Behind the Scenes with Andrew Jarecki

Summary

Revisionist History – Behind the Scenes with Andrew Jarecki

Date: March 26, 2026
Host: Malcolm Gladwell
Guest: Andrew Jarecki, director of The Alabama Solution

---

Episode Overview

This special episode of Revisionist History features a wide-ranging conversation between Malcolm Gladwell and acclaimed documentarian Andrew Jarecki, recorded live at On Air Fest in Brooklyn. Their discussion centers on the deep, fraught problems within the Alabama prison system, as told through the dual lens of Gladwell’s seven-part podcast series (The Alabama Murders) and Jarecki’s recent HBO documentary (The Alabama Solution). They explore the challenges of investigating and revealing conditions inside Alabama prisons, narrative choices in storytelling, and the nature of systemic cruelty—offering listeners a behind-the-scenes look at exposing a hidden American crisis.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Origins of the Alabama Documentary

• Jarecki’s Entry Point:
  • Jarecki shares that his entry into the subject wasn’t direct but evolved from a longstanding curiosity about U.S. prisons, first piqued during visits to correctional facilities while filming earlier documentaries like Capturing the Friedmans.
  • A pivotal moment: a trip with his 14-year-old daughter to Montgomery, inspired by Anthony Ray Hinton’s story, led to a fateful dinner with Alabama’s first Black prison chaplain.
  • The chaplain’s haunting promise—“If you come back, I'll take you on the death row at Holman Prison, and you'll see it's a slave ship” (07:33)—set Jarecki on a seven-year journey.

2. Barriers to Transparency and Access

• Systemic Secrecy of Prisons:
  • Both Gladwell and Jarecki marvel at the lack of transparency: “Isn't it crazy that if you're a journalist, you can go to a war zone, but you can't go to a prison in your own country?” (07:20, Gladwell quoting the film).
  • Prisons in Alabama, and across the U.S., are effectively “black sites” shielded from press and public scrutiny.

3. Innovative Storytelling: Prisoners as Co-Filmmakers

• Contraband Cell Phones as a Window

  • The documentary’s most radical element: much of its footage comes from FaceTime calls and videos secretly recorded by inmates on contraband phones (11:10–12:35).

  • Prisoners became both subjects and cinematographers: “It was like talking to Mandela on Robben Island on a cell phone” (12:26, Jarecki).

  • The immediacy of these clips breaks documentary conventions and brings viewers directly into the present-tense of suffering and resistance.

    Quote:

    “The only way that these people can get away with treating human beings this way is if it’s in darkness. You can’t do this if the public knows.”
    (13:27, Jarecki)

4. Exposing Brutality and the Mechanics of Obfuscation

• Embedded Cruelty and Cover-Ups

  • The film uncovers not just violence but how the system covers it up—such as delays in notifying families, reassigning witnesses, and reliance on an elaborate security theater.

  • Ironic twist: the same contraband phones (sold to inmates by guards) that enable illicit communication also become tools for documenting and exposing abuse (24:01).

    Quote:

    “The tool that the men are using to identify the crimes that are being committed… are sold to them by aforementioned law enforcement officers.”
    (24:01, Jarecki)

5. Moral Failure Cascades and Human Degradation

• Gladwell’s “Moral Failure Cascade”

  • The conversation reflects on how a succession of small systemic failures snowball into chronic brutality—leading to phenomena like rampant deaths, suicides, sexual assaults, and appalling living conditions.

    Quote:

    “People get used to it… At some point are we going to look at that and say, like, maybe we're doing something wrong?… They are death camps. We have to say. That's what they are.”
    (27:25–28:52, Jarecki)

• Visuals That Shock:

  • Rats swimming in toilets, food hanging from the ceiling to avoid vermin, and disciplinary action for coping mechanisms drive home the everyday inhumanity (26:03–26:49).

6. Alabama’s Distinctive Culture and Policy

• Alabama Exceptionalism:
  • Both Gladwell and Jarecki view Alabama as peculiar even among other troubled states: insularity, rhetorical bravado, and unapologetic cruelty set it apart (33:23–34:58).
  • The state motto—“We dare defend our rights”—captures this ethos: "If you want to come and have an opinion, you can go fuck yourself" (33:52, Jarecki).

7. Political Will and Moral Blindness: The Steve Marshall Interviews

• No Remorse from State Officials

  • Alabama’s Attorney General Steve Marshall emerges as a “cinematic villain,” unashamed and unwavering: “I’ve been told that there’s some systemic problem in all of our facilities, and I wholeheartedly disagree with that.” (28:52, quoting Marshall)

  • Gladwell and Jarecki probe the psychology of such officials—how they rationalize, deflect, and politick their way out of responsibility, sometimes with religious rhetoric (38:00–40:09).

    Quote:

    “There’s no shame in it… He knows what the statistics are… I don’t know how he describes it to himself.”
    (38:31, Jarecki on Marshall)

8. Modern-Day Convict Leasing and Forced Labor

• Economic Incentives to Incarcerate and Deny Parole

  • Alabama profits from an estimated $450 million a year in unpaid inmate labor—prisoners work in state buildings, for private corporations, and even at fast food restaurants (42:00–45:31).

  • Those deemed “safe enough” to work outside are paradoxically the least likely to be paroled.

    Quote:

    "If you're considered safe enough to go out into the community to work at McDonald's... you have a statistically lower chance of being paroled..."
    (45:05–45:07, Jarecki and Gladwell)

9. Storytelling Ethics: Backstories, Labels, and Empathy

• Withholding Crime Details: A Moral Strategy

  • Jarecki deliberately omits or downplays the details of inmate crimes to challenge the audience’s instinct to “qualify” compassion (47:29–54:38).

  • Test screenings revealed a desire for moral permission—viewers wanted to know the charges to “justify” caring about inmates, an urge Jarecki resists.

    Quote:

    “This idea that anything goes if somebody's a criminal, we're just going to suspend our humanity… That's the basic idea of the Constitution: you’re not supposed to be treated to cruel and unusual punishment.”
    (51:04–54:38, Jarecki)

10. The Documentary Process and Prisoners as Partners

• Artistic Collaboration and Ongoing Obligations

  • Jarecki describes his seven-year “dark night of the soul” (63:04-63:57), the iterative process of building the story, and the immense responsibility to his incarcerated collaborators.

  • The documentary’s power emerges from this collaborative relationship: “They're your collaborators on this. And the result is something quite unlike any other” (64:15, Gladwell).

  • The film, in Jarecki’s view, succeeds because it’s built on the agency and insight of the prisoners themselves (64:58–68:09).

