The Worst Poet in the World | From Cautionary Tales

Summary

---

Revisionist History — "The Worst Poet in the World" (from Cautionary Tales with Tim Harford)

Air Date: May 7, 2026
Host: Tim Harford
Subject: The life, work, and legacy of William McGonagall, often labeled "the worst poet in the world"

---

Episode Overview

This special crossover episode from Cautionary Tales explores the tragicomic life and enduring legacy of Scottish poet William McGonagall. Host Tim Harford traces McGonagall’s journey from humble weaver to infamous literary figure, famed for poetry of staggering ineptitude—yet also, perhaps, sly wit. The episode probes whether McGonagall is a figure of ridicule, a misunderstood creative spirit, or even a comic genius, ultimately re-examining notions of creativity, failure, and artistic value.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. The Tay Bridge Disaster: A Catastrophe and a Poet’s Muse

• Harford opens with a gripping reconstruction of the 1879 Tay Bridge disaster, a tragic railway accident in Scotland.
  • [03:14] The drama of the storm, the collapse, and the loss of the train set the stage for McGonagall’s most (in)famous poem.
• First recitation from McGonagall’s “The Tay Bridge Disaster” shows its infamous lack of artistry:
  • [08:14]

    “So the train moved slowly along the Bridge of Tay / until it was about midway. Then the central girders with a crash gave way…”

• Harford confesses a morbid fascination with both the disaster and the poem’s ineptitude.
  • [09:53] Harford: “It’s awful. I’m obsessed with William McGonagall. I have so many questions. Who was this man? What does he teach us about art? And above all, how does a poem get to be this bad?”

---

2. William McGonagall: Origins and Aspirations

• McGonagall’s early life marked by humble roots, erratic education, and theatrical ambitions.
  • [10:30-12:09] Childhood story: traumatized by a teacher’s pet tortoise, leading to school skiving.
  • McGonagall idolized Shakespeare, describing himself as having “complete mastery” of tragic roles.
• Anecdote of his Macbeth performance is a highlight:
  • [13:24] Historical witness: “Instead of dying when run through... he maintained his feet and flourished his weapon... The performance ending in real tragedy seemed possible.”
  • McGonagall (retelling): “He tried to spoil me in the combat... I continued the combat until he were fairly exhausted… and an old gentleman cried out, ‘Well done, McGonagall. Walk into him!’” [13:53]
  • The audience loved the shambolic spectacle, hinting at McGonagall’s appeal to “the cheap seats.”

---

3. The Poet Awakens

• Losing work as a weaver due to machinery, McGonagall claims to be seized by the "spirit of poetry."
  • [16:36] McGonagall: “Dame Fortune has been very kind to me by endowing me with the genius of poetry. I remember how I felt when I received the spirit of poetry.”
  • [17:03] “All of a sudden, my body got inflamed… I heard a voice crying in my ears, ‘Write.’”
• First poem is published—encouragement followed by escalating mockery and rejection.
  • [18:12] McGonagall sent poems to newspapers; after one success, is then “artfully” rejected (“We can only express the fervent hope that he may put into execution this artful threat.”)
• Falls for (and perhaps participates in) elaborate pranks, including a fraudulent invitation from the Queen and a fake patronage offer from the Burmese royal court.
  • [21:43] Balmoral incident: “They canna be bothered with you.” — Castle constable
  • [26:30] Receives a fake knighthood from “the King of Burma” and accepts it with pride.

---

4. Public Performances and Ridicule

• Despite continuous mockery, McGonagall thrives in his notoriety, attracting riotous crowds who heckle him and throw eggs/cabbages.
  • [27:00s] He arms himself with a small round shield to parry projectiles.
• He dies in poverty, but not before performing widely and being denied official recognition (kept away by police, banned from reciting in Dundee).

---

5. What Can We Learn From "The Worst Poet"?

• Literary critics: cite McGonagall as a cautionary example; point to his “humdrum plainness, vapid statement, dull diction, crappy meter…”
  • [29:00] Joseph Salemi: “Can we stop with the humdrum plainness... the tedious length, the triviality…?”
  • Scholar Gerard Carruthers: “It’s time for us to close the book on McGonagall once and for all.”
• Harford offers a more charitable (and even celebratory) reframing:
  • [30:50] “We shouldn’t complain about a man who wrote bad poetry. We should celebrate a man who wrote poetry… most acts of human creativity are fairly incompetent… Who cares? Dance and sing anyway.”
  • Raises the possibility of McGonagall as comic genius—not just hapless but self-aware, possibly orchestrating his own public persona (“What if William McGonagall is the most brilliant clown who ever lived?”) [32:54]

