Overtime – Episode #692: Douglas Murray, Sen. Tina Smith, Matt Welch

Summary

Real Time with Bill Maher: Detailed Summary of Overtime – Episode #692

Podcast Information:

• Title: Real Time with Bill Maher
• Host/Author: HBO Podcasts
• Episode: Overtime – Episode #692: Douglas Murray, Sen. Tina Smith, Matt Welch
• Release Date: April 22, 2025

Participants:

• Bill Maher: Host
• Douglas Murray: Best-selling author
• Matt Welch: Editor at Large, Reason Magazine; Co-host, The Fifth Column Podcast
• Sen. Tina Smith: Democratic Senator from Minnesota

---

1. Introduction and Guest Introductions (01:01 – 01:56)

Bill Maher opens the episode by introducing the guests:

• Douglas Murray: Known for his works on political and cultural issues.
• Matt Welch: Editor at large of Reason magazine and co-host of The Fifth Column podcast.
• Sen. Tina Smith: A Democratic senator from Minnesota.

Key Point: The panel is set to discuss contemporary sociopolitical issues, with a focus on gender definitions, historical legacies, public health, environmental concerns, and economic policies.

---

2. UK Supreme Court's Definition of Woman (01:57 – 04:49)

Discussion Starter: Bill Maher references the recent UK Supreme Court ruling that defines "woman" based on biological sex, explicitly excluding transgender individuals.

Notable Quotes:

• Douglas Murray ([01:57]): “We should include you in this too. It's about women, is based on biological sex and excludes transgender people.”

• J.K. Rowling ([02:28] & [02:39]): “Everyone who said this for years has been particularly women who've been defamed and lied about... Sex is not a spectrum. I mean, it's male and female.”

• Tina Smith ([04:37]): “It's not hard to get to toleration and acceptance without rewriting biology.”

Key Points:

• Biological Sex vs. Gender Identity: The panel debates the implications of defining "woman" strictly based on biological sex.

• Cultural and Legal Implications: Emphasis on how such legal definitions affect transgender individuals and societal norms.

• Generational Perspectives: Douglas Murray and Matt Welch express skepticism towards the evolving definitions of gender, suggesting a biological basis is paramount.

• Senator Smith's View: Advocates for acceptance without altering biological definitions, promoting a balance between tolerance and scientific reality.

Conclusion of Section: The panel acknowledges the complexity of gender identity issues, balancing biological definitions with social acceptance and the rights of transgender individuals.

---

3. Legacy of Paul Revere's Ride (06:46 – 07:26)

Topic Introduction: Douglas Murray reflects on the historical significance of Paul Revere's ride, marking its 250th anniversary.

Notable Quotes:

• Douglas Murray ([06:46]): “What is the legacy of Paul Revere's ride, which was 250 years ago today? The fact that no under 40 knows what the fuck I'm talking about.”

• Matt Welch ([07:03]): “Well, maybe the legacy is that we decided we didn't want a king and...”

Key Points:

• Historical Memory: The discussion highlights concerns about the diminishing public awareness of foundational historical events among younger generations.

• Symbolism of Rebellion: Matt Welch suggests that the enduring legacy may lie in the principles of resisting authoritarianism, as exemplified by Revere's actions.

Conclusion of Section: The panel agrees that while specific historical events like Paul Revere's ride may fade from public consciousness, the underlying values of independence and resistance to tyranny continue to influence contemporary society.

---

4. RFK Jr.'s Claims on Autism (07:08 – 08:52)

Topic Introduction: Bill Maher inquires about RFK Jr.'s announcement to identify the cause of autism by September.

Notable Quotes:

• Tina Smith ([07:26]): “I think it's when OJ Finds the real killer. I think it's...”

• Douglas Murray ([08:00]): “He did speak. What I read in the paper is he did speak on it this week... environmental toxins is really the story of my lifetime.”

• Matt Welch ([07:46]): “That's right...”

Key Points:

• Autism Causes Debate: The panel discusses RFK Jr.'s assertion that environmental toxins, rather than genetics, are the primary cause of autism.

• Skepticism Towards Timelines: Concerns are raised about the feasibility of pinpointing autism's cause within a short timeframe, labeling such promises as unrealistic.

• Environmental vs. Genetic Factors: Douglas Murray supports the environmental toxins hypothesis, citing his own views on pollution and its impact on health.

• Counterpoint by Tina Smith: Highlights improvements in pollution levels in OECD countries, suggesting that overall environmental conditions have been improving despite localized issues.

Conclusion of Section: The panel remains divided on the primary causes of autism, with discussions highlighting the tension between genetic and environmental explanations and skepticism about public figures' timelines and claims.