    Quote:

    “The men knew what they needed… The men in the film have seen the film… you’re in a relationship with them forever.”
    (64:58–68:09, Jarecki)

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• Chilling Memoir of a Prison Visit:

  “If you come back, I'll take you on the death row at Holman Prison, and you'll see it's a slave ship.”
  (07:33, Jarecki recounting)

• On Filmmaking Innovation:

  “It was like talking to Mandela on Robben Island on a cell phone.”
  (12:26, Jarecki)

• On the Power and Irony of Contraband:

  “The contraband cell phones that are in the prison are all sold to the inmates in the prison by the guards.”
  (24:01, Jarecki)

• Visuals That Haunt:

  “He shows you his toilet, and you see rats swimming in his toilet. And he says, I caught 11 of these last night.”
  (26:03, Gladwell recounting documentary moment)

• On Alabama's Culture:

  “Alabama’s motto is ‘we dare defend our rights’… If you want to come and have an opinion, you can go fuck yourself."
  (33:52, Jarecki)

• On Moral Judgment and Story Construction:

  “What are we using that information for?… the value of that incremental information about these characters reduces the quality of our moral judgment.”
  (54:38, Gladwell discussing the decision not to focus on crimes)

• On Ongoing Relationship and Responsibility:

  “You’re in a relationship with them forever… I feel very lucky that they’re in my life…”
  (68:09, Jarecki)

---

Important Timestamps

| Time | Topic / Quote | |-----------|---------------------------------------------------------------------| | 02:35 | Gladwell introduces the Alabama Murders series and the HBO doc | | 05:25 | Jarecki recounts how he became involved in the prison story | | 07:20 | “Isn't it crazy…journalist can go to a war zone…not a prison…” | | 11:10 | Use of contraband cell phones for documentary footage | | 13:27 | Glimpse into the documentary’s real-time, unfiltered impact | | 24:01 | Guards providing the very phones used to document their abuses | | 26:03 | Rats in cells and daily indignities described | | 28:52 | Steve Marshall’s denial of systemic problems | | 33:52 | Jarecki describes Alabama’s unique defiant culture | | 38:00–40:09 | Delving into AG Steve Marshall’s mindset and tactics | | 42:00–45:31 | Incarceration for profit and forced prison labor | | 47:29–54:38 | Ethics of withholding details about crimes in storytelling | | 64:58–68:09 | The prisoners’ agency and ongoing partnership |

---

Conclusion

This episode offers an unblinking look at the hidden machinery of the Alabama prison system—its cruelty, secrecy, and economic exploitation—and the innovative, sometimes harrowing paths required to tell that story responsibly. Gladwell and Jarecki challenge listeners to confront not just Alabama’s failures, but the broader American penchant for moral blindness in the face of institutionalized suffering. Through their discussion of narrative choices, documentary ethics, and the real-life stakes for their collaborators, they ask: what does it take, as storytellers and citizens, to bear honest witness—and will we look away?

---

Transcript

[Malcolm Gladwell]

Imagine never buying gas again. EVs electric vehicles are as easy to charge as your phone and perfect for everyday life Drive daily with confidence Everywhere you go Most Americans drive 40 miles a day. Most EVs are equipped with 200 to 400 miles of range. They've got fewer parts, fewer repairs, and fewer headaches. With hundreds of new and used EV models available today, there's an EV to fit every lifestyle and and every budget. Ghost the gas station and save up to $2,000 a year not buying gas. EVs are perfect for real life, with a daily range that allows you to drive with confidence wherever you want to go. And charging is easy. Plug in overnight at home, just like your phone, or use a fast charger and get back on the road in as little as 20 minutes. Learn [e-mail] Support for the show comes

[Public Ad Narrator]

from Public if you look at your investing app, what do you see? An Interface stuck in 1997 or something that looks modern but feels more like a casino than a place to build wealth. Public is different. It's the investing platform for those who take it seriously. On public, you can build your portfolio for the long haul. Stocks, options, bonds, crypto. It's all there. But what really makes Public different is the technology behind it. Imagine starting your day with an AI summarized market briefing, getting clear summaries of earnings calls the moment they end, or turning any idea into an investable index just by typing a prompt. This is what investing looks like when the tools finally catch up. Go to public.com and earn a 1% uncapped match when you transfer your portfolio. Public Investing for those who take it seriously AD paid for by Public Holdings Brokerage Services by Public Investing Member FINRA SIPC Advisory Services by Public Advisors SEC Registered Advisor Crypto Services by ZeroHash all investing involves risk of loss. See complete [e-mail] if your finance team

[Malcolm Gladwell]

spends more time finding data than using it. If there's one entity here and one there and one here and one there. If scaling your business feels like starting over, you need the Intuit ERP. Intuit Enterprise Suite is the AI native ERP solution that's powerful, painless, and proven. Learn more at intuit.comerp.

foreign.

Hello, hello revisionist history listeners. As many of you will know, we did a seven part series last fall called the Alabama Murders. The story of the death of a preacher's wife in the shoals in northwestern Alabama 35 years ago and the tragic reverberations of that case. I honestly think it's one of the best things we've ever done on revisionist history. And almost the exact time that our series dropped, HBO aired a brilliant documentary called the Alabama Solution. The revisionist history series was about the death penalty in Alabama. The Alabama Solution was about the prison system in Alabama.

[Andrew Jarecki]

We had record numbers of people leaving out of here in body bags. They don't want the public to see

[Public Ad Narrator]

what's really going on on the inside.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

How can a journalist go into a war zone but can't go into a prison in the United States of America? The state is selling one lawsuit after another. There's no consequences for their actions. There's an argument that there is some systemic problem within all of our facilities, and I wholeheartedly disagree with that.

The two projects fit together almost perfectly. So I called up the director of the documentary, Andrew Jarecki, and said, do you want to sit down for a conversation? And he said, yes. And so we got together at On Airfest in Brooklyn for a long talk about Alabama and filmmaking and all kinds of other things. If the name Andrew Jarecki seems familiar to you, it's because he's one of the preeminent documentarians of our time. He did capturing the Freedmans, the Jinks. A brilliant, brilliant guy. Here's our conversation.

Andrew, welcome to Brooklyn.

[Andrew Jarecki]

Thank you.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

Thank you for doing this. The reason you and I are on stage is that back in the fall, we released a seven part series on revisionist history called the Alabama Murders. And almost at exactly the same time, you released a documentary on HBO called the Alabama Solution. Our series was about a capital punishment case. Your series was about the Alabama prison system. And it was this marvelous instance of two works that overlapped but didn't overlap. And I texted you and said we should have a conversation and here we are. And I found your documentary extraordinary. And I was just telling you backstage, I'm not someone who listens, watches a lot of documentaries, but I have seen all of yours. Caption of Friedman's Jinx. This is the best in my mind.

[Andrew Jarecki]

Thank you.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

And I was curious, I would like you to start tell us how you came to do a story about the Alabama prison system, because I suspect it's not a straight line. You didn't sit down one day and say, I want to do a story about the Alabama prison system.

[Andrew Jarecki]

Yeah, I think nothing's a straight line, certainly for me. And I was noticing also your podcast around that same time. And then, and I was sort of, I was kind of holding back because I thought, is this going to influence what we're working on, you know, just because it's hard, like, when you're making one thing and then somebody else does something else, and especially if it's a smart person, you're like, what if they do this better? What do they have an idea? And then I'm drawn to that idea or something like that. But I did get to listen to it, and it's really superb and. And extremely familiar to me. So I. You know, when I was making Capturing the Friedmans, I had reason to go into Dannemora Correctional Facility in upstate New York. And I found that the visit was so punishing. Just as a visitor, everything about it was so difficult and brutal. And then when I saw the waiting room and I saw how people were being treated there, I just thought, I think I need to get deeper into this prison. And I wasn't able to do that. But then over the years, I just visited a lot of prisons, and I was really amazed at how poorly we do this. But I never really understood the Alabama system because it's so secretive. I mean, I would say all prisons in the US Are sort of treated like black sites. And you drive down the highway and you see a little metal sign that says XYZ Correctional Facility in upstate New York or someplace, and you think, well, I probably don't need to drive down there. If anything really bad's happening, you know, somebody will tell me about it. But that presupposes that you will be able to read it in a paper. You will be able to see a television show that explains it. And that's not the case, because the press is really not allowed to visit prisons.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

There's a great line from one of your. One of your characters in your documentary, one of the prisoners who says, isn't it crazy that if you're a journalist, you can go to a war zone, but you can't go to a prison in your own country.

