Overtime – Episode #729: John Fetterman, Dan Crenshaw, Donna Brazile

Summary

Real Time with Bill Maher: Overtime – Episode #729

Guests: John Fetterman (Democratic Senator, PA), Dan Crenshaw (Republican Congressman, TX), Donna Brazile (Former DNC Chair, ABC News Contributor)
Date: May 12, 2026

---

Episode Overview

This Overtime segment of Real Time with Bill Maher features a lively, candid discussion among Bill Maher and guests John Fetterman, Dan Crenshaw, and Donna Brazile. They tackle the Republican Party's internal conflicts, the crisis facing young men, shifts in parenting across cultures, the ongoing Iran war, and the legacy of Ted Turner and 24-hour news. The conversation is notable for its frank language, differing perspectives, and the blending of humor with political commentary.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. The Republican Civil War and Party Grievances

[01:12–03:52]

• Donna Brazile opens by referencing the "split in MAGA" and questions if a Republican civil war is brewing.
• John Fetterman frames the split as rooted in "grievance politics" and "pay-to-play influencers" rather than conservatism.
  • “I love that we’re having that battle. It’s a battle against the influencers that are pay-to-play. ... a battle against the podcast grift, too.” (Fetterman, 01:39)
• Fetterman reflects on being an early critic and receiving criticism for it, emphasizing he wants to “write [his] own history.”
• Discussion of integrity, misinformation, and campaign attacks—including Fetterman’s own experiences with rumors and attacks around 2020.

2. The Crisis Facing Young Men

[03:58–06:58]

• Donna Brazile cites the statistic that men are "nearly twice as likely as women to be living with their parents," asking how to help young men.
• Dan Crenshaw ties some male disaffection to perceptions of anti-male sentiment in the Democratic Party, noting migration away from the party.
  • “There’s part of the Democratic Party that became more and more anti-men... that’s really why one of the parts why we lost in 2024.” (Crenshaw, 04:30)
• Brazile acknowledges challenges for young men, noting women have long had to "be overconfident just to appear qualified." She reframes the “crisis” as a societal evolution of gender roles.
  • “Don’t want men to think...the reason young men are suffering is because some woman. No, young men are dealing with what young women had to deal with centuries ago.” (Brazile, 05:38)

3. Parenting, Race, and Cultural Shifts

[06:58–07:44]

• The panel debates "gentle parenting" versus traditional, discipline-based styles, referencing differences across racial and political communities.
• Brazile recalls her upbringing in a Black conservative household, with both sons and daughters doing household chores and strict parenting regardless of gender.

4. Loss of Traditional Voters and Masculinity in Politics

[07:59–08:31]

• Dan Crenshaw notes long-term loss of traditional, union “male” voters from the Democratic coalition, urging for reframing to avoid blaming men.
  • “We absolutely have a problem in that part of the demographic. ...we have to make better arguments without blaming them...” (Crenshaw, 07:59)

5. The Iran War and U.S. Strategy

[09:46–15:30]

• Donna Brazile initiates a pivot to the ongoing war with Iran, critiquing U.S. strategy as lacking an end game and costing more than American lives.
  • “I believe that the precise war we’re fighting now is one without a strategy and one without an end game.” (Brazile, 10:14)
• Dan Crenshaw stresses bipartisan consensus against Iran's nuclear ambitions and supports current interventions.
  • “Every single Democrat has said, we can’t ever let Iran build a bomb...and finally we did something about that.” (Crenshaw, 10:34)
• John Fetterman emphasizes U.S. energy independence and the effectiveness of economic blockades, outlining a hardline deterrence strategy.
  • “The blockade is a strategy to get to the negotiating table and be reasonable. ...And what’s reasonable is our demands.” (Fetterman, 12:09)
• They discuss broader consequences for oil markets, international responses, and whether more direct intervention (“boots on the ground”) is desirable or feasible.
  • “We can’t keep kicking the can down the road and impose longer term costs.” (Fetterman, 15:30)

6. Ted Turner’s Legacy & the 24-Hour News Cycle

[15:51–18:52]

