Ridiculous History: Episode Summary - "Bhutan Grades Itself On Happiness"
Release Date: November 12, 2024
Welcome to another enlightening episode of Ridiculous History, where hosts Ben Boland and Noel Brown explore some of the most fascinating and unconventional stories from across human civilization. In this episode, "Bhutan Grades Itself On Happiness," the duo delves into the unique philosophy and practices of Bhutan, a small Himalayan kingdom renowned for prioritizing Gross National Happiness (GNH) over traditional economic indicators.
1. Introduction to Bhutan and Its Enigmatic Appeal
Ben Boland opens the episode by introducing Bhutan as a landlocked country nestled in the eastern Himalayas, often referred to as the "Shangri La" by travelers. He remarks, “For most people, the answer is no. And sadly, statistically, if you asked most of most Americans, we're Americans. If you ask most of us to point to Bhutan on a map, couldn't do it” (02:09).
Noel Brown humorously adds, “They call me Bilbo Bagman. It’s true” (01:14), setting a lighthearted tone as the hosts describe Bhutan's elusive presence on global maps and its status as the only Vajrayana Buddhist nation.
2. Historical Context: Bhutan’s Ancient Origins and the Spread of Buddhism
The conversation shifts to Bhutan's rich history, with Noel Brown providing insights into the introduction of Buddhism in the 7th century AD by Tibetan King Songsten Gampo (06:24). He elaborates on the Tibetan empire's expansion and Bhutan's consolidation under Buddhist theocracy by figures like Nawang Namgyal, who unified the warring clans and established impregnable fortresses known as "zongs" (07:11).
Ben Boland adds, “They didn’t say. He made some good points. No. This was the old story of historical conquest. Blood and treasure” (07:13), emphasizing the tumultuous methods of Bhutan's early unification.
3. The Philosophy of Gross National Happiness (GNH)
A significant portion of the episode is dedicated to Bhutan's groundbreaking approach to national success measurement. Noel Brown sets the stage: “Bhutan is not a big country by any means. It has a population of about 800,000 in 2024. It decided at some point not to grade its success in terms of gross domestic product, in terms of economic output” (04:40).
Ben Boland expands on this, stating, “Instead, they hung out. And back in the 1970s, they said maybe we should define success for our country by how happy the people living in it are” (05:19). This philosophy challenges the conventional GDP-centric view prevalent in Western nations.
The hosts discuss how Bhutan's GNH encompasses various facets such as socioeconomic equity, environmental conservation, cultural preservation, and governmental integrity. Noel Brown aptly summarizes, “That's a checklist of cool stuff” (15:37).
4. Bhutan’s Transition to Constitutional Monarchy and Democracy
The episode explores Bhutan's political evolution, highlighting the 2008 constitutional changes that shifted from absolute monarchy to a constitutional monarchy with democratic elements. Ben Boland recounts the struggle, noting, “The people of Bhutan, the Bhutanese weren’t super on board with this. They loved the king as a, this is a religious figure” (28:18).
Noel Brown reflects on the population's initial resistance to democracy, saying, “The people were not keen on embracing this” (27:50). They discuss the challenges faced during this transition, including concerns about replicating failed democracies seen in neighboring South Asian countries.
An insightful quote from Bhutan’s first democratically elected prime minister, Thinly, encapsulates the tension: “We'll break it up. Like you said, the people were not keen on bringing the kind of change that in their eyes and in their mind could not be very different from what they saw in the world at large” (31:02).
5. Cultural Heritage: Architecture, Art, and Daily Life
The hosts delve into Bhutan's vibrant cultural landscape, highlighting architectural marvels like the Tiger's Nest monastery. Noel Brown describes it as “mounted like on the sides of these incredible steep cliffsides and it’s an absolute marvel of engineering” (24:39).
Ben Boland shares his admiration for Bhutanese monasteries, stating, “I'm a nihilistic optimist. Okay, cool” (34:30), and humorously invites travelers to visit Bhutanese monasteries, ensuring a no "hot air balloons" policy (24:49).
The conversation also touches on Bhutan's unique traffic management, where Noel Brown observes, “There's no traffic lights in Bhutan at all” (35:44), comparing it to the manual traffic control similar to North Korea's approach.
