
Loading summary
Ben Bolan
Ridiculous History is a production of iHeartradio. Welcome back to the show, fellow ridiculous historians. Thank you as always, so much for joining us. We've got none other than the man, the myth, the legend, Our super producer, Mr. Max Masshole Williams, joining us.
Max Williams
Are you a mask guy? You're. You're.
Jake Brennan
He's a Michigan guy.
Max Williams
You're a Michigan.
Jake Brennan
I'm a Michigander out the Michigan.
Ben Bolan
Yeah. Yeah. That's Mr. Noel Brown over there on the ones and twos.
Max Williams
I'm not from anywhere.
Ben Bolan
I don't.
Max Williams
I don't claim any. Any.
Ben Bolan
Yeah. A young German boy.
Max Williams
Oh, that's true. I am a. No, I was once a young German German boy.
Ben Bolan
I am legally required to disclose that I am called Ben Bolan in this world. And no, we had a fascinating conversation very many years ago when we were just absolutely fanboying about this crazy guy who is really fascinated. An author, a podcaster, I would say a thought leader, and one of the nicest people I've ever met from Massachusetts.
Max Williams
Are you talking about Johnny Ace? No, you're not.
Ben Bolan
Yet you're not.
Max Williams
You're talking about Jake Brennan.
Ben Bolan
None other than that.
Jake Brennan
You guys are too kind.
Max Williams
Well, you may have heard Jake unleashing earlier when we were talking that that's breaking the fourth wall, which wal.
Ben Bolan
The fourth wall. It is the fourth wall if you're talking to the audience.
Max Williams
That's right.
Ben Bolan
Jake Britton is here with us right now, coming to us live and direct. Jake, how you doing?
Jake Brennan
I'm fantastic. I'm stoked to be talking to you guys. Excited to be talking ridiculous music history. Fan of your show. And anytime I can talk about music with some informed lads, I'm happy. So we're right in my sweet spot this afternoon.
Max Williams
We're nothing if not informed lads. And as we talked about off mic, Ben is not only the king of. He's also the king of intros, and he really sets you up beautifully. Our buddy Jake is an incredible podcaster with the Disgraceland podcast and various music documentary podcasts that sort of have a take a true crime fusion with music history approach. And it's incredible video content that you may have seen go viral on the interwebs. And again, also an author. So we're super stoked to have you with us, Jake. Indeed. To talk about some ridiculous music history. This one's a little dark. It's one that maybe would also feel right at home on our sister podcast. Stuff they don't want you to know because we're talking about a bit of a history mystery involving a very influential musician by the name of Johnny Ace.
Jake Brennan
I've said multiple times, Johnny Ace, one of a kind. And I love this. I love the conversation because it fits in your wheelhouse. Guys, it's kind of like this story. 90% of people think it's one thing, but it's actually something else. So we're in that historical myth busting phase, which is a very cool spot to be this is an iHeart podcast.
Ben Bolan
Guaranteed Human this episode of Ridiculous History is brought to you in part by American Public University.
Max Williams
You're juggling a lot. Full time job, side hustle, maybe a family.
Ben Bolan
And now you're thinking about grad school.
Max Williams
That's not crazy, that's ambitious.
Ben Bolan
At American Public University, they respect the Hustle and they're built for it.
Max Williams
Their flexible online Master's programs are made for real life because big dreams deserve a real path.
Ben Bolan
Learn more about APU's 40 plus career relevant master's degrees and certificates at APU APUS.
Max Williams
Edu APU built for the hustle. Man, people really love Harry Potter and you too now can experience Harry Potter stories like you've never heard them before on Audible.
Ben Bolan
Yeah, that's right. Harry Potter the Full Cast Audio Editions presents J.K. rowling's iconic series as a phenomenal spellbinding listening event for your entire.
Max Williams
The first story in the series, Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone, is available now, with new audiobooks in the series releasing every month thereafter.
Ben Bolan
It's Harry Potter like you've never heard it before. Listen on audible. Go to audible.com HP1 and start listening today.
Max Williams
Everybody knows Shaq, but off camera, he's.
Ben Bolan
Just a regular guy.
Sleep Apnea Ad Voice
People never believe me when I say I'm just like them. I take out the trash, do dishes, and I struggle with moderate obstructive sleep apnea, or osa. And a lot of adults with obesity also struggle with moderate to severe osa. You know those skin, scary breathing, interruptions during sleep, the loud snoring, choking and daytime fatigue? I knew I had to talk to my doctor. Don't sleep on the symptoms. Learn more at don'tsleeponosa.com this information is.
Max Williams
Provided by Lilly, a medicine company. If you're a maintenance supervisor at a manufacturing facility, your job is a little like being a historian. You have to keep the past alive, including your older machines.
Ben Bolan
So when you notice a set of drive belts is showing wear and tear, you call on Grainger.
Max Williams
Grainger makes it easy to find and order the products you need and their next day delivery can help you keep your machines working like the day they were made, no matter how long ago that was.
Ben Bolan
So call 1-800-GRAINGER, click grainger.com or just.
Max Williams
Stop by Grainger for the ones who get it done.
Starbucks Ad Voice
The holidays are back at Starbucks, so share the season with a peppermint mocha. Starbucks signature espresso, velvety mocha and cool peppermint notes topped with whipped cream and dark chocolate curls together is the best place to be at Starbucks.
Ben Bolan
Now, Jake, you're a legendary. I would call you a journalist at this point as well as a storyteller. So can you introduce us for anyone who is unfamiliar to, to this character? Johnny?
Jake Brennan
Sure. Johnny Ace, a Memphis musician sort of in the years just prior to Elvis breaking out as a. First a regional star in the south and then as a global superstar. So Johnny Ace, look at it this way. Like, Elvis is 16 years old and he's. He's lurking around Memphis, these clubs. He's kind of like looking into windows to the black clubs to watch Ike.
Max Williams
Turner and stealing all their moves.
Jake Brennan
Yeah, exactly. And B.B. king and, and Johnny A.C. is one of these guys. Johnny Ace was at first the piano player in B.B. king's. B.B. king's band called the Beale Streeters before B.B. king became huge. And of course, if you saw the Elvis movie, they. They get into the relationship between Elvis and B.B. king. But Johnny Ace was like, you know, there's. There's cool musicians or there's cool people and then there's just like, cool. There's a level of cool that's like extraterrestrial.