• Following Ted Turner’s death, the panel reflects on how CNN and 24-hour news shifted information consumption, often for the worse.
• Donna Brazile and Bill Maher voice nostalgia for “just the news” versus today’s endless analysis and entertainment.
  • “Sometimes there isn’t news for 24 hours. So every time I see breaking news, I’m a little skeptical.” (Brazile, 16:16)
• Dan Crenshaw laments the rise of opinion as news and proliferation of infotainment personalities.
  • “Opinions have become actual real news and we’ve lost that... opinions are not news.” (Crenshaw, 16:46)
• John Fetterman and others argue for incentives to demand real news over “slop,” agreeing that viewers’ appetites have shaped the industry.
  • “That’s the—whose fault is this news organization? People have to change what they want to incentivize.” (Fetterman, 18:36)

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• Fetterman on modern politics:
  • “I was an AOC a lot longer than I was a politician.” (03:16)
• Brazile on gender and parenting:
  • “For years, decades, centuries, women had to be overconfident just to appear qualified.” (05:29)
• On the Ted Turner/cable news legacy:
  • “Now there are so many shitty twerks out there in the world now. Why are people still talking about Tucker Carlson or any of these people?” (Crenshaw, 16:46)
• Meta-commentary on Real Time itself:
  • “This is an entertainment show. It says real on the title.” (Brazile, 17:41)
  • “Let me tell you, the senator’s absolutely right. ...the American people need to learn to distinguish between opinion and fact.” (Fetterman, 18:01)

---

Important Timestamps

• [01:12–03:52] – Republican Party and influencer grift
• [03:58–06:58] – Crisis in young men, educational and economic
• [07:59–08:31] – Union voters and shift in party allegiance
• [09:46–15:30] – Iran war strategy: objectives, blockades, military action
• [15:51–18:52] – Ted Turner, rise of 24-hour news, blurring of fact and opinion

---

Tone and Dynamics

Throughout, the conversation is open and unscripted, with honest disagreements and personal anecdotes. There’s a blend of humor (“You can’t be a politician now without saying the word fuck.” – Brazile, 03:47), sharp critique, insider perspective, and moments of bipartisan agreement. The panel occasionally veers into entertaining digressions, but the heart of the episode remains political and cultural analysis delivered in plain, lively language.

---

Summary Takeaway

This Overtime episode delivers a rare bipartisan look at party rifts, American masculinity, U.S. foreign strategy, and how 24-hour news has muddied distinctions between reporting and opinion. The guests challenge each other, share personal stories, and, despite sharp differences, connect over the changes and challenges facing American politics and society in 2026.

Transcript

[Redfin Advertiser]

This episode is brought to you by Redfin. You're listening to a podcast, which means you're probably multitasking, maybe even scrolling home listings on Redfin, saving homes without expecting to get them. But Redfin isn't just built for endless browsing. It's built to help you find and own a home with agents who close twice as many deals. When you find the one, you've got a real shot at getting it. Get [e-mail] own the dream.

[Taco Bell Advertiser]

From sauce to dust to nuggets. Diablo Dusted Crispy Chicken Nuggets. No, they don't come in mild. That would make, like, zero sense with the name new Diablo Dusted Crispy Chicken Nuggets only at Taco bell, at participating U.S. taco Bell locations for a limited time and while supplies last.

[Bill Maher]

Welcome to an HBO podcast from the HBO late night series Real Time with Bill Maher.

All right, he's a Democratic senator from Pennsylvania, John Fetterman. He's the Republican con from Texas and host of the podcast hold these Truths, Dan Crenshaw. And she is an ABC News contributor and former DNC chair, Donna Brazile. All right, let's get to the questions

[Donna Brazile]

that the people want to know. They want to know, what do you make of the split in maga? Is there a Republican civil war brewing? Well, there certainly is. Big disagreements. I mean, you know, I've been fighting

[John Fetterman]

the Civil War for a long time, you know, pointing out the atrocities and the grifting of people like Tucker Carlson. And now there's a lot more people obviously realizing that some of us had to be first across the beachhead and take all the bullets. But I like that we're having that civil war. It's not new. You know, you think about it back in the day, Buckley versus the Birch Society, it's similar. It's. It's grievance politics. It's populist politics. It's not conservative politics. And we need to root it out, at least. I love that we're having that battle. It's a battle against the influencers that are pay to play. It's a battle against the companies they use cutouts. Battle against the podcast grift, too. People getting their news from this stuff. And I'm glad we're talking. People are waking up.