---

6. Re-evaluating McGonagall: Fool, Victim, or Genius?

• Harford dwells on the idea of McGonagall as an intentional court jester, using humor and public failure to speak truth to power.
  • [37:12] McGonagall’s “prayer” that the Tay Bridge not collapse—two years before it does—painted as eerily prescient, perhaps slyly subversive.
  • [38:11] “Idiot or court jester, you be the judge.”
• The enduring cultural value of McGonagall’s legacy:
  • His name lives on, famously inspiring Professor Minerva McGonagall of Harry Potter fame.
  • [40:20] At auction, his poetry sells for more than J.K. Rowling’s signed first editions—a wry twist on literary greatness.

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• [09:53] Tim Harford: “How does a poem get to be this bad?”
• [13:53] McGonagall (on Macbeth fight): “He tried to spoil me in the combat… until there was one old gentleman in the audience cried out, ‘Well done, McGonagall. Walk into him!’”
• [16:36] McGonagall: “Dame Fortune has been very kind to me by endowing me with the genius of poetry.”
• [21:43] Balmoral gatekeeper: “They canna be bothered with you.”
• [30:50] Tim Harford: “Who cares? Dance and sing anyway.”
• [32:54] Harford: “What if William McGonagall is the most brilliant clown who ever lived?”
• [38:11] Harford: “Idiot or court jester, you be the judge.”
• [40:20] Harford, on McGonagall’s auctioned poems: “If commercial success is the mark of a great artist, then J.K. Rowling is one of the best. But she’s no William McGonagall. He will be remembered for a very long time.”

---

Timestamps for Key Segments

• 03:14 – The Tay Bridge disaster: narration and poetic recitation
• 09:53 – Introduction to McGonagall’s backstory and his obsession with poetry
• 13:24–14:23 – The legendary Macbeth stage fight
• 16:36–17:35 – McGonagall describes being overtaken by the spirit of poetry
• 18:26 – Early reception of his poems: “Bonny Dundee”
• 21:21–22:05 – The failed Balmoral visit and Tennyson’s inconvenient existence
• 24:49–26:30 – Career humiliations, transatlantic failures, and the fake Burmese knighthood
• 27:00s – Public performances, heckling, and defensive tactics
• 29:00–30:50 – Literary criticism and Harford’s celebration of ordinary creativity
• 32:54–38:11 – Reframing McGonagall: clumsy fool or comic genius?
• 40:20 – McGonagall’s poems fetch a high price at auction, reflecting on legacy

---

Conclusion: McGonagall’s Lasting Legacy

Ending on a characteristically wry and generous note, Tim Harford urges listeners to rethink creative “failure” as an act of courage, humor, and perhaps subtle wisdom. Whether McGonagall was a deluded hack or a knowing trickster, Harford insists his poetry endures because, good or bad, it was—above all else—unafraid. For every joke at McGonagall’s expense, listeners are reminded of the pleasure, spectacle, and reflection that both bad poetry and flawed creative attempts can bring.

---

For full source details, see the show notes at timharford.com.

Transcript

[Tim Harford]

Foreign.

[Narrator/Host Introduction]

You're about to hear an episode of Cautionary Tales with Tim Harford. Tim's podcast explores mistakes from history and importantly, what we can learn from them. As you can imagine, there's a lot of disasters to choose from, but there's always an interesting angle on what we can take from them. I learn something new every time. You'd be surprised, but a shipwreck from the 60s can teach us something about a mistake we all make when making decisions Today, this episode is about a poet. William McGonagall is remembered today as the worst poet in the world, and Tim is obsessed with his work. I think I am too. Here's a quick example. A pathetic tale of the sea I will unfold enough to make one's blood run cold concerning four fishermen cast adrift in a dory. As I've been told, I'll relate the story. Twas on the 8th April, on the afternoon of that day that the village of Louisburg was thrown into a wild state of disarray. So what can we learn from a disastrous poet? Tim has a few ideas, and in true revisionist history style, he has a feeling we've been understanding McGonagall all wrong. Enjoy the episode. It's one of my favorites. And make sure you subscribe to Cautionary Tales for plenty more disasters and plenty more lessons. This message is a paid partnership with Apple Card there's something interesting about how seamlessly certain tools fit into daily life. Apple Card is one of those things it can be applied for right in the wallet app on iPhone and approval can happen in minutes, so it's ready to use immediately with Apple Pay. I'm so glad the days of finding my wallet, fishing out the credit card, using it, putting it back in my wallet, or oops, maybe I use cash. Where's the atm? Enough. The first time I used Apple Pay on my phone with my Apple Card, I was like, this is the future. There's no going back. With Apple Card, purchases earn daily cash up to 3% with no points to track and no waiting for rewards. It's simply daily cash back that I earn on every purchase. There's even an option to open a high yield savings account through Apple Card. And while I haven't done it yet, if I do, my daily cash can grow automatically over time without any extra effort. Because Apple Card lives in the Wallet app, it's always accessible on iPhone and can be used with Apple Pay at over 85% of merchants in the US and the security of Face ID and Touch ID prevents unauthorized purchases. Whether using iPhone or Apple Watch to exploit yourself. You can apply for Apple Card in the Wallet app on your iPhone, subject to credit approval. Savings is available to Apple Card owners subject to eligibility Savings in Apple Card by Goldman Sachs Bank USA Salt Lake City Branch Bank Member FDIC terms and [e-mail].