Ben Bolan
Like, like even like, like Tom Waits.
Max Williams
Yeah, exactly.
Jake Brennan
You nailed it. Like, like how, how David obsessed with Iggy Pops cool. Like that's, that's what Johnny Ace was. He was just this like, young dude in Memphis who was just the coolest guy. And Elvis and many others loved him. And after, you know, Johnny Ace is in PB King's band, he starts a solo career after that and he starts to have some, some hits on the R B charts under his own name, Johnny Ace.
Max Williams
And there's a certain kind of cool that you're describing that also comes along with a little crazy.
Jake Brennan
Yes.
Max Williams
If I'm not mistaken. I mean, I think I'm not mistaken. We've observed it in Folks. Do you like mentioned with Iggy Pop. Bowie certainly had his crazy days that he got past, you know, God rest his soul, but where he was just sustaining on milk and red peppers and cocaine while watching like, Nazi propaganda videos in his murder mansion.
Ben Bolan
You get in situations. Is it crazy to be cool, or is it cool to be crazy? That seems like a thesis statement we're going to be following along with. Right. So, Jake, what first drew you to the story of this up and coming cool, crazy musician Johnny Ace?
Max Williams
The name to go along with it, too.
Jake Brennan
Yeah, the name is Radh.
Max Williams
Is that a Christian name? Do we know this?
Jake Brennan
I doubt it.
Max Williams
Okay, fair, Fair.
Ben Bolan
Okay. Johnny Asowitz. Excuse me. All right, so give us the provenance, the origin story, if you may.
Jake Brennan
Well, I first, I first heard the myth, which is what most people hear. And there's a great book by, I believe, Grail Marcus. And it has all sort of these short little. It's an anthology book much like my own, but it's way better. It's all about these sort of unknown hellraisers from the early rock and roll and R and B days. And there's a.
Max Williams
And I have to be honest, I was not aware of Johnny Ace at all before you texted us about this topic. And I do know the Elvis song, but kind of only in passing. So I really am excited to dig into more of this history. But you mention the kind of provenance or the legend, the myth behind this sort of inciting event that caused us.
Jake Brennan
To talk about this guy today.
Ben Bolan
I'm just gonna. Jake, I'm gonna interrupt you to brag about you, Noel. I'm just gonna pile on. Jake has a book out pretty recently called Disgraceland. Musicians Getting Away With Murder and Behaving Very Badly. I did read it. I do think it's. Beat me here, Max. I think it's amazing.
Jake Brennan
Wow. Very well done. Thank you so much. I really appreciate that. There's a through line in that book thematically about grief, which is a big part of the Graham Parsons chapter in that book and the two Elvis chapters. And Elvis was, I believe, perpetually. Others believe this as well, sort of perpetually grieving this loss. Lost like a phantom limb, which was the death of his. Of his twin brother who died at childbirth. And a lot of people think, you know, if they're going to analyze him, armchair psychologist, that that's sort of why he was so excessive. He was trying to compensate for this thing. And it. It plays into this story somewhat as well. You know, it's like. You guys know what it's like because you're so.
Ben Bolan
You're.
Jake Brennan
You're so. You're so music and culture conscious. You know, like, you come up in a. In a scene and you have. I'm. I'm talking about from Elvis's perspective. And they're sort of like cool guys in your local. Local scene, whatever it is, if it's music or if it's acting or if it's podcasting. And you're kind of. You just. You just. I mean, honestly. No, it was a lot like the. The whole, like, stuff you should know crew at iHeart. When I first got into podcasting, I was like, I want these guys to think I'm cool.
Ben Bolan
Me. Let me put my hands by the window, you know, while you guys are playing. Yeah, I know piano.
Jake Brennan
Yeah, well.
Max Williams
And also, I mean, you know, it's people you look up to. It's people that you want to hear. It's the only way you get those stories, and it's the only real way to learn about a world like that, whether it be podcasting or blues music. And those things are definitely equivalent. And I. And you could fight me on that. I will die on that hill. They are the same. Yes, but, no. These people are hugely important to the oral tradition and to kind of carrying on a legacy and a through line, through a genre of music or a scene, much like you're talking about there in Memphis, which is a storied music scene.
Jake Brennan
Right. And so that's who Johnny Ace was to Elvis Presley. He was the cool kid on the block and kind of obscure, and he remained that way even in his passing while Elvis was still alive. And the inciting incident, the myth, if you will, is this story. And I'm going to get back to answering your question, Ben. This story that Johnny Ace, this great R B singer who died at the age of 25 years old, tragically from playing Russian roulette. So I kind of heard that in passing as a young man. And then when I started the Disgraceland podcast and I'm looking for these sort of music and true crime stories that I can tell, this pops up on the radar and I start researching it, and I'm like, motherf. Er didn't die from Russian Roulette. Oh, man, that's not at all what happened. I mean, it kind of is part of the story, but that's not what happened.
Ben Bolan
It's a myth, though, right?
Jake Brennan
It is a myth, and this is my fate. These are my favorite types of stories. When you can really. When you can do a podcast episode, there's a couple other big ones that are just like this. Like, Mama Cass Elliott from the Mamas and Papas did not die. She did not die from choking on a ham sandwich. You know, Michael Hutchins from INXS did not die. From autoerotic asphyxiation.
Ben Bolan
And it was not Robert Johnson, but Bobby Johnson.
Jake Brennan
Tommy Johnson. Tommy Johnson.
Ben Bolan
Tommy Johnson. Yeah, I'm actually good at this.
Jake Brennan
I'm actually. My head is fully in the Robert Johnson thing right now because I'm working on a documentary about how this is kind of the take on my Robert Johnson episode that, okay, Robert Johnson did not sell his soul to the devil. Robert Johnson was the devil.
Max Williams
Hell, yeah.
Ben Bolan
What if you actually.
Max Williams
I support that fully.
Jake Brennan
If you get into how Robert Johnson behaved and what he did and what he said about God and how he spoke about faithful people and people who had faith around his. His friends stopped hanging around with him because they were so like, this guy's on a level.