[Andrew Jarecki]

Yeah, yeah, yeah, you can. You can visit a war zone, and you can't go to a prison in the United States of America. And so I was always curious and then didn't think I would ever get a chance to do it. And then, oddly, my daughter, who was like, 14, she went to Dalton, and at Dalton, they had a really good speaker program, and they had brought in a guy named Anthony Ray Hinton, who had been wrongfully convicted in Alabama and had been in this prison system for, like, 30 years. And she said, you know, I think you should read this book with me, because I think, you know, you're interested in this Stuff. And then we read the book together, and we just sort of spontaneously decided to take a road trip to Montgomery. We went to Montgomery. We didn't know anybod. We almost accidentally met a man who was almost 80 years old, who was the first black prison chaplain in the state of Alabama appointed by George Wallace. I think he was, like George Wallace's one black friend because he had to have one. And so I asked him to have dinner with us. So we sat and had dinner, and I started asking him questions. And he was kind of reluctant to tell me too much, but I could also tell he had a lot of pain because he goes into these prisons all the time. So he knows what's happening in the prisons, but he's afraid that if he tells me too much, then I'm gonna get too nosy, and then maybe he's gonna get kicked out of the prisons because we start. But I could tell he didn't wanna let me leave either. And so we had this little standoff for a while where I was asking questions, and he said, well, why don't you just, you know, come back and you can see for yourself? And I said, well, I'm a filmmaker. They're not going to let me into the Alabama prison system. And he said, well, just come in without a camera. Just come in and volunteer, and we'll give out hygiene packages and food. And. And. And so I said, all right, maybe I'm going to do that. Well, if I do come back, what will I see? And I could tell that he was sort of thinking about whether he wanted to say this thing that he was going to say to me, because he knew if he said the right thing, I would come back. And if he didn't, maybe I wouldn't. And he said, if you come back, I'll take you on the death row at Holman Prison, and you'll see it's a slave ship. And that was a very important kind of moment for me. That was seven years ago. And I think it's the reason that line was the reason I went back, because I just thought, well, whatever this is, I have to see. And then I went back. And you'll see in the film, we sort of get access until we don't. But in the course of going into Easterling Prison, we start hearing from these men who are saying, look, this visit you're making here, I'm not supposed to be talking to you, but this is a curated visit, right? They're showing you just what they want you to see. But see that building over there, that's where they do solitary confinement. They're men that have been in there for five years or seven years at a time, seeing nobody. And see that building over there is the Y dorm. That's the behavior modification dorm. And. And somebody was just killed there by a guard. And we just started to understand how bad it was. And then last thing that happened is, you know, we get kicked out. And then we thought we didn't know how we were gonna tell the story until we discovered that there was this network of people inside who had contraband cell phones and had access to a charger or were borrowing a charger from a friend and would have to put the cell phones up when the guards came. But it was our only window into this very secretive system.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

Had anyone. I want to pause on that for a moment because one of the many remarkable. The most remarkable thing about the documentary from a technical standpoint is that it is largely shot in FaceTime, right. Or in video calls.

[Andrew Jarecki]

Various things. Yeah.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

I don't know what percentage of the movie ends up being 30. 30% of the movie is just the prisoners FaceTiming with you. And you had this. Has this been done before?

[Andrew Jarecki]

I mean, I don't know of it having been done before because it was such an unusual situation, not only because the men had access to cell phones, but because they had collected all this material over years that showed what was really happening in the system and showed episodes of, you know, really shocking episodes. I mean, when I saw it, I thought, you know, this is. It's like watching Tidicut Follies. You're looking at a whole segment of the population that's just been abandoned. And not just abandoned, but also harmed. And then we discovered that there were these men inside who were leaders who were really civil rights leaders who had been managing, like, a nonviolent protest movement for years even before we got there. And so we had the benefit of, you know, it was like talking to Mandela on Robben island on a cell phone.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

So I want to pause on this because I think it's a really important point. And I was naive enough about documentaries that it hadn't occurred to me before. But with the. The notion that you were. The narrative engine of this documentary is the videos being recorded by the prisoners themselves in real time and being sent to you. And with that, you overcome what has always been the biggest problem with documentaries, Right. Which is you're telling a story after the fact. And any. Almost always in documentaries, any video that you're capturing, unless you get some archival, you're having. You're talking to people as they reconstruct something that happened far away and long ago.

This.

All of that artificiality is gone from Alabama Solution. You're right there in the prison with these guys.

[Andrew Jarecki]

Yeah, I mean, it was an enormously eye opening and I would say violent experience to be drawn into that and to understand that the only way that these people can get away with treating human beings this way is if it's in darkness. You can't do this if the public knows that you're doing it. Even a jaded public in Alabama who, you know, as you know very well, Alabama's sort of inured to certain kinds of indignities. And, you know, they're very propagandized group. You know, it's sort of very tough on crime. And the politicians really like weaponize the crime victims. To just have this constant narrative. It's like watching Cops 24 hours a day. It's just an advertisement for poor people are crazy and dangerous. And so being able to eliminate that layer, that propaganda layer, there's a great line. I mean, one of the leaders in the film, Robert Earl Council, who goes by Kinetic justice, says, I'm in prison. I'm supposed to lie, I'm supposed to exaggerate. I'm supposed to make up excuses. So that narrative's so strong that unless we can tell the story directly to people, they're just going to assume that it's not true. And, you know, and I felt like going into the prisons there I was far more, you know, they would say, oh, well, don't talk to the men because they're very dangerous and they're going to tell you lies and so on. And I felt so much more comfortable talking to the men who were incarcerated than the guards.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

Well, how long did it take for you to realize that the movie was going to be constructed out of these, the FaceTime videos the prisoners were sharing with you?

[Andrew Jarecki]

Well, you know, my biggest anxiety was that we were not going to be able to get enough material talking to the men. Obviously, this archival material where you can see really telling things that happen, there was an embarrassment of traumatic events. I mean, it was just a. That was like terabytes worth of that material. But being able to talk directly to the men was. Once you do it, once you're talking to them for five minutes, you think, this is the only thing I want to watch? I don't want to hear anybody. I don't want to hear experts. You know, we had this. Zach Stuart Pontier was my partner in Making the Jinx, who's sitting here right there. Um, he and I talked a lot about experts when we were making the Jinx. You know, we had access to the people that were in Bob Durst's life, and we had access to people that were present during crimes and helpful in crimes and so on. And so it just was. Every time we'd interview, somebody would say, well, let me tell you how this works, or something. It just wasn't very effective. And in this case, it was. It would have been absurd. You know, there was. We wanted to talk to some of the system actors, so we ended up getting access to, like, the Attorney General, who's an incredible cinematic villain.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

It is. I want to. I want to talk to him in more detail. I want to come back to him. Just pause on that because. Anyway, keep going.

[Andrew Jarecki]

And by the way, I particularly enjoyed, and my mind was a little bit blown by hearing Steve Marshall, the Attorney General, in your podcast, you know, speaking as the convincingly. Right. As the authority who's explaining how he's there for crime victims and they've waited 35 years for justice and all that stuff. And this is a guy who's presiding over death camps in an American state, but he was something. He was somebody that had to be there.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

So to pause for a moment. The movie is about. It's in general, an investigation of the extraordinary brutality inside the Alabama prison system, and in particular about the murder of a young man at the hands of a guard, of a sadistic guard. And then the COVID up that ensues that you're able to uncover by virtue of these calls with the prisoners inside the same institution. So it's simultaneously a kind of Upton Sinclair like, expose of a institution, and also a murder mystery. And the murder mystery, which I don't know whether we should give away one of the key kind of moments in the movie, but you get. It takes a surprising and horrifying twist. As you're in the middle of it, you think you're investigating one murderer, and then you end up investigating two. And how far into the film was the twist?