[Tim Harford]

The wind is fierce, no doubt about it. It's the strongest gale that John Watt can remember, and he's been working for the North British Railway since 1867, a full 12 years. It's a good night to be safe. You sheltered in the railway signal cabin, sharing a mug of tea with a friend, signalman Thomas Barkley. As Watt and Barclay sip their tea and look out of the window into the darkness, it can see the faint line of lamps all along the new railway bridge running almost two miles across the wide River Tay to the city of Dundee. Every now and then the clouds gust apart and the full moon picks out the high girders of the longest bridge in the world. A few minutes after 7 o' clock comes the signal from the south. The northbound train is approaching. Thomas Barclay steps out of the cabin into the wind and waits as the train approaches, the sparks from the wheels visible in the dark. He greets the crew with a smile, handing over the baton that gives permission for a train to cross the bridge. The train is moving at walking pace. He sees a child peer out of the window of a carriage as it passes. Then, as the train passes over the long, high iron span, Thomas goes back to his friend in the shelter of the cabin and sends a message to the signal box over on the other side of the River Tay. The signal bell rings three times in response, and still the wind howls. Thomas turns back to his mug of tea, but John Watt is gazing out of the window at the bridge. There's something wrong with the train, he says. Thomas Barclay thinks he's imagining it, but John knows what he's seen. Three red tail lamps fading into the distance over the bridge. And then a series of flashes, three small and one big. Then darkness. No tail lamps. The train's gone over. Thomas, he says. Thomas Barclay still isn't convinced. Surely the train has just disappeared from view after cresting the highest point of the bridge. Surely they'll see her again soon. But they don't. Thomas tries calling the signal box on the other side of the bridge. Nothing. They go outside briefly venture onto the bridge. Men retreat as the wind threatens to tear them off the girders and into the waters below. The clouds part again and the full moon reveals the SCENE A thousand yards of the bridge are gone. The high girders of the central spot, the iron piers that had supported them, also gone. And of course, the train has gone too, and every one of its passengers. It's a catastrophe. But this is not a story about a fatal bridge collapse. It's a story about a poet. I'm Tim Harford, and you're listening to Cautionary Tales. Beautiful railway bridge of the silvery Tay. Alas, I am very sorry to say that 90 lives have been taken away on the last sabbath day of 1879, which will be remembered for a very long time. Thus begins a poem titled the Tay Bridge Disaster. It is widely regarded as the worst poem ever written and its author, William McGonagall, is widely regarded as the worst poet. I'll spare you the full poem, but here's a central verse. So the train moved slowly along the Bridge of Tay until it was about midway. Then the central girders with a crash

[William McGonagall (quoted or recited poetry)]

gave way and down went the train and passengers into the te. The storm fiend did loudly Bray because 90 lives had been taken away on the last sabbath day of 1879, which will be remembered for a very long time.

[Tim Harford]

When I was just a boy, I saw an illustration of the Tay Bridge catastrophe in a children's picture book. It stayed with me. I can still see it in my mind. The bridge seems so horribly high and thin as it collapses into the storm. The train is just steaming off into thin air. It's awful. And then I encountered William McGonagall's truly terrible poem. And it stuck with me just as vividly. Or should I say, it has been remembered for a very long time. Here's the end of the poem.

[William McGonagall (quoted or recited poetry)]

O ill fated bridge of the silvery Tay. I must now conclude my lay by telling the world fearlessly without the least dismay that your central girders would not have given way. At least many sensible men do say had they been supported on each side with buttresses. At least many sensible men confesses, for the stronger we our houses do build, the less chance we have of being killed.

