a phone call in an hour and 13 minutes with Cold Case Files producers...” ([04:49])

The hosts extend their gratitude to the loyal audience, emphasizing the importance of community support in bringing these true crime stories to light.

Notable Quotes:

• Cindy Overton ([07:36]): “Her naked body was found the next morning behind a blood-stained cinder block wall. She was stabbed 56 times.”

• Woody Overton ([10:15]): “...he's doing 25 years... Thank you to the detective that didn't give up on it.”

• Cindy Overton ([24:11]): “She was convicted of theft, computer fraud, and illegal transmission of monetary funds.”

• Woody Overton ([27:07]): “I don’t wear jewelry, of course. I don’t carry a purse unless it’s a cross body...”

Join the Conversation

Stay tuned for more episodes as Woody and Cindy continue to unravel the darkest corners of real-life crimes. Subscribe to Real Life Real Crime on your preferred podcast platform, and follow their journey in bringing justice and awareness to victims and their families.

For more information, visit Real Life Real Crime Community App or support the podcast on Patreon.