Max Williams
He got too spooky.
Jake Brennan
Yeah, he got two. And then the whole trope of selling your soul to the devil, I mean, that's kind of a grail. Marcus makes the point that that's kind of a racist explanation of being how.
Max Williams
You got so good.
Jake Brennan
The only way. Exactly. Of white journals possible. Exactly. They couldn't. They couldn't explain his talent, which. The guy sounds like he's playing guitar with three hands. It's incredible.
Ben Bolan
Yeah. Maybe he just. What's the old joke? How do I get to Broadway? Says a tourist in New York. Local says, I think practice Carnegie hall.
Max Williams
But Broadway works as well.
Jake Brennan
Both of those.
Max Williams
You got to practice.
Jake Brennan
Can I tell you a quick myth busting story about that? How do you get to Carnegie hall for practice? So I've actually played Carnegie hall and I didn't practice at all. A friend of mine was part of Patti Smith's birthday party as a performer. My friend Adam from Low Cut Connie, about four or five years ago at Carnegie Hall. And Patty gets out there and she's doing Gloria. And I'm sidestage with all these musicians, and all these musicians, Josh Ritter and David Johansson, they just start walking out on stage to sing backups. And I'm like, I just kind of got caught up with them all and.
Max Williams
I walked out on stage. That's how you do it.
Jake Brennan
And the next day, there's a picture of me in Rolling Stone behind Patti Smith in Carnegie Hall.
Ben Bolan
That's amazing. So one thing we love about a chorus is everyone can sing along, hopefully. Exactly.
Jake Brennan
Yes.
Ben Bolan
And again, Tom Waits, if you're listening, you are part of Americana, and we'd love for you to hang out with Jake on his show. Jake, the boys and I were very close to getting Tom Waits to do a show with us. True story. He only accepts payments in 1957 used Chevy car parts.
Max Williams
It's true. And also, you know, pirate doubloons.
Jake Brennan
I literally, I literally can't tell if you're with me or not.
Max Williams
I can't either, Jake. And I usually can't. And that's just the way of the world.
Jake Brennan
Like, I would believe that from Tom Waits.
Max Williams
Like, I would believe that a million percent.
Ben Bolan
Man.
Max Williams
I love that. What a good lo fi trick he used to do. And he would just have like, what is it? Like chalk dust, like on the stage. And he's just stomping in the chalk dust and it just looks like he's just kicking up dust clouds. Coolest thing. What a cool guy. I'd love to go back really quickly to your point about the racist trope or the inherent racist trope of like selling your soul to the devil. Because nobody accused Django Reinhardt of selling his soul to the devil. And that guy played guitar with two fingers.
Ben Bolan
Yeah. So I'm just the othering.
Jake Brennan
Yeah, yeah. Or Tony Iommi from Black Sabbath, who literally doesn't have fingertips and has somehow, somehow figured out how to create an entire genre called heavy metal. No one accused him of selling his soul to the devil either. Yeah, I don't know. I mean, I don't think it's one of these things that was like purposefully racist or whatever. It's just like, it just happened. And it's interesting when you actually unpack it. And that trope, it goes back like me and the devil walking or whatever the lyric is from Robert Johnson. It actually goes back to the sort of blackface minstrel lyrics that back then those songs were considered pop music. So Robert Johnson would play those. So the reality is he got a lot of that devil imagery in his lyrics from white dudes in blackface who were, who were co opting black music from the slave era. You know what I'm saying?
Max Williams
So it's just so weird for him to be revving to reverse cover the songs that were co opting this imagined version of his legacy or his, you know, his people. That's really wild.
Ben Bolan
Fascinating. Mirrors Upon Mirrors Game of Telephone this episode of Ridiculous History is brought to you in part by American Public University.
Max Williams
You're juggling a lot. Full time job, side Hustle, maybe a family.
Ben Bolan
And now you're thinking about grad school.
Max Williams
That's not crazy, that's ambitious.
Ben Bolan
At American Public University, they respect the hustle and they're built for it.
Max Williams
Their flexible online master's programs are made for real life because big dreams deserve.
Ben Bolan
A real path learn more about APU's 40 plus career relevant master's degrees and certificates at Apu Apus.
Max Williams
Edu Apu Built for the Hustle man. People really love Harry Potter and you too now can experience Harry Potter stories like you've never heard them before on Audible.
Ben Bolan
Yeah, that's right, Harry Potter the Full Cast Audio Editions presents J.K. rowling's iconic series as a phenomenal, spellbinding listening event for your entire family.
Max Williams
It is quite the romp. The Full Cast Audio Editions features a spectacular a list cast including Hugh Laurie. I think we all love we love Hugh as Albus. Yeah yeah. Dr. House, MD as Albus Dumbledore and Riz Ahmed as Severus Snape.
Ben Bolan
Folks, this one is just phenomenal. For any fellow longtime Harry Potter fans, this is a delightful new way to introduce the stories to a new generation.
Max Williams
The first story in the series, Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone is available now with new audiobooks in the series releasing every month thereafter.
Ben Bolan
It's Harry Potter like you've never heard it before. Listen on audible, go to audible.com HP1 and start listening today.
BritBox Ad Voice
It's the coziest time of year on Britbox. That means curling up with a gripping murder mystery basking in a sumptuous period drama, or the discovering a new hidden gem. See the holidays differently when you stream the best of British TV with BritBox. Watch BritBox original series, including the new season of the award winning Belfast police drama Blue Lights. However you cozy this holiday, it's a bit warmer with Britbox. Watch with a free trial@britbox.com these days.
Okta Ad Voice
It seems like AI agents are just about everywhere you turn, every field and every function. But without identity, you can't trust they'll serve your business instead of jeopardizing it. Fortunately, Okta helps you get identity right by securing your AI agents identities, giving you a single layer of control, a single standard of trust. So whether an AI agent supports a single user or your entire enterprise, with Okta you'll turn risk into opportunity. Secure every agent. Secure any agent. Okta secures AI.
Max Williams
Everybody knows Shaq, but off camera, he's just a regular guy.