[Andrew Jarecki]

Well, we didn't know what we were making. We never know what we're making. Right. And sometimes today, I think in documentary world, some streamer or something will send you an email saying, you need to make this film. And I almost never open them, but when I do open them, there's always a deck. And the deck literally will say to you, here are the main characters, and we've already made agreements with them. And this is what they're gonna say, and then here's what your plot line is going to be. And I just think, like, now that should be an AI film. Like, you already know what it is, and you should just AI that thing. And some people watch it. But the whole idea is the journey, right? The whole idea is that we don't know what's going to happen. When I was making Capturing the Friedmans, I thought I was making a film about professional children's birthday party entertainers in New York City. And then it turned out to be something that was radically different from that because you discover something along the way. When we were making the Jinx, we knew that Bob Durst wanted to talk. And that was interesting enough for me and Zach, what we found, the fact that he wanted to talk enough that it would lead us down enough paths that we would discover evidence and he would get arrested for murder the day before. The last episode was totally unpredictable. And that's why you do it, right? I mean, it's. So in this case, we had just gotten a text message from one of the men inside. And I guess the only precursor of that was that we had been looking at all of the pro se lawsuits filed by prisoners. You know, lawsuits that are filed without the benefit of a lawyer. But these guys are kind of incredible lawyers. Some of them are really extraordinary sort of jailhouse lawyers, but very, very sophisticated. And we had been looking at all these lawsuits because we wanted to see who are the guards that are coming up repeatedly in these lawsuits. And we had found this one guard named Rod Gadson, Roderick Gadson. And he was named In, I think, 24 different brutality suits. And you have to understand, like, bringing one of these lawsuits in prison is. It's the most optimistic and kind of absurdist thing because there's no money in it. They never get an award. There are conversations that happen like, okay, well, this guy got his finger intentionally cut off in a cell door by a guard. But how much is a finger really worth? You know, maybe it's $5,000. It's very hard to get a lawyer to cover that. We have lawyers that would say to us along the way, like, find me at, you know, a murder. That might be worth it. That might be worth my getting into it. So in this particular case, Rod Gadsden's name had kept coming up. And then one day, Melvin Ray texts Charlotte, my co director, and says, hey, we understand somebody got beaten very badly at Donaldson Prison. And he's currently at UAB Hospital. So he was moved off the campus to the hospital. So Charlotte and I just got in a car and in Birmingham, and we just drove over to the hospital. We walked in, and I, like, took my iPhone I stuck in my pocket and, you know, moved it around a little bit. And they said, oh, you got to go up to the fourth floor. And we went up there, and by the time we got there, we found that this young man, Stephen Davis, had died. So he had been. He had. And we didn't know how that had happened other than that he had been beaten. And then we went to find his mother. Because often the prison doesn't tell the family members if somebody's been killed in prison, especially if it's done by a guard. If the guard is responsible, they immediately scramble all the witnesses, and they will say, well, let's not tell his mother for two weeks. We'll move these guys around, and we'll give this guy an incentive to go to a different facility, and we'll help this other guy because they just don't want the evidence. And in that case, we went to Sandy Ray's house. She had just been with her son hours before that and had taken him off life support. And she said, you guys are making a film? And we said, yeah. She said, well, I want to help you do it. I don't want this to happen to any other mother. And so right now, they're lying to me. I know the prison's calling me right now, and they're lying to me about what happened. So show me how to record my phone calls. So we got on her phone, and we showed her how to record a phone call. And then she said, by the way, there are no motels here because Uniontown only has 400 people in it. So, you know, I have this spare room. So Charlotte just, like, got her duffel bag and just moved in for a couple weeks into Sandy's house, which is why.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

Yeah, waiting for the call to come.

[Andrew Jarecki]

Not just that call, but just watching how Sandy was discovering what had really happened to her son and eventually getting, you know, a call from somebody inside the prison who was a whistleblower who doesn't even want to identify himself, but says, you know, this is not. This was not a way to describe it.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

While watching, my first kind of, like, technical question was, you had. You're there in the room on camera with the mom when she gets the call from the state or the Department of Corrections. I was like, how on earth were they there in the room? Like, I didn't understand technically. Now I know how it happened. They were victims of their Own because they built a delay in order to build a cover up. And in so doing, they destroyed their cover up, weirdly.

[Andrew Jarecki]

Well, yeah. And by the way, in terms of being shot with your own gun, the contraband cell phones that are in the prison are all sold to the inmates in the prison by the guards. Right. As a matter of fact, when I started to discover how many. Just how much drugs were coming into the prison or this enormous cache of cell phones that were coming to the prison, I was talking to one of the prisoners and I said to him, you know, where's all this coming from? And he looked at me like I was an idiot. And he said, you know, we don't leave, right? So clearly, the people that come and go every day are the ones that are going out and getting drugs and going out and buying cell phones and bring them in. So it's kind of incredibly ironic that the tool that the men are using to identify the crimes that are being committed by the ostensible law enforcement officers are sold to them by aforementioned law enforcement officers.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

I had a lot of difficulty, even after I had spent months and months and months doing my Alabama project. I was just aghast. I don't know why was I. I was just. Something about seeing it. Cause I only heard my whole thing was just listening to people tell me stories, right? I didn't see anything. What would be the point? I'm doing a podcast. There's a scene in the doc when I don't know why this scene has stayed with me, but I've forgotten. One of your characters gets sent to solitary, and he's on the phone and he shows you these jars he has that are full. He's telling me why he hangs his food up in a bag high off the ground on his prison cell. And then he gets in trouble for it every day. But he says, well, the reason I do that is because of these guys. And he shows you jars that have little live rats inside of it. And then he shows you his toilet, and you see rats swimming in his toilet. And he says, I caught 11 of these last night.

[Andrew Jarecki]

11 caught in one night.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

11 caught in one night to keep

[Andrew Jarecki]

my food in a laundry bag, hang it from the bars. Then they write me disciplinaries for hanging things from the bars, but if I put it on the floor, they'll get it. Rats. 11 call in one night.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

And that was a point where it was like. I was like, jesus,

[Andrew Jarecki]

I don't know why.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

That's not the worst, by the way. Not even close to being the worst thing that happens, but something about the visual of realizing there are people who will happily tolerate conditions like that inside a prison, like the administration is fine with that. Somehow. That somehow got me.

[Andrew Jarecki]

Well, first of all, I can tell from your description that everyone's going to run out and immediately go to HBO and watch this film so that they can see. But it is extraordinary that the. And I have to say, just. I think one of the things that. In your podcast that was so telling to me, and I really think it brings these stories together, is your postulate of the moral failure cascade.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

Yeah.

[Andrew Jarecki]

You know, that. That you have a series of small or larger or growing problems and events that happen, and then one thing leads to another and it gets worse and worse and worse. And I think, you know, people get used to it. You know, they get to the point where they say, well, I don't know. I mean, how many people are really, you know, I mean, we. Some people are going to die, right? Well, I don't know. What if we have the deadliest prison system in America? At some point, are we going to look at that and say, like, maybe we're doing something wrong? But here you have Steve Marshall, like the one person that we share in this, the podcast, and also in the film, who says, you know, I've been told that there's some kind of systemic problem in all of our facilities. Right. We've just been watching an hour of the most punishing material you can't imagine. Prison after prison after prison. Donaldson Prison, Kilby Prison, Bibb Prison. Each one of these places, Holman, where they have 240 people on the death row. And your guy was right before he's executed. The. You've been watching that for an hour. And then here's Steve Marshall, the chief law enforcement officer of the state of Alabama, and he says, I've been told that there's some systemic problem in all of our facilities. And I wholeheartedly disagree with that.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

Yeah.