[Donna Brazile]

It's also about integrity, isn't it? You lost your job because you wouldn't say the 2020 election.

[John Fetterman]

That's right. I know you're being kind when you, when you say that, but that's not what one person was saying. Going in. And this goes back to the podcast Grift and like the social media grift. The people were going into that voting booth thinking I was worth millions of dollars from insider trading. It was wild. People, people were getting. Democrats spent about almost a million dollars on attack ads on me.

[Donna Brazile]

But you said the 2020 election.

[John Fetterman]

Alcohol related incidents. Like it was. I mean, I did say that.

[Donna Brazile]

You said the 2020 election was legitimate.

[John Fetterman]

Yeah, of course I said that. But that didn't take the compliment.

[Bill Maher]

Like I said, I know you trying to give me props, but I want

[John Fetterman]

to write my own. I got to write my own history. Like, I want people to know the truth about what happened. Not one person was going in there thinking, you're not with Trump. Me and Trump have a great relationship. It had nothing to do with this. And that election had nothing to do with it. Also, I've had elections since then, remember? Like, it just hasn't. That wasn't a factor. And I know you're being kind.

[Donna Brazile]

Trump didn't come after you for that.

[John Fetterman]

Truth teller. When has Trump made it a secret of Congressman? He doesn't like, does he? When does he kept that a secret? No, if he doesn't like you, you know, it. So we have. It just didn't come up. I mean, I'm in a unique position because my name is Clickbait and I fight back, right? People make up crap about me and I might tweet back at them, you know, and I might say the word fuck or something like that. People are like, well, we don't like that. I'm like, I thought you said you didn't want politicians. I was an AOC a lot longer than I was a politician.

[Donna Brazile]

You can't be a politician now without saying the word fuck. Well, you're.

[Bill Maher]

I mean, that's.

[John Fetterman]

So it creates this cottage industry. It's a unique case, but I want people to know what actually happened.

[Donna Brazile]

Okay. Senator Fetterman, men are nearly twice as likely as women to be living with their parents in the current financial climate. How do we help young men? Wow. Twice as likely. Whoa.

[John Fetterman]

Oh.

[Dan Crenshaw]

Right now, I'm not really running for anything right now, but I'm just saying. But not, you know what exactly. I mean.

[Donna Brazile]

I mean, men are. I mean, we hear this all the time, that young men are in crisis, that women are doing better in college. They're doing better.

[Dan Crenshaw]

I mean. Well, without a doubt, though, you know, there's part of the Democratic Party became more and more anti men or describing that they were part of the problem or they have toxic traits and for those things. And that's why there's been such a big, big migration away from the Democratic Party from young men. And that's really why one of the parts why we lost in 2024. Now if you identify anyone as the problem or blame them for some things, then you're going to lose. We forgot that we are in the business of addition, not subtraction or subtraction.

[Donna Brazile]

I mean, so we have figured out.

So it was a testerone shift in 2024. I don't think that's a long term trend. I think it was a very short term generational shift that we're experiencing within the Democratic Party overall. Look, I've been a part time college professor for 33 years. There is something going on with young men in our country. They are reticent. Many of them are holding back and we need to address that. But at the same time holding back, holding him. I pulled them back because sometimes I think they don't know their place anymore. And that's something that men need to decide and discuss. But as a woman, for years, decades, centuries, women had to be overconfident just to appear qualified. So I don't want men to think that the reason why young men are suffering is because some woman. No, young men are dealing with what young women had to deal with centuries ago. You'll find your place at the table. Come sit with me sometime. I'll get you some help.

[Dan Crenshaw]

And like you know all those.

[Donna Brazile]

Oh, trust me, Bill, Bill, let me tell you something. You grew up in the Brazil household. My mom used to say, Cheryl, Sheiladon, Tater, Chet, Lisa, Demetri, Kevin Zola, get your asses up.

[Bill Maher]

I think that's the way you turned out. No, I think that's the way to do it.

[Donna Brazile]

And everybody had to get their ass up. Yes. My brothers had to get up and make up the bed. The sisters had to make up the bed. The brothers put out the trash. The sisters, they what? We didn't have one of these. The boys do this and the girls do this. My daddy used to tell the girls, don't let no naked baby dolls in the house. Don't ask me why, but he didn't like naked baby dolls. And I told him I didn't mind either because Barbie had nothing going on and Ken had absolutely nothing going on. So it was fine with me.