Sleep Apnea Ad Voice
People never believe me when I say I'm just like them. I take out the trash, do dishes, and I struggle with moderate obstructive sleep apnea or osa. And a lot of adults with obesity also struggle with moderate to severe osa. You know, those scary breathing interruptions during sleep, the loud snoring, choking and daytime fatigue. I knew I had to talk to my doctor don't sleep on the symptoms. Learn more at don't sleep on OSA.com.
Max Williams
This information is provided by Lilly, a medicine company.
Ben Bolan
As we continue. Jake Noll. I believe we need to explain just briefly what we mean by Russian roulette, which is itself also mythologized, for sure.
Max Williams
And it's also one of those things where. Yeah, it's exactly. There's a lot of Russian. There's a whole movie about it where there's, like, a Russian roulette club. I forget what it's called, but it's like a Eastern European art film. And it's about this, like, fight club where people, like, play Russian roulette for whatever, as high stakes as you could possibly have. So. Yes, do tell.
Jake Brennan
Jake.
Max Williams
Yeah, give us a little bit about Russian.
Ben Bolan
What is it?
Jake Brennan
Well, if you would Both refer to the 32 snub nodes I sent to both of you.
Max Williams
Right.
Ben Bolan
Yeah. Thank you.
Jake Brennan
Load both of those up. It's a utility gun. Yeah, There you go. And then. Yeah, just there's one bullet in the. In one bullet in the. In the. What do they call it, the chamber there or the barrel? I don't even know. Just, you know, make that go whirly, whirl.
Max Williams
And then.
Jake Brennan
And then. I got it.
Sleep Apnea Ad Voice
Put it to your.
Jake Brennan
Put it here. Yep, there you go. There you go. Now we don't know where the bullet is. There's.
Max Williams
You gotta do the hard click and close it, though. That's the most badass move, is when you spin it.
Ben Bolan
Hang on, hang on, hang on.
Jake Brennan
Okay, There you go. So now there's six options. There's six places that bullet might be. It's only going to be in one. You have a one in six chance of shooting yourself in the head if you put that gun, that.32 snub nose to your temple and pull the trigger. Now, I know we're not actually going to reenact that scene from Deer Hunter right here, as much as I kind of want to, but this is what Johnny Ace would do for fun in addition to drinking quarts of vodka.
Ben Bolan
No way.
Jake Brennan
This was his sort of, like, parlor trick that he would whip out backstage to sort of entertain his friends.
Max Williams
He was just quite a fan of just waving his piece around in general. And when I say his piece, I mean his pistol.
Jake Brennan
Oh, we know what you meant, though. We know.
Max Williams
Thank you.
Ben Bolan
Thank you. So, okay, so this is different from Australian roulette, which, as we know, is the thing where you aim the gun at your lower parts. Yeah, I'm doing geography jokes. They're not all gonna land.
Max Williams
Gotta land. I thought that was real too.
Ben Bolan
So one out of six. And this guy, John Marshall Alexander, right?
Jake Brennan
Full name for Johnny Ace. Yeah, if you say so. But I have it somewhere. But yeah, that makes sense.
Ben Bolan
Okay, so Johnny Ace were going by this guy. This guy would literally Jake backstage, he would put a gun to his head.
Jake Brennan
Yeah, yeah.
Ben Bolan
Do the spin and the click.
Jake Brennan
Yeah. So this is a Christmas story because this.
Max Williams
Oh, we forgot to mention. This is our holiday episode.
Ben Bolan
This is our holiday episode. Thank you, Starbucks.
Jake Brennan
Merry Christmas. So this happens on Christmas Day, 1954. He's backstage. Johnny Ace is backstage with his label mate and friend, Big Mama Thornton, who had the first hit with the Lieber and Stoler tune Hound Dog, which Elvis made a massive hit with later on. So it's Johnny Ace, Big Mama Thornton backstage and Johnny Ace's girlfriend at the time, Olivia. And B.B. king is out on stage. This is in Houston. He's playing with. It's kind of like a big review show. And I think Johnny Otis is kind of like the. The mc. So there's a whole thing going on out there. Johnny Ace has already played, I believe, and he's back there and he's getting shit face. He was want to do with a quart of vodka. And he's, you know, entertaining, quote unquote, Olivia, his girl, and Big Mama Thornton by playing Russian or trying to play Russian roulette. Typically when you. This is the thing, this is where the myth comes into play. When you play Russian roulette, it's three or four guys sitting around a table. Like we are virtual table, but a real table. And. And you. You spin the barrel and you click. And if you survive, you pass the gun to somebody else. And people are betting on this and you're betting on this as well. Then you just gun around until someone actually kills himself. And this was. That's Russian roulette.
Ben Bolan
Well, you spin it between the turns.
Jake Brennan
You spin it between the turns. I believe.
Max Williams
Can I just say, the film that I was talking about, I just looked it up and it's called 13, and it's pretty cool. And in this article that mentions 13 from Russia beyond, they have some pretty cool stats. So they break it down. The first attempt, you got a 16.6% chance. The second, 20% chance. The third, 25%. The fourth, 33.3. And the fifth, fifth, 50. The sixth shot, of course, is always fatal.
Jake Brennan
Oh, okay.
Ben Bolan
That's why you spin it between the turns, because you want to keep the casino going.
Jake Brennan
But it Sounds like.
Max Williams
Okay, you don't have to. This is a version of it, too, where maybe you don't spin it, but, like, you. You know, wherever it starts, you've got that many. You know, you're gonna potentially land on the bullet eventually. It could be two away, it could be three away, it could be four away. So maybe you don't. If you don't spin it, it. Those are the odds.
Ben Bolan
I like your reference to Deer Hunter, Jake, which is fundamental. It's fundamentally important to this because it already tells us our protagonist here, Johnny Ace, is meeting with, you know, secular popular success. But he's maybe not in the best place mentally if he's drinking a quart of vodka and then saying.
Max Williams
Playing with guns.
Ben Bolan
Yeah. And saying, hey, you know what we should do while I'm drunk? We should try to shoot each other in the head.