[Tim Harford]

It's awful. I'm obsessed with William McGonagall. I have so many questions. Who was this man? What does he teach us about art? And above all, how does a poem get to be this bad? I have several biographies of the poet McGonagall in front of me. One of them says he was born in 1825. Another says he was born in 1830. And both were written by William McGonagall himself. William McGonagall's parents were Irish, but he was born in Edinburgh and went to school in South Ronaldsay, one of the Orkney Islands, remote even by the standards of Scotland. William's education was interrupted by, of all things, an encounter with his teacher's beloved pet tortoise. William was fascinated by the creature, but when he picked it up to fully admire the beauty of its shell, the unfortunate animal voided its bowels on his hand. In disgust, the boy hurled the tortoise to the ground, nearly killing it. And McGonagall's teacher, enraged, started thrashing his face with a cane. All very distressing. William's father complained to the local magistrate. The magistrate threatened to disbar the teacher. And the practical outcome was that the teacher lived in fear of ever upsetting William again, who skipped school with impunity. That was the story McGonagall would tell, and his point was clear. William McGonagall was much like William Shakespeare. He had learned more from nature than he learned at school. McGonagall adored his namesake, William Shakespeare. He read and re read Macbeth, Richard iii, Hamlet and Othello.

[William McGonagall (quoted or recited poetry)]

I gave myself no rest until I obtained complete mastery over the above four characters.

[Tim Harford]

McGonagall's family moved to Dundee, where both he and his father worked as weavers. William would give impromptu performances of Shakespeare to his shopmates. He says they were quite delighted, and perhaps they were, since they were willing to pay good money to support his theatrical ambitions. William McGonagall was to play the title role in Macbeth just as long as he paid one pound to the theatre owner for the privilege, about $100 in today's money. His colleagues all contributed, and nobody can say they didn't get their money's worth. McGonagall couldn't afford a costume of his own, so so borrowed a few items from friends and colleagues and took the stage dressed less like the ambitious nobleman Macbeth and more like a highland beggar. The play traditionally ends with a climactic fight in which Macbeth is slain by Macduff. This concept proved too pedestrian for McGonagall. One witness described the result. An immortal scene in more ways than one.

[Narrator/Storyteller or Historical Commentator]

McGonagall had evidently made up his mind to astonish the gods at his performance. For instead of dying when run through the body by the sword of Macduff, he maintained his feet and flourished his weapon about the ears of his adversary in such a way that there was for some time an apparent probability of the performance ending in real tragedy.

[Tim Harford]

McGonagall saw it differently.

[William McGonagall (quoted or recited poetry)]

The actor who was playing Macduff against My Macbeth tried to spoil me in the combat by telling me to cut it short. I continued the combat until he were fairly exhausted and until there was one old gentleman in the audience cried out, well done, McGonagall. Walk into him. And so I did, until he was in a great rage and stamped his foot and cried out, fool, why don't you fall?

[Tim Harford]

With macduff audibly urging McGonagall's Macbeth to go down and Macbeth ignoring him over and over again. Macduff, enraged, wrapped Macbeth over his knuckles with a flat of the blade, forcing him to drop his own sword. McGonagall was now unarmed but undaunted. And he dodged around and around Macduff looking for all the world as though he now planned to wrestle for it. The Macduff actor, disgusted at the tomfoolery cup, tossed his own sword aside and charged in to tackle McGonagall. The sublime tragedy of Macbeth came to an undignified end with a title character swept off his feet and deposited on his backside. The audience were ecstatic. They bellowed for McGonagall to be brought forward to receive a standing ovation. What a shame that McGonagall's artistic sensitivities were not put to full time use. He continued to work as a weaver for decades. Not to worry. Good things come to those who wait. He would eventually emulate all William Shakespeare, the man he so admired. William McGonagall would become a poet. Cautionary tales will be back after the break.

[Liberty Mutual Advertiser]

And Doug, there's nowhere I wouldn't go to help someone customize and save on car insurance with Liberty Mutual. Even if it means sitting free front row at a comedy show.

[Narrator/Host Introduction]

Hey, everyone, check out this guy and his bird.

[Tim Harford]

What is this, your first date?

[Liberty Mutual Advertiser]

Oh, no. We help people customize and save on car insurance with Liberty Mutual. Together we're married. Me to a human, him to a bird.

[William McGonagall (quoted or recited poetry)]

Yeah, the bird looks out of your league.

[Liberty Mutual Advertiser]

Anyways, get a'@libertymutual.com or with your local agent.