You mean they were not anatomically correct?

Well, you know, it smart parents.

[Bill Maher]

No, I'm smart it parents. I'm with you.

[Donna Brazile]

I'm not a fan of Gentle parenting. I mean, you're saying you didn't have gentle parenting. And it seems to be more acceptable to say that in the black community than the white community, to be able to say, yes, my parents whooped me, and then that's okay. But when the white people say it, boy, they get pissed.

[Dan Crenshaw]

People.

[John Fetterman]

White liberal community.

[Donna Brazile]

Yeah, the white liberal community.

What's the difference between white liberals and white conservative? What's the deal?

[John Fetterman]

No, that is the difference would be the cult. There's a cultural difference in, like, how you would raise. Yeah, absolutely.

[Donna Brazile]

Absolutely.

I consider. I grew up in a black conservative household.

Seriously.

We went to church, but we have

[John Fetterman]

the same opinions, it seems like, on raising kids. So that's what I'm.

[Donna Brazile]

Well, that means that we're colorblind, huh?

[John Fetterman]

Yeah, pretty good.

[Donna Brazile]

Good for you.

[John Fetterman]

I am colorblind and half real blind.

[Donna Brazile]

Look, I'm coming to your house and don't serve me nothing but steak. I'm with you. I don't want that bio shit.

[Bill Maher]

I don't want that bio shit.

[Donna Brazile]

I don't want no shit that's been created in the laboratory, and you can't

[Dan Crenshaw]

pick it and see it. We've lost the vote. You talk to any of the traditional union members that are men? You know, we've lost them a long time ago. I've witnessed that migration away from the Democratic Party starting back in 2016. You know, we absolutely have a problem in that part of the demographic. So we really have to find a way to bring them back and make better, better arguments without blaming them or describing they are the problem.

[Palmolive Advertiser]

This episode is brought to you by Palmolive. Family time isn't just the big moments. It's weeknight dinners, sitting around the table, everyone talking all at once. So when the plates are empty and the sink is full, use Palmolive Ultra. Palmolive's most powerful formula removes up to 99.9% of grease, leaving your dishes sparkling clean. And the new convenient pump makes cleaning even easier, so you can spend less time tackling dishes and more time together. Shop [e-mail] tomorrow morning is knocking.

[Bill Maher]

Stock your fridge now. How about a creamy mocha Frappuccino drink? Or a sweet vanilla smooth caramel, maybe? Or a white chocolate mocha? Whichever you choose, delicious coffee awaits. Find Starbucks Frappuccino drinks wherever you buy your groceries.

[Donna Brazile]

We gather here tonight to bring women

back to their rightful place.

[Hulu Advertiser]

The Testaments, a new Hulu original series from the executive producers of the Handmaid's Tale.

[Redfin Advertiser]

It's easier to Accept a story than believe that the people around you are monsters.

[Hulu Advertiser]

The battle isn't over. There comes a time when you have to take action, when you have to choose your own destiny.

[Bill Maher]

Never quite as it seems.

[Hulu Advertiser]

Watch the new Hulu original series, the Testaments, streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney plus for bundle subscribers. Terms apply.

[Donna Brazile]

And if I could wheel this over to the war, because it is somewhat related, because I hear a lot of things now. I know you're against the war. We have two people.

Don't say that.

The Iran war.

Oh, that war.

Yeah. Which one were you talking about?

There's so many going on. I didn't know which one.

That's the main one that we're going on now.

Okay. Because there are a lot of them. But let me just say this. You want me to speak. No, let him speak first. I'm gonna tell you something. Well, only because Ayatollah was not a fan of us.

No.

The Iranian regime was not a fan of their neighbors. And so I believe that the precise war that we're fighting now is one without a strategy and one without an end game. And one that is costing us more than just American lives.

Yeah. That may be the case.