6. Environmental Stewardship and Sustainable Practices
Bhutan's commitment to the environment is a recurring theme. Noel Brown proudly states, “At least 60 to 72, I think, 72% of its country remains forested” (22:49), highlighting Bhutan’s extensive forest cover and its status as a carbon-negative country.
Ben Boland explains, “Bhutan is better for the global environment” (38:12), attributing this to their rigorous conservation policies and minimal industrialization. The hosts admire Bhutan’s dedication to maintaining natural resources and preventing environmental degradation.
7. Travel to Bhutan: Challenges and Attractions
The episode offers practical insights for potential travelers. Ben Boland warns, “It’s going to be a make your peace with God stuff” (42:00), referring to the challenging landing at Bhutan's Paro Airport, one of the most difficult airports to navigate globally.
Travelers are encouraged to embrace Bhutan's unique experiences, from hiking the treacherous paths to the Tiger's Nest to immersing themselves in Bhutanese archery, the national sport with deep cultural and religious significance.
Noel Brown highlights Bhutanese cuisine, describing it as “similar in some. It’s a transit point, Right. Because we’ve got Indian cuisine coming in. We’ve got a certain kind of rice with a specifically unique, nutty flavor” (44:58), noting its distinct flavors and the prevalence of red chilies and cheese in their dishes.
8. Fun Facts and Trivia
To wrap up, the hosts share intriguing trivia about Bhutan:
- Nicknamed the "Land of the Thunder Dragon," Bhutan features the Druk, a mythical creature symbolizing strength and protection.
- Unique Traffic Control: Manual traffic direction replaces traffic lights in the capital.
- Endangered Wildlife: Bhutan is home to diverse endangered species, offering opportunities for cryptid enthusiasts.
- Penis Artwork: Commonly found flanking doorways and adorning rooftops, Bhutan embraces humorous and symbolic art forms (38:51).
Ben Boland humorously remarks, “You had me at penis artwork” (38:51), showcasing the hosts' playful dynamic.
9. Conclusion: Bhutan’s Inspirational Model and Its Global Relevance
The episode concludes with Ben Boland and Noel Brown reflecting on Bhutan's success with GNH and its potential applicability on a global scale. Ben Boland muses, “Could this only work in a very small isolated place high in the Himalaya, the so-called Kingdom of Heaven? Or just maybe could something like gross domestic happiness also make life a little better for all of us schmucks down here off the mountain?” (34:14).
Noel Brown optimistically adds, “I'm choosing to be optimistic about this” (34:20), inspiring listeners to consider alternative measures of national success beyond GDP.
Notable Quotes with Timestamps
- Noel Brown: “They call me Bilbo Bagman. It’s true” (01:14).
- Ben Boland: “For most people, the answer is no. And sadly, statistically, if you asked most of most Americans, we're Americans” (02:09).
- Ben Boland: “We need to figure out our country's vibe based on how much everybody wins” (15:37).
- Noel Brown: “We're not here to soapbox about any of this kind of stuff” (13:58).
- Noel Brown: “More money, more problems. I mean there's. That's absolutely true” (14:40).
- Ben Boland: “It is a theocracy, dude” (16:16).
- Ben Boland: “They’re home to a ton of endangered animals too” (37:26).
- Max Williams: “Penis artwork, I'm in” (39:06).
- Ben Boland: “Don't miss it” (27:18).
- Ben Boland: “Could this only work in a very small isolated place high in the Himalaya, the so-called Kingdom of Heaven?” (34:14).
Final Thoughts
"Bhutan Grades Itself On Happiness" offers a compelling look into a nation that dares to redefine success by prioritizing the well-being and happiness of its citizens over economic metrics. Through engaging discussions and insightful anecdotes, Ben Boland and Noel Brown illuminate Bhutan's unique approach, inspiring listeners to re-evaluate traditional paradigms of national prosperity.
Whether you're intrigued by Bhutan's historical journey, its cultural richness, or its environmental triumphs, this episode provides a comprehensive and entertaining exploration of why Bhutan stands out as a beacon of happiness and sustainability in the modern world.
For more fascinating episodes, tune into Ridiculous History on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or your preferred podcast platform.