---

5. Environmental Pollution Concerns (08:52 – 09:55)

Key Points:

• Regional Pollution Issues: Douglas Murray emphasizes ongoing pollution problems in California, such as wildfire smoke and plastic pollution.

• Senator Smith's Perspective: Argues that developed nations are reducing overall pollution through cleaner technologies and adherence to the Kuznets Curve, which postulates that pollution increases with economic growth up to a point before decreasing as societies become wealthier.

• Debate on Pollution Trends: The conversation underscores differing views on whether environmental conditions are improving globally or remain dire in specific areas.

Notable Quotes:

• Tina Smith ([09:35]): “I'm talking about I can see the mountains from Long beach, which I couldn't growing up. We pass rules, we do cleaner tech over time.”

• Douglas Murray ([09:55]): “Okay, well, you may be sanguine about that...”

Conclusion of Section: While acknowledging localized environmental challenges, Senator Smith advocates for a broader view of global pollution trends, suggesting that wealthier nations are making progress in reducing overall environmental harm.

---

6. Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell and Political Influence (10:12 – 11:44)

Topic Introduction: Douglas Murray shifts the discussion to the political pressure on Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell, particularly from former President Trump.

Notable Quotes:

• Douglas Murray ([10:12]): “After Trump said Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell's termination can't come fast enough. Do you think Powell will last until the end of his term?”

• Matt Welch ([10:31]): “Not unless he just commits, you know, massive malfeasance... it's a classic example of why we do want parts of our government to be independent from political influence.”

• Tina Smith ([10:56]): “Donald Trump... he's trying to light fires everywhere. And it'll be difficult for Powell to stay in this job.”

• J.K. Rowling ([11:24]): “There's one way he'll get fired immediately, which is if he's bad on tv.”

Key Points:

• Independence of the Federal Reserve: The panel underscores the importance of maintaining the Federal Reserve's autonomy to ensure long-term economic stability without political interference.

• Trump's Interference: Discussion centers on former President Trump's attempts to undermine Jerome Powell’s position, raising concerns about the erosion of institutional independence.

• Potential Outcomes: Speculation on whether Powell can withstand political pressures without compromising his role, with mentions of possible public appearances affecting his tenure.

Conclusion of Section: The panel expresses concern over attempts to politicize the Federal Reserve, emphasizing the necessity of safeguarding its independence to preserve economic integrity and prevent short-term political maneuvers from destabilizing critical financial institutions.

---

7. Closing Remarks (11:37 – End)

Bill Maher wraps up the discussion, thanking the guests for their insights and encouraging listeners to tune in to future episodes.

---

Overall Summary:

In this episode of "Real Time with Bill Maher," host Bill Maher engages with a panel consisting of Douglas Murray, Matt Welch, and Senator Tina Smith to delve into pressing sociopolitical issues. The conversation navigates through the UK Supreme Court's definition of "woman," the fading legacy of historical events like Paul Revere's ride, RFK Jr.'s controversial claims about autism's causes, environmental pollution debates, and the political pressures on Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell.

Throughout the discussion, notable themes of biological definitions versus social constructs, the impact of environmental policies, and the importance of institutional independence are explored. The panelists offer a range of perspectives, highlighting the complexities and divergent viewpoints that characterize contemporary political discourse.

Notable Quotes with Timestamps:

• Douglas Murray on Gender Definition ([01:57]): “We should include you in this too. It's about women, is based on biological sex and excludes transgender people.”

• J.K. Rowling on Biological Sex ([02:28]): “Sex is not a spectrum. I mean, it's male and female.”

• Douglas Murray on Environmental Toxins ([08:00]): “Environmental toxins is really the story of my lifetime. I'm glad I was born as old as I am at a time when everything wasn't completely polluted.”

• Matt Welch on Federal Reserve Independence ([10:31]): “It's a classic example of why we do want parts of our government to be independent from political influence.”

This structured and detailed summary encapsulates the key discussions and insights from Episode #692, providing a comprehensive overview for those who have not listened to the episode.

Transcript

[Leigh]

Get ready to spring into action and into style with Leigh. Lee's got all the classics from shorts and tees to carpenters and cargos, pastels and prints that can't help but pop and selvedge denim, crop tops and barrel cut jeans to set the trends for spring and beyond. It's all stitched with the tried and true craft Lee's been known for since 1889 and you've loved since day one. So ready, set denim and get yourself over to Lee.com Spring moms deserve our.

[Kaley Cuoco]

Very best, especially on Mother's Day. There's only one place I trust to deliver high quality mom Approved rose bouquets. 1-800-flowers.com this year, 1-800-Flowers wants to make sure all the mothers in your life get the best with double the roses for free. When you buy one dozen, they'll double your bouquet to two dozen roses. To claim the double roses offer, go to 1-800flowers.com Spotify that's 1-800-flowers.com Spotify, the official florist of Mother's Day.