[Dan Crenshaw]

Every single Democrat has said, we can't ever let Iran build a bomb. And then every single president. When Kamala Harris was running for president, she identified that as the top, top concern for her international. And then finally we did something about that. And I absolutely support that thing. And for me now, I think. I think it shouldn't be controversial as a Democrat to say, look, we don't have to agree every aspect of epic fury, but I do think we should all agree that here we are at the cusp. No. Hold them accountable and remind them they are the bad guys. We are not the bad guy. And I'm absolutely convinced, too, the Democratic contempt for Trump exceeds the concern of the anger about. Towards Iran. And that's why that's pushed us into. You know, we've lost the entire. And we. It used to be standing for. Behind the military, regardless, behind everything. That's become bipartisan. It's lost being bipartisan.

[Donna Brazile]

Yeah.

[Bill Maher]

If I. You can disagree on whether.

[John Fetterman]

Well, let's back it up to strategic objectives. Saying every. Every president believes that Iran should not have a nuclear bomb. We don't want another North Korea. That is a strategic objective. Okay. We did Midnight Hammer. We bombed their nuclear facilities. What do they try to do? They keep trying to rebuild them. They rebuilt. They start rebuilding and producing more and more missiles. So many more. This Is why, by the way, we had to go in when we did that, we were not going to be able to start intercepting all of them. And so the strikes had to begin. And like, what. What strategy does everyone prefer? Boots on the ground? Is that what everybody wants?

[Donna Brazile]

No, so.

[John Fetterman]

Because what they're saying is now is beat them into submission. You know, we don't live in the 1970s. Iran thinks we do. We live in a time when we have energy independence. So, yeah, there's a cost to us, but it is not near what the. What the cost imposed on the Iranian regime right now. And the blockade and its effectiveness has been massive as well. Iran is acting desperate. They just attacked UAE last night. They attacked a bunch of our destroyers. Nothing got through because we have already adapted to that drone warfare age. And the Iranians are now desperate. They're going to run out of their ability to even store the oil that they're producing. That's going to be a massive problem for them. So the blockade is a strategy. It's a strategy to get to the negotiating table and be reasonable. And what's reasonable is our demands. And if you don't like it, we'll keep buying it.

[Donna Brazile]

While we undertake this strategy, what happens is they're running out of jet fuel. We are.

[Dan Crenshaw]

We're fine.

[Donna Brazile]

Other. Other countries are.

[John Fetterman]

That's their problem.

[Bill Maher]

We're not. We're not.

[Donna Brazile]

We're not. That's terrible. Well, not only is it terrible, first

of all, fuel is fungible.

[John Fetterman]

As you know, we're down about 10 million barrels a day. Okay, okay, 20 million a day. Come out of the straits or moves. We're down about 10 million because the world can adapt. Because we did the operation in Venezuela, we get more barrels out of that. Texas produces a lot more. We don't live in the 1970s anymore. Again, I know that other countries are locking down in very serious ways, but it's not just.

[Donna Brazile]

It's just at the jet fuel. It's a lot of stuff around the world that this is affected by. And I don't know how we are actually going to get this Strait of

[John Fetterman]

Horror moose opened again.

[Donna Brazile]

Nobody said, I have an idea. We send in the cruise ships with the Hantavirus,

[Bill Maher]

Deal with that Iran.

[Donna Brazile]

Everybody will part ways eventually.

[John Fetterman]

Eventually.

[Bill Maher]

You have to explain.

[Donna Brazile]

But at the same time, we want to make sure that the United States come out of this conflict with not only the ability to reopen the Strait of Hormuz, but also the ability to rebuild the bases in the Middle east and to rebuild our alliances. We Are losing.

[John Fetterman]

We have solid solidified the Gulf Arab states against Iran. The alliances are literally stronger than Iran.

[Dan Crenshaw]

We have to make sure Iran cannot be build a nuclear bomb.

[Donna Brazile]

We all agree on that.

[Dan Crenshaw]

If they become a nuclear state, they are untouchable in the region 100%. And if now they think you can control this straight now imagine if they are nuclear power, then they could really maintain that control. Absolutely. Pay whatever that they had a friend.

[Donna Brazile]

How you are going to get nuclear material unless you go in and occupy that mountain under which it is.

[John Fetterman]

Yeah, it's an option. I mean look, all these options are on the table. Option is we always know when someone is going there and every time someone does, we bomb it. I mean that's also an option. Right. So what we've done is decimated their conventional military, which is the outer ring of security for their nuclear program. We can pretend that like any kind of deal, you know, but it was unverifiable. It didn't count for military bases. You know, it gave them money before we were able to verify anything. It wasn't a good deal to begin with. The only language these people speak is deterrence and strength. Because they speak the language of martyrdom. They will take pain like no one else. Yes, but it's not infinite. And what we're doing is.