[Narrator/Host Introduction]

Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty.

[Tim Harford]

McGonagall was about 50 when it became clear to him that there was no future in weaving. Machine looms had taken over.

[William McGonagall (quoted or recited poetry)]

I couldn't make a living from it. But I may say Dame Fortune has been very kind to me by endowing me with the genius of poetry. I remember how I felt when I received the spirit of poetry.

[Tim Harford]

It was June 1877. McGonagall was lamenting that he couldn't get away to the Highlands for a holiday.

[William McGonagall (quoted or recited poetry)]

All of a sudden, my body got inflamed. And instantly I was seized with a strong desire to write poetry. So strong, in fact, that in imagination I thought I heard a voice crying in my ears. Write.

[Tim Harford]

Write.

[William McGonagall (quoted or recited poetry)]

I wondered what could be the matter with me. And I began to walk backwards and forwards in a great fit of excitement, saying to myself, I know nothing about poetry.

[Liberty Mutual Advertiser]

But still a voice kept ringing in my ears.

[William McGonagall (quoted or recited poetry)]

Write.

[Tim Harford]

Write.

[William McGonagall (quoted or recited poetry)]

Until at last, being overcome with a desire to write poetry, I found paper, pen and ink and in a state of frenzy sat me down to think what would be my first subject for a poem.

[Tim Harford]

That subject was the Reverend George Gil Fillan, a local preacher McGonagall wished to praise. The poem stirringly concludes My blessing on

[William McGonagall (quoted or recited poetry)]

his noble form and on his lofty heed May all good angels guard him while living and hereafter win his deed.

[Tim Harford]

McGonagall sent the poem to the Dundee Weekly News, which took the unwise step of printing it. Thus encouraged, he sent a second poem. Bonnie Dundee.

[William McGonagall (quoted or recited poetry)]

O bonny Dundee, I will sing in thy praise. A few but true simple lays regarding some of your beauties of the present day and virtually speaking, there's none can them gainsay for superfine goods there's none can excel From Inverness to Clerkenwell and your tramways I must confess that they have proved a complete success, which I am right glad to see and a very great improvement to Bonnie Dundee

[Tim Harford]

There is more. But alas, the Weekly News declined to print what it described as a so called poem. At which point McGonagall sent them a letter threatening to stop sending any more poems. The Weekly News dryly explained to its readers that we can only express the fervent hope that he may put into execution this artful threat. In the summer of 1878, McGonagall had been a poet for just a year when he received a letter from Queen Victoria's private secretary, Sir Thomas Biddulph, informing him that Her Majesty would like to become a patron of his poems. McGonagall seems not to have registered any surprise at this sudden honour. But he was inspired to make the 59 mile journey from Dundee to Queen Victoria's residence at Balmoral so that he could recite his verse for her. For an unemployed weaver, there was no way to reach Balmoral except to walk. The journey took three days, during which time McGonagall was fed and sheltered by shepherds who took pity on him. He recorded some of his journey in poetry, notably on the Spittle of Glenshee,

[William McGonagall (quoted or recited poetry)]

which is most dismal for to see, with its bleak and rugged mountains and Clear crystal spouting fountains with their misty foam and thousands of sheep there together doth roam.

[Tim Harford]

He was drenched by hours of rain and threatened by the roaring and flashing of a thunderstorm overhead, but was undaunted having told his friends back in Dundee that on his way to see Her Majesty and Balmoral he would pass through fire and water rather than retreat. Finally, mid afternoon on the third day, McGonagall reached Her Majesty's residence at Balmoral Castle. He was intercepted by the constable at Balmoral's Gatehouse Lodge who presumably, presumably observed McGodigal's collar length wave of hair, his drenched patched up clothes and his dirty boots and did not think to himself, here comes a future poet laureate.

[William McGonagall (quoted or recited poetry)]

I showed him Her Majesty's royal letter of patronage for my poetic abilities. And he read it and said it was not Her Majesty's letter.

[Tim Harford]

Someone had played a cruel trick, but McGonagall insisted that the letter was genuine. The constable took it away for a while before returning to announce, well, I've

[Narrator/Storyteller or Historical Commentator]

been up at the castle with your letter and the answer I got for you is they canna be bothered with you.

[Tim Harford]

McGonagall showed the constable a copy of his poems, including the claim that McGonagall was poet to Her Majesty.

[Narrator/Storyteller or Historical Commentator]

The constable objected, you are not poet to Her Majesty. Tennyson's the real poet to Her Majesty.