[Andrew Jarecki]

And it's not just willful blindness. I mean, it's just intentional cruelty. It's a willingness to preside over a system of death camps. They are death camps. We have to say. That's what they are. Since we started working the film, which was seven years ago, 1500 people have died in that little prison system. They have 20,000 people in the prison system. They have another 25,000 in the jails in Alabama where people die regularly. And somehow people are dying of highest level of drug overdose of any prison system in the country. Not that there are not lots of other horrific ones, highest numbers of suicide, highest level of sexual assault, and just the brutality of the situation. You can't run that without knowing it. You can't say, well, I wasn't aware of it because there were enough layers between me and the people that were actually in the trenches doing the business of killing people.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

After the break, more from my conversation with Andrew Jarecki. Imagine never buying gas again. EVs electric vehicles are as easy to charge as your phone and perfect for everyday life Drive daily with confidence everywhere you go. Most Americans drive 40 miles a day. Most EVs are equipped with 200 to 400 miles of range. They've got fewer parts, fewer repairs and fewer headaches. With hundreds of new and used EV models available today, there's an EV to fit every lifestyle and every budget. Ghost the gas station and save up to $2,000 a year not buying gas. EVs are perfect for real life, with a daily range that allows you to drive with confidence wherever you want to go. And charging is easy. Plug in overnight at home, just like your phone, or use a fast charger and get back on the road in as little as 20 minutes. Learn [e-mail] Support for the show comes

[Public Ad Narrator]

from public if you look at your investing app, what do you see? An Interface stuck in 1997 or something that looks modern but feels more like a casino than a place to build wealth? Public is different. It's the investment platform for those who take it seriously. On public, you can build your portfolio

[Andrew Jarecki]

for the long haul.

[Public Ad Narrator]

Stocks, options, bonds, crypto. It's all there. But what really makes public different is the technology behind it. Imagine starting your day with an AI summarized market briefing, getting clear summaries of earnings calls the moment they end, or turning any idea into an investable index just by typing a prompt. This is what investing looks like when the tools finally catch up. Go to public.com and earn a 1% uncapped match when you transfer your portfolio. Public Investing for those who take it seriously Ad paid for by Public Holdings Brokerage Services by Public Investing member FINRA SIPC Advisory Services By Public Advisors SEC Registered Advisor Crypto Services By ZeroHash all investing involves risk of loss. See complete [e-mail] disclosures lately, car buying

[Malcolm Gladwell]

has become a pretty dull experience. But on ebay, behind every car, in part, is a story waiting to be shared. Like this guy I read who bought a 2020 Porsche Cayman GT4 on eBay. It was well loved. I mean, there are plenty of Caymans in great condition on eBay. But this one needed some work. That's just the start of the story. So after this guy gets a great deal on his dream car, he rebuilds the whole thing with all these parts he found on ebay. Performance brakes, suspension, body panels, the works, guaranteed to fit. Next thing you know, this nearly scrapped Cayman was out there on the track as a full blown race car. You're ready to go. Daily driver. Your next restomod. Hello, Lotus Salon. And the parts to finish it. Ebay has thousands of cars and is the largest online selection of vehicle parts and accessories. EBay, things people love.

Let's talk a little bit about Alabama because I'm curious about what was your level of understanding, knowledge, familiarity with Alabama before you did this project?

[Andrew Jarecki]

It was probably the state I knew the least about in the Union. It's just not something. If you grew up in New York City and you study history, you're not spending a ton of time on Alabama. I knew a little bit, you know, like, they're. I don't know, like the state motto of, you know, a typical American state will be like the Sunshine State or the show me State. You know, Alabama's motto is we dare defend our rights.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

Yeah.

[Andrew Jarecki]

You know, which is really, like, if you want to come and have an opinion, you can go fuck yourself. We're not interested in your opinion. We're just going to do our thing. And certainly we don't want you telling us how to deal with our Negroes or our population of prisoners or our crime or any of it. It's just there's a wall.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

I'm not sure whether that's more or less egregious than New Jersey calling itself the Garden State. But where are these gardens in New Jersey? I get to see anything along the turnpike. But it's a hard. You know, I've done. I was. I think that I have done more podcast episodes of Origin's history that are situated in Alabama than in any other state. I'm drawn to this place and for the same reason. I feel like it's not the United States. It's something, isn't. It's. It is within the United States, but not of the United States. Or maybe I'm being too kind to the United States. It is clearly in some ways a foreign country.

[Andrew Jarecki]

It's kind of amazing. You're saying that because the chaplain who I visited and met and encouraged me to come back, Chaplain Browder, after I was in it for six months or the first year or two, and I stayed in touch with him constantly, he's quite a bit older now. He's seven years older than when I first met him. But he's still very thoughtful guy. And he said, I'm telling you, Andrew, Alabama ain't in these United States.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

Yeah.

[Andrew Jarecki]

But, you know, then you ask yourself whether that's even right. You know, the reality is that, you know, upstate New York. Robert Brooks just got killed in upstate New York by corrections officers who beat him to death. And the only reason we don't think it was natural causes or a drug overdose is because they were, I don't even wanna say dumb enough. They were entitled enough to just leave their body cameras on. Cause they just assumed that nobody was ever really gonna try to figure out what happened to poor Robert Brooks, who was handcuffed when they beat him to death. So it's happening in New York. You know, if you were in a. If you had put your dog in upstate New York in a kennel because you were going on holiday and you saw this, you would say, I'm calling the aspca. This is a total disaster. Nobody can put their dog in this. So it's not a whole lot better in a lot of these places.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

Two things can be true simultaneously. One is that in general, the prison conditions in the United States are appalling compared to our peers around the world. But there is something particular and unusual about Alabama that elevates Alabama even above its miserable peers. And I'm wondering whether we can sort of, since we've both been immersed in this, we can put our finger on what it is. And I'm wondering. I'm thinking about Steve Marshall, which is if you. I don't know. I'm making this up. But if you sat down with the Attorney General of New York State, they would have the good grace to be embarrassed about what was happening in the prisons. Steve Marshall and I want you to talk a little bit about your interview with Steve Marshall. Steve Marshall, when confronted with these questions, wasn't even remotely embarrassed. In fact, he had the gall when he had to give that one quote from him about when you ask him about Christian grace, he says, I believe in Christian grace, but that doesn't mean somebody should get out of prison. I mean, look, I think anybody can have a change of heart. I'll say that. I think God can invade somebody. I believe in the concept of grace. But grace itself doesn't mean release from prison. Grace means that you're relieved from the burden of your sin. It's not even that he's defiant. It's that he thinks he's on the side of God right now. That is different. Can you, what are your thoughts on the peculiarity of Alabama and can you talk about. Let's talk about Steve Marshall because you spent time with him.

[Andrew Jarecki]

Yeah.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

How long was that interview?

[Andrew Jarecki]

I think that interview was shorter than most. Maybe it was too two hours.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

By the way, this is why I love documentarians. Your idea of shorter than most is two hours? Yeah, my idea of shorter than most is 10 minutes.

[Andrew Jarecki]

We do some sevens and some nines, you know, Jesus. Yeah, yeah. They're kicking out. Usually the wife is like standing in the corner and being like looking at the watch.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

But Steve Marshall gave you two hours?