[Donna Brazile]

Well, it's never for the leadership. They're always for martyrship for others. They never have to do it.

[John Fetterman]

We've made them do it pretty recently. Yeah, we've changed the dynamics and we've effectively countered with strategic deterrence and re established that deterrence. And yes there's short term costs, but it's long term stability and we can't keep kicking the can down the road and impose longer term costs.

[Bill Maher]

Okay, final question because this is,

[John Fetterman]

this

[Donna Brazile]

show airs on CNN as of a couple of years ago. What is the legacy of Ted Turner who died this week? What has the impact been of the 24 hour news cycle? Well, he certainly was one of the giants of broadcasting because. Yeah, because before Ted Turner and before CNN we did not have 24 hour news. Now I mean sometimes there isn't news for 24 hours. So every time I see breaking news I'm a little skeptical.

You know, maybe he brought the. I think Mr. Turner, he was able to let us see the world. I mean I, I was a fan of CNN even before I got hired by cnn.

Me too.

And I still love cnn. I mean in the middle of the night I love to watch CNN during my bathroom breaks. You figure that one out.

[Bill Maher]

I think I Know, where's the tv?

[Dan Crenshaw]

Opinions have become actual real news and we've lost that Billy. Like, you know, like, opinions are not news, you know, and there are so many shitty twerks out there in the world now. Why are people still talking about Tucker Carlson or any of these people now? Even Alex Jones now is back. You know, I have to see that asshole in my feed anymore. Why? Because if they are criticizing. If they are criticizing Trump, it's like now sometimes we and the Democrats say, well, maybe they have a point, you know, mtg crazy pants. Why are we hearing about her now?

[Donna Brazile]

Marjorie Taylor Greene.

Yeah,

yeah.

[Dan Crenshaw]

I mean, so what I'm saying, it's like, you know, like focusing on real news and the real dynamic there, you know, I'm so tired of if opinions have become news and now there's countless, countless ones and it's all become slop.

[Donna Brazile]

And let me just make the point. This is a. This is an entertainment show. It says real on a title.

[Bill Maher]

It is?

Yeah.

Cause it's a lot more real than that other shit.

[John Fetterman]

Let me tell you, the senator's absolutely right. I mean, the problem is the American people need to learn to distinguish between opinion and fact.

[Donna Brazile]

But this is an entertainment network and an entertainment show. It deals with news as comedy fodder and also gives opinions. And by the way, they are realer than the other bullshit.

[Bill Maher]

But that's different. And I am a fantasy.

[Donna Brazile]

But I agree, it's too much opinion. I would rather just. When CNN was first out there, you could just always count on to turn it on and you would just get the story, get the news, get the

facts, get the news.

[John Fetterman]

That's what I want, to make money that way. We all know that you're in the business. You won't make money that way. So that's the. Whose fault is this news organization? People have to change what they want to incentivize.

[Donna Brazile]

News organizations shouldn't be making money to begin with.

[John Fetterman]

They didn't used to.

[Bill Maher]

They didn't used to have to. All right, but we gotta go. All right. Thank you very much. Thank you.

Catch all new episodes of Real Time with Bill Maher every Friday night at 10 or watch him anytime on HBO On Demand. For more information, log on to HBO.com

[Ryan Reynolds]

Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile. I don't know if you knew this, but anyone can get the same Premium Wireless for $15 a month plan that I've been enjoying. It's not just for celebrities. So do like I did and have one of your assistant's assistants switch you to Mint Mobile today. I'm told it's super easy to [e-mail]

[Bill Maher]

Switch upfront payment of $45 for 3 month plan equivalent to $15 per month required intro rate first 3 months only, then full price plan options available, taxes and fees extra. See full [e-mail] There's a new way

[Taco Bell Advertiser]

to Sweetgreen meat wraps handheld, hearty and made for life on the move. With bold, chef crafted flavors, fresh ingredients, ingredients and over 40 grams of protein. They're built to satisfy without slowing you down. Try wraps today in the app [e-mail] available at all participating locations.