Jake Brennan
Yeah. I couldn't get a lot of info on Johnny Ace's state of mind. There's not a lot written about him. But what I did uncover is that. And this goes to sort of the conspiracy around this. Okay, so there's the myth and there's the conspiracy. And I'm going to comment on your comment, Ben, by setting these two up. So the myth is, of course, he died playing Russian roulette, which he did not. He eventually does in front of Big Mama Thornton, and Johnny Ace shoot himself and dies backstage.
Ben Bolan
Right.
Jake Brennan
So that's. The myth is that he played Russian roulette. No one else was playing. They were trying to get him to stop, and he wouldn't stop. Okay, There's. There's a conspiracy, and then there's the truth, which is conspiracy adjacent, that I happen to believe. So the conspiracy is that Big Mama Thornton snuck a bullet into the.22 that Johnny Ace had because she was just.
Max Williams
Tired of all his shenanigans, all his foolishness. He had just been acting a fool backstage, just drinking too much, throwing weapons around. She was just like, I'm putting a stop to this.
Ben Bolan
And now we're at folklore.
Jake Brennan
Yes.
Ben Bolan
So that's a yes. So we're saying the hidden bullet is the conspiracy theory.
Jake Brennan
This is the conspiracy. Now people actually believe this. I'm not one of them. People believe the Big Mom Authority, Jordan had done this on behest of a guy named Don Roby, who is the most fascinating character in the story. Don Roby was a proto Suge knight. Don Roby was to R B what Al Capone was to the Chicago Mafia. Don Roby was a larger than life, violent, exploitative, black, Jewish gangster. From Houston, didn't he?
Max Williams
Wasn't he a label head? Kind of.
Jake Brennan
Yes, he was the head.
Max Williams
Was it Duke Records?
Jake Brennan
He was the head of a record label that was first called Peacock. And then he merged that with a white radio promoter, last name of Mattis, who had a label called Duke. And then it became Duke Peacock for a while, to paint the picture of who this guy was, he also had a club called like the Golden Peacock. Wasn't the Golden Peacock, but it was something Peac in Houston. And every Saturday morning he would take all the cash he made at the club the night before, throw it in a burlap bag, put it over his shoulder, take his shotgun, put two shells in the shotgun, put that on his other shoulder and waltz downtown through Houston, daring anyone to with him while he went to the bank to deposit the money. He did this himself because he did not believe that anybody was tough enough. Tough as him, violent as him. Violent enough to fend off anybody who would actually try to rob him.
Max Williams
It was also a bit of flex to like show how tough. Oh, yeah, Just parade through the street like that.
Ben Bolan
Yes. Like you were saying, Jake, Suge Knight is a pretty good analog.
Jake Brennan
Yes, exactly.
Ben Bolan
Okay, so we got this. We got this character.
Jake Brennan
Yes. So Don Roby had all his bases covered. He had. He had the label which Johnny Ace was signed to. And Big Mama Thornton, Peacock Records.
Max Williams
Venue.
Jake Brennan
Right, the venue, the whatever. Peacock Club.
Ben Bolan
And then probably also had such a. You could probably also touch local politicians, maybe law enforcement.
Jake Brennan
I don't know about that. Who knows? Probably. I mean, who knows what those relationships are? But he also had. He was a booking agent. And he was one of the first successful promoters on what would become to be known the Chitlin Circuit, which was the black R and B network of clubs throughout America during this time. So he represented. He was the first. He represented Little Richard early on on the road. He represented Clarence Gatemouth Brown and T Bone Walker, these Texas blues musicians. So he's kind of got his hands. He's all over the board and. And what he wants more than anything. What Don Roby wants more than anything is a hit on the. The white pop charts. Now Johnny Ace had a hit on the R and B chart. Number one hit with. Oh, God. What was the name of the song? My Song. That was the name of the song. My Song. Number one hit for Johnny Ace on the R B charts. Didn't sniff the pop charts. Big Mama Thornton, she does the Lieber and Stoler song. Ain't Nothing But a Hound Dog. It's It's a hit on the R B charts and Elvis covers it and it becomes a huge hit on the white charts. But then it becomes kind of a novelty song. But Don Roby starts to get a sniff of how much money is available if you can get a chart on the white. If you can get a song on the white chart on the pop chart. So he really wants this for Johnny Ace. He thinks Johnny Ace is so cool. He's got the charisma to actually be able to pull this off, to cross over. And it doesn't happen for Johnny Ace. Now this when Johnny shoots himself, it's 1954. What? That's on Christmas Day. On New Year's Day, 1953, Hank Williams dies. And what happens to Hank Williams single at the time? It rockets up the charts and it becomes a number one hit. Not on the country charts, on the pop charts. And Don Roby goes, oh, okay, okay. When you die, when Hank Williams I'll never Get out of this World Alive is available for the public as a single and the artist dies, that'll go to the number one. Number one on the pop charts.
Ben Bolan
This episode of Ridiculous History is brought to you in part by American Public University.
Max Williams
You're juggling a lot. Full time job, side hustle, maybe a family.
Ben Bolan
And now you're thinking about grad school.
Max Williams
That's not crazy, that's ambitious.
Ben Bolan
At American Public University they respect the hustle and they're built for it.
Max Williams
Their flexible online master's programs are made for real life because big dreams deserve a real path.
Ben Bolan
Learn more about APU's 40 plus career relevant master's degrees and certificates at APU.
Max Williams
APUS EDU APU built for the hustle, man. People really love Harry Potter and you too now can experience Harry Potter stories like you've never heard them before on audible.
Ben Bolan
Yeah, that's right. Harry Potter. The Full cast Audio Editions presents J.K. rowling's iconic series as a phenomenal spellbinding listening event for your entire.
Max Williams
It is quite the romp. The full cast audio editions features a spectacular a list cast including Hugh Laurie. I think we all love. We love Hugh as Albus. Yeah, yeah. Dr. House, M.D. as Albus Dumbledore and Riz Ahmed as Severus Snape.
Ben Bolan
Folks, this one is just phenomenal. For any fellow longtime Harry Potter fans, this is a delightful new way to introduce the stories to a new generation.
Max Williams
The first story in the series, Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone is available now. With new audiobooks in the series releasing every month thereafter.
Ben Bolan
It's Harry Potter like you've never heard it before. Listen on audible go to audible.com HP1 and start listening today.