[Tim Harford]

Ah, yes, Alfred Lord Tennyson, the actual poet laureate. How inconvenient. In writing the Charge of the Light Brigade, Alfred Lord Tennyson performed a rare feat. He created a poem that is as famous as the disaster it describes.

[Alfred Lord Tennyson (quoted poetry)]

Cannon to the right of them, Cannon to the left of them, Cannon in front of them volleyed and thundered, Stormed at with shot and shell. Boldly they rode and well into the jaws of death, into the mouth of hell rode the 600.

[Tim Harford]

William McGonagall never got close to succeeding Tennyson as poet laureate. Yet his poem the Tay Bridge Disaster matches Tennyson's achievement. I mean, Tennyson was good, but he was no William McGonagall. But I digress. The constable suggested that McGonagall demonstrate his skills by reciting some poetry at the castle gate. No, sir, said McGonagall. He wasn't some wandering charlatan. He was the real thing.

[William McGonagall (quoted or recited poetry)]

Take me into one of the rooms in the lodge and pay me for it and I will give you a recital.

[Tim Harford]

The constable didn't oblige, but he gave McGonagall some advice. Unless you want to be arrested, go home and don't Think of returning to Balmoral. McGonagall duly began the three day walk home to Dundee. When he got back, he wrote up his adventures, sent them to the newspapers and before long was being mocked up and down the British Isles. As a headline in the Evening Telegraph put it, Extraordinary freak of a dundee poet, William McGonagall at Balmoral. Genius still unrecognised. When a cruel prank wastes a week of your life, dashes your hopes and leads you to being mocked in the national press, what can you do? The answer? Pick yourself up and try again. McGonagall noted that Tennyson was famous for his war poetry, so he decided to dabble in war poems too. They are not very good. The Battle of Crecy begins.

[William McGonagall (quoted or recited poetry)]

Twas on the 26th of August, the sun was burning hot in the year of 1346, which will never be forgot

[Tim Harford]

and ends with the classic McGonagall move of cramming some extra syllables in free of charge.

[William McGonagall (quoted or recited poetry)]

And the King's heart was filled with great delight. And he thanked Jack for capturing the Bohemian standard during the fight.

[Tim Harford]

But McGonagall was soon encouraged to receive a lucrative job offer from the famous playwright and theater impresario Dion Boucicault. Boucicault's letter invited him to a fine dinner, but as McGonagall tells the story, he arrived to find several men awaiting him, barely suppressing giggles as McGonagall was served a cheap sandwich. McGonagall had been pranked again, although when Boucicault heard about the joke, he sent McGonagall a sympathetic letter and £5, enough money for McGonagall to visit London. He had hoped to meet with one or two of London's most celebrated actors, but had no more luck there than at Balmoral. Later, McGonagall ventured to New York, a city he honoured in distinctive style.

[William McGonagall (quoted or recited poetry)]

As for Brooklyn Bridge, it's a very great height and fills the stranger's heart with wonder at first sight and with all its loftiness, I venture to say it cannot surpass the new railway bridge of the Silvery Taylor.

[Tim Harford]