[Andrew Jarecki]

Yeah. I mean, you know, the great thing about somebody like this is that they say the quiet part out loud. There's no shame in it. And I don't really know how he manages it as a self proclaimed Christian. I don't know how he goes and kisses his kids and says daddy's upholding the law and so on. Because he knows what the statistics are. Right. Let's say he just doesn't. He forces himself or he prevents himself from having access to the prisons. You can always put some kind of apparatchik in between you and the prisons. And then you say, I don't know, I saw the reports and it doesn't look like it's all that bad. So I don't know how he describes it to himself. And I think politicians are kind of will o' the wisp. And he used to be a Democrat and then now he's a Republican. And then he was recently so Republican that he was one of the guys who, one of the local state officials who came to New York and put on the red tie and the Trump outfit and went down to lower Manhattan and start talking about how Trump was being railroaded by the justice system and so on. So he's always auditioning. And by the way, right now Steve Marshall is trying to run for Senate. He's trying to run for Tommy Tuberville's seat in the Senate. So the football coach Tommy Tuberville became a U.S. senator from Alabama. He's the one that did not know that there were three branches of government. Right. He did not have a lot of training.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

He just thought it was offense and defense.

[Andrew Jarecki]

Exactly. What would you do with this third branch especially? That's what's happening in the federal government too. They're getting rid of some of the branches. I hear we have too many branches that we're going to doge those branches right out. But I Think he just imagines, first of all, I think he's very politically expeditious. You know, he wants to become a US Senator. He wants to be the guy that's the tough on crime guy. He, he, he, he's sort of made book with this organization called Vocal in Alabama, which is victims of crime and leniency, which is literally like a group of women who are crime, who you know, have had a crime happen in their family. And they go to every parole hearing and they don't know the people. They get a little card before they go there. We sort of embedded with them and maybe should make a film about them. And they go to a parole hearing where you have a guy who's been locked up for 25 years. He's an ordained minister, he's taken every conceivable class. He's like mentored 500 young men that have been in there. And this woman will get up and say, you know, I'm here to protest the parole of Kevin Johnson. And you know, he committed a crime in 1973. They have no idea what it is. They just know he committed a crime and he should not be paroled. And then they stand in front of the parole board and they say to the three members of the parole board, if you let this man out and he reoffends, it will be on your neck and everyone will know that you did that. And you know, that's one of the things that drove Alabama's parole rate to

[Malcolm Gladwell]

8% is that's the lowest in the country?

[Andrew Jarecki]

Yeah, it was at that time. It's improved a little bit. And I think it's improved in part because of the work in and around the film. Because among other things, it was a lawsuit that was sparked by the film, this class action lawsuit in which Kinetic Justice Robert Earle, counsel, is the lead plaintiff that really calls out Alabama for having a system of convict leasing. Because a lot of people don't realize a, that Alabama and many states like it benefit from, let's say just in the case of Alabama, $450 million a year in unpaid labor. And the men inside are forced to provide this labor. And by forced, you know, maybe there's not a man with a bullwhip that's standing over them, but it's in some ways, you know, every bit as bad because if you refuse to work, then you can be given a disciplinary which can extend your sentence. You can be placed in solitary, which happens a lot in Alabama. So basically the, you know, UN says solitary confinement for more than 15 days is torture. They're putting people in for years at a time. And you could be moved to an even more violent facility than the one that you're in. So it is a coerced forced labor. You can't be sick one day. You can't do any of that. But I think what people don't understand is the prisoners in Alabama and some other states, it's not that they're being forced to work in the prison. Maybe reasonable people could say, oh, maybe you should be sweeping the floor in the prison if you're working in the prison. But they also get leased out to the governor's mansion, where they clean the floors and they polish the tiles and they do the landscaping. They also get leased out to road crews, construction crews. State makes money from all of that. They issue invoices, which you can see in the film. You know, this is for X dollars an hour. And then they pay the men $2 a day to do sanitation work or something like. And then they send them out to work at McDonald's. They lease them to McDonald's, they lease them to Burger King, they lease them to the Hyundai parts company. They lease them to the Budweiser distributorship. So, you know, you go to the state fair in Alabama, we have this kind of amazing shot of a guy in a corrections uniform who's standing with a little girl, and he is reaching into the duck pond, and he takes a little duck out, a little baby duckling, and he hands it, and the mother's clapping and is taking photographs. And the chilling statistic behind that, Alabama does not track this, but we tracked it, is that if you're considered safe enough to go out into the community to work at McDonald's or to work at the state fair, you have a statistically lower chance of being paroled than if you're somebody at a higher custody level.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

Why? Because you're economically valuable to them.

[Andrew Jarecki]

Absolutely. Yeah. And they don't track that statistic. And I think Steve Marshall might be surprised if I said that. Or he would say, oh, that doesn't sound right. And then we would say, well, you know, that's a. There's a reason why you don't track that statistic. But it kind of makes sense, right? The people that are out there and people there are all these anecdotal stories of people saying, well, I was sick, and I woke up in the morning, and that guy came in and said, you need to go out there and make me some money.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

Yeah.

How? I want to talk a little bit about the difference in the way that. So you and I both, or your team and my team both began with a similar kind of question, which was, how can we shed light on the practices of this very strange state? And I was working in the podcast genre, you're working in the documentary genre. And both of us made very, very different choices. And I wanted you to reflect on one of the biggest differences, which is in our Alabama murders, we spend an enormous amount of time on the backstory of our characters, our protagonists. We really want you to know we're telling the story of these two guys on death row. We really wanted you to know about those guys. We talked to their. And who they were and what happened, you know, et cetera. In your movie documentary, we only learn we get that kind of backstory in passing. Right? There's a moment, for example, where you're talking about James Sayles, one of the principal characters in the documentary. And we learn why he. Why was he in one of the highest security prisons in Alabama? Because he got 15 years for breaking into a unoccupied building. It just. It happens in like 10 seconds. We learn this piece of information, and then you move on. Right now, it's incredibly powerful in that little form. But I'm curious, why do you do things that way? Why is it that the form that you've chosen encourages you or directs you away from kind of luxuriating in the backstory the way that we do in the podcast world?

[Andrew Jarecki]

I mean, if you look at capturing the Friedmans, there's just an enormous amount of archival material of that family, including going back 75 years to the family members that kind of came to this country. And then in the Jinx, we have lots of photographs, but we also have moving pictures of Robert Durst when he was a kid. And you get to see the awkwardness. You get to see the feeling that this is a person who didn't particularly fit in. And you see him in modern day, you see him twitching. Robert Durst has a lot of twitches. And then you see a little film of him getting up on the diving board as a kid or somebody doing a movie of him like his mother, and you see the same kind of twitches. You see the early phases of what his. So I think that stuff is extremely valuable in this film. I think that we had so many. You know, there was ten pounds of flour in a two pound bag. Always. It was always so hard to convey the tapestry of how we got here and try to incorporate everything from the slave labor to the parole to why they aren't letting people out of the system, how they put people in the system, how people are when they're in the system. And then also try to have a narrative thread that was going to bring people along. Because we used to have this expression just in the storytelling process. I always have a blackboard in my office. And I. And I, at the very beginning of this, when we started to see what we had, I wrote this, like, mnemonic device. I said, smitwit knows. And that stood for how do we not make the saddest movie in the world that no one ever sees? And it was a real concern because, you know, you're dealing with this very dark material. So we knew it had to have a very compelling narrative. It needed to have, you know, we needed to have a story. And that's like, you know, you gotta keep telling yourself what is the story. So you only have enough room for this archival material. Yeah, you do as much as you can. And also some of those people, you know, it's kind of a deprived economy. And a lot of these families of people who are incarcerated just, you know, they don't have like, extra room in their house where they have all the photo albums or they have 8 millimeter video or whatever.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

Yeah, I was thinking. And it's not a criticism at all. I'm marveling about how you made a compelling story where I cared about the protagonists even though I knew so little about them. That's the puzzle. So I came away. So your main character is Stephen Davis. White guy, seems like a very poor family. And we briefly learn what his mom tells us in one sentence. Why he's in prison. That's all we get. We don't know when his offense occurred. We don't know what his sentence was. We don't know what his personality was. We don't know anything about him. We barely see him because He's. He's dead 10 minutes in.

