Redacted: Declassified Mysteries with Luke Lamana

Episode: The Plot to Kill George Washington

Release Date: March 25, 2025

Introduction

In the gripping episode titled "The Plot to Kill George Washington", Luke Lamanna, a Marine Corps Reconnaissance Veteran, delves deep into a lesser-known yet pivotal moment in American history. Hosted by Wondery | Ballen Studios, this episode uncovers the intricate web of espionage, betrayal, and the nascent formation of American counterintelligence during the American Revolution.

Setting the Scene: A Nation in Turmoil [00:00 - 05:19]

The episode opens on June 28, 1776, amidst the chaos enveloping New York City. General George Washington, identifiable by his distinctive blue sash, stands resolute in his headquarters, preparing to lead his troops through the dense woods of northern Manhattan. The atmosphere is thick with tension as the Continental Army grapples with internal and external threats. Washington's unease stems from a recent discovery—a British plot aimed at kidnapping or assassinating him, cultivated through leaks from within his own lifeguard unit.

[00:45] "Washington's eyes narrowed with resolve. This was the cost of war. A war that was only just beginning."

As Washington and his officers approach the gallows to execute Thomas Hickey, the first man condemned for treason against the nascent United States, the gravity of their situation becomes palpable. The execution serves as a stark reminder of the fragile trust within the ranks and the ever-present danger of betrayal.

Unveiling the Conspiracy: Washington's Counterintelligence Efforts [05:19 - 17:16]

John Jay, a key figure in Washington's inner circle, provides an insightful analysis of Washington's multifaceted leadership roles—spymaster, militia officer, and commander in chief. Jay elucidates how Washington recognized the imperative need for intelligence and counterintelligence to safeguard the fledgling nation.

[07:48] "The use of spycraft saved Washington's life and secured a future for America."

Under Washington's directive, the Committee on Conspiracies was established, marking America's first formal counterintelligence operation. This committee was instrumental in deciphering British codes, detaining potential spies, and unearthing enemy plots within the American ranks. The British strategy involved not only conventional warfare but also subterfuge aimed at destabilizing the American leadership.

[07:45] "Before becoming the first President of the United States, he was a militia officer, revolutionary delegate, and commander in chief of the Continental Army."

The committee's work was critical in identifying and neutralizing threats. Washington's adeptness at espionage ensured that plots against him were detected and thwarted, maintaining the integrity of the Continental Army during its most vulnerable phases.

Key Players and Betrayal: Internal Threats [17:16 - 30:59]

The narrative introduces Isaac Ketchum, a man wrongfully imprisoned and caught in the crosshairs of Loyalist schemes. Ketchum's interactions reveal the depth of Loyalist infiltration, with trusted soldiers like Thomas Hickey and William Greene conspiring against Washington. Their motivations—stemming from delayed pay, poor living conditions, and disillusionment with Washington's stringent policies—highlight the internal strife within the Continental forces.

[17:16] "The worst of all these offenses was General Washington himself. He didn't approve of the soldiers drinking, so he had banned the city from selling alcohol to them."

Gilbert Forbes, a Loyalist gunsmith, emerges as a pivotal antagonist, orchestrating the recruitment of disenchanted soldiers to aid the British cause. His alliance with Mayor David Matthews underscores the collaborative efforts between Loyalist officials and British operatives to undermine Washington's command.

Through meticulous interrogation and strategic pressure, the Committee on Conspiracies manages to dismantle the plot, leading to the execution of Thomas Hickey. This decisive action not only serves as a deterrent against future betrayals but also cements the importance of intelligence work in the continuity of the American Revolution.

[17:16] "Fear got the best of him, and he started talking."

Climax and Resolution: Securing Leadership [30:59 - 44:58]

As the British threats intensify with the imminent arrival of their fleet, Washington's resolve is tested. The successful exposure and elimination of traitors like Hickey fortify his leadership and the unity of the Continental Army. The episode culminates with the significance of these espionage efforts laying the groundwork for modern American counterintelligence practices.

Washington's ability to navigate through internal treachery and external pressures not only secured his position but also ensured the survival and eventual success of the American Revolution. The establishment of the Culpa Ring, an extensive spy network, is portrayed as a direct outcome of the thwarted assassination plot, highlighting the enduring legacy of these early intelligence endeavors.

Conclusion: The Birth of American Espionage

"The Plot to Kill George Washington" vividly illustrates the precarious nature of early American leadership and the indispensable role of intelligence in nation-building. By uncovering and neutralizing threats from within, Washington not only preserved his command but also set a precedent for American espionage that continues to influence the nation's security apparatus today.

[42:21] "These are methods still used today. In many ways, the plot to assassinate George Washington resulted in the birth of American espionage."

Notable Quotes

• George Washington: "This was the cost of war. A war that was only just beginning." [00:45]

• John Jay: "The use of spycraft saved Washington's life and secured a future for America." [07:48]

• General Reflection: "In many ways, the plot to assassinate George Washington resulted in the birth of American espionage." [42:21]

Closing Remarks

This episode of Redacted: Declassified Mysteries with Luke Lamana masterfully intertwines historical facts with dramatic storytelling, bringing to light the clandestine operations that safeguarded America's first leader. For enthusiasts of history, espionage, and military strategy, this episode offers a compelling exploration of how internal loyalty and strategic intelligence were pivotal in shaping the United States.

Listen to "The Plot to Kill George Washington" on the Wondery App or wherever you get your podcasts. Join Wondery+ for early and ad-free access.