[Bill Maher]

Welcome to an HBO podcast from the HBO late night series Real Time with Bill Maher.

[Douglas Murray]

All right, youtubers. He is a best selling author. His new book is called On Democracies and Death Cults. Douglas Murray, to my left, to my right, an editor at large of Reason magazine and co hosted the Fifth Column podcast. Matt Welch. And she is a Democratic senator from Minnesota. Tina Smith, okay, here are the questions the actual people for Douglas, what is your reaction to the UK Supreme Court declaring that the definition of a woman is. Well, we should include you in this too. It's about women, is based on biological sex and excludes transgender people. Yeah. This was a big ruling this week in England, the Supreme Court. Their definition of woman is biological sex. To put it in shorthand. J.K. rowling. Wonderful. Yes.

[J.K. Rowling]

J.K. rowling1 Everyone who said this for years has won all the particularly women who've been defamed and lied about and bullied and chased and much more for years they were right. And I just think apart from being a statement of the obvious, isn't it amazing that the best legal minds in Britain spent years having to work out the first thing we knew as a species?

[Douglas Murray]

But just to be clear, we're not saying there's not such a thing as trans, right? We're not saying there's not such a thing as someone who is quote unquote, born in the wrong body.

[J.K. Rowling]

I don't think people get born in the wrong body.

[Douglas Murray]

No. Oh, I do.

[Matt Welch]

I do.

[Douglas Murray]

Yeah. I mean, I think there's a default setting for humans.

[Matt Welch]

Yep.

[Douglas Murray]

Like, we should acknowledge that it's not just every time there's a baby. Ooh, who knows what the fuck it is? That's crazy. But there are.

[J.K. Rowling]

Beyond me.

[Douglas Murray]

But there are variations in homosexuality. It's a continuum, but it's how we handle that. That's right. I mean, and I think we would agree that, you know, children. And this is where. This is where America is now, an outlier country. We're the only country that went full. And I guess Trump is reversing it, but certainly under Biden, who went fully toward that. Like, we don't care what age kids can self diagnose themselves. I mean, that to me was going way too far on this. Again, nobody just comes back to the sensible center.

[Matt Welch]

Yeah. I mean, to me, the sensible center is that, like, you respect people, you trust parents, you let parents figure out what to do with their kids. And you don't need a bunch of politicians in Washington making decisions about their parents.

[Douglas Murray]

That is not the Democratic position, at least here in California.

[Matt Welch]

Well, that's my position.

[Douglas Murray]

I'm good. I'm good. I think that's where the Democratic Party should. That is not the position that we've had here in California, which is like, don't tell the parents what the kids are doing at school. That's a whole. And that you really alienate voters. Parents are voters. When you're not a parent yet, you know, it's like, oh, voting, whatever.

[J.K. Rowling]

Sex is not a spectrum. I mean, it's male and female. There are some people with very unusual conditions who deserve absolute sympathy and support. But that does not mean that we're a hermaphroditic species. We're just not.

[Douglas Murray]

No, but not. No, not the whole species. But this goes back. I mean, like, I mean, I don't want to use the term chicks with dicks, but I could. I mean, this goes back to like ancient Rome. And like, there was always people who were like, not quite.

[Tina Smith]

It's not hard to get to toleration and acceptance without rewriting biology.

[Douglas Murray]

Right, Right.

[Tina Smith]

It's a norm. That's your normal sir.

[Kaley Cuoco]

Hey there, travelers.

Kaley Cuoco here. Sorry to interrupt your music. Great artist, BT Dubs, but wouldn't you rather be there to hear it live? With Priceline, you can get out of your dreams and into your dream concert. They've got millions of travel deals to get you to that festival, gig, rave, sound bath or sonic experience you've been dreaming of. Download the Priceline app today and you can save up to 60% off hotels and up to 50% off flights. So don't just dream about that trip. Book it with Priceline.

[Douglas Murray]

Go to your happy price. Priceline.

[Shopify]

This episode is brought to you by Shopify. Forget the frustration of picking commerce platforms when you switch your business to Shopify, the global commerce platform that supercharges your selling wherever you sell. With Shopify, you'll harness the same intuitive features, trusted apps and powerful analytics used by the world's leading brands. Sign up today for your $1 per month trial [e-mail] tech all lowercase.