BritBox Ad Voice
It's the coziest time of year on BritBox. That means curling up with a gripping murder mystery, basking in a sumptuous period drama, or discovering a new hidden gem. See the holidays differently when you stream the best of British TV with BritBox. Watch Britbox original series, including the new season of the award winning Belfast police drama Blue Lights. However you cozy this holiday, it's a bit warmer with Britbox. Watch with a free trial@britbox.com these days.
Okta Ad Voice
It seems like AI agents are just about everywhere you turn, every field and every function. But without identity, you can't trust they'll serve your business business instead of jeopardizing it. Fortunately, Okta helps you get identity right by securing your AI agents identities, giving you a single layer of control, a single standard of trust. So whether an AI agent supports a single user or your entire enterprise, with Okta you'll turn risk into opportunity. Secure every agent, secure any agent. Okta secures AI and Now Superhuman Shack.
Sleep Apnea Ad Voice
I keep telling them not to say that. I'm no superhuman. Believe it or not, I struggle with moderate obstructive sleep apnea, or osa in adults with obesity. Moderate to severe OSA is a condition where breathing is interrupted during sleep, with loud snoring, choking, gasping for air, and even daytime fatigue. Let's just say it could sound a lot like this. Sound familiar? Learn more@don'tsleeponosa.com this information is provided by.
Max Williams
Lilly, a medicine company. Maybe not with singles per se, but we've seen plenty of that phenomenon with like the death of Prince or David Bowie. Like all of a sudden Purple Rain's like on the charts again and people are just hard to find a reissue of, you know. So this is very real phenomenon. The question then becomes was the dude just a little bit callous in releasing the single postmortem, or did he actually manipulate events to create the situation that led to Johnny Ace's untimely demise?
Jake Brennan
Yeah, so that that single, Johnny Ace's single at the time, the day he died on Christmas, was Pledging My Love was actually already out. It had just been released. So the conspiracy piece of this is that people think Don Roby had manipulated Big Mama Thor Horton into doing his bidding by slipping that bullet in the chamber. So if you think Don Roby wants this number one hit, he wants Johnny Ace dead, then you've got motive. If you think that Johnny Ace is A reckless drunkard who likes a lot of gunplay. Then you've got. Then you've got means. And that's sort of how the conspiracy took off.
Max Williams
Right?
Ben Bolan
Yeah.
Max Williams
And then the question becomes, I don't know, we. We talk about stuff like this on our other show, stuff they don't want you to know with our buddy Matt quite a lot. And oftentimes, the more Elabor conspiracy, the less likely such a conspiracy was required to make the thing happen.
Jake Brennan
Yes. You know what I mean?
Max Williams
Like, it's just the situation was already rife for dude, right. Blow his own head off by drinking too much and, you know, flashing his gun around.
Jake Brennan
You're exactly right. You're exactly right. And this is where the myth busting piece comes into play, too, because what happens after he dies is it's perfect for Don Roby because the press being the duplicitous, lying scumbags that they just have forever been sure they pick up the story and they leave out half the facts. And literally the headlines are that he died playing Russian roulette. And he's got this song called Pledging My love, and it starts to go up the charts and it starts to become a huge hit. And Don Roby's not going to call anyone up at the Houston Chronicle and be like, oh, excuse me, you got that wrong. No, he didn't die from Russian roulette. He died because he was drunk and playing with a gun. So the myth just is allowed to take shape. The records start to sell, and a.
Max Williams
Guy like that can't buy that kind of coverage. And that's just the right level of getting it wrong that benefits him because it creates this mythological larger than life, this crazy guy, not just this drunken buffoon who maybe had a little too much to drink and accidentally shot himself.
Ben Bolan
Well, now it's folklore. Now it's zeitgeist. Now it's also. So as you said, Jake, it's hitting past the chitlin circuit. Right. It's public interest. Everybody is talking about it at the proverbial water cooler of the day. What happens to Ruby?
Jake Brennan
In a just fantastic stroke of irony, Elvis is fishing around for songs for what would become his last record. And this is in 1976, and he still has his fascination with Memphis boy Johnny Ace. So Elvis records Pledging my love, and then Elvis dies.
Max Williams
The double tap.
Ben Bolan
The double tap.
Jake Brennan
Yeah, exactly. And Elvis is album is not a critical success. That last record, I believe, is called Blue. What is it called?
Max Williams
Moody Blue.
Jake Brennan
Moody Blue. Thank you, Noel. And. But it Sells a ton as his albums did. And what happens is Don Roby rakes in the royalties and his estate anyways. Rakes in the royalties because Don Roby's dead by that point. I don't remember how he met his end, but the sad irony is that Johnny Ace's family received.
Ben Bolan
I wasn't gonna say, yeah, nothing, zip, zilch.
Max Williams
It's a good example of people like that that are taking advantage of, you know, there's this guise of like, I'm going to help you out, I'm going to lift you up out of the ghetto or whatever it might be, because you're my people and I have your best interest at heart. But there's just as many examples of people like that taking advantage of their own, you know, folks and then giving bad contracts, you know, making duplicitous deals and then just keeping the money for themselves.
Jake Brennan
Or worse, dudes like Don Roby forcing their way into co writes even though they had nothing to do with the song. You know what I mean? Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Ben Bolan
Oh, man, that still happens, doesn't it?
Jake Brennan
I wouldn't doubt it. It's hard.
Max Williams
Yeah, yeah, it's. It's certainly. There were. There was a. There was a golden age for that kind of stuff in politics. I mean, maybe it happens more in politics, but in music it's a little harder to get away with that, I think, these days. But we also have, you know, some. Some Johnny A songs being covered by some other pretty big names. Bob Dylan and Joan Baez did one of his tunes, Never Let on the Rolling Thunder Review, which I think is featured in some of the film clips from that incredible tour. Luther Vandross did a cover in the 90s of a song that he had recorded originally. And then of course, the biggest one was Elvis's Pledging My Love, which was on that 1976 record you're talking about.
Jake Brennan
Yeah, yeah.
Ben Bolan
Now, as we said, Johnny Ace passes away in what may seem like a long time ago. Right. But we must remember, history is always closer than it looks in the rear view mirror. A lot of people show up to the funeral. Right. And I've got to ask you, Jake, is our buddy Don alive at this point? Does he show up to see the passage of Johnny Ace?