Right.

Whatever it is. And yet I. My concern over him and feelings for him sustained me through the entire movie. This is what it. This is what I'm. In a million years, I would never have thought I could tell a story like that, where my main character is someone the audience knows almost nothing about and who exits, and yet I still care an hour later. That's what I'm trying to get at. How did you do that?

[Andrew Jarecki]

Well, I mean, you know, as a young storyteller, I think you're going to evolve, you know, you're going to learn more about how to tell these stories. And I'm Looking forward to that. But I think a little goes a long way. We do see pictures of him as a child, and I think that's extremely powerful. You know, when you see somebody who you've been trained to believe is gonna be a hardened, terrible criminal, but we sort of know really what he was, was a drug addict. And now you see a picture of this young man with his hair shorn and his face pale and wearing a jumpsuit. That's exactly what everybody else in the prison wears. And he becomes totally homogenized and dehumanized. And then you get to see a photograph of him as a child, you know, with a smile and just seeing pride on his face or him starting to play Little League or something like that. And then you're just reminded that I have somebody in my family who was playing Little league and then 10 years later was a drug addict, you know, was playing Little League, and 10 years later was an alcoholic and his life was falling apart. So you make a connection to those people that goes beyond whatever their, you know, their. Their crime was. But it's. You're bringing up an interesting point that I've not talked about regarding this film, which was that there were people who came to test screenings of the film and literally said the following. I'm uncomfortable if I don't know what crime they committed. So could you have some kind of a device where as soon as I see somebody on screen, there's some kind of a chiron or a little designator on the bottom that says murder one, or that says burglary, or that says, you know, and I was so instructive to hear somebody say that, right? And of course, you could have the debate with them, or you could say, so you're saying that it's okay for prison guard to beat somebody to death. You're going to make the evaluation of whether that's reasonable or not based on whether they had a burglary charge or an aggravated burglary charge. And then they always say, well, no, no, no, of course, of course, of course, of course. But they're revealing that they're propagandized. They're revealing that, like, nobody. Everybody wants safety. Everybody wants their family to be safe. Everybody doesn't. You know, people don't want people to rob their store or whatever. But this idea that anything goes if somebody's a criminal, we're just going to suspend our humanity. We're going to suspend. Right. And that's the basic idea of sort of the Constitution is you have this absolutely minimal level. You're not supposed to be treated to cruel and unusual punishment, which is already kind of a, you know, I know it when I see it kind of situation, you know, but, well, if they committed a crime, then maybe they should just be locked up forever. You know, does it make sense for. You know, there are plenty of countries where the maximum sentence for any crime is 10 years. Because you say somebody commits a crime when they're 19 years old to completely different human being 11 years, 12 years later, you know, maybe, maybe 10 years is enough to reset that person and try to bring them back into civilization. And yet Alabama has these three strikes laws that are locking people up for life without parole.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

But this is a really interesting point which I think is worth dwelling on a little bit, which is that as storytellers, so the urge when the people in the screening said, I want to know what crime they committed, that was my urgent when I watched it. Just, it's a natural human urge to want to know as much as possible about the person whose world and what we don't think about is what are we using that information for? And how will that kind of information at the margin affect the quality of our moral judgments? And what you're saying is the value of that incremental information about these characters reduces the quality of our moral judgment. It actually contributes to precisely the phenomenon you are trying to confront, which is people, regardless of who they are, deserve a certain level of respect and decency in the way we treat them. Right. In other words, there is an obligation here on the part of the titration. And the limitation of information given by the storyteller is a hugely consequential question. It's not just a storytelling question, it's a moral question. It's what do you want people to take home from this story? Right. In a profound way. And like, so you shouldn't. Now I agree with you. I had that impulse and then I thought about it and I was like, no, I don't need to know. It is not relevant what Stephen Davis was in for. It's like it shouldn't matter or it shouldn't matter with Robert.

[Andrew Jarecki]

Robert Earl.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

Robert Earl. Who is the one who had the rats swimming in the toilet? Robert Earl.

[Andrew Jarecki]

Robert Earl. Yeah. But Robert Earl's crime. I mean, Robert Earl's crime. Yeah. There's a guy, and it's sort of undisputed that there was a guy trying to run him over with a car.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

That's right.

[Andrew Jarecki]

And he was 19 and he had a gun, which everybody in Alabama has a gun. And he Shot the guy and he prevented him from running him over. In today's world, you know, that's like stand your ground. Yeah, right. So there's no question that would have been a self defense case, but for the fact that the police went to incredible lengths to try to tie him into an earlier altercation that night because that nobody died in. But they were sort of trying to say, well, he was involved in a robbery, which he actually wasn't involved in because that enables you to give him a life sentence because you can say it's capital murder. So I guess our, you know, kind of theory going in was maybe we don't need to talk about the crimes at all. And then we realized that there are certain crimes. Right. And the, and, and Steve Marshall of the world will want you to assume that everybody's in there for this. Right. They say, oh, everybody. We've already let out all the non violent criminals. That sounds like totally reasonable. Well, yeah, I guess people that are non violent should be let out. Right. But in Alabama, I think in the rest of the country maybe we have like, maybe in the federal system we have like four crimes that are considered violent. And in Alabama it used to be, you know, 10 and then it was 20 and then it was 30 and now it's 44 crimes. And they include entering an unoccupied building. That's considered a violent crime. So by redefining what a violent crime is, you get more and more and more people and then you get to stand in front of a crowd and say, we've let out all the, you know, good ones, but Robert Earle. I guess we concluded that we had to tell something about some of the crimes because we didn't. We felt like if the audience was going to really have to fall in love with Robert Earle, which is not hard to do because man's a genius and he's an unbelievable human being, then we would have to let people know that he's not Jeffrey Dahmer, you know, that he's not somebody who's like a serial killer or a child killer. And the percentage of people that are in prison who are serial killers or child killers, minuscule. But if you're going to give the audience the desire to fall in love with somebody, they're going to hold back their empathy. Unless you can just give them a little bit of a pass, a little bit of a feeling like this is not one of those people that's just going to be released and then immediately go and murder somebody or push somebody in front of a bus.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

We'll be right back. Imagine never buying gas again. EVs electric vehicles are as easy to charge as your phone and perfect for everyday life Drive daily with confidence Everywhere you go Most Americans drive 40 miles a day. Most EVs are equipped with 200 to 400 miles of range. They've got fewer parts, fewer repairs, and fewer headaches. With hundreds of new and used EV models available today, there's an EV to fit every lifestyle and every budget. Ghost the gas station and save up to $2,000 a year not buying gas. EVs are perfect for real life, with a daily range that allows you to drive with confidence wherever you want to go. And charging is easy. Plug in overnight at home, just like your phone, or use a fast charger and get back on the road in as little as 20 minutes. Learn [e-mail] Support for the show comes from Public Huh.

[Andrew Jarecki]

I wonder if this can beat the market. Everyone's talking about the NASDAQ 100, but

[Malcolm Gladwell]

let's get more specific.

[Andrew Jarecki]

Software? Actually, too broad. How about software that's already profitable? Companies that beat the last five quarters? Oh, and I want founders who are marathon runners. That's discipline. Yeah, let's see what that looks like.

[Public Ad Narrator]

With generated assets on public, you can turn any idea into an investable index. Just enter a prompt and watch the AI screen thousands of stocks in seconds. You can then back test your index against the S&P 500, make adjustments, refine your criteria, and when you're ready, invest in what you've built. Go to public.com and build your own index with generated assets, plus earn a 1% uncapped match when you transfer your portfolio. Public Investing for those who take it seriously Ad paid for by Public Holdings Brokerage Services by Public Investing member FINRA SIPC Advisory Services by Public Advisors SEC Registered Advisor Sample prompts are for illustrative purposes only, not investment advice. All investing involves risk of loss. See complete [e-mail] disclosures lately, car buying

[Malcolm Gladwell]

has become a pretty dull experience. But on ebay, behind every car, in part, is a story waiting to be shared. Like this guy I read who bought a 2020 Porsche Cayman GT4 on eBay. It was well loved. I mean, there are plenty of Caymans in great condition on ebay, but this one needed some work. That's just the start of the story. So after this guy gets a great deal on his dream car, he rebuilds the whole thing with all these parts he found on ebay. Performance brakes, suspension, body panels, the works. Guaranteed to fit next Thing you know, this nearly scrapped Cayman was out there on the track as a full blown race car. You're ready to go. Daily driver. Your next resto mod. Hello, Lotus Salon. And the parts to finish it. Ebay has thousands of cars and is the largest online selection of vehicle parts and accessories. EBay, things people love.

What's the stage in the process where you're happiest?

[Andrew Jarecki]

It's a really good question, and I think it's a question you have to ask in a kind of longitudinal way because you're having the most fun in the very beginning because it's all new. And then you're halfway through it and it's like the dark night of the soul. And you think it's a disaster. And then you look back and you think, oh, my God, you know, that was the time. And then you get further along and you solve a problem, and then that's the time. And then you get to the end of the whole thing. You look back and that's a different. So I guess the question, you know, if you ask the question over time,

[Malcolm Gladwell]

did you have a dark night of the soul moment with this documentary?

[Andrew Jarecki]

It lasted like seven years.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

So you, by definition.

[Andrew Jarecki]

But it wasn't so much. I mean, there were plenty of times we thought, I don't know whether this is gonna work. And you go to the best advisors you have and you show material and you just watch and see how people react. And then we do these other things. Like, we'll do like a session with a whiteboard, and the whole team of people that are working on the film will say, okay, what are the five things that I feel like if these aren't in the movie, we've made a terrible mistake. And then you end up with 35 things on the board. And then you think, all right, well, what is this telling me? You just try to look at it a million different ways. You kind of keep moving it around.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

You're in deep, dark depression on something. You just call me. Because if you just. You. I didn't have to show me. If you just called me and said, malcolm, I have cell phone video footage from inside Alabama, the Alabama prison system. I have a lot of it, but I don't think it's going to work. I would have said it's going to work.

[Andrew Jarecki]

Oh, good.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

It's like there's no way for it not to work. I think the correct answer, it really is a. I mean, I realize I had been gushing, but it is an extraordinary piece of work. And I'm both complimenting you, but also complimenting the prisoners who found a way to get their story out in the world. Right. They're your collaborators on this. And the result is something that is quite unlike any other. Like I said, it solves the documentary problem for me. You solved it like there's no. You're not reconstructing anything.

[Andrew Jarecki]

There's this great moment in Ibsen, you know, in Master Builder, and there's this character named Hilda who works with this architect. And the architect is this very grand fellow that is building big buildings and all that stuff. And then you see her saying at the end of it, her last line as she says, the master builder. My master builder. And a lot of people have commented about that over the years and written about it, that it's really that Hilda, at that time in history, like a young, brilliant woman, needed another person who thought that they were a great builder. But really it was her ideas that were coming through. And I do feel that way here, that the men knew what they needed. I don't want to act like it's working. I mean, Alabama is still. This is still an urgent problem. Alabama is still killing people in its custody all the time. I think people right now are dying at the rate of around one a day. And that's just in one system. We have 2 million people incarcerated around the country. But I do get the feeling that while we're walking around thinking we're making a film, the men inside are driven by their own brilliance, their own survival instinct, are saying, we need to get this material in front of the public. We're not a position to do it. Let's see if this collaboration can work. And that, I think, is the thing I feel the most grateful for, is that we were able to deliver that. And the men in the film have seen the film, you know, because we showed it to them on cell phones and. And when we were done, I think they were very emotional seeing it. I think we, you know, we spent so much time and showed it to them, talked to them about what we were making because it's such a responsibility to say, you know, hey, you guys, you've been running a non violent organized protest movement that includes work stoppages and hunger strikes. And somehow we're going to characterize that and we're going to put that on television or we're going to put that in movie theaters. But it's really their story. So you have to be in constant dialogue with them about what that is, including now, you know, telling them what we're doing and what we're thinking and trying to, you know, we created this sort of whistleblower defense committee of really smart lawyers because we knew that these men have been retaliated against time after time after time. And so they jump in and they'll go and do wellness checks on the men. You're in a relationship with them forever. You know, it's a little different, right. Because in your. I mean, maybe you'll choose to go and have coffee with Steve Marshall once a week if he really enjoys company. But, you know, most of the people that are in your film are kind of already, you know, you're not going back to Alabama much, and you're not gonna go talk to the people that are in the story. But these guys are like, they're in my life happily. I feel very lucky that they're in my life, in Charlotte's life. Yeah.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

Yeah. Andrew, we are out of time. I want to thank you very much both for coming to on airfest and singing with me, and also for the movie, which has, you know, as the best art does, has left America a little. A little better off than it was before. Thank you so much.

[Andrew Jarecki]

Really appreciate it.

[Malcolm Gladwell]

Revisionist history is produced by lucy sullivan, ben denaf haffrey, and nina bird lawrence. Our editor is karen shakurji. Our executive producer is jacob smith. Engineering by nina byrd lawrence. Original music by luis guerra. Mixing and mastering by jake korski. I'm malcolm glabel. Imagine never buying gas again. EVs electric vehicles are as easy to charge as your phone and perfect for everyday life. Drive daily with confidence everywhere you go. Most Americans drive 40 miles a day. Most EVs are equipped with 200 to 400 miles of range. They've got fewer parts, fewer repairs, and fewer headaches. With hundreds of new and used EV models available today, there's an EV to fit every lifestyle and every budget. Ghost the gas station and save up to $2,000 a year not buying gas. EVs are perfect for real life, with a daily range that allows you to drive with confidence wherever you want to go. And charging is easy. Plug in overnight at home, just like your phone, or use a fast charger and get back on the road in as little as 20 minutes. Learn more at electricforall.org if your finance team spends more time finding data than using it. If there's one entity here and one there and one here and one there. If scaling your business feels like starting over, you need the Intuit ERP. Intuit Enterprise Suite is the AI native ERP solution. That's powerful painless and proven. Learn more at intuit.com erp In a world where everyone has access to the same data and the same AI, how do you actually win? Most people are fighting for 1% gains. But the real upside, the exponential growth, comes from the creative leap. It's what Sir John Hegarty calls the creative dividend. It's the ability to make your entire business irreplaceable, from your product and your process to your company culture. John's eight part series, Creativity for Growth, is the playbook for building your creative capability and embedding it into your organization. Creativity is a system, not a spark. Learn it today. Visit creativityforgrowth.com.