William McGonagall did not succeed in selling his poems in New York, so returned to Scotland. He was cheered to receive a letter from the poet laureate of Burma writing on behalf of Burma's king Tibor, making McGonagall Topaz McGonagall, Knight of the White Elephant of Burma. McGonagall accepted the honour and wore his medal, a silver elephant, with pride. If he ever feared that this letter was as fraudulent as the others, he shared no doubts. McGonagall spent his final years giving public performances in Perth, Glasgow and Edinburgh where the main attraction appeared to be the opportunity to hurl abuse and worse at the aspiring poet laureate. McGonagall would dash about the stage excitedly enacting the action as he gave dramatic recitals of his war poems clad in a kilt and brandishing a claymore with perilous enthusiasm. More useful was his small round shield with which he could parry incoming eggs and cabbages. William McGonagall died in poverty on 29 September 1902. He was 72 years old, or 77. He was buried in a pauper's grave, having practiced the art of poetry for 25 years and having been mocked for every one of them. The death certificate misspells his name. Emil Zola died on the same day. As it happens, Zola a fine writer he was no William McGonagall. Cautionary tales will return after the break. The poetry critics argue that McGonagall has an important lesson to teach us. He is the perfect example of how not to write poetry. If you must read him, be sure to do the opposite of whatever he does. Joseph Salemi, an award winning poet, complains, I know far too many persons who share some of McGonagall's faults. Can we at least resolve that we will not commit the poetic crimes that McGonagall committed? Can we stop with the humdrum plainness, the vapid statement, the dull diction, the crappy metre, the tedious length, the triviality, the commonplace thoughts and the cliched perceptions? Dr. Gerard Carruthers, an expert in Scottish literature, agrees. There is something rather cruel about a still reprinting and republishing McGonagall. He told the BBC, it's time for us to close the book on McGonagall once and for all. But that feels so narrow minded. I draw a different lesson. We shouldn't complain about a man who wrote bad poetry. We should celebrate a man who wrote poetry. Of course the poems are bad, but most poems are bad. Most acts of human creativity are fairly incompetent. Most of us can't write novels, not that anyone else would pay to read. Most of us can't draw or paint anything that anyone else would pay to look at. Most of us can't act, we can't sing, we can't dance. Who cares? Dance and sing anyway. I think we're prone to making a sad mistake. When we think about creative acts we instinctively set the benchmark at an absurdly high level. We've been Spoiled, perhaps, because at the touch of a button, we can listen to Glenn Gould playing Johann Sebastian Bach. We can watch Ian McKellen and Judi Dench performing Shakespeare. We can read a novel by Austen or watch a film by Coppola, or gaze at an interior by Vermeer. Not only has modern technology made these wonders possible, but modern technology also makes more humdrum creative acts economically worthless. Nobody is going to pay me to perform Bach or paint a watercolour, but I still play the piano from time to time. And very occasionally I pick up a pencil and a sketchbook. It doesn't matter if there's no economic value in the result. There's personal value. For me, in the process of trying to express myself, that might seem obvious, but it's easy to forget. In debates about the rise of generative AI, people worry about the death of human creativity. But I don't think generative AI is more of a threat to human creativity than the camera or the record player. It changes the economics. To be sure, McGonagall lost his job as a weaver because of machine looms, so he would have understood all about losing work to a machine. But while a new technology changes who might be paid for creative work and what sort of creative work they might be paid for, and how much they might be paid for it, it doesn't make creative work impossible. All of us are free to sit down in front of a piano or an easel and try to create something beautiful. And while it's nice to succeed, it's more important to try. As we grow from children into adults, we often express our creativity less. It might be because we're afraid of failure, which is another thing to admire about McGonagall. He wasn't afraid of creative failure. In fact, he wouldn't recognise creative failure if it hurled an egg at him. That's one way to look at McGonagall, anyway, as a man who was always willing to express his inner creativity. But that's not actually the way I see him. I don't think William McGonagall was admirable because he gave poetry a try. I think he was a genius. You've perhaps heard the story about the man who goes to a doctor. He feels depressed. The world seems so frightening and bleak. Don't worry, says the doctor. The great clown Pagliacci is in town tonight. Go and see him perform. That'll cheer you up. The man starts to sob. But doctor, I am Pagliacci. It's a story that's been retold and remixed countless Times. So here's another remix. What if William McGonagall isn't the pompous, talentless, sad victim of bullies that he seems to be? What if William McGonagall is the most brilliant clown who ever lived? And what if, unlike Pagliacci, whose despair became clear when he took off the mask, McGonagall never removed his mask because underneath it, he was the one laughing harder than anyone. Think back to that appearance as Macbeth, in which McGonagall refused to lie down and die and wrestled with the infuriated actor playing Macduff. It's hard to think of a funnier scene in the history of theatre. Was it really just McGonagall's arrogance and stupidity? Or did he know full well that he was putting on a show? When the reviewer said that McGonagall had decided to astonish the gods, he wasn't referring to some pagan pantheon. The gods is theatre. Speak for the cheap seats. McGonagall was playing to the crowd and specifically to the poorest theatre goers of all. His friends from the workshop had all contributed to get him on stage in the first place. And they loved what they saw. McGonagall certainly gave you a show. And once you read McGonagall's poetry, not as an exhibit of utter incompetence but as a deliberate sly joke, you quickly detect hints of mischief. A one poem, an Ode to the

[William McGonagall (quoted or recited poetry)]

Moon, begins, Beautiful moon, with thy silvery light Thou seemest most charming to my sight. As I gaze upon thee in the sky so high a tear of joy doth moisten mine eye.

[Tim Harford]

Just the usual clumsy cliche. No, McGonagall's winking at us. He knows what we do in the dark. The next verses celebrate the way that the moon provides light for the fox to steal a goose from the farmyard and the poacher to set his snares

[William McGonagall (quoted or recited poetry)]

and Beautiful moon, with thy silvery light Thou cheerest the lovers in the night as they walk through the shady groves alone making love to each other before they go home.