Jake Brennan
He's definitely alive then. Yeah, for sure. And I can't say that I know he did or did not, but I would bet money that he did. He was still sort of milking the cow at that point financially, and he was heavily invested in.
Max Williams
And he had an appearance to keep up. Because it wasn't going to be immediately apparent that he was taking everybody to the cleaners.
Ben Bolan
He has to be supportive.
Max Williams
The same way of the community. Yeah, yeah.
Ben Bolan
Who's that? Who's that dude who took advantage of Elvis Presley?
Jake Brennan
The Colonel was.
Max Williams
The Colonel.
Jake Brennan
Tom Hanks.
Ben Bolan
The Colonel. Yeah. Yeah. Okay.
Max Williams
Weirdly as hell portrayed by Tom Hanks in the Elvis movie.
Ben Bolan
What? Tom Hanks.
Max Williams
What an odd performance. I'm sorry, man.
Jake Brennan
I don't.
Max Williams
We don't. I don't. Footage of this guy. I don't know what he was like, but Tom made some choices.
Ben Bolan
Yeah, Tom from earlier. That guy is so wholesome. You know, his main thing that Tom Hanks loves is typewriters.
Jake Brennan
Oh, really?
Ben Bolan
More than acting? Yeah, he collects typewriters. Really? Yeah. And Jake, if you. If you have a typewriter and you type out a letter and send it to him, he'll probably type a letter back.
Max Williams
I love that. Nice. It's kind of cool. It's like Neil Young and his model trains. Yeah.
Jake Brennan
Yeah. It's like Nolan, his cocaine habit.
Max Williams
If you and my modular synths excuse you.
Sleep Apnea Ad Voice
Exactly.
Ben Bolan
All right, Max, we'll keep.
Max Williams
All stays. We get debauched when Jake's around. Do you have any other, like, little closing thoughts or takeaways from the story or how it kind of. Maybe you mentioned the. It tied into that grief aspect that was such a through line in your book. I'm curious as to maybe how. How some of the. This fits in with that.
Jake Brennan
Well, I sort of imagine Elvis Presley sitting in his jungle room, which was the. The man cave at Graceland, sort of, you know, it's Christmas time. The snow is falling lightly outside, and he's, you know, he's. You know, his grief kind of comes back around the holidays. I'm not the first one to say that. And I could see him at that time sort of, you know, it's 1976. He's in bad, bad shape. And he's. He's fishing around, he's thinking about his brother and he's. He's thinking about that song Pledging My Love. And I could just, you know, I could see that all clicking into place dramatically and being motivation for Elvis to. To cover that tune.
Max Williams
Oh, my God. You paint a picture, my friend. I'm right there with you. Yeah, no, that's. What a great little. Little Christmas bow to put on. This pretty dark Christmas story also.
Ben Bolan
Yeah. We all think. Think a little bit about melancholy at this time of the year. A little bit of nostalgia. Right. And we get we all get a little Counting Crows, Long December, I would say.
Max Williams
Which I think, to Ben's point from earlier, is a Christmas song if you want it to be.
Ben Bolan
I love that.
Max Williams
I love that.
Jake Brennan
I'm taping a show later today about Christmas movies that aren't Christmas movies. And I'm gonna. I'm gonna. I'm gonna steal that idea and pass it off as my own on Ben something.
Ben Bolan
Please.
Max Williams
I give you full permission on Ben's behalf.
Ben Bolan
Yeah. Thank you, Noel, for giving Jake permission for my idea. There is one conspiracy theory we have to ask you about, since you are our expert on music history and if you'd like to be a returning correspondent, we'd be absolutely just over the moon to have you. Have you ever heard, Jake, the idea that Elvis Presley is a Melungeon?
Jake Brennan
First of all, I'd love to come back anytime I might discredit myself here in that endeavor by saying I don't know what a Melungeon is. What are we talking about?
Ben Bolan
What is that, Jake? It's a tri racial isolate in East Tennessee with dodgy genetics, usually accused historically of being. See, how's it go, Noel? It goes well.
Max Williams
It's considered a native. Like a First nation group, correct? To some degree. And then there's like a. There's a treasure. There's a mythological treasure of the Melungeons. And of course, this has come up. So I'm not scooping you here, Ben. I believe you are a member of this triracial isolate.
Ben Bolan
I am. And it is a subject of fascination, the idea that Elvis Presley might be Melungeon, that. That Abraham Lincoln might be a Melungeon, basically. And just so you know, folks, we're an audio podcast. Noel, Jake, Max, and yours truly can all see each other. I don't have the tan to pull this off, but I'm mainly bringing this up to note that anytime someone achieves a certain threshold of fame, there will inevitably be folklore about them. We agree with that.
Jake Brennan
Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely.
Ben Bolan
So, Jake, what's a myth or a piece of Americana or folklore you would like us to propagate about you?
Max Williams
And by that, he means where can people find your work? Because you've got the folklore. It's out there already in book form and podcast form and video form. It's all out there for the picking.
Jake Brennan
You can listen to Disgraceland, the podcast, wherever podcasts are available. The Iheart app, the Spotify app, Apple podcast, wherever that's available. We're gonna bump this Elvis Johnny Ace archive episode up to the top, right around the time that. That this version of the ridiculous history episode goes live. So people should be able to find it pretty easily. And I'd love to have you guys on one of my bonus episodes to sort of.
Ben Bolan
Are you kidding?
Jake Brennan
That'd be. Yeah, yeah. No, I'm not kidding at all. You know, oftentimes, you know, like last week in the bonus episode, which is much different from the main scripted episodes, you know, I was talking about there's this big video, this big documentary, the Age of Disclosure. Have you guys seen this?
Ben Bolan
Yes.
Jake Brennan
It's fantastic. And I was talking about that relative to musicians like, Merle Haggard was a huge. He had a UFO experience that he would not shut up about at the end of his life. John Lennon put it into nobody told me. Blink182. We have an episode on Tom DeLong being part of the disclaimer movement. So oftentimes we touch on topics that you guys are interested. That you guys are interested in. I know, and I'd love to have you on to just sort of, you know, have it go both ways, so to speak.