[DraftKings]

That's shopify.com tech the NBA 82 game grind is done. And now the real fun begins. The NBA playoffs are here and DraftKings sportsbook has you covered as an official sports betting partner of the NBA. Make it a playoff run to remember with DraftKings. Download the DraftKings sportsbook app and use code Fieldgoal. That's code Fieldgoal for new customers to get $200 in bonus bets. When you bet just five bucks only on DraftKings, the crown is your yours. Gambling problem. Call 1-800- gambler in New York. Call 877-8-HOPENY or text HOPENY 467-369 in Connecticut. Help is available for problem gambling. Call 888-789-7777 or visit ccpg.org Please play responsibly on behalf of Boothill Casino and resort in Kansas, 21 and over. Age and eligibility varies by jurisdiction. Void. In Ontario, new customers only. Bonus bets expire 168 hours after issuance. For additional terms and responsible gaming resources, see DKNG Co Audio.

[Douglas Murray]

What is the legacy of Paul Revere's Bidnot ride, which was 250 years ago today? The fact that no under 40 knows what the fuck I'm talking about. What's the legacy of that?

[Tina Smith]

Maybe 60.

[Douglas Murray]

Yeah, right. Maybe 60.

[Matt Welch]

Well, maybe the legacy is that we decided we didn't want a king and. Oh, what the fuck. Here we have one, right?

[Douglas Murray]

There you go. What does the panel think of RFK Jr announcing he will find the cause of autism by September of this year?

[Tina Smith]

I think it's when OJ Finds the real killer. I think it's.

[Douglas Murray]

I mean, well, he's dead, so that's not gonna happen. Well, I would say, you know, this is why people think he's a quack. Because you're not gonna put a date on something they've been looking into for 30 years.

[Matt Welch]

That's right.

[Douglas Murray]

And say we're going to have it by September. It's not going to be, oh, it's the gummy bears.

[Matt Welch]

But that might be something. That might be something you say if you think you already know the answer to the question you're asking and you're going to deliver the answer in September. Right?

[Douglas Murray]

He did speak. What I read in the paper is he did speak on it this week. And I did not agree with the point of view of the article I was reading, which was that he's completely crazy because he was saying it's not mostly genetic, it's mostly environmental toxins. I happen to believe that's probably a more likely answer. And they were saying, well, no genetics and like could. Of course, genetics is involved in everything health wise. But to present the argument I saw framed in that way that he's a kook. Cause he thinks it's coming. I mean, environmental toxins is really the story of my lifetime. I'm glad I was born as old as I am at a time when everything wasn't completely polluted. I think that's why I'm still alive today. And it just got worse and worse and worse.

[Tina Smith]

The air is less polluted, the water is less polluted. As countries get richer, they pollute less. When they're industrializing, they pollute more. There might be individual environmental toxins, yes, but as a broader like description of the status of OECD countries, we are polluting on net less.

[Douglas Murray]

It depends on where you live, first of all. That's right out here in California, I believe I'm breathing in the fire still. The fire burned a lot of this city and a lot of this city had plastic in their home. And we were already getting, they say a credit card's worth of plastic in our body on a weekly basis. So I don't know what you're talking about. Like it's better than it used to be.

[Tina Smith]

I'm talking about I can see the mountains from Long beach, which I couldn't growing up. We pass rules, we do cleaner tech over time. And all rich countries do this. It is a process. It's a whole theory of the case called the Kuznets Curve. It's a thing. It's worth reflecting on and respecting too.

[Douglas Murray]

Okay, well, you may be sanguine about that. Maybe that's a libertarian in you, but this is what I worry about more than anything is the plastic in my head. Because someday it's just gonna.

[Matt Welch]

I worry about it too.

[Douglas Murray]

You should. You should. After Trump said Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell's termination can't come fast enough. Do you think Powell will last until the end of his term? Now, the president is absolutely not allowed to fire the head of the Federal Reserve, right?

[Matt Welch]

Not unless he just commits, you know, massive malfeasance. And, you know, Jay Powell has said, you can't fire me and I'm not going to leave. So this is a classic example of why we do want parts of our government to be independent from political influence, particularly the parts of our government that are going to have a big impact on the long term strength of our economy.

[Kaley Cuoco]

So.

[Tina Smith]

I give it to the side. You can make a person uncomfortable. And Donald Trump right now is on a making person people uncomfortable spree. He's trying to light fires everywhere. And it'll be difficult for Powell to stay in this job.

[Douglas Murray]

Also, we're at war. We're at war with Venezuelan gangs. So when you're at war, you can do anything, right? Isn't that the argument they'll make? I mean, they'll just make it up. This is what happens when you lose all your power.

[J.K. Rowling]

There's one way he'll get fired immediately, which is if he's bad on tv.

[Douglas Murray]

He doesn't go on tv.

[J.K. Rowling]

Somebody should send him on. He'll be bad. The president will hate it. He's gone.

[Douglas Murray]

Okay. All right. Thank you very much. You're a great crowd. I appreciate it.

[Leigh]

Thank you.

[Bill Maher]

Catch all new episodes of Real Time with Bill Maher every Friday night at 10 or watch him anytime on HBO on Demand. For more information, log on to hbo.com.