Real Life Real Crime – True Crime Time For October 20, 2025
Oklahoma State Shooting, McDonald’s Brawl, and a Florida Fake Abduction Hoax
Podcast: Real Life Real Crime
Hosts: Woody Overton & Cindy Overton
Air Date: October 20, 2025
Overview
On this episode of “True Crime Time For,” Woody and Cindy Overton explore several striking recent crime stories with their trademark unfiltered dialogue, real-world police insight, and a blend of shock, empathy, and occasional dark humor. The show opens with Woody’s updates on ongoing cold cases and tips from listeners before diving into current headlines: a shooting at Oklahoma State University, a violent altercation at a Florida McDonald’s, child neglect at a Florida beach, a devastating cold case development from the UK, a bizarre faked abduction story in Florida, and a harrowing Connecticut child homicide involving a year-long cover-up.
Case Updates and “Lulu Bell’s Channeling” (02:12)
Woody recaps ongoing cold case efforts and psychic involvement:
- “We release an episode to all lifers on Saturday. I'm still working the case. Continue calling your tips... there are more tips than ever.” (Woody, 02:27)
- Lulu Bell’s “channeling” continues to provoke responses, some believing and some skeptical, but all keeping cold cases alive in the public mind (03:00–03:40).
Cindy reveals the psychic’s latest vision involves a map, possibly providing a new clue (03:43).
Oklahoma State University Dorm Shooting (05:57)
Incident Summary:
- A shooting at Carreker East Residential Hall left multiple victims hospitalized at ~3:40am.
- At least one OSU student is among the injured; three hospitalized in Oklahoma City and Tulsa.
- No immediate updates on victims’ condition. No clarification if suspects are in custody or among the injured.
Woody’s Policing Perspective:
Reflects on how parties, particularly with off-campus attendees, often cause problems:
“The real problems, the people we have were the people who didn't go to school there that came to hang out with their friends...” (Woody, 05:10)
Discussion:
- Changes in residential hall security over the years (06:13)
- Student perception of safety, requirements for scanning into dorms (06:35)
- Parental anxiety about sending kids to college where such incidents occur
Florida: McDonald’s “Mac Mess” Shooting (07:00–16:54)
Incident Recap and Sheriff’s Colorful Commentary:
- Altercation at a Polk County McDonald’s between employee Yoan Soto (21), and customers Nicholas Jones (18) and Peter Story (20).
- Store overwhelmed by online orders; employee tells customers they can’t take more.
- “They threatened to attack the man who just told him, hey, we're busy. We can't take any more orders.” (Woody, 09:33)
- Customers threaten violence and claim to be armed. Employee arms himself; confrontation escalates.
- Customers try to grab the employee’s gun—he fires, Story is shot in the neck (minor wound).
Sheriff Grady Judd’s Notable Quote:
"What do these goober smoochers do?... They're having a Mac argument in the McDonald's over MC hamburgers or lack of MC hamburgers.” (Sheriff Judd, 10:00)
“It was just a Mac mess, but we'll sort it out because we're Mac good at investigating Mac crime.” (Sheriff Judd, 15:00)
Legal Consequences:
- Soto (employee): Charged with felony tampering with evidence (removed gun, casing, projectile from scene)
- Jones and Story: Charged with trespass after warning and disorderly conduct
- Discussion about self-defense (“stand your ground”) vs. bringing a firearm to work (16:45)
- Commentary on fast food chain policies regarding firearms (“I'm sure he's McFired.” – Woody, 17:02)
Florida Beach: Child Neglect Arrest (23:16)
Story Details:
- At Miramar Beach, Walton County, FL, a crying infant found alone in a tent; parents out for a walk with other kids, gone for nearly an hour (24:21).
- Parents, Brian (40) and Sarah Wilkes (37) of Houston, admitted to leaving the six-month-old unattended due to "losing track of time" (24:58).
- Infant unharmed; parents arrested for child neglect; children taken into state custody until family arrives from Texas.
Discussion Points:
- Dangers of heat, strangers, and abductions at beaches (25:14–26:38).
- Critical question: “How do you lose track of time when you have an infant? And how do you go for a stroll?” – Cindy (27:53)
- Reflection on frequent child snatching cases and the importance of vigilance.
Cold Case Update: 1994 UK Murder of Lindsay Remmer (28:01)
Case Details:
- 13-year-old Lindsay Remmer went missing in West Yorkshire in 1994; found dead five months later, weighed down in a canal.
- Recent arrest made in the case—suspect already in prison for other offenses (30:08).
Notable Quotes:
- “Went to buy some corn flakes. 13 years old and never came home...I always like to talk about a cold case being solved.” (Woody, 30:04–30:51)
- “I just hope you sweat it every day and be looking over your shoulder. One day justice will catch up with you.” (Woody, 31:01)
Florida: Faked Abduction Hoax (31:39)
Incident Narrative:
- 17-year-old Kayden Speight from Marion County sends family a text claiming abduction, shooting, and naming “four Hispanic men in a white van.”
- Scene looks real—bullet hole, blood, abandoned truck, smashed phone.
- “On the surface, if you're looking at it, you think there was a violent kidnapping, right?” (Cindy, 32:50)
Investigation:
- Police review Walmart footage: find Kayden buying camping gear and a bike that matches tracks from the scene (33:12).
- Located alive two weeks later, self-inflicted gunshot wound. Hoax intended to simulate abduction (34:31).
Legal Outcome:
- Charges include discharging firearm, presenting false evidence, filing false report, possession as a minor (34:31).
- Motive unclear; search history shows research on “how to collect blood without causing pain” and cartel references (35:05).
Woody’s Reaction:
- “The prisons are full of dummies and cameras are everywhere.” (Woody, 36:05)
Connecticut: Discovery of Missing 12-Year-Old’s Remains (36:59)
Details:
- Remains of Jacqueline “Mimi” Torres Garcia found in a plastic container at an abandoned property (37:00).
- Jacqueline likely died in Fall 2024 after “prolonged physical abuse and malnourishment.” Body hidden in basement, then moved when family relocated (37:44).
- Mother, aunt, and mother's boyfriend all arrested and charged with murder, cruelty, and improper disposal (38:00).
- Complex, year-long coverup: Mother withdraws child from school for “homeschooling,” has another child pose as Mimi in a video call with Child Protective Services (41:31–42:11).
Quotes & Reaction:
- “Jacqueline was a bright, joyful 12 year old who brought laughter and warmth to everyone around her.” (Woody, 40:59)
- “At the end of the Day. They didn't murder Mimi. Her parents did.” (Woody, 45:15)
- “They deserve the death penalty, period.” (Woody, 46:41)
Discussion:
- DCF (Department of Children and Families) challenged for failing to detect the cover-up; systemic issues recognized.
- Siblings placed together in state custody.
Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments
Sheriff Grady Judd’s wordplay:
“McArgument ... Mac mess ... we'll sort it out because we're McGood at investigating McCrime.” (13:37–16:45)
Woody on Vigilant Parenting:
“You send your kids to college, I mean...” (05:55)
Cindy on Parental Responsibility:
“How do you lose track of time when you have an infant?” (27:53)
Woody on Cold Case Justice:
“I just hope you sweat it every day and be looking over your shoulder. One day justice will catch up with you.” (31:01)
On Child Neglect:
“They deserve the death penalty, period. I don't know.” (Woody, 46:41)
Timestamps: Key Segments
- 02:12: Case updates & ongoing “Lulu Bell’s Channeling”
- 05:57: Oklahoma State University dorm shooting
- 07:00–16:54: Florida McDonald’s brawl & Sheriff Grady Judd’s “Mac mess”
- 23:16: Miramar Beach child neglect and parental arrest
- 28:01: UK cold case arrest – Lindsay Remmer
- 31:39: Florida fake abduction hoax (Kayden Speight)
- 36:59: Connecticut child homicide uncovered after a year-long deception
Overall Tone & Takeaways
Woody and Cindy maintain a candid, often blunt approach—mixing law enforcement realism with emotional reactions and the occasional sardonic laugh at the absurdity or tragedy of their stories. Woody’s storytelling remains gripping, and Cindy provides the voice of common sense from a parental perspective.
The episode serves as both a warning and a remembrance, reminding listeners of the importance of vigilance, community reporting, and perseverance in justice, while also exposing the sometimes-overlooked faults in larger systems meant to protect the vulnerable.
For listeners who missed the episode, this summary gives a comprehensive look at all discussed cases, key participant insights, and host commentary, highlighting both the facts and the emotional resonance that defines the Real Life Real Crime podcast.