Max Williams
Well, between ridiculous history and stuff they don't want you to know, we're basically interested in everything that there is. So I think we could probably find a crossover opportunity.
Jake Brennan
Love that, love that.
Max Williams
But man, dude, what a pleasure having you. This is such an interesting topic and a bit of a dark one for Christmas, but we did do fruitcake last week, so I think we're. We're okay. We balanced it out. You know, you gotta have the light with the dark.
Jake Brennan
Yeah. You guys Talked about my 90s band Fruitcake.
Max Williams
100% loves your words.
Ben Bolan
Mainly. Just so you know, Jake, when you listen, it's a three hour podcast, so not a time commitment. And the first 2 hours and 50 minutes are the study of your band fruitcake.
Max Williams
The rest of it is just various historical fruitcake recipes.
Ben Bolan
Yeah, yeah, that's it. The last dude. Thank you so much for joining us. Also, we have to thank a couple of other people, including our super producer, Mr. Max Williams.
Jake Brennan
Thank you, Max.
Max Williams
Oh, yeah, Alex Williams, who composed this theme. Who is this is maybe news to you, Jake, but is Max's actual fax brother and he's in the town for the holidays and we're excited to hang out with him very soon. Chris Frasiotes. And he's just both here in spirit.
Jake Brennan
Love that.
Ben Bolan
And Jake, I hate to hold you to the point, but ethics require. Can you give me one legend to make up about you?
Jake Brennan
About me that I am actually the grandson of Elvis Presley's twin brother.
Ben Bolan
Oh my.
Jake Brennan
Who did not die at birth but was in fact given away to heal people because his mama Gladys could not afford to raise him.
Ben Bolan
And that is our show. That is a fact. It is on record. Library of Congress fight with us.
Jake Brennan
Thanks, guys. It's my pleasure.
Ben Bolan
Appreciate you.
Max Williams
Oh heck yeah. We'll see you next time, folks. For more podcasts from iHeartRadio, visit the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts or wherever you listen to your favorite show.
BritBox Ad Voice
It's the coziest time of year on BritBox. That means curling up with a gripping murder mystery, basking in a sumptuous period drama, or discovering a new hidden gem. See the holidays differently when you stream the best of British TV with BritBox. Watch BritBox original series, including the new season of the award winning Belfast Police drama Blue Lights. However you cozy this holiday, it's a bit warmer with Britbox. Watch with a free trial@britbox.com hey audiobook lovers.
Ben Bolan
I'm Cal Penn.
Jake Brennan
I'm Ed Helms.
Ben Bolan
Ed and I are inviting you to join the best sounding book club you've ever heard with our new podcast, Irsay The Audible and iHeart Audiobook Club.
Jake Brennan
Each week we sit down with your favorite iHeart podcast hosts and some very special guests to discuss the latest and.
Ben Bolan
Greatest audiobook books from audible, listen to Earsay on America's number one podcast network, iHeart. Follow Earsay and start listening on the free iHeartradio app today.
Starbucks Ad Voice
It's the season to come together over your holiday favorites at Starbucks. Warm up with a creamy caramel brulee latte, get festive with an iced gingerbread chai, or share a velvety peppermint mocha. Together is the best place to be at Starbucks. Season two of Unrivaled basketball is here and the talent is unreal. Paige Beckers, Nafiza Collier, Kelsey Plumb, Brianna Stewart and more are back to redefine the game. Unrivaled basketball season two, sponsored by Samsung Galaxy, tips off January 5th on TNT, TruTV and HBO.
Max Williams
Max, you know what a girl's best.
Jake Brennan
Friend is not diamonds her lawyers. From executive producer Ryan Murphy comes a fiery new legal drama.
BritBox Ad Voice
It's our own boutique women representing women.
Jake Brennan
You can't afford to miss. Make it Ray Showtime, ladies. Stand up straight and breeze into that.
BritBox Ad Voice
Room like a storm no one saw coming.
Jake Brennan
Hulu Original Series All's Fair now streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney plus.
Max Williams
For bundle subscribers terms apply.
Jake Brennan
This is an iHeart podcast.
Starbucks Ad Voice
Guaranteed human.
Podcast: Ridiculous History by iHeartPodcasts
Episode Date: December 16, 2025
Guests: Jake Brennan (Disgraceland podcast), Hosts Ben Bowlin, Noel Brown, Max Williams
Theme: The haunting and myth-laden story of Johnny Ace, the R&B star whose tragic death became the stuff of music folklore and Christmas legend.
The hosts invite music storyteller and "Disgraceland" creator Jake Brennan to unravel the life, legend, and dark legacy of Johnny Ace — an influential Memphis R&B musician whose mysterious death on Christmas Day, 1954, has inspired decades of rumor and myth. As the conversation unfolds, the trio peels back the mythology surrounding Johnny Ace’s demise, exposes the racial undercurrents of music folklore, and explores how urban legends are birthed from both tragedy and the machinations of the music industry. It’s a tale as much about the stories we tell as the grim, ridiculously true events that underpin them.
Description & Place in History:
The Mythic Cool:
Prevailing Legend:
Reality vs. Folklore:
Robey’s Profile:
Conspiracy Theories:
Who Profited?:
Racialized Myths:
Media’s Role:
On Johnny Ace’s reputation:
On the allure of myth-busting:
On the Russian roulette legend:
On the racialized “deal with the devil” trope:
On Don Robey’s parallel to industry figures:
On industry exploitation:
On perpetual folklore:
The conversation is simultaneously scholarly and playful, moving quickly between musicology, industry intrigue, emotional reflection, and on-brand, tongue-in-cheek asides. Jake Brennan delivers meticulously researched history with the casual swagger of someone who grew up loving the legends he studies, while the hosts punctuate with humor and warmth.
The episode deftly weaves together the threads of music history, the machinery of fame, and the evolution of cultural mythologies—centering Johnny Ace as both cautionary tale and misunderstood legend. The hosts and Jake invite listeners to question not just the facts behind the stories they know, but why the stories themselves endure.
Listen for:
Recommended for anyone who loves their history absurd, their music tragic, and their legends larger than life.