[Tim Harford]

Really, we're going to believe that William McGonagall was only accidentally funny. McGonagall is best known today for his poem about the Tay Bridge disaster. But in an early poem, he also describes the Tay Bridge when it was first built.

[William McGonagall (quoted or recited poetry)]

Beautiful railway bridge of the silvery Tay the longest of the present day that has ever crossed o' er a tidal river stream most gigantic to be seen nearby Dundee and the Magdalene green.

[Tim Harford]

At nearly two miles in length, it was an engineering miracle. But McGonagall was a Dundee local, and like any local, he would have known that the high girders of the central bridge had already been blown down once during construction. Otherwise, why on earth include this verse?

[William McGonagall (quoted or recited poetry)]

Beautiful railway bridge of the Silvery Tay. I hope that God will protect all passengers by night and by day, and that no accident will befall them while crossing the bridge of the Silvery Tay, for that would be most awful to be seen nearby Dundee and the Magdalene Green.

[Tim Harford]

This isn't the work of an idiot. It's the work of an old school medieval fool, a court jester using humour to speak truth to power. Two years later the bridge was down and dozens of people were dead. After a disaster at a shipyard which killed 38 people, McGonagall composed a long lament, including praise for £1,000 from the

[William McGonagall (quoted or recited poetry)]

directors of the Thames Iron Works and Shipbuilding Company, which I hope will help to fill the bereaved ones hearts with glee.

[Tim Harford]

Idiot or court jester, you be the judge. As for those prank letters from Queen Victoria's secretary, from Dion Boucicault, from the King of Burma, maybe they were hoaxes on McGonagall. Maybe they were hoaxes by McGonagall on the rest of us. They certainly helped to shape the legend. For a man almost universally viewed As a failure, McGonagall knew how to draw a crowd. When a statue of Scotland's greatest poet, Robert Burns, was unveiled in Dundee, McGonagall was kept away from the occasion by police to avoid a disturbance of the peace. His Dundee performances so often ended in a near riot that he was eventually banned from giving any more recitals in the town. No wonder he died in poverty. He'd been making 15 shillings a night, the equivalent of a week's wages for an ordinary labourer. Not so bad for a man who lost his trade because of the march of the machines. His downfall wasn't because his poems were terrible. It was because his clowning performances were too riotously successful to be allowed to continue. He died in poverty, not because he was bad, but because he was just too good. We'll never know what William McGonagall was really thinking as he took to the stage each night. Was he oblivious as he seems to be, a man with skin so thick that neither insults nor insights ever got through? Or was he far more tragic than the mythic figure of Pagliacci the clown, proud of his poems but knowingly subjecting himself to knightly humiliation because there was no other way to put food on the table? Or was the whole thing a comic masterstroke? Did he never take off the mask, or did he never put it on in the first place? But while we can't read his mind, we can read his poems, and they've brought pleasure to countless people. A few years ago, an Edinburgh auction house put up for sale a collection of first editions of Harry Potter books signed by the author J.K. rowling, who, it turns out named Professor Minerva McGonagall in honour of the man she described as the worst poet in British history. The books went for a handsome enough price, I suppose, but in the same auction a rather higher sum was paid for a different literary gem, 35 poems by William McGonagall, some of them signed by the great man himself, J.K. rowling. If commercial success is the mark of a great artist, then she's one of the best. But she's no William McGonagall. He will be remembered for a very long time. For a full list of our sources, see the show [e-mail] Cautionary Tales is written by me, Tim Harford, with Andrew Wright, Alice Fiennes and Ryan Dilley. It's produced by Georgia Mills and Marilyn Rust. The sound design and original music are the work of Pascal Wise. Additional sound design is by Carlos San Juan at Brain Audio. Ben Nadaff Haffrey edited the scripts. The show features the voice talents of Genevieve Gauntlet, Melanie Guttridge, Stella Harford, Oliver Hembrough, Sarah Jopp, Masaya Munroe, Jamal Westman and Rufus Wright. The show also wouldn't have been possible without the work of Jacob Weisberg, Greta Cohn, Sarah Nix, Eric Sandler, Carrie Brodie, Christina Sullivan, Keira Posey and Owen Miller. Cautionary Tales is a production of Pushkin Industries. It's recorded at Wardle Studios in London by Noria Barr and Lucy Rowe. If you like the show, please remember to share, rate and review. It really makes a difference to us. And if you want to hear the show ad free, sign up to Pushkin plus on the show page on Apple Podcasts or at Pushkin FM